Posts: 670
Threads: 123
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation:
2
Palmer 7 great save in the 1st half, not much to do
Pieters 7 steady
Kipre 8 getting better and better
Barts 8 not troubled, should of been awarded a pen
Furlong 8 tireless display, great crosses
Swift 8 good goal, looked after the ball well
Philips 7 good work rate,
Okay 8 best display this season
Mowatt 8 great to see him back to his best
Wallace 7 movement was key to the goal, worked hard all night
BTA 5 no good enough, not sure if it was an off day or his finally been found out?
Subs
Townsend 6 did nothing wrong
Diang 5 not enough mins
Chabs 3 just cause everyone says he’s shit!
Sheff Weds very poor, played 11 behind the ball at all times,
embarrassing really.
CC got his tactics spot on, 2 wins on the spin and 4 out of 5 clean sheets
really look like we’ve turned a corner.
Posts: 8,841
Threads: 315
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
78
10-03-2023, 10:19 PM
(This post was last modified: 10-03-2023, 10:21 PM by Squid.)
Wallace deserves higher than a 7. The pass to set up Swift's goal was beautiful and he did everything to drag us over the line.
BTA is suffering with the pressure and having to lead the line. He works better when the opposition has the ball and he can buzz around them and be a pest and snaffle the ball.
Posts: 15,040
Threads: 339
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
93
(10-03-2023, 10:19 PM)Squid Wrote: Wallace deserves higher than a 7. The pass to set up Swift's goal was beautiful and he did everything to drag us over the line.
BTA is suffering with the pressure and having to lead the line. He works better when the opposition has the ball and he can buzz around them and be a pest and snaffle the ball.
Agree with this. BTA had an off night, he still covered the ground, made the runs and challenged all night but the ball never stuck to him once. We have little to no other option. Wallace was quality 1st half and stepped in nicely again as a makeshift no.9 at the end. It would've been nice to get a decent lead and rest a few but by 85 minutes I just wanted to see out the night with 3 points.
Stand outs were Mowatt, Swift and Okay. Furlong and Bartley making me eat my words. Best of all, the squad appear to be buying into Carlos and his ideas.
Posts: 3,903
Threads: 18
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
14
(10-03-2023, 10:44 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: (10-03-2023, 10:19 PM)Squid Wrote: Wallace deserves higher than a 7. The pass to set up Swift's goal was beautiful and he did everything to drag us over the line.
BTA is suffering with the pressure and having to lead the line. He works better when the opposition has the ball and he can buzz around them and be a pest and snaffle the ball.
Agree with this. BTA had an off night, he still covered the ground, made the runs and challenged all night but the ball never stuck to him once. We have little to no other option. Wallace was quality 1st half and stepped in nicely again as a makeshift no.9 at the end. It would've been nice to get a decent lead and rest a few but by 85 minutes I just wanted to see out the night with 3 points.
Stand outs were Mowatt, Swift and Okay. Furlong and Bartley making me eat my words. Best of all, the squad appear to be buying into Carlos and his ideas. Long may it continue ill happily eat humble pie. Still think injuries and suspensions with lack of squad depth will derail our season again , but lets just enjoy the here and now and who knows maybe we will get new owners in the not to distant.
Posts: 1,906
Threads: 31
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
14
7 for Pieters is generous. Mistake of his in the first half nearly cost us a goal and he let one bounce instead of just clearing it in the second half, which led to a mix-up between him and Palmer. On another night, those both cost of goals and we lose the game. 5 at best.
Posts: 2,927
Threads: 44
Joined: Sep 2019
Reputation:
7
I'd say some of those marks are rather generous and harsh on BTA as it was one of those nights where it just didn't happen for him but not through any lack of effort and endeavour.
It was a very good first half performance but we made very hard work of things in the second half and seemed to stop moving the ball forward quickly as we had done in the first 45. Mowatt was my MOTM, excellent performance. Bartley was very solid at the back. Phillips and Furlong got plenty of space on the wings and made things happen. Whilst it didn't always come off for Wallace, he never gave up throughout the entire game.
As for Sheffield Wednesday, it's going to be a long hard season for them. I think they're one of the poorest sides I've seen in the Championship in recent years. Moore did well to get them up on the basis of what I saw last night. Very little quality there.
Posts: 10,545
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
10-04-2023, 07:40 AM
(This post was last modified: 10-04-2023, 07:41 AM by Ted Maul.)
Palmer: one good save first half and never shuts up - 7
Pieters: let one bounce as said above, but on the ground he wins it every time and uses the ball well -7
Bartley: when told to defend first he's probably the best we've got now. Did well against a big centre forward - 7
Kipre: getting better, you can tell CC really likes him. I think it would be a big miss if we didn't extend his contract - 8
Phillips: lots of running but his lack of a left foot killed us time and time again - 7
Okay: better than recent weeks, hopefully a sign that he's playing himself into a little bit of form - 7
Mowatt: bloke was everywhere and I don't think he gave it away once. One who was unfairly tarnished with the Ismael brush, he's a good player at this level - 8
Furlong: good in the air defensively and tireless up and down the flank all night, good ball in behind for the goal - 8
Wallace: even when he's not playing well he doesn't stop running, always a bloke you want on your side and I can see why CC made him captain. Good assist - 8
Swift: took his goal really well. Would have been a 9 but loses a couple of points for some sloppiness with the ball prior to being brought off - 8
BTA: he's a great lad, will run all day and is a pain in the arse for defenders. However, against those centre halves last night he was never going to win anything and looked a bit lost at times - 6
Subs all did their bit.
Posts: 988
Threads: 43
Joined: Jul 2023
Reputation:
0
Can't believe Swift is criticised for his sloppiness when Wallace was far, far worse. Gave it away at least 7 times to put us under pressure. I really like the guy and his attitude but I don't get the other reviews, yes he works hard and never gives up.
BTA again I like him but right now he's no better than Grant was, can't control the ball, falls over, misplaces passes, misses chances (when he gets them).
Posts: 7,408
Threads: 458
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
29
(10-04-2023, 08:11 AM)1952 Wrote: Can't believe Swift is criticised for his sloppiness when Wallace was far, far worse. Gave it away at least 7 times to put us under pressure. I really like the guy and his attitude but I don't get the other reviews, yes he works hard and never gives up.
BTA again I like him but right now he's no better than Grant was, can't control the ball, falls over, misplaces passes, misses chances (when he gets them).
Sorry can’t agree Wallace in the first half was the catalyst for us winning tore there left back to pieces. Second half he was no better or worse than any of our players.
As for BTA comparing him to Grant is an insult, when did you ever see Grant put in the effort that BTA does and remember Grant came in as a 15 mill striker how much was BTA 300,000 and he kept Grant out of the side.
Being the only fit striker is taking its toll on BTA but saying he’s no better than Grant is Pathetic I know which one I would pick.
Posts: 8,841
Threads: 315
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
78
(10-04-2023, 08:20 AM)wba13 Wrote: (10-04-2023, 08:11 AM)1952 Wrote: Can't believe Swift is criticised for his sloppiness when Wallace was far, far worse. Gave it away at least 7 times to put us under pressure. I really like the guy and his attitude but I don't get the other reviews, yes he works hard and never gives up.
BTA again I like him but right now he's no better than Grant was, can't control the ball, falls over, misplaces passes, misses chances (when he gets them).
Sorry can’t agree Wallace in the first half was the catalyst for us winning tore there left back to pieces. Second half he was no better or worse than any of our players.
As for BTA comparing him to Grant is an insult, when did you ever see Grant put in the effort that BTA does and remember Grant came in as a 15 mill striker how much was BTA 300,000 and he kept Grant out of the side.
Being the only fit striker is taking its toll on BTA but saying he’s no better than Grant is Pathetic I know which one I would pick.
Correct. Comparing BTA to Grant is laughable. BTA never stops and is in the centre of everything.
|