The Silent Majority
#31
Well this went exactly as predicted.

Genuine question for Spandau here, do you ever question the opinions of those who supposedly "self-cancel"? Are we not always taught to think before we speak, are you advocating for people being able to say what they like without a comeback? As that would only represent 50% of free speech. In the case of Danny Baker, if I were to think of that 'joke', run it round my head a couple of times and still put it out there into the public domain, at best I am a fucking idiot and at worst I'm a racist.
Reply
#32
(11-14-2023, 09:35 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Well this went exactly as predicted.

Genuine question for Spandau here, do you ever question the opinions of those who supposedly "self-cancel"? Are we not always taught to think before we speak, are you advocating for people being able to say what they like without a comeback? As that would only represent 50% of free speech. In the case of Danny Baker, if I were to think of that 'joke', run it round my head a couple of times and still put it out there into the public domain, at best I am a fucking idiot and at worst I'm a racist.

Yes. It was stupid, but it's a mistake. We all make them.

And genuine question to you, look at the example I gave of the barrister with an innocent remark that was set upon and has now gone off social media. He's a bright guy, but he didn't see that coming.

I really can't be bothered to add any more to this as I've given examples of people I know who stay off social media as they find it dangerous, don't know the right terms, or just know they'll be hijacked. These are all  people who aren't even right wing.

As I said this inability to now debate differences has caused Brexit and Trump. This is one of my favourites summing up where we are. If you're too busy see it from about 1m 35, where it explains the intolerant left who label everyone a bigot if they don't think the same. https://www.google.com/search?q=jonathan...BAF60,st:0

By the way, here is more food for thought. https://bigthink.com/series/collective-i...ial-media/

(11-14-2023, 09:16 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(11-14-2023, 07:17 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(11-13-2023, 11:36 PM)Duffers Wrote:
(11-13-2023, 11:01 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(11-13-2023, 10:49 PM)Duffers Wrote: But who has cancelled him exactly?

People complain about “cancel culture” and the like but the reality is that if he was walk back on to BBC Radio tomorrow nobody would care. People have short attention spans and Baker’s crime happened long enough ago that most have forgotten about it. It’s the bosses at the BBC who have decided they don’t want him back, not the court of public opinion.

Woke mobs don’t cancel individuals, they do it themselves through their behaviour.

I can’t give names and addresses but you can be certain most corporations won’t touch him with a barge pole. It’s not worth the hassle. That’s common sense by them in this climate. 

Honestly your replies absolutely depict perfectly the situation I have described surrounding all this debate. It clearly doesn’t bother you that people have careers ruined through innocent mistakes or changes of what is culturally acceptable. They shouldn’t have said it is your simple answer. Well maybe then they are too scared to say anything? Has that occurred to you?

Your reply is one of intolerance of human frailties and you display a lack of forgiveness, which seems incredibly unpalatable traits. Sadly though many are like you in this respect whilst freakily thinking you’re tolerant. 

And that chap  is simply why many people, even highly educated barristers, will choose to say nothing except to close friends as they can see the weird uncomfortable world that you stand up for. Free speech eh?


Remarkable how quickly you went from “Good post” to calling me intolerant and accusing me of not being bothered by people losing their careers simply for presenting a different view to you.

Are you not being the very thing you are railing against?

More interesting is that you’ve clearly not read what I’ve actually said either. I said I liked Baker, said I wouldn’t care if he was back in radio, I said there’d be no real issue if he came back.

Not what I’d call intolerant.

What exactly is the defence here anyway?

If I sent jokes and pictures around my workplace that could be construed as racist I’d probably be sacked. I’d also probably struggle to find work in the future if all potential employers knew I’d been sacked for racism.

The whole point of this thread is to discuss if there is a silent majority. I really can’t see that there’s any much else to add in what I’ve said except saying I know lots of people that say nothing in fear of saying the wrong thing and even given a living example I was involved with. 
Your argument is ridiculously weak and shows a really unforgiving nature in you. 
It doesn’t matter that you like Danny Baker. Many still won’t let him back.
Also for someone you like and you’ve said isn’t racist you have put up a simple argument saying he shouldn’t have said it so got the consequences!
Great who needs supporters like that?
It’s a pity you weren’t around 20 years earlier so you could have warned the generation above of mistakes they are making at the time that will be judged against different standards way in the future. 
I think you’re investing far too much effort in trying to win an argument and protect your ego rather than take on board that there are many who self cancel, stay quiet, and consider themselves a part of a silent majority.

I do enjoy Spandau's monthly "the woke are ruining everything/why can't the world be like I want it to be/I'm the voice of reason here" tirades.

What's especially interesting Spandau is that if you read back through this conversation all I have done is present an opinion in a neutral and measured tone, backed with the occasional fact. I haven't been particularly provocative or offensive. Whereas as the thread has progressed your language has gotten more inflammatory, more emotive, there's been attempts to get personal (I've taken the liberty of highlighting some examples in your last post), you are making large and hysterical leaps in logic and presuming you know what I think ("if you think this then you mustn't care about..."). Your posts on this thread have perfectly exemplified the sort of social media hysteria you claim to be above.

