Posts: 8,845
Threads: 269
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
29
(10-17-2023, 01:01 PM)fuzzbox Wrote: It's not religion that is the problem.
If you took away religion, there would still be genocide and wars. In fact, the biggest atrocities so far, have had nothing to do with religion.
I'm not religious, but I'm willing to bet there are far more people who are 'moderated' by religion, than those who are turned violent by it.
If you are going to be cynical, you could argue that religion was designed by those in control as 'the opiate of the people' and that those in power general want society to stay as it is with them on top. Revolution and violent change is to be avoided at all costs because it endangers the profitable status quo. Therefore, war is to be discouraged and religion plays it part.
If you were going to be idealistic, you could argue that religion keeps many wars from starting. It's logical that nobody ever gets to hear about that because if they succeed, the newsworthy events are prevented from occuring. Ironically, by the very religion that people are blaming.
It really is a 'no-win' for religion.
If an evil man does something - he and we blame religion.
if the man is stopped or positively influenced by his religion - we don't get to hear about it.
And are much, much higher number who are just humane and happen to have a religious bent and the two elements dovetail. Of course, religion is used by the powerful to guide the weak and always has been. In WW1 and 2 people on both sides were going to war in the belief that God was with them.
Steven Weinberg — 'With or without religion, good people can behave well and bad people can do evil; but for good people to do evil - that takes religion.'
Posts: 1,987
Threads: 36
Joined: Jul 2023
Reputation:
4
10-17-2023, 01:19 PM
(This post was last modified: 10-17-2023, 01:21 PM by NewWanker.)
At nearly all religions' cores are stories of one man with 12 hangers on. The 1 man is the SUN (no typo), the 12 are the months of the year. The Sun vanished at around the same time if year, and is reborn / arises a few days later. Or put a other way, the son dies and is reborn.
Nearly all religions are based simply on the seasons and phases of the sun, even Egyptian and earlier ones followed similar patterns
Anyone interested look up Zeitgeist, I think it's freely available on YouTube etc... It goes into great detail on how nearly all of them follow the same patterns and stories, because the same patterns and stories happen every year and directly affect people's lives (or did moreso back then).
At some point some clever types realised they could monetise it, and control the populace through it. Most ancient sites are religion based, why? Because they got the power and the money, so could build the biggest and best made things, to dominate and thrust it in people's faces to control them better.
Organised religions are the old world versions of the big corporations like Apple are now. A what do we see around these mega brands? Yep, tribalism, thankfully not seemingly too violent, outside of thefts and pushing people over in shops to get the new must have.
To say that religion hasn't been involved in the biggest genocides is false, The Nazis wiped out millions of Jews. Jew is not a race, it is a religion. There is no such thing as a Jewish race, as Jews come in different colours and from different backgrounds.
Posts: 1,712
Threads: 20
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
18
10-17-2023, 01:21 PM
(This post was last modified: 10-17-2023, 01:25 PM by fuzzbox.)
(10-17-2023, 01:19 PM)NewWanker Wrote: To say that religion hasn't been involved in the biggest genocides is false, The Nazis wiped out millions of Jews. Jew is not a race, it is a religion. There is no such thing as a Jewish race, as Jews come in different colours and from different backgrounds.
It's a bit harsh to blame religion when they are the ones being targetted by a non-religious faction!!
Posts: 8,845
Threads: 269
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
29
(10-17-2023, 01:21 PM)fuzzbox Wrote: (10-17-2023, 01:19 PM)NewWanker Wrote: To say that religion hasn't been involved in the biggest genocides is false, The Nazis wiped out millions of Jews. Jew is not a race, it is a religion. There is no such thing as a Jewish race, as Jews come in different colours and from different backgrounds.
It's a bit harsh to blame religion when they are the ones being targetted by a non-religious faction!!
The first act Hitler signed was the Concord Act with the Catholic Church and his birthday celebrated by the church every year until he died. Whether he really was religious himself is almost irrelevant, the Church gave their backing to the Nazis (and fascists in Italy and Spain), the SS wore belt buckles with "Gott Mit Uns" enscribed onto them, etc, etc. and those that followed were given the impression they had God on their side. It was also easy to blame the Jews for the death of Christ, of course, without which many people wouldn't have been made to hate them as much as they did.
Posts: 1,712
Threads: 20
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
18
10-17-2023, 02:38 PM
(This post was last modified: 10-17-2023, 02:40 PM by fuzzbox.)
(10-17-2023, 01:31 PM)Fido Wrote: (10-17-2023, 01:21 PM)fuzzbox Wrote: (10-17-2023, 01:19 PM)NewWanker Wrote: To say that religion hasn't been involved in the biggest genocides is false, The Nazis wiped out millions of Jews. Jew is not a race, it is a religion. There is no such thing as a Jewish race, as Jews come in different colours and from different backgrounds.
It's a bit harsh to blame religion when they are the ones being targetted by a non-religious faction!!
The first act Hitler signed was the Concord Act with the Catholic Church and his birthday celebrated by the church every year until he died. Whether he really was religious himself is almost irrelevant, the Church gave their backing to the Nazis (and fascists in Italy and Spain), the SS wore belt buckles with "Gott Mit Uns" enscribed onto them, etc, etc. and those that followed were given the impression they had God on their side. It was also easy to blame the Jews for the death of Christ, of course, without which many people wouldn't have been made to hate them as much as they did.
That's a very unorthodox position to take. I'm not a great fan of the catholic church, but I thought it was an established fact that the catholic church was very heavily persecuted by the Nazis? Priests even had their own separate wing in Dachau!
Hitler signed many agreements whilst consolidating power. Russia and Britain spring to mind...
Whilst many Christians were Nazis, that doesn't make Nazism christian.
In fact, you could argue that the protestant church was one of the few German establishments that was able to stand up to Nazism. Hitler tried to co-opt religion by setting up the Positive Church (yes, really, that's what they called it!!) in the same way as Henry VIII did. Unlike Henry VIII, it failed.
I bet you could easily pursuade many atheists to hate, say, islam. You don't have to be religious to hate a religion.
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
(10-17-2023, 02:38 PM)fuzzbox Wrote: You don't have to be religious to hate a religion.
This is absolutely true. The only thing I have in common with a Marxist is an aversion to organised religion as a means of coercive control.
Unlike a Marxist I don't want to replace that coercive control with my own secular version.
Posts: 1,712
Threads: 20
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
18
10-17-2023, 03:45 PM
(This post was last modified: 10-17-2023, 04:34 PM by fuzzbox.)
(10-17-2023, 01:19 PM)NewWanker Wrote: At nearly all religions' cores are stories of one man with 12 hangers on. The 1 man is the SUN (no typo), the 12 are the months of the year. The Sun vanished at around the same time if year, and is reborn / arises a few days later. Or put a other way, the son dies and is reborn.
Nearly all religions are based simply on the seasons and phases of the sun, even Egyptian and earlier ones followed similar patterns
Anyone interested look up Zeitgeist, I think it's freely available on YouTube etc... It goes into great detail on how nearly all of them follow the same patterns and stories, because the same patterns and stories happen every year and directly affect people's lives (or did moreso back then).
At some point some clever types realised they could monetise it, and control the populace through it. Most ancient sites are religion based, why? Because they got the power and the money, so could build the biggest and best made things, to dominate and thrust it in people's faces to control them better.
Organised religions are the old world versions of the big corporations like Apple are now. A what do we see around these mega brands? Yep, tribalism, thankfully not seemingly too violent, outside of thefts and pushing people over in shops to get the new must have.
Meant to say, I've always liked this argument. Many say that if you obliterated all scientific books exactly the same ones would re-appear. Whereas religious books would be replaced by completely different ones. The reality - as proven by religions with striking similarities independently developing throughout time and geography - is that the religious books would be broadly the same. Not because of any divine truth, but more due to the commonality of man. This suggests religion is just a human construct borne from man's nature. (Or maybe one true god that gets off on fancy dress parties...) Therefore, any blaming of religion for our ills is missing out the real culprit - man himself. This makes the whole argument of whether religion is good or bad irrelevant. It's us and only us that are to blame.
Posts: 2,796
Threads: 22
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
17
(10-17-2023, 03:45 PM)fuzzbox Wrote: (10-17-2023, 01:19 PM)NewWanker Wrote: At nearly all religions' cores are stories of one man with 12 hangers on. The 1 man is the SUN (no typo), the 12 are the months of the year. The Sun vanished at around the same time if year, and is reborn / arises a few days later. Or put a other way, the son dies and is reborn.
Nearly all religions are based simply on the seasons and phases of the sun, even Egyptian and earlier ones followed similar patterns
Anyone interested look up Zeitgeist, I think it's freely available on YouTube etc... It goes into great detail on how nearly all of them follow the same patterns and stories, because the same patterns and stories happen every year and directly affect people's lives (or did moreso back then).
At some point some clever types realised they could monetise it, and control the populace through it. Most ancient sites are religion based, why? Because they got the power and the money, so could build the biggest and best made things, to dominate and thrust it in people's faces to control them better.
Organised religions are the old world versions of the big corporations like Apple are now. A what do we see around these mega brands? Yep, tribalism, thankfully not seemingly too violent, outside of thefts and pushing people over in shops to get the new must have.
Meant to say, I've always liked this argument. Many say that if you obliterated all scientific books exactly the same ones would re-appear. Whereas religious books would be replaced by completely different ones. The reality - as proven by religions with striking similarities independently developing throughout time and geography - is that the religious books would be broadly the same. Not because of any divine truth, but more due to the commonality of man. This suggests religion is just a human construct borne from man's nature. (Or maybe one true god that gets off on fancy dress parties...) Therefore, any blaming of religion for our ills is missing out the real culprit - man himself. This makes the whole argument of whether religion is good or bad irrelevant. It's us and only us that are to blame.
Joseph Campbell - The Masks Of God is a good reference on this point.
Posts: 1,090
Threads: 72
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
2
Is Tony Blair still a middle east peace keeper?
The man sho said removing dictators from the region would bring western style democracy
Posts: 6,454
Threads: 192
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
26
The strike on the hospital killing hundreds .... as much a war crime as some atrocities that have gone on in previous conflicts? Or not?
|