Sandwell Council Obsession Thread
#51
(10-16-2023, 01:49 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(10-16-2023, 01:30 PM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote:
(10-16-2023, 12:45 PM)Protheroe Wrote: When the Allies fought the Germans from street to street in Berlin in the closing days of WWII I don't believe there were many calls for restraint. This time the enemy in Gaza is not dis-similar, but the rules of engagement will be because the world is watching.

Huh?

Do I really have to spell it out? 

An evil fascist regime dug in amongst its own people with little regard for their welfare. Their propensity for atrocities against Jews is also similar, apparently.

Do you have any idea how bloody the Battle for Berlin was?

Even by expected standards, that is quite something.

Wow.
Someone could have been killed
Reply
#52
(10-16-2023, 02:18 PM)CaptainFantastico Wrote:
(10-16-2023, 01:49 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(10-16-2023, 01:30 PM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote:
(10-16-2023, 12:45 PM)Protheroe Wrote: When the Allies fought the Germans from street to street in Berlin in the closing days of WWII I don't believe there were many calls for restraint. This time the enemy in Gaza is not dis-similar, but the rules of engagement will be because the world is watching.

Huh?

Do I really have to spell it out? 

An evil fascist regime dug in amongst its own people with little regard for their welfare. Their propensity for atrocities against Jews is also similar, apparently.

Do you have any idea how bloody the Battle for Berlin was?

Even by expected standards, that is quite something.

Wow.

Is it? How exactly is it? Hamas is intent on the destruction of Israel. Its self-confessed tactics are no different from any other murderous regime in history.

(10-16-2023, 01:45 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: I Don't disagree with one word of your assessment on Hamas.

I would make the following observations. Sadly I see no evidence that Israel is interested in pursuing a 2 state solution.
700k settlers in the West Bank might be evidence that they are deliberately pursuing a policy that makes a 2 state solution impossible.

And I am not sure you can say that Israel does not deliberately target civilians. Clearly it does. There may be a military rational behind it, you could argue that it is necessary for Israel to defend itself, but when you bomb an area such as Gaza where you know civilians are going to be, you cannot argue that you are not targeting civilians.

Thank you. Several others seem oblivious to that.

You're right Israel has no current interest in pursuing a two-state solution. Why would they? The regime running one of your neighbours is intent on eradicating you and your nation. OK, fuck them.

Settlements in the West Bank de facto make a two-state solution impossible, but lets be clear - the increase in settlement building came after the Palestinian rejection of the two-state solution. And, I'd also refer back to my previous post about the West Bank never having been "owned" by anyone but conquistadors for the best end of 2000 years. Jordan renounced any claim on the West Bank in the Israel - Jordan Peace Treaty, washing their hands of it after defeat in 1967.

I don't read of anything like the same hand-wringing about say, the Kurds and their struggle for statehood from Turkey and Iraq. I've certainly never read anything on here about Turkish military adventures into Syria and Northern Iraq to protect their interests. Maybe its because Turks on the whole aren't Jewish (though I do know one Turkish Jew!).

I simply don't agree that Israel "clearly" targets civilians. What you're essentially saying, is that Israel should be prevented from taking military action in those areas where Hamas, by its own confession (not my words), surrounds weapons and munitions with people. I'm afraid I don't believe that is a sustainable course of action after the atrocities of just a week ago.

I'd also love someone to explain to me why a hundred thousand can march on a Saturday afternoon about Israel's action in Gaza, yet you'd be hard pressed to get more than a handful out to protest against atrocities committed by the Turkish army against the Kurds, the Chinese army against various minority groups, Egyptian terrorists against Coptic Christians and other minorities.

It almost as though Israel is held to a higher state of accountability than other states, despite it being a beacon of democracy in a sea of despotism. I can't work out why.





Oh, yes I can....
Reply
#53
You cannot bomb an ideology into submission.
Reply
#54
Ok. I’ll ask again then Dekka - what would you do to neutralise an enemy that exists only to destroy the Israeli state and its people?
Reply
#55
(10-16-2023, 05:30 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Ok. I’ll ask again then Dekka - what would you do to neutralise an enemy that exists only to destroy the Israeli state and its people?

I have no idea and the truth is no one does or they would have done it by now.
Reply
#56
Fortunately we live in a world where some have enough freedom of thought to see that there is more than one set of people here that have suffered oppression and eventually there has been a backlash. Quite a minor one in some ways when you consider the extent of occupation and humiliation they've experienced.

I did say 6 months ago what the deteriorating state of Israel was Proth and you couldn't see it. Perhaps now you can. Lead by a leader who is politically finished and about to be fighting two wars against people they have tried to suppress for a long period of time.

What a tragedy they can't all see where never ending escalation will end up

Good summary below from a Jewish Israeli who sees it for what it is

Sharone Lifshitz said: “We know that the situation for Palestinian civilians in Gaza is absolutely petrifying and horrific. We are not trying to say it’s not happening. We do also agree with the prime minister that the top of the pyramid is Hamas, a terrorist organisation that is terrorising its own population.

“I wouldn’t wish anything even on the children of those Hamas fighters. We need to bring more love, not hate into the region.”

Sagi, who grew up in Nir Oz near the border with Gaza and moved to London 22 years ago, praised the Labour MPs Dawn Butler and Stella Creasy for their help but said he had yet to hear from the government.
Someone could have been killed
Reply
#57
(10-16-2023, 03:10 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(10-16-2023, 02:18 PM)CaptainFantastico Wrote:
(10-16-2023, 01:49 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(10-16-2023, 01:30 PM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote:
(10-16-2023, 12:45 PM)Protheroe Wrote: When the Allies fought the Germans from street to street in Berlin in the closing days of WWII I don't believe there were many calls for restraint. This time the enemy in Gaza is not dis-similar, but the rules of engagement will be because the world is watching.

Huh?

Do I really have to spell it out? 

An evil fascist regime dug in amongst its own people with little regard for their welfare. Their propensity for atrocities against Jews is also similar, apparently.

Do you have any idea how bloody the Battle for Berlin was?

Even by expected standards, that is quite something.

Wow.

Is it? How exactly is it? Hamas is intent on the destruction of Israel. Its self-confessed tactics are no different from any other murderous regime in history.

(10-16-2023, 01:45 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: I Don't disagree with one word of your assessment on Hamas.

I would make the following observations. Sadly I see no evidence that Israel is interested in pursuing a 2 state solution.
700k settlers in the West Bank might be evidence that they are deliberately pursuing a policy that makes a 2 state solution impossible.

And I am not sure you can say that Israel does not deliberately target civilians. Clearly it does. There may be a military rational behind it, you could argue that it is necessary for Israel to defend itself, but when you bomb an area such as Gaza where you know civilians are going to be, you cannot argue that you are not targeting civilians.

Thank you. Several others seem oblivious to that.

You're right Israel has no current interest in pursuing a two-state solution. Why would they? The regime running one of your neighbours is intent on eradicating you and your nation. OK, fuck them.

Settlements in the West Bank de facto make a two-state solution impossible, but lets be clear - the increase in settlement building came after the Palestinian rejection of the two-state solution. And, I'd also refer back to my previous post about the West Bank never having been "owned" by anyone but conquistadors for the best end of 2000 years. Jordan renounced any claim on the West Bank in the Israel - Jordan Peace Treaty, washing their hands of it after defeat in 1967.

I don't read of anything like the same hand-wringing about say, the Kurds and their struggle for statehood from Turkey and Iraq. I've certainly never read anything on here about Turkish military adventures into Syria and Northern Iraq to protect their interests. Maybe its because Turks on the whole aren't Jewish (though I do know one Turkish Jew!).

I simply don't agree that Israel "clearly" targets civilians. What you're essentially saying, is that Israel should be prevented from taking military action in those areas where Hamas, by its own confession (not my words), surrounds weapons and munitions with people. I'm afraid I don't believe that is a sustainable course of action after the atrocities of just a week ago.

I'd also love someone to explain to me why a hundred thousand can march on a Saturday afternoon about Israel's action in Gaza, yet you'd be hard pressed to get more than a handful out to protest against atrocities committed by the Turkish army against the Kurds, the Chinese army against various minority groups, Egyptian terrorists against Coptic Christians and other minorities.

It almost as though Israel is held to a higher state of accountability than other states, despite it being a beacon of democracy in a sea of despotism. I can't work out why.





Oh, yes I can....

You absolutely nail it, brave and forthright. As I just heard on Times Radio you never heard a "but" after 911. By the time this is done over 2000 Jews will be dead including the hostages who I expect the powers that be consider already dead. 2000 people. The only thing that explains the antipathy to Israel doing what we did in WW2 is anti semitism or mealy mouthed quasi-pacifism or both. I've witnessed it in the Labour Party first hand. I listened to the debate this afternoon and some of the left wing MPs made me feel sick. You fight ideolgy and win because you are overwhelming strong. If the Palestinians don't want HAMAS they will have to sacrifice, they may be dead if they do but they're certainly gonna be dead if they don't.
Reply
#58
Yet here we have a Jew saying only the Labour party has helped him and 3000 dead Palestinian civilians.

On with the narrative though, hey.
Someone could have been killed
Reply
#59
(10-16-2023, 03:10 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(10-16-2023, 02:18 PM)CaptainFantastico Wrote:
(10-16-2023, 01:49 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(10-16-2023, 01:30 PM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote:
(10-16-2023, 12:45 PM)Protheroe Wrote: When the Allies fought the Germans from street to street in Berlin in the closing days of WWII I don't believe there were many calls for restraint. This time the enemy in Gaza is not dis-similar, but the rules of engagement will be because the world is watching.

Huh?

Do I really have to spell it out? 

An evil fascist regime dug in amongst its own people with little regard for their welfare. Their propensity for atrocities against Jews is also similar, apparently.

Do you have any idea how bloody the Battle for Berlin was?

Even by expected standards, that is quite something.

Wow.

Is it? How exactly is it? Hamas is intent on the destruction of Israel. Its self-confessed tactics are no different from any other murderous regime in history.

(10-16-2023, 01:45 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: I Don't disagree with one word of your assessment on Hamas.

I would make the following observations. Sadly I see no evidence that Israel is interested in pursuing a 2 state solution.
700k settlers in the West Bank might be evidence that they are deliberately pursuing a policy that makes a 2 state solution impossible.

And I am not sure you can say that Israel does not deliberately target civilians. Clearly it does. There may be a military rational behind it, you could argue that it is necessary for Israel to defend itself, but when you bomb an area such as Gaza where you know civilians are going to be, you cannot argue that you are not targeting civilians.

Thank you. Several others seem oblivious to that.

You're right Israel has no current interest in pursuing a two-state solution. Why would they? The regime running one of your neighbours is intent on eradicating you and your nation. OK, fuck them.

Settlements in the West Bank de facto make a two-state solution impossible, but lets be clear - the increase in settlement building came after the Palestinian rejection of the two-state solution. And, I'd also refer back to my previous post about the West Bank never having been "owned" by anyone but conquistadors for the best end of 2000 years. Jordan renounced any claim on the West Bank in the Israel - Jordan Peace Treaty, washing their hands of it after defeat in 1967.

I don't read of anything like the same hand-wringing about say, the Kurds and their struggle for statehood from Turkey and Iraq. I've certainly never read anything on here about Turkish military adventures into Syria and Northern Iraq to protect their interests. Maybe its because Turks on the whole aren't Jewish (though I do know one Turkish Jew!).

I simply don't agree that Israel "clearly" targets civilians. What you're essentially saying, is that Israel should be prevented from taking military action in those areas where Hamas, by its own confession (not my words), surrounds weapons and munitions with people. I'm afraid I don't believe that is a sustainable course of action after the atrocities of just a week ago.

I'd also love someone to explain to me why a hundred thousand can march on a Saturday afternoon about Israel's action in Gaza, yet you'd be hard pressed to get more than a handful out to protest against atrocities committed by the Turkish army against the Kurds, the Chinese army against various minority groups, Egyptian terrorists against Coptic Christians and other minorities.

It almost as though Israel is held to a higher state of accountability than other states, despite it being a beacon of democracy in a sea of despotism. I can't work out why.





Oh, yes I can....


A couple of points..again.

I thought the Palestinian authority on the West bank, had recognised the state of Israel and so were in favour of the two state solution.

I make no public judgement on Israels military operations in Gaza, I have my own opinions but i keep them to myself.Whether right or wrong they are clearly targeting civilians, to suggest otherwise is a distortion of truth.
Reply
#60
I think it's more of an inability to accept something that debases everything else Proth and others have been manipulated to believe in this case, and many others
Someone could have been killed
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)