I daresay the self-styled voice of reason is being a little unreasonable.

For someone who has such a neutral tone it's incredible how you seem to get in more arguments with many posters than practically anyone on here.

By the way I never appointed myself as a voice of reason. However, it does remind me of the saying: "You can't reason with the unreasonable."
Reply
#33
(11-14-2023, 10:21 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(11-14-2023, 09:35 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Well this went exactly as predicted.

Genuine question for Spandau here, do you ever question the opinions of those who supposedly "self-cancel"? Are we not always taught to think before we speak, are you advocating for people being able to say what they like without a comeback? As that would only represent 50% of free speech. In the case of Danny Baker, if I were to think of that 'joke', run it round my head a couple of times and still put it out there into the public domain, at best I am a fucking idiot and at worst I'm a racist.

Yes. It was stupid, but it's a mistake. We all make them.

And genuine question to you, look at the example I gave of the barrister with an innocent remark that was set upon and has now gone off social media. He's a bright guy, but he didn't see that coming.

I really can't be bothered to add any more to this as I've given examples of people I know who stay off social media as they find it dangerous, don't know the right terms, or just know they'll be hijacked. These are all  people who aren't even right wing.

As I said this inability to now debate differences has caused Brexit and Trump. This is one of my favourites summing up where we are. If you're too busy see it from about 1m 35, where it explains the intolerant left who label everyone a bigot if they don't think the same. https://www.google.com/search?q=jonathan...BAF60,st:0

By the way, here is more food for thought. https://bigthink.com/series/collective-i...ial-media/

I did. What was the lawyer thinking telling people what was and wasn't presentable in a public forum?! That is just another case of an opinion from thirty years ago that is now thankfully past its sell by date. It's not on the same level as racism but it's still a bit dense. If you can't see why that would irk some people then I'm afraid I don't know what to say to you.
Reply
#34
(11-14-2023, 10:47 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(11-14-2023, 10:21 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(11-14-2023, 09:35 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Well this went exactly as predicted.

Genuine question for Spandau here, do you ever question the opinions of those who supposedly "self-cancel"? Are we not always taught to think before we speak, are you advocating for people being able to say what they like without a comeback? As that would only represent 50% of free speech. In the case of Danny Baker, if I were to think of that 'joke', run it round my head a couple of times and still put it out there into the public domain, at best I am a fucking idiot and at worst I'm a racist.

Yes. It was stupid, but it's a mistake. We all make them.

And genuine question to you, look at the example I gave of the barrister with an innocent remark that was set upon and has now gone off social media. He's a bright guy, but he didn't see that coming.

I really can't be bothered to add any more to this as I've given examples of people I know who stay off social media as they find it dangerous, don't know the right terms, or just know they'll be hijacked. These are all  people who aren't even right wing.

As I said this inability to now debate differences has caused Brexit and Trump. This is one of my favourites summing up where we are. If you're too busy see it from about 1m 35, where it explains the intolerant left who label everyone a bigot if they don't think the same. https://www.google.com/search?q=jonathan...BAF60,st:0

By the way, here is more food for thought. https://bigthink.com/series/collective-i...ial-media/

I did. What was the lawyer thinking telling people what was and wasn't presentable in a public forum?! That is just another case of an opinion from thirty years ago that is now thankfully past its sell by date. It's not on the same level as racism but it's still a bit dense. If you can't see why that would irk some people then I'm afraid I don't know what to say to you.
I'll leave that  reply as the crowning moment in this thread explaining why so many don't go near social media and self-cancel.
Reply
#35
(11-14-2023, 10:54 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(11-14-2023, 10:47 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(11-14-2023, 10:21 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(11-14-2023, 09:35 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Well this went exactly as predicted.

Genuine question for Spandau here, do you ever question the opinions of those who supposedly "self-cancel"? Are we not always taught to think before we speak, are you advocating for people being able to say what they like without a comeback? As that would only represent 50% of free speech. In the case of Danny Baker, if I were to think of that 'joke', run it round my head a couple of times and still put it out there into the public domain, at best I am a fucking idiot and at worst I'm a racist.

Yes. It was stupid, but it's a mistake. We all make them.

And genuine question to you, look at the example I gave of the barrister with an innocent remark that was set upon and has now gone off social media. He's a bright guy, but he didn't see that coming.

I really can't be bothered to add any more to this as I've given examples of people I know who stay off social media as they find it dangerous, don't know the right terms, or just know they'll be hijacked. These are all  people who aren't even right wing.

As I said this inability to now debate differences has caused Brexit and Trump. This is one of my favourites summing up where we are. If you're too busy see it from about 1m 35, where it explains the intolerant left who label everyone a bigot if they don't think the same. https://www.google.com/search?q=jonathan...BAF60,st:0

By the way, here is more food for thought. https://bigthink.com/series/collective-i...ial-media/

I did. What was the lawyer thinking telling people what was and wasn't presentable in a public forum?! That is just another case of an opinion from thirty years ago that is now thankfully past its sell by date. It's not on the same level as racism but it's still a bit dense. If you can't see why that would irk some people then I'm afraid I don't know what to say to you.
I'll leave that  reply as the crowning moment in this thread explaining why so many don't go near social media and self-cancel.

