Posts: 13,568
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
11-01-2023, 01:35 PM
(This post was last modified: 11-01-2023, 01:36 PM by Borin' Baggie.)
(11-01-2023, 12:53 PM)Pontificator Wrote: (11-01-2023, 11:20 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: That's like saying that Israel should be allowed to hang, draw and quarter because we did it 300 years ago.
After WWII things like the Geneva Conventions were brought in as a response to not just Axis atrocities but also Allied responses like Caen and Dresden.
No it isn't
The Bosnian War: Yugoslav government estimated that no fewer than 1,200 civilians and up to 2,500 civilians were killed and 5,000 wounded as a result of NATO airstrikes (Wiki)
Not Ok if its Israel (Jews)
Yes it is.
And, FYI, the point of the NATO airstrikes were literally to pressure the Serbian side to engage in negotiations for a ceasefire, the Dayton Agreement was drafted before the air strikes started. Are the Israeli forces invading Gaza to force a ceasefire with Hamas? Are they fuck. The whole point of NATO intervention was to force a ceasefire.
Here's the thing, you can simultaneously want aid provisions for refugees and civilians in Gaza as a priority and call out attempts to minimise that while also believing that Israel has a right to self defence and the use of proportional force (such as precision misiles on presumed military targets) in retaliation. That is not contradictory, and quite frankly I don't see independent humanitarian aid organisations being starved of resources as proportional.
As someone who has been vocally critical of Saudi Arabia doing the same thing to Yemen, who has been vocally critical of the Turks doing the same things to the Kurds, who has been vocally critical of the Myanmar junta doing the same thing to Rohingya, who has been vocally critical of what Azerbaijan doing the same thing to ethnic Armenians, as someone who has consistently criticised our intervention in Iraq, Kenya and Northern ireland yourself and Proth trying to paint this as there being double standards by people who are not rimming Netanyahu's arsehole is outright pathetic.
Posts: 6,416
Threads: 305
Joined: Aug 2022
Reputation:
28
yourself and Proth trying to paint this as there being double standards by people who are not rimming Netanyahu's arsehole is outright pathetic.
It's not just pathetic, the same as the desperate use of the anti-semitism line on repeat - it's people who are out of sane arguments and out of the ability to examine their own terrible prejudices
Someone could have been killed
Posts: 782
Threads: 40
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
(11-01-2023, 01:35 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (11-01-2023, 12:53 PM)Pontificator Wrote: (11-01-2023, 11:20 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: That's like saying that Israel should be allowed to hang, draw and quarter because we did it 300 years ago.
After WWII things like the Geneva Conventions were brought in as a response to not just Axis atrocities but also Allied responses like Caen and Dresden.
No it isn't
The Bosnian War: Yugoslav government estimated that no fewer than 1,200 civilians and up to 2,500 civilians were killed and 5,000 wounded as a result of NATO airstrikes (Wiki)
Not Ok if its Israel (Jews)
Yes it is.
And, FYI, the point of the NATO airstrikes were literally to pressure the Serbian side to engage in negotiations for a ceasefire, the Dayton Agreement was drafted before the air strikes started. Are the Israeli forces invading Gaza to force a ceasefire with Hamas? Are they fuck. The whole point of NATO intervention was to force a ceasefire.
Here's the thing, you can simultaneously want aid provisions for refugees and civilians in Gaza as a priority and call out attempts to minimise that while also believing that Israel has a right to self defence and the use of proportional force (such as precision misiles on presumed military targets) in retaliation. That is not contradictory, and quite frankly I don't see independent humanitarian aid organisations being starved of resources as proportional.
As someone who has been vocally critical of Saudi Arabia doing the same thing to Yemen, who has been vocally critical of the Turks doing the same things to the Kurds, who has been vocally critical of the Myanmar junta doing the same thing to Rohingya, who has been vocally critical of what Azerbaijan doing the same thing to ethnic Armenians, as someone who has consistently criticised our intervention in Iraq, Kenya and Northern ireland yourself and Proth trying to paint this as there being double standards by people who are not rimming Netanyahu's arsehole is outright pathetic.
