Starmer in new bid to offer no alternative
#31
Arfage
Someone could have been killed
Reply
#32
(12-05-2023, 09:01 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Maybe I should just do what Proth does when he’s proven wrong countless times and just say, well if they had done it my way it would have worked.

What have I been "proven wrong" about Dekka?

I've been predicting an age of stagnation / stagflation for 15 years - and here we are.

I've been predicting a crisis in housing and here we are.

I predicted that closing schools during the pandemic would lead to the greatest disaster a generation of schoolkids have ever known and here we are.

I predicted that Brexit would not lead to economic collapse and mass unemployment and instead would have mild and manageable consequences, despite our useless governments failure to embrace regulatory change.

I predicted that the monetary cost to individuals of net zero would eventually come home to roost and here we are. 

I actually posted on here the July before Kwarteng's budget that borrowing for tax cuts in an inflationary environment would be the most reckless thing to do. Was I proven wrong about that as well?

And I told you all to #buygold.

I may well have posted some things that haven't come to pass, but unlike you at least I put my head above the parapet.

It may not be compulsory for you to explain what you want, but it does make you sound mealy-mouthed when all you do is complain without ever suggesting any solutions. You're the Gollum of the board.
Reply
#33
I might well have predicted some things that haven't come to pass is possibly the closest I ever expect to hear Proth skirt reality.

What a slogan.

You've still never answered how you'd have possibly kept schools open. Observing that it was going to have a terrible impact on mental health wasn't really the stuff of genius.
Someone could have been killed
Reply
#34
(12-05-2023, 09:37 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(12-05-2023, 09:01 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Maybe I should just do what Proth does when he’s proven wrong countless times and just say, well if they had done it my way it would have worked.

What have I been "proven wrong" about Dekka?

I've been predicting an age of stagnation / stagflation for 15 years - and here we are.

I've been predicting a crisis in housing and here we are.

I predicted that closing schools during the pandemic would lead to the greatest disaster a generation of schoolkids have ever known and here we are.

I predicted that Brexit would not lead to economic collapse and mass unemployment and instead would have mild and manageable consequences, despite our useless governments failure to embrace regulatory change.

I predicted that the monetary cost to individuals of net zero would eventually come home to roost and here we are. 

I actually posted on here the July before Kwarteng's budget that borrowing for tax cuts in an inflationary environment would be the most reckless thing to do. Was I proven wrong about that as well?

And I told you all to #buygold.

I may well have posted some things that haven't come to pass, but unlike you at least I put my head above the parapet.

It may not be compulsory for you to explain what you want, but it does make you sound mealy-mouthed when all you do is complain without ever suggesting any solutions. You're the Gollum of the board.

You would have let thousands more die or locked away without a vaccine during the pandemic particularly the disabled and the most vulnerable as they were the ones disproportionately affected. 

You would have cut more from public services at a time where they have been cut and mismanaged to the point of collapse. 

Brexit has wasted billions of pounds (think of the good that could have done for society) to produce a more divided, less tolerant country, that has normalised industrial scale lying, not to mention damaged thousands of small business’s who traded with Europe. 

You want to cut regulation so that there is little protection for workers, the environment and to allow companies to avoid paying tax to support public services. 

You knocked on doors for liars like Johnson, you endorsed campaigns built on lies. 

Everyone knew, well everyone but a sizeable proportion of your former colleagues that Truss and Kwarteng’s plans were folly. 

You just move the goalposts whenever things go wrong.
Reply
#35
Choose your response Dekka.

A) "Not every member or MP will agree with all of their parties policies..."

B) "I haven't been a member for three years, what could I have done to stop it?"

C) "#LeastWorst [including something random about Communism or Hamas that would make zero material difference to the lives of the average person in this country]"
Reply
#36
(12-05-2023, 10:39 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(12-05-2023, 09:37 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(12-05-2023, 09:01 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Maybe I should just do what Proth does when he’s proven wrong countless times and just say, well if they had done it my way it would have worked.

What have I been "proven wrong" about Dekka?

I've been predicting an age of stagnation / stagflation for 15 years - and here we are.

I've been predicting a crisis in housing and here we are.

I predicted that closing schools during the pandemic would lead to the greatest disaster a generation of schoolkids have ever known and here we are.

I predicted that Brexit would not lead to economic collapse and mass unemployment and instead would have mild and manageable consequences, despite our useless governments failure to embrace regulatory change.

I predicted that the monetary cost to individuals of net zero would eventually come home to roost and here we are. 

I actually posted on here the July before Kwarteng's budget that borrowing for tax cuts in an inflationary environment would be the most reckless thing to do. Was I proven wrong about that as well?

And I told you all to #buygold.

I may well have posted some things that haven't come to pass, but unlike you at least I put my head above the parapet.

It may not be compulsory for you to explain what you want, but it does make you sound mealy-mouthed when all you do is complain without ever suggesting any solutions. You're the Gollum of the board.

You would have let thousands more die or locked away without a vaccine during the pandemic particularly the disabled and the most vulnerable as they were the ones disproportionately affected. 

You would have cut more from public services at a time where they have been cut and mismanaged to the point of collapse. 

Brexit has wasted billions of pounds (think of the good that could have done for society) to produce a more divided, less tolerant country, that has normalised industrial scale lying, not to mention damaged thousands of small business’s who traded with Europe. 

You want to cut regulation so that there is little protection for workers, the environment and to allow companies to avoid paying tax to support public services. 

You knocked on doors for liars like Johnson, you endorsed campaigns built on lies. 

Everyone knew, well everyone but a sizeable proportion of your former colleagues that Truss and Kwarteng’s plans were folly. 

You just move the goalposts whenever things go wrong.

So you say. Relentlessly. Usually misrepresenting me or simply wholly too dense to understand. But you have no answers #MyPrecious
Reply
#37
D) A conflation of The State of Israel with Anti-semitism
Someone could have been killed
Reply
#38
(12-05-2023, 10:28 AM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: You've still never answered how you'd have possibly kept schools open. 

I've always failed to understand why teachers were treated differently from supermarket workers.

Both provide an absolutely essential service. One group stayed in their place of work interacting with hundreds or thousands of people every day. One group didn't.

It's not just the mental health of kids being affected - it's their ability to communicate with others and to deal with conflict. There's a cohort that spent the thick end of two years looking at a screen instead of being taught. The contract between parents and schools has been broken for good - you know that as well as I do.

Closing the schools will prove to be the greatest social policy disaster of the decade.
Reply
#39
(12-05-2023, 10:50 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(12-05-2023, 10:39 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(12-05-2023, 09:37 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(12-05-2023, 09:01 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Maybe I should just do what Proth does when he’s proven wrong countless times and just say, well if they had done it my way it would have worked.

What have I been "proven wrong" about Dekka?

I've been predicting an age of stagnation / stagflation for 15 years - and here we are.

I've been predicting a crisis in housing and here we are.

I predicted that closing schools during the pandemic would lead to the greatest disaster a generation of schoolkids have ever known and here we are.

I predicted that Brexit would not lead to economic collapse and mass unemployment and instead would have mild and manageable consequences, despite our useless governments failure to embrace regulatory change.

I predicted that the monetary cost to individuals of net zero would eventually come home to roost and here we are. 

I actually posted on here the July before Kwarteng's budget that borrowing for tax cuts in an inflationary environment would be the most reckless thing to do. Was I proven wrong about that as well?

And I told you all to #buygold.

I may well have posted some things that haven't come to pass, but unlike you at least I put my head above the parapet.

It may not be compulsory for you to explain what you want, but it does make you sound mealy-mouthed when all you do is complain without ever suggesting any solutions. You're the Gollum of the board.

You would have let thousands more die or locked away without a vaccine during the pandemic particularly the disabled and the most vulnerable as they were the ones disproportionately affected. 

You would have cut more from public services at a time where they have been cut and mismanaged to the point of collapse. 

Brexit has wasted billions of pounds (think of the good that could have done for society) to produce a more divided, less tolerant country, that has normalised industrial scale lying, not to mention damaged thousands of small business’s who traded with Europe. 

You want to cut regulation so that there is little protection for workers, the environment and to allow companies to avoid paying tax to support public services. 

You knocked on doors for liars like Johnson, you endorsed campaigns built on lies. 

Everyone knew, well everyone but a sizeable proportion of your former colleagues that Truss and Kwarteng’s plans were folly. 

You just move the goalposts whenever things go wrong.

So you say. Relentlessly. Usually misrepresenting me or simply wholly too dense to understand. But you have no answers #MyPrecious

Describe what you mean by deregulation. That doesn’t mean reducing worker and environmental protections etc. 

Are you arguing that Johnson and the Conservatives didn’t mislead, tell untruths on an unprecedented scale at the last election, or for that matter Vote Leave? 

What were your solutions other than house arrest or tough shit solutions for thousands of vulnerable people before the vaccine? 

Is the U.K. better or worse for Brexit socially, economically, politically? 

Have cuts to public services helped the country? You argue they weren’t deep enough or am I mistaken?

If I’m misrepresenting what you are arguing then here’s a great opportunity to say what I’m misrepresenting.
Reply
#40
(12-05-2023, 10:58 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(12-05-2023, 10:28 AM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: You've still never answered how you'd have possibly kept schools open. 

I've always failed to understand why teachers were treated differently from supermarket workers.

Both provide an absolutely essential service. One group stayed in their place of work interacting with hundreds or thousands of people every day. One group didn't.

It's not just the mental health of kids being affected - it's their ability to communicate with others and to deal with conflict. There's a cohort that spent the thick end of two years looking at a screen instead of being taught. The contract between parents and schools has been broken for good - you know that as well as I do.

Closing the schools will prove to be the greatest social policy disaster of the decade.

I reckon you're being enough to answer your first line if you put some real thought into.

Supermarkets don't cease to function completely if 20% or more of their staff can't be on site. Which even work a policy aimed at keeping schools open would've been a natural bi product of those with COVID, those whose kids had COVID, those of us that were caring for sick parents or those on the shielding list.

You are mixing up your quite correct (in my opinion) assesment of the damage with a totally barmy idea that the problem could've easily been eliminated. It couldn't.
Someone could have been killed
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)