If more and more people are self-cancelling because they can't stop saying dumb things then I guess that's a positive in the end.
Reply
#36
Nice to have some recent academic research to back up my points. Not Oxbridge granted but reasoned research of 1000 people all the same.
Paragraph 5 mirrors my own personal findings that even those moderately conservative self-censor. Can't beat a good debate when there's no football about! On other matters I do think the Beatles were brilliant and pioneers.
https://news.byu.edu/intellect/social-me...u-research
Reply
#37
(11-14-2023, 04:20 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: Nice to have some recent academic research to back up my points. Not Oxbridge granted but reasoned research of 1000 people all the same.
Paragraph 5 mirrors my own personal findings that even those moderately conservative self-censor. Can't beat a good debate when there's no football about! On other matters I do think the Beatles were brilliant and pioneers.
https://news.byu.edu/intellect/social-me...u-research

Not sure the linked article proves anything other than the old adage about those who shout loudest.

Is it really 'self-cancelling' or is it just thinking before you speak? The latter I do, the former I wouldn't say I've ever done.

I can't stand the Beatles either  Big Grin
Reply
#38
(11-14-2023, 04:52 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(11-14-2023, 04:20 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: Nice to have some recent academic research to back up my points. Not Oxbridge granted but reasoned research of 1000 people all the same.
Paragraph 5 mirrors my own personal findings that even those moderately conservative self-censor. Can't beat a good debate when there's no football about! On other matters I do think the Beatles were brilliant and pioneers.
https://news.byu.edu/intellect/social-me...u-research

Not sure the linked article proves anything other than the old adage about those who shout loudest.

Is it really 'self-cancelling' or is it just thinking before you speak? The latter I do, the former I wouldn't say I've ever done.

I can't stand the Beatles either  Big Grin

I never had you having anything in common with FF! Do you share his sartorial elegance also?
Reply
#39
This is why in political terms we are in danger of voting in an extremist in coming years

Cast your minds back good few years ago

From around 2004 mass movement of people to UK from Europe (for work & all)
Many of the rich & wealthy & businesses had their cake & ate it

But due to increase in population it added more pressure on UK public services

So people raised concerns about our infastructure not coping

Powers that be at the time could have done either of the following
1) Increase resources & services to cope with huge increase in population and income from those working here of course
2) Ignore & label everyone (including tradional Labour voters) racist bigots etc to shut them up

Fast forward a few years & opportunity comes to give the political classes a smack on the nose =brexit

Same will happen again
Public labelled racist etc etc over numbers of single male migrants and pressures on services

Along comes a Donald Trump type figure & public vote him into no 10

All because their opinions fears views are ignored & are labelled the above
Reply
#40
(11-14-2023, 05:20 PM)Pipkins Wrote: This is why in political terms we are in danger of voting in an extremist in coming years

Cast your minds back good few years ago

From around 2004 mass movement of people to UK from Europe (for work & all)
Many of the rich & wealthy & businesses had their cake & ate it

But due to increase in population it added more pressure on UK public services

So people raised concerns about our infastructure not coping

Powers that be at the time could have done either of the following
1)  Increase resources & services to cope with huge increase in population and income from those working here of course
2) Ignore & label everyone (including tradional Labour voters) racist bigots etc to shut them up

Fast forward a few years & opportunity comes to give the political classes a smack on the nose  =brexit

Same will happen again
Public labelled racist etc etc over numbers of single male migrants and pressures on services

Along comes a Donald Trump type figure & public vote him into no 10

All because their opinions fears views are ignored & are labelled the above

Reality people came here to do jobs others were not prepared to do, didn’t have the numbers to do and didn't have the skills to do. 
Cameron and Osbourne and the rest of the Tory Party gleefully used the financial crash that bankers caused to cut services to the bone. 
Snake oil salesmen and women convinced communities it was all the fault of them foreigners and the EU when it was an ideological decisions by the Conservative Party that was and still is obsessed with cutting service's.
The only reason Cameron went for a referendum was to try and stop the endless psychodrama in the Tory party that continues to this day and has wrecked this country for over a decade. 

I really don’t have any sympathy for those who chose the lazy and ignorant route of blaming immigrants and the EU for the woes of this country. The reason the country is in a mess, divided, losing influence is because of the Conservative Party first and foremost. Pandering to those who still believe the shite they spew faster than a privatised water companies storm drain simply drags this country further and further into the mire. Perhaps those who hide behind the excuse that nasty lefty’s made me hobble my own community and country because they called me a name should take some responsibility for why it is, that despite them voting or supporting ever more right wing policies nothing gets any better for them or their communities.

Oh and we had a Poundland Trump in Johnson and look where that got us.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: