HS2
It was always destined to fail.

Cutting the train time slightly and having pay a higher price for a ticket was never going to work.

So who lives in the centre of Birmingham that would pay a higher price to travel to London? Noone. The only people who would pay a higher price would be living in Sutton Coldfield & Solihull areas and would drive to International to catch it.

I say international as that's where they'd have to park to then catch a shuttle train to the HS2 station.

Even before Covid, large firms were moving out of London to pay lower wages and lower rents of office space. HSBC retail banking HO moved out of canary wharf to Brum RBS closed 5 large offices (and has one remaining in central London) with jobs moved to India, Manchester & Edinburgh.

Whilst I was working for RBS 4 years ago, staff had to work 3 days at home, to save on office space / costs. Again, this was pre- Covid.

Covid has had the effect of more home working than there was 3 years ago.

So the writing has been on the wall for a number of years, that a fast train to London would fail, as there wont be the demand to pay higher ticket prices to travel on it.

Unless it travels into central London, then it will totally fail and fold. The time saved on the travel time to outside London will be more than negated by the travel time across London.

What a complete and utter fuck up!!!
Reply
I've only ever been able to scrape the cost of a ticket to the Albion from Stourbridge.
Tains are astronomical and never run on time.Always said there must only be a handful of people who would ever use it.
Reply
It turns out that the government spent £7m on a new golf course clubhouse in Lichfield because the old one was in the way of the non existent line https://inews.co.uk/news/golf-club-hs2-b...nt-2679981

I'd love to see the club's membership list. Although, I suspect if I asked it would just be fabricanted.
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
(10-14-2023, 09:52 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: It turns out that the government spent £7m on a new golf course clubhouse in Lichfield because the old one was in the way of the non existent line https://inews.co.uk/news/golf-club-hs2-b...nt-2679981

I'd love to see the club's membership list. Although, I suspect if I asked it would just be fabricanted.

It goes behind a paywall after I've read about 4 lines. The gist appears to be more money wasted.
Reply
(10-08-2023, 12:28 PM)Fulham Fallout Wrote: It was always destined to fail.

Cutting the train time slightly and having pay a higher price for a ticket was never going to work.

So who lives in the centre of Birmingham that would pay a higher price to travel to London?  Noone.  The only people who would pay a higher price would be living in Sutton Coldfield & Solihull areas and would drive to International to catch it. 

I say international as that's where they'd have to park to then catch a shuttle train to the HS2 station.

Even before Covid, large firms were moving out of London to pay lower wages and lower rents of office space. HSBC retail banking HO moved out of canary wharf to Brum  RBS closed 5 large offices (and has one remaining in central London) with jobs moved to India, Manchester & Edinburgh. 

Whilst I was working for RBS 4 years ago, staff had to work 3 days at home, to save on office space / costs. Again, this was pre- Covid.

Covid has had the effect of more home working than there was 3 years ago.

So the writing has been on the wall for a number of years, that a fast train to London would fail, as there wont be the demand to pay higher ticket prices to travel on it.

Unless it travels into central London, then it will totally fail and fold. The time saved on the travel time to outside London will be more than negated by the travel time across London.

What a complete and utter fuck up!!!

This is the falsehood of HS2. As I posted prior it’s a capacity solution. 

Total rail travel is 93-97% at pre-pandemic levels, commuting is just below 90%. 

We live in a Victorian rail system, near max capacity, near the point of where signalling innovation can’t add more. Worse still, our intercity lines form part of our regional railways so intercity capacity is directly linked to regional capacity 

Shifting all intercity rail (which was the plan not just HS2 rolling stock) removed huge amount of load from the East and West Coast Mainlines. This creates the ability to reorganise and create new regional rail that’s more frequent and more reliable (due to capacity limits a small issue has a massive knock on effect to reliability). 

Add to this the huge huge availability for freight, shifting from road to rail, removing lorries from roads and reducing carbon. 

£90bn isn’t buying you a quicker journey, it’s enabling a new railways system for local people. This opportunity is now gone because of short term thinking and NIMBYISM.

Those people celebrating its loss or calling it a white elephant will be the first to complain when their train is delayed or cancelled…reap what you sow.
Reply
(10-14-2023, 11:56 AM)BurleyBaggie Wrote:
(10-08-2023, 12:28 PM)Fulham Fallout Wrote: It was always destined to fail.

Cutting the train time slightly and having pay a higher price for a ticket was never going to work.

So who lives in the centre of Birmingham that would pay a higher price to travel to London?  Noone.  The only people who would pay a higher price would be living in Sutton Coldfield & Solihull areas and would drive to International to catch it. 

I say international as that's where they'd have to park to then catch a shuttle train to the HS2 station.

Even before Covid, large firms were moving out of London to pay lower wages and lower rents of office space. HSBC retail banking HO moved out of canary wharf to Brum  RBS closed 5 large offices (and has one remaining in central London) with jobs moved to India, Manchester & Edinburgh. 

Whilst I was working for RBS 4 years ago, staff had to work 3 days at home, to save on office space / costs. Again, this was pre- Covid.

Covid has had the effect of more home working than there was 3 years ago.

So the writing has been on the wall for a number of years, that a fast train to London would fail, as there wont be the demand to pay higher ticket prices to travel on it.

Unless it travels into central London, then it will totally fail and fold. The time saved on the travel time to outside London will be more than negated by the travel time across London.

What a complete and utter fuck up!!!

This is the falsehood of HS2. As I posted prior it’s a capacity solution. 

Total rail travel is 93-97% at pre-pandemic levels, commuting is just below 90%. 

We live in a Victorian rail system, near max capacity, near the point of where signalling innovation can’t add more. Worse still, our intercity lines form part of our regional railways so intercity capacity is directly linked to regional capacity 

Shifting all intercity rail (which was the plan not just HS2 rolling stock) removed huge amount of load from the East and West Coast Mainlines. This creates the ability to reorganise and create new regional rail that’s more frequent and more reliable (due to capacity limits a small issue has a massive knock on effect to reliability). 

Add to this the huge huge availability for freight, shifting from road to rail, removing lorries from roads and reducing carbon. 

£90bn isn’t buying you a quicker journey, it’s enabling a new railways system for local people. This opportunity is now gone because of short term thinking and NIMBYISM.

Those people celebrating its loss or calling it a white elephant will be the first to complain when their train is delayed or cancelled…reap what you sow.

Agreed. No fuggin foresight whatsoever. I’m sure people moaned like fugg when the London Underground was put in too.
Reply
(10-14-2023, 11:56 AM)BurleyBaggie Wrote:
(10-08-2023, 12:28 PM)Fulham Fallout Wrote: It was always destined to fail.

Cutting the train time slightly and having pay a higher price for a ticket was never going to work.

So who lives in the centre of Birmingham that would pay a higher price to travel to London?  Noone.  The only people who would pay a higher price would be living in Sutton Coldfield & Solihull areas and would drive to International to catch it. 

I say international as that's where they'd have to park to then catch a shuttle train to the HS2 station.

Even before Covid, large firms were moving out of London to pay lower wages and lower rents of office space. HSBC retail banking HO moved out of canary wharf to Brum  RBS closed 5 large offices (and has one remaining in central London) with jobs moved to India, Manchester & Edinburgh. 

Whilst I was working for RBS 4 years ago, staff had to work 3 days at home, to save on office space / costs. Again, this was pre- Covid.

Covid has had the effect of more home working than there was 3 years ago.

So the writing has been on the wall for a number of years, that a fast train to London would fail, as there wont be the demand to pay higher ticket prices to travel on it.

Unless it travels into central London, then it will totally fail and fold. The time saved on the travel time to outside London will be more than negated by the travel time across London.

What a complete and utter fuck up!!!

This is the falsehood of HS2. As I posted prior it’s a capacity solution. 

Total rail travel is 93-97% at pre-pandemic levels, commuting is just below 90%. 

We live in a Victorian rail system, near max capacity, near the point of where signalling innovation can’t add more. Worse still, our intercity lines form part of our regional railways so intercity capacity is directly linked to regional capacity 

Shifting all intercity rail (which was the plan not just HS2 rolling stock) removed huge amount of load from the East and West Coast Mainlines. This creates the ability to reorganise and create new regional rail that’s more frequent and more reliable (due to capacity limits a small issue has a massive knock on effect to reliability). 

Add to this the huge huge availability for freight, shifting from road to rail, removing lorries from roads and reducing carbon. 

£90bn isn’t buying you a quicker journey, it’s enabling a new railways system for local people. This opportunity is now gone because of short term thinking and NIMBYISM.

Those people celebrating its loss or calling it a white elephant will be the first to complain when their train is delayed or cancelled…reap what you sow.

I agree Burley, although it was very much lauded as High Speed which suggests it was never really publicised correctly. For me this is a huge failure of management, again, like any huge project we just can't get it right. We are the ultimate example of too many cowboys not enough Injuns.
Reply
(10-14-2023, 12:07 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(10-14-2023, 11:56 AM)BurleyBaggie Wrote:
(10-08-2023, 12:28 PM)Fulham Fallout Wrote: It was always destined to fail.

Cutting the train time slightly and having pay a higher price for a ticket was never going to work.

So who lives in the centre of Birmingham that would pay a higher price to travel to London?  Noone.  The only people who would pay a higher price would be living in Sutton Coldfield & Solihull areas and would drive to International to catch it. 

I say international as that's where they'd have to park to then catch a shuttle train to the HS2 station.

Even before Covid, large firms were moving out of London to pay lower wages and lower rents of office space. HSBC retail banking HO moved out of canary wharf to Brum  RBS closed 5 large offices (and has one remaining in central London) with jobs moved to India, Manchester & Edinburgh. 

Whilst I was working for RBS 4 years ago, staff had to work 3 days at home, to save on office space / costs. Again, this was pre- Covid.

Covid has had the effect of more home working than there was 3 years ago.

So the writing has been on the wall for a number of years, that a fast train to London would fail, as there wont be the demand to pay higher ticket prices to travel on it.

Unless it travels into central London, then it will totally fail and fold. The time saved on the travel time to outside London will be more than negated by the travel time across London.

What a complete and utter fuck up!!!

This is the falsehood of HS2. As I posted prior it’s a capacity solution. 

Total rail travel is 93-97% at pre-pandemic levels, commuting is just below 90%. 

We live in a Victorian rail system, near max capacity, near the point of where signalling innovation can’t add more. Worse still, our intercity lines form part of our regional railways so intercity capacity is directly linked to regional capacity 

Shifting all intercity rail (which was the plan not just HS2 rolling stock) removed huge amount of load from the East and West Coast Mainlines. This creates the ability to reorganise and create new regional rail that’s more frequent and more reliable (due to capacity limits a small issue has a massive knock on effect to reliability). 

Add to this the huge huge availability for freight, shifting from road to rail, removing lorries from roads and reducing carbon. 

£90bn isn’t buying you a quicker journey, it’s enabling a new railways system for local people. This opportunity is now gone because of short term thinking and NIMBYISM.

Those people celebrating its loss or calling it a white elephant will be the first to complain when their train is delayed or cancelled…reap what you sow.

I agree Burley, although it was very much lauded as High Speed which suggests it was never really publicised correctly. For me this is a huge failure of management, again, like any huge project we just can't get it right. We are the ultimate example of too many cowboys not enough Injuns.

It's only through reading ponners' stuff on here that I have learned about the capacity stuff and the scope of the project.  May be that I have not been alert enough but it does seem to be terrible PR and comms.
Reply
(10-05-2023, 02:24 PM)WorcsWBA Wrote: After 13 years of the Tories, and bearing in mind in particular the disgraceful chaos and incompetence of Johnson and Truss, I think that other non-extreme parties (in England at least) should get something of a clean slate.

My main wish for the next election is for the Tories to have their worst ever result, in modern times at least, to show them that their accelerating massive lurch to the right has been a drastic mistake. Such an outcome would be fully deserved.

Incidentally, I'm not sure why the Green Party is being lumped in with the main parties by implication. I can't recall them ever being anything other than honest. if there was PR, I'd always vote for them. In the next election, with the Lib Dems coming second in my constituency, I'll vote for Lib Dems if the polls at the time suggest they can potentially overturn the large Tory majority. Tactical voting still has a big part to play, so I'd encourage people to think carefully before wasting their vote.

Agree completely with your last paragraph. Tactical voting is something I've never done, I've voted Green since the late 80's as it's the only party whose policies and most of their philosophies align with my own outlook on life. If I was more of a floating voter I'd have no problem voting for a party that would remove the Tories, but I have conviction in who I vote for so don't go down that route. I view the Tories and Labour as two sides of the same devalued coin, who retain cyclical power by maintaining the cynical FPTP system and through the default small 'c' conservatism, entrenched loyalties and lack of imagination and boldness in vast swathes of the voting public. (Not) sorry if that sounds condescending but FFS, how anyone could vote Tory in the next GE after the 13 years' shitshow defies belief, whilst this Labour bunch have to be the most uninspiring version of their party ever yet are looking on course for victory. The two party hegemony is a sad state of affairs.
Reply
Green Party? Give me a break

The greens voted against and campaigned against HS2. I drive an electric car, I’ve got solar, I’m not a climate change denier.

Yet the road to net zero cannot be that all things win all the time as long as they’re virtuous. The greens were against HS2 because it went through patches of green belt and limited amounts of deforestation. They never considered the net carbon effect of HS2 to road and rail and the decarbonisation of transport that HS2 brought.

A sister lobby group none affiliated to the Green Party, splinter group - Greens for HS2, broke away form the Green Party due to their stance.

The Greens are a great example of a protest party unable to grasp the choices and realism facing us as a society to balance our required climate commitments with the need for economic stability and tough choices.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: