VAR again
#1
Much as have an irrational delight in any Liverpool defeat, last nights game highlighted the inadequacy of this system.

I think the Jones red card was the right decision, but was it a clear and obvious error. Nowhere near for me. What's the point of this guideline if it's never applied.

On Jotas red card, the second yellow was probably deserved and he was an idiot for making that tackle knowing he was 9n a yellow. But the first was ridiculous. Not being able to review yellow cards is a problem if they can lead to red cards is an issue, especially when straight red cards are reviewed.

The offside goal is something else and to my mind potentially sinister. The explanation last night is plausible but stinks of incompetence. But when you see things like this happens it makes you think that the ability for var to manipulate results is there.

I would take offside decisions away from var, and give the power back to the linesman.

Actually I would scrap var altogether.
Reply
#2
(10-01-2023, 08:58 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: Much as have an irrational delight in any Liverpool defeat, last nights game highlighted