No it isn't
Nevertheless civilians were killed
Why would I not agree with proportionality. And I would expect the Israelis to tell the occupants of a Hospital to leave before they flatten it with bunker busting bombs
I'll ignore the condescending, holier than thou bullshit and insult in the last paragraph
Posts: 13,568
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
Yes it is. You were literally trying to justify that Israel should be immune to criticism of proportionality because of something that happened 80 years ago ignoring all the progress made in WWII to limit things like Dresden and Caen and bring those who carry out things proportional to those things to justice.
Civilians casualties are an inevitability in modern warfare but that does not mean that they should be accepted especially when they're avoidable through access to aid provisions compared to collateral from precision air strikes. Israel having the right to defend itself and retaliate does not mean the Israeli government are immune to criticism for the proportionality or strategy of their actions. The major difference which shows that comparing NATO operations in Bosnia vs this is that the whole point of the NATO operations was to force a ceasefire based on a previously drafted amendment, where is the equivalent action from the Israeli government? The only two senior Israeli politicians that have outlined a plan over what Israel's outcome should be are Bennett and Lapid and neither are in government. We literally had the US trying to pressure the Israeli government to hold off so aid could trickle through into Gaza via Israel, were the US government holding Israel to different international standards there?
And the cheek of you to accuse anyone of being condescending and insulting after you implied that I was holding Israel to different standards (when I don't, I'm holding the Israeli government to the same standards as I hold other countries to including the UK and US) by implying I'm antisemitic in a post you directly replied to. I repeat, you are being pathetic.
Posts: 6,416
Threads: 305
Joined: Aug 2022
Reputation:
28
Bloke has the moral compass of a spider on whizz.
Someone could have been killed
Posts: 566
Threads: 1
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
4
(11-01-2023, 01:12 PM)TETLEY74 Wrote: Whether Israels actions now are right or wrong i think people have lost sight of what sparked this latest round of violence and that was the brutal murder of over a 1000 innocent Israeli citizens , by Hamas ,unarmed men women children and babies many killed in their own beds some butchered horrifically, yet i hear very little condemnation for that on here now. Israel may well have gone to far in retaliation but lets not forget what started this. It started 70 years ago and has been tit for tat ever since
Posts: 3,903
Threads: 18
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
14
(11-01-2023, 09:03 PM)Baggybenny Wrote: (11-01-2023, 01:12 PM)TETLEY74 Wrote: Whether Israels actions now are right or wrong i think people have lost sight of what sparked this latest round of violence and that was the brutal murder of over a 1000 innocent Israeli citizens , by Hamas ,unarmed men women children and babies many killed in their own beds some butchered horrifically, yet i hear very little condemnation for that on here now. Israel may well have gone to far in retaliation but lets not forget what started this. It started 70 years ago and has been tit for tat ever since
I was refering more to the current hostilities rather than the historical conflict, although it is all intrinsically linked and probably goes back even further. Seems to me there will never be lasting peace in the middle east as there never has been for centuries take the west/jews / Christianity out of the equation and the people of the middle east just squabble amongst themselves as they have always done.There has been over years an abundance of factions all wanting to stamp their ideology on others going back 2000 yers or more doubt it will ever change. This is just my onions mind from the outside looking in im sure there are folk on here who know alot more in detail than i do.
Posts: 782
Threads: 40
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
(11-01-2023, 02:48 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Yes it is. You were literally trying to justify that Israel should be immune to criticism of proportionality because of something that happened 80 years ago ignoring all the progress made in WWII to limit things like Dresden and Caen and bring those who carry out things proportional to those things to justice.
Civilians casualties are an inevitability in modern warfare but that does not mean that they should be accepted especially when they're avoidable through access to aid provisions compared to collateral from precision air strikes. Israel having the right to defend itself and retaliate does not mean the Israeli government are immune to criticism for the proportionality or strategy of their actions. The major difference which shows that comparing NATO operations in Bosnia vs this is that the whole point of the NATO operations was to force a ceasefire based on a previously drafted amendment, where is the equivalent action from the Israeli government? The only two senior Israeli politicians that have outlined a plan over what Israel's outcome should be are Bennett and Lapid and neither are in government. We literally had the US trying to pressure the Israeli government to hold off so aid could trickle through into Gaza via Israel, were the US government holding Israel to different international standards there?
