Posts: 10,859
Threads: 497
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
23
11-11-2023, 07:49 PM
(This post was last modified: 11-11-2023, 08:09 PM by Peachy.)
Just home. Firstly what a cracking performance that was. Full of spirit and endeavour. We deserved so much more from that game. Talking to Saints fans coming out of the game and they said "we stole that!".
Our fans were also brilliant today. Never stopped singing for 97 minutes and gave the lads a rousing send off after the whistle.
Palmer - 8 - Nowt to do. Couldn't do anything about either goal and damn nearly kept the first out.
Furlong - 7 - Meh. Played Ok. Headed against bar and can't fault effort but we have to find better moving forwards imo. He frustrates me with his final ball.
Townsend - 6 - See Furlong. Thought he was our weak link today. Didn't do much going forwards and caught out defensively for the goals.
Kipre - 8 - Thought he was superb today. He just seems to get better and better. So committed and a decent baller too.
Bartley - 7.5 - Good solid game imo and good following up for his goal.
Phillips - MOTM 9 - So impressed today. All power and pace and menace. Never stopped.
Wallace - 7 - Never fault his effort but he looked out of sorts first half and final ball was poor. Much better 2nd half.
Chalobah - 6 - Nothing of note first 45 and then injured and hooked. Don't like pairing him and Okay personally.
Okay - 8 - Thought he was great today and surprised how fit he looked. Pressing really high all 2nd half before being subbed.
Grady - 7 - Quiet first 45 but much better 2nd half. Great defensively today and probing going forwards especially late on.
BTA - 8 - Worked his absolute knackers off and held the ball up really well with some lovely effective spins and turns which set up attacks in the 2nd 45. Great header for Bart's goal.
Subs
Fellows - 7 Looked really good
Mowatt - 8 Changed the midfield and looked great I thought
Molumby - 7 Got stuck in
Ajayi - 7 Looked comfortable.
Thought the ref had a shocker today. From the first whistle he looked like a homer. Gave them everything all day with some bizarre decisions.
Posts: 599
Threads: 25
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
2
Don’t disagree with the points however an Armstrong or Che Adam’s would have scored 2/3 for us today. We looked really good without a central striker, performance and team deserved something out of that.
Posts: 10,859
Threads: 497
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
23
11-11-2023, 10:28 PM
(This post was last modified: 11-11-2023, 10:33 PM by Peachy.)
(11-11-2023, 09:00 PM)BasingBaggie Wrote: Don’t disagree with the points however an Armstrong or Che Adam’s would have scored 2/3 for us today. We looked really good without a central striker, performance and team deserved something out of that.
Totally agree. Said the same to my old man. A decent striker away from being a top side. Interesting reading the Saints board......
-----------------------------------------
I thought WBA were massive!
And they are a play off team for sure I’d say. WBA def up there as one of best teams we played in the league, if not quite the best.
A bit fortunate to get a win, but will take it. We played well first half, with some tremendous passing out from the back. But WBA were by far the better side on the second half and could easily have won the game.
--------------
West Brom were pretty good to be honest ...condensed the play and were very physical side ....they will defo be in the play off places ....only gripe was we gave them all day to cross the ball ..far to easy in that respect .
-------------------
West Brom are a good side. That could have gone either way. Great match from an entertainment point of view.
----------------
Thought we were lucky, whereas we were always in control in the previous couple of games. West Brom were shit. They had quite a few opportunities to find the right pass and instead found the touchline. When they were on top in the second half, they had the ball in the middle of the field with acres of space but made the wrong pass or were too slow. We were lucky
Posts: 5,201
Threads: 197
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
14
11-11-2023, 10:49 PM
(This post was last modified: 11-11-2023, 10:51 PM by Cuzer.)
I’m pretty much with you on the marks
For me
Palmer 7 Little to do so hard to give more
Furlong 6 Frustrated me today and also thought Carlos shoukd have brought Pippa on when we were well in the ascendancy. His crossing and final ball was below average all day but my biggest frustration was their winner, vintage Darnell Furlong. Just backed off and backed off and let the winger put a cross in, he’s got previous doing this and today cost us badly
Townsend 6 Probably my weakest player on the day, had a hand in their winner when he ball watched and got sucked inside but seemed to have a lot of space going forward and his final ball was always poor
Kipre 8* Another excellent game, solid, good passing everything we’ve come to expect
Bartley 7 Fortunate goal but they all count. Very flat forward and ambled back for their early first goal but improved as the game went on
Okay 8 Thought he was very good again today, pressed really high at times, couple of key passes just millimeter's off putting players in but seems to be edging towards top form
Chalobah 6 With Townsend as the one real negative. Big call from CC and one ultimately he got wrong. First half we were labored, especially first 30 and the game passed him by. Hooked and was the right call, thought he may have been in to use his physicality at set pieces then we left him out the box when we had a corner!
Phillips 7 Surprised by the rave reviews, my POTY so far but today wasn’t one of his best, he was always a threat but looked leggy and tired, especially last 20. Some good crosses but we’re not getting on the end of enough of them
Wallace 7 Similar to Hull more direct running in behind and he carries way more threat, chose wrong option when we broke in the first half and missed chance to play BTA in on goal, can’t fault effort and looks in decent form
Grady 7 Nowhere near the level of the past few weeks, struggled to beat his man most the time in a one on one. Some real good stuff but a good 20% down on previous weeks
BTA 7 Thought he looked really sharp personally, constantly stretching back line of Saints, tireless running and very unlucky with header before the goal.
Subs
Mowatt 8 Fitted in well alongside The Turk and showed in 30 minutes he really should have started
Molumby 7 Got about the pitch well but missed 3 good chances others may not have seen. Missed a near post header from a corner in injury time when any contact would have likely scored, from Sarmiento’s ball in he again missed a header just before BTA was denied on the line and in another goal mouth scramble missed his bloody kick! Classic case of falling to the wrong person
Fellows 7 Another lively cameo. Paper talk of Leicester and Saints interest, out of contract in the summer
Semi 7 Solid and composed when brought on
Hopefully a good performance to build on with returning players around tbe corner
Hard to criticize King Carlos but the Chalobah call back fired today and can’t help thinking Pippa for DF 20 left may have got us a better result
Cuzer
Fisheatingdeludedsealwankers
Posts: 599
Threads: 25
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
2
I was quite vocal afterwards that it was mistake not to start Mowatt however to be fair to King Carlos the early goal changed the game. We had to try and force it and that is not Chalobah’s game at all. With the strikers they have they should make the play offs however would expect us to turn them over at our place
Posts: 7,971
Threads: 254
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
Nice one Peachy.
CT was fine earlier this season but he was our weak link last week as well (the Hull goal was on MP albeit).
DF for his part should be closer and make a better fist of blocking the cross
Posts: 9,603
Threads: 515
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
11-14-2023, 04:04 PM
(This post was last modified: 11-14-2023, 04:10 PM by Lurker#3.)
Full disclosure - I have only seen the 4 minutes highlights, and that was when I was hammered early hour Sunday morning. But I would be interested to see how the stats stand up in isolation for those of you that watched the game 'with your own eyes'.
Palmer - 6 - A Post Shot XG Against of 1.8, so seems like it was an average showing by Palmer, so scored bang down the middle.
Furlong - 7 - Second highest number of touches in the team, and many of them being progressive receives (11-most in the team) which shows that off the balls he was high and wide, and usually in the game often. He also crossed the ball into the box the joint highest number of times in team. However he only clocked up one Key Pass (shot assist) which shows poor delivery, he also played less progressive passes than usual, perhaps due to his high receiving position. Defensively he was slightly above average too. Won the majority of his aerial duels, and made joint highest number of ball recoveries.
Kipre - 9 - Stats show a defensive masterclass. Won all of his tackles/challenges, made a team high number of blocks (3), 2 of those being shots. Most interceptions (5) and clearances (5). Won all of his aerial duels, too. Less progressive in possession than when he plays in a three, but accurate and effective.
Bartley - 7 - Statistically passive by Bartley's standards defensively. Only 2 clearances, 1 tackle and 0 interceptions. He did however assist one shot and pass the ball more progressively than usual with 2 progressive passes into the final 3rd. Also the goal took him up a mark.
Townsend - 8 - Stats show him to be playing deeper, almost tucking in to make the "3". In possession he made very few crosses and only 4 progressive receives, 7 less than furlong on the opposite side. However in possession he register the 2nd highest number of progressive passes (7), 2 of which setting up a shot and 3 into the final third. Defensively he made the 2nd highest number of clearances (4), again showing his narrower and deeper position and important defensive interceptions.
Diangana - 7 - As always Grady had the highest number of Take On attempts (8) and the highest number of Progressive Passes (9) with 5 into the final 1/3 and 3 into the penalty area. However, he didn't hurt the opposition enough. He only made 1 key pass, and only 3 Shot Creating Actions, which whilst not low, is low for Grady considering the amount of possession, in good areas, he had. Also considering his average position was in the #9 position he didn't have any shots.
Okay - 8 - Looks like a classic Okay showing. Won every challenge against people who tried to dribble past him (2), made 3 tackles and 3 clearances and made 5 recoveries. Now onto his work in possession. 3rd highest number of Progressive passes (6) with 5 of those being into the final 1/3. He also progressively carried the ball joint most in the team (4) with half the time that going into the final 3rd. Playing really well at the moment.
Chalobah - 5 - I guess he was the player tasked with getting forward playing with Okay. But frankly the stats show a very poor showing. No tackles. No progressive carries. No shot creating actions. Only 1 shot (off target). On the positive (...ish) side, 3 progressive passes and 3 recoveries which were on par with other players given the number of minutes he played.
Phillips - 7 - Similar story to Grady. Plenty of take on attempts (6/2), progressive carries (4) and progressive receives (7), but only 1 shot, 2 shot creating actions, 1 progressive pass and 0 key passes. Interestingly his average position was almost in the left side #9 position, similar to Grady on the right.
Wallace - 8 - Similar story to both Grady and Phillips. But with a little more cutting edge. He was successful in half of his 4 take ons, carried the ball progressively from the 10 position he was in joint second number of times (3), progressively recieving it centrally 5 times, as well. He also clocked up 3 SCA and his cross was vital to our goal.
BTA - 8 - Much better statistically from Brandon. 100% take in success (2/2), most shots (4)z including the header for the goal which was unlucky not to go in. He also made 5 progressive passes which shows good link up play.
Subs:
Mowatt - 9 (MoTM) - You have to consider these stats extrapolated out over 90. Joint 2nd highest number of tackles (2), 2 highest dribblers challenged (2/3) and 5 recoveries. Offensively; 5 shot creating actions, 3 progressive passes, and 3 key passes. All in 35 minutes. Over 90 those stats would have been insane.
Fellows - 7 - Really starting to be a useful out ball for us from the bench. In only 10 playing minutes he made; 3 progressive receives and 3 progressive carries all init the final third. Nothing in the way of final ball/delivery though, which is his biggest challenge to put right compared to...
Sarmiento - 7- only 9 minutes here, but in those 9 minutes he had; 2 shot assists (key passes), whilst also progressively passing and carrying the ball effectively. He had the highest xAG in the team. If we had if scored he would have been an 8.
Molumby - 7 - Tried the pass progressively in his shirt time on the pitch (3) and got a shot away.
Ajayi - 6 - again, only 9 mins when I presumed we were on top. But got a shot off but nothing else to report.
Seen a few people point out CT for their goal. Neither goal was down to an individual, rather us not defending our box well enough collectively. Which is a surprise after recent defensive showings.
"IMO of course..."
Posts: 12,682
Threads: 1,158
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
15
(11-14-2023, 04:04 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Full disclosure - I have only seen the 4 minutes highlights, and that was when I was hammered early hour Sunday morning. But I would be interested to see how the stats stand up in isolation for those of you that watched the game 'with your own eyes'.
Palmer - 6 - A Post Shot XG Against of 1.8, so seems like it was an average showing by Palmer, so scored bang down the middle.
Furlong - 7 - Second highest number of touches in the team, and many of them being progressive receives (11-most in the team) which shows that off the balls he was high and wide, and usually in the game often. He also crossed the ball into the box the joint highest number of times in team. However he only clocked up one Key Pass (shot assist) which shows poor delivery, he also played less progressive passes than usual, perhaps due to his high receiving position. Defensively he was slightly above average too. Won the majority of his aerial duels, and made joint highest number of ball recoveries.
Kipre - 9 - Stats show a defensive masterclass. Won all of his tackles/challenges, made a team high number of blocks (3), 2 of those being shots. Most interceptions (5) and clearances (5). Won all of his aerial duels, too. Less progressive in possession than when he plays in a three, but accurate and effective.
Bartley - 7 - Statistically passive by Bartley's standards defensively. Only 2 clearances, 1 tackle and 0 interceptions. He did however assist one shot and pass the ball more progressively than usual with 2 progressive passes into the final 3rd. Also the goal took him up a mark.
Townsend - 8 - Stats show him to be playing deeper, almost tucking in to make the "3". In possession he made very few crosses and only 4 progressive receives, 7 less than furlong on the opposite side. However in possession he register the 2nd highest number of progressive passes (7), 2 of which setting up a shot and 3 into the final third. Defensively he made the 2nd highest number of clearances (4), again showing his narrower and deeper position and important defensive interceptions.
Diangana - 7 - As always Grady had the highest number of Take On attempts (8) and the highest number of Progressive Passes (9) with 5 into the final 1/3 and 3 into the penalty area. However, he didn't hurt the opposition enough. He only made 1 key pass, and only 3 Shot Creating Actions, which whilst not low, is low for Grady considering the amount of possession, in good areas, he had. Also considering his average position was in the #9 position he didn't have any shots.
Okay - 8 - Looks like a classic Okay showing. Won every challenge against people who tried to dribble past him (2), made 3 tackles and 3 clearances and made 5 recoveries. Now onto his work in possession. 3rd highest number of Progressive passes (6) with 5 of those being into the final 1/3. He also progressively carried the ball joint most in the team (4) with half the time that going into the final 3rd. Playing really well at the moment.
Chalobah - 5 - I guess he was the player tasked with getting forward playing with Okay. But frankly the stats show a very poor showing. No tackles. No progressive carries. No shot creating actions. Only 1 shot (off target). On the positive (...ish) side, 3 progressive passes and 3 recoveries which were on par with other players given the number of minutes he played.
Phillips - 7 - Similar story to Grady. Plenty of take on attempts (6/2), progressive carries (4) and progressive receives (7), but only 1 shot, 2 shot creating actions, 1 progressive pass and 0 key passes. Interestingly his average position was almost in the left side #9 position, similar to Grady on the right.
Wallace - 8 - Similar story to both Grady and Phillips. But with a little more cutting edge. He was successful in half of his 4 take ons, carried the ball progressively from the 10 position he was in joint second number of times (3), progressively recieving it centrally 5 times, as well. He also clocked up 3 SCA and his cross was vital to our goal.
BTA - 8 - Much better statistically from Brandon. 100% take in success (2/2), most shots (4)z including the header for the goal which was unlucky not to go in. He also made 5 progressive passes which shows good link up play.
Subs:
Mowatt - 9 (MoTM) - You have to consider these stats extrapolated out over 90. Joint 2nd highest number of tackles (2), 2 highest dribblers challenged (2/3) and 5 recoveries. Offensively; 5 shot creating actions, 3 progressive passes, and 3 key passes. All in 35 minutes. Over 90 those stats would have been insane.
Fellows - 7 - Really starting to be a useful out ball for us from the bench. In only 10 playing minutes he made; 3 progressive receives and 3 progressive carries all init the final third. Nothing in the way of final ball/delivery though, which is his biggest challenge to put right compared to...
Sarmiento - 7- only 9 minutes here, but in those 9 minutes he had; 2 shot assists (key passes), whilst also progressively passing and carrying the ball effectively. He had the highest xAG in the team. If we had if scored he would have been an 8.
Molumby - 7 - Tried the pass progressively in his shirt time on the pitch (3) and got a shot away.
Ajayi - 6 - again, only 9 mins when I presumed we were on top. But got a shot off but nothing else to report.
Seen a few people point out CT for their goal. Neither goal was down to an individual, rather us not defending our box well enough collectively. Which is a surprise after recent defensive showings.
Beautiful stats/analysis, still no pretty graph B+
Posts: 15,040
Threads: 339
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
93
Interesting that, Lurker, not so different to the general consensus. Where it may come unstuck is with the last paragraph. Clearly either CT - not picking up at the far post, or Matty P- not tracking back, was to blame for their winner (IMO).
Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
Interesting write up Lurker and echoes the comments of those who saw the game.
The big frustration is the willingness to drop Mowatt for Chalobah when there are many examples of just how important to our play - especially away from home - the Mowatt-Yokuslu axis is in central midfield.
I’ve also not been a fan of this switch to a back 4. Phillips was really thriving on the LWB role, but since the set up has changed he’s contributed less in defence and attack. This is the second game running him and Townsend have misread a situation and caused a preventable goal.
|