Has the EU ended the Tory Party?
#1
Starmer can make sure no young person ever votes Tory again
If Labour deliver on their housebuilding promises, the Conservatives face a bleak future
HENRY HILL Deputy Editor, ConHome.
10 October 2023 • 11:31am

Last week, at the Conservative conference in Manchester, I addressed a fringe event on the housing crisis hosted by Centre for Cities about the housing crisis. I was asked to sum up the political situation for the Tories. This can be simply done: the abyss is gazing back.
It is difficult to overstate quite how catastrophic for the Conservatives’ medium-term fortunes this problem is going to be. Readers may be familiar with the long-term argument: that as generations of voters fail to acquire a decent home, start a family, or pass the other milestones of life which traditionally moved people rightwards, they will stick with the left. This is perfectly true.
But the problem with the long term (or the comfort of it, if you’re a Tory MP) is that it’s always a little way off. It might be very difficult being a Conservative in a generation’s time, sure – but with the average MP now serving just three terms in Parliament, why should you care? However, this already-bleak assessment ignores how the housing crisis is crushing the Tory vote in the here and now.
London, gripped by a spiralling rents and house price crisis, is trending rapidly away from the party. Seats the Conservatives won or came close to winning in 2010 now boast five-figure Labour majorities; MPs such as Theresa Villiers and Iain Duncan Smith (fierce anti-housing warriors both) won only narrowly in their traditionally-safe seats in 2019, despite a national landslide.
Worse still, the capital is now radiating angry, precarious voters into its commuter belt; in the so-called Blue Wall of once-safe shire constituencies, YouGov reveals that the average age is trending downwards, against the national trend. Where Brighton and Canterbury led, more will surely follow.
Yes, some of those voters will be moving out to buy homes. But “homeowner” is not a magical category that automatically shifts your priorities. Many of those buyers will be mortgaged to the hilt and putting up with a long commute, all to own a home smaller than their parents had at their age.
Those who won’t or can’t afford to move out face living with relatives or sharing with flatmates well into their thirties, even on good professional salaries. Why would they vote Tory?
Sir Keir Starmer clearly sees an opening here: the Labour leader has gone big on housing, at least rhetorically, pledging to build a new generation of (highly desirable) Georgian homes and even to build in parts of the Green Belt.
Of course, we will need to see how that talk comes out in the wash. But the contrast with Rishi Sunak, who didn’t even mention housing or rents once in his own keynote speech last week, is already huge.
What’s most extraordinary is that the Conservatives could have avoided this. Forget full-fat planning reform: the vast majority of the demand for housing is in the middle of our largest cities, areas which already return few if any Tory MPs. An aggressive city-centre housing programme would have gone a huge way toward solving the problem, at the cost of angering some Labour councils.
Instead, successive prime ministers have allowed Duncan Smith and Villiers – atypical MPs representing doomed London marginals – to more or less dictate the Government’s housing policy, or more rather lack of housing policy.
Starmer, on the other hand, seems to get that he will be free to put the true-blue Shires to the spade, filling them with his voters whilst the Tories howl in impotent fury from the back benches. And you know what? Good luck to him.



and Anna Soubry is voting Labour
Reply
#2
Interesting post (especially as it didn't mention the EU but all good points).

This was always going to be the way when they panicked about UKIP and saw them taking away key votes that they would need in a close election. It was the start of the end for the Tory party as we knew it (the current version is nothing like the one's of my lifetime). They allowed a minority view become their obsession but needed to put the party before the country and have paid the price.
Reply
#3
Labour have learnt the hard way that if you move away from the centre of politics in the U.K. you won’t win an election and you allow those on the radical fringes a voice to dictate the direction of the party. The Tories have done similar to appease the radical right of their party and those voters it wanted to win back off UKIP. Sadly the Tories have been in power so the damage they have inflicted due to their own petty squabbles has been to the country, hopefully now that may change and they can be fight like rats in a sack out of power sooner rather than later. The country needs positive, caring, less ideological change, it doesn’t need the Tories pretending for the umpteenth time that they are a different party from 6, 12, 24mths ago.

I hope they are out of power (I still think Labour have the ability to feck the next election up) for years, they deserve to be. Their motives for the last 13yrs have never for the good of the nation, it’s always been about them, it’s always been about scapegoating others, vindictive policies, cronyism and power for powers sake. Just look at the state of the country’s public services as proof, look at the wedge issues they created, look at the mess that Brexit caused none of this was for the county and even if you cut them some slack for the pandemic the problems were still their, their awful tactics of lying and blaming others was still at the vanguard of how they won elections and they are still damaging politics now with their populist agenda.
Reply
#4
Cameron panicking about UKIP and giving the referendum was the biggest tactical blunder he could have made. It got them a few years, but it really could put the Tories into a truly inescapable mess. This isn't the Conservative party New Labour beat, it's a hideous, almost far right wing caricature of itself. The party conference showed that, some of those speeches would have felt at home in 1930's Germany ffs.

For Democracy to work you need as many electable voices as possible, not just one or two that stick a different colour tie on. Currently that's what we're lacking, I hope if the Tories really do suffer badly, we may start towards a better democracy for us all
Reply
#5
Some of us have been saying this for years, whilst the Tory party has peddled the Derek Hardballs policy on housing development.
Reply
#6
I don't know where this idea that the Conservatives are finished comes from.

It's very likely they will be booted out of office next year, and deservedly so, but they are unlikely to be uncompetitive in the election after. Which is very scary, given the direction of travel the party is currently on.

It's why PR is a voting red line for me, if a party does not support electoral reform it's not getting my vote.

It did look for a brief moment that Labour might get behind electoral reform, but that ship has passed, mainly because they look likely to get a majority at the next election, and see no need for it now. Short sighted.

We need genuine and real choice that produces representation at parliament that is reflective of a wide range of political views, even if you really don't like some of those views, to pretendvthey don't exist is dangerous.

There is a real danger that in 2028 or 2029 we elect a very nationalistic govt that seek to restrict the ability of opposition voices to express their opinion, what I understand is describe as the Hungrification of UK politics. Such a Govt could be elected with relatively small levels of support.
Reply
#7
(10-11-2023, 02:51 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Some of us have been saying this for years, whilst the Tory party has peddled the Derek Hardballs policy on housing development.

Proth running away from the poop you took on the kitchen floor like a naughty puppy doesn’t absolve you of advocating for the worst government in living memory for a decade not to mention Brexit. 

Btw show me where I have been adverse to new towns being built? Seems better to build new towns than other solutions like the awful Black Country plan. Which was so bad I thought you might have put it together. Building on the only small pockets of green spaces in struggling working class communities in heavily built up areas, with decimated public services, failing schools, poor roads, no NHS dentists, no youth clubs etc yes I am against and always will be. Are you saying those areas and the people who already live there don’t deserve decent green spaces for leisure, recreation, health, wellbeing? Wanting to take those spaces away from working class areas and thinking that’s a solution is spoken like someone who doesn’t live in those areas, doesn’t know how much those spaces are needed and doesn’t really care.
Reply
#8
(10-11-2023, 01:48 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Cameron panicking about UKIP and giving the referendum was the biggest tactical blunder he could have made. It got them a few years, but it really could put the Tories into a truly inescapable mess. This isn't the Conservative party New Labour beat, it's a hideous, almost far right wing caricature of itself. The party conference showed that, some of those speeches would have felt at home in 1930's Germany ffs.

For Democracy to work you need as many electable voices as possible, not just one or two that stick a different colour tie on. Currently that's what we're lacking, I hope if the Tories really do suffer badly, we may start towards a better democracy for us all

Trumpish Tories. We often seem to follow America's lead and right now amongst the Conservative Party it's a hideous lurch to the right emboldened by the shameless populist rhetoric and reactionary outlook of Trump. If he can do it, so can we. Check out Braverman, Rees-Mogg and perennial hanger-on Farage for starters and the dangerous Fox News style crap endlessly promoted on GB News. Derek's description above of the current bunch of cronies in office could, by omitting the Brexit reference, be an equally apt description of the MAGA cult across the pond. Challenging times for democracy.
Reply
#9
(10-11-2023, 03:44 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: I don't know where this idea that the Conservatives are finished comes from.

It's very likely they will be booted out of office next year, and deservedly so, but they are unlikely to be uncompetitive in the election after. Which is very scary, given the direction of travel the party is currently on.

It's why PR is a voting red line for me, if a party does not support electoral reform it's not getting my vote.

It did look for a brief moment that Labour might get behind electoral reform, but that ship has passed, mainly because they look likely to get a majority at the next election, and see no need for it now. Short sighted.

We need genuine and real choice that produces representation at parliament that is reflective of a wide range of political views, even if you really don't like some of those views, to pretendvthey don't exist is dangerous.

There is a real danger that in 2028 or 2029 we elect a very nationalistic govt that seek to restrict the ability of opposition voices to express their opinion, what I understand is describe as the Hungrification of UK politics. Such a Govt could be elected with relatively small levels of support.

The Tories picked up 30% of the 18-25 vote in 2010, compared with Labour's 31% and the Lib Dems' 30%.

The only 18-24 polling done has them below the Lib Dems in the mid-teens, polling subsamples have them below 5% consistently for that demographic. They need a radical shift to entice young voters. If Labour go all in with housing as Starmer is saying, what can the Tories do exactly? They're not going to pivot to being pro-EU (even the Tory voters that are under 24 say they're in favour of rejoining) which is the only thing I can see that would be a pro-youth vote differentiator than Labour. And the older voters they've pandered to are not going to live forever. I genuinely don't see what they're going to campaign on for 2029 to bring back the demographic that hates them.
Reply
#10
This is a cracking read

https://www.theneweuropean.co.uk/the-era...-hastings/
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)