And the cheek of you to accuse anyone of being condescending and insulting after you implied that I was holding Israel to different standards (when I don't, I'm holding the Israeli government to the same standards as I hold other countries to including the UK and US) by implying I'm antisemitic in a post you directly replied to. I repeat, you are being pathetic.
There have been dozens of conflicts throughout the 20th & 21st century. All of them have brought opprobrium on the parties involved, but there is a special place reserved for Israel (jews) as the demonstrations in the US and the UK illustrate perfectly. I really do not think Israel have carte blanche immunity to end Gaza although it would be understandable in the face of the October 7th atrocity. It's interesting that I have not accused anyone of being antisemitic only a failure to understand that Jews don’t count and that AS is the root. It’s a concept which Baddiel tries to explain. It reminds me of the anti-racist multicultural training that institutions received in the 80s which started out with the notion that “all white people are racist” It put the backs up of many people, they simply couldn’t cope with the idea that the institution was in fact racist, because they themselves couldn’t possibly be racist.
Posts: 6,416
Threads: 305
Joined: Aug 2022
Reputation:
28
https://twitter.com/timand2037/status/17...9KqTQ&s=19
Occasionally through all the madness, you get clarity and truth
Someone could have been killed
Posts: 5,322
Threads: 356
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
(11-02-2023, 08:13 AM)Pontificator Wrote: (11-01-2023, 02:48 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Yes it is. You were literally trying to justify that Israel should be immune to criticism of proportionality because of something that happened 80 years ago ignoring all the progress made in WWII to limit things like Dresden and Caen and bring those who carry out things proportional to those things to justice.
Civilians casualties are an inevitability in modern warfare but that does not mean that they should be accepted especially when they're avoidable through access to aid provisions compared to collateral from precision air strikes. Israel having the right to defend itself and retaliate does not mean the Israeli government are immune to criticism for the proportionality or strategy of their actions. The major difference which shows that comparing NATO operations in Bosnia vs this is that the whole point of the NATO operations was to force a ceasefire based on a previously drafted amendment, where is the equivalent action from the Israeli government? The only two senior Israeli politicians that have outlined a plan over what Israel's outcome should be are Bennett and Lapid and neither are in government. We literally had the US trying to pressure the Israeli government to hold off so aid could trickle through into Gaza via Israel, were the US government holding Israel to different international standards there?
And the cheek of you to accuse anyone of being condescending and insulting after you implied that I was holding Israel to different standards (when I don't, I'm holding the Israeli government to the same standards as I hold other countries to including the UK and US) by implying I'm antisemitic in a post you directly replied to. I repeat, you are being pathetic.
There have been dozens of conflicts throughout the 20th & 21st century. All of them have brought opprobrium on the parties involved, but there is a special place reserved for Israel (jews) as the demonstrations in the US and the UK illustrate perfectly. I really do not think Israel have carte blanche immunity to end Gaza although it would be understandable in the face of the October 7th atrocity. It's interesting that I have not accused anyone of being antisemitic only a failure to understand that Jews don’t count and that AS is the root. It’s a concept which Baddiel tries to explain. It reminds me of the anti-racist multicultural training that institutions received in the 80s which started out with the notion that “all white people are racist” It put the backs up of many people, they simply couldn’t cope with the idea that the institution was in fact racist, because they themselves couldn’t possibly be racist.
Again this is nonsense.
There really isn't a specific agenda against Israel. Again I would point you in the direction of the second gulf, where there were far bigger demonstrations against that conflict.
And I am particularly disturbed by how you connect Israel with the Jewish faith in its entirety. For one not everyone who lives in Israel is Jewish, so are they not Israelis, your posts imply this. This might give credence to those who believe Israel to be an apartheid state, not something I believe (and hope) to be the case.
Also this linking of Israel to Jewish people in general, suggests that any criticism of the state if Israel is a c is the Iriticism of the religion and therefore anti semitic. This is really dangerous, because it provides a blank cheque to whoever is the Israeli Govt of the day, to behave however they want, safe in the knowledge that any external criticism can be howled down by accusations of anti semitism.
We feel free to criticise the actions of many countries where the majority religion is Islam , and would not expect to be called islamaphobic.
I like David Baddiel, and I think he is a good example of a good faith debater. But I don't agree with his belief that Jews don't count. A study of very recent British politics would suggest they very much do count, and rightly so.
|