Ref Anthony Taylor
#1
Gets relegated to the Championship for giving a dodgy penalty against Wolves. But the VAR official who didn't overturn the decision gets away with no sanction. Wrong on two levels - if he's crap stop him refereeing, don't inflict him on someone else - surely it's a two man job, both failed, not just the on-field ref?
Reply
#2
Not sure why the Aussie ref has avoided the same fate as he's more culpable.
Reply
#3
I take it still nothing on that travesty of a decision at Blues. He should be demoted to Sunday morning pub league for that decision
Reply
#4
This type of action is playing to the crowds. What's the point. So the ref made a mistake, it happens. Overall I think Taylor is one of the better refs, why would you want to punish him like this for an error.

And yes if it was that egregious an error that needs a sanction, why is the var official , who looked at the incident for some minutes and didn't think it was a clear and obvious error not sanctioned.
Reply
#5
Depends on the conversation between Taylor and VAR. If VAR told him it looked like a dive and to look at the incident again on the monitor then there is nothing VAR can do if Taylor refuses and insists it was a foul.
Reply
#6
It's always the same, they get relegated for a week and are then back. It should be that if you're dropped to the champ you have to work your way back up through good performances
Reply
#7
(11-03-2023, 04:31 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: This type of action is playing to the crowds. What's the point. So the ref made a mistake, it happens. Overall I think Taylor is one of the better refs, why would you want to punish him like this for an error.

And yes if it was that egregious an error that needs a sanction, why is the var official , who looked at the incident for some minutes and didn't think it was a clear and obvious error not sanctioned.

Totally agree with this post, except, I personally think Taylor is a truly terrible ref!
Reply
#8
(11-03-2023, 05:18 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(11-03-2023, 04:31 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: This type of action is playing to the crowds. What's the point. So the ref made a mistake, it happens. Overall I think Taylor is one of the better refs, why would you want to punish him like this for an error.

And yes if it was that egregious an error that needs a sanction, why is the var official , who looked at the incident for some minutes and didn't think it was a clear and obvious error not sanctioned.

Totally agree with this post, except, I personally think Taylor is a truly terrible ref!

Agree - I was worried we had him tomorrrow when I saw the thread
Reply
#9
AT is decent.  He just shouldn’t referee the Manchester or Liverpool clubs given the presumption of bias.  Even tho he is an Alty fan.  

He’s miles better than the shite we get in the Champo
Reply
#10
(11-03-2023, 09:19 PM)MancBaggie Wrote: AT is decent.  He just shouldn’t referee the Manchester or Liverpool clubs given the presumption of bias.  Even tho he is an Alty fan.  

He’s miles better than the shite we get in the Champo

I can see past the crap we get at this level Manc as it just feels incompetent, in the PL it feels targeted and biased. Down here they even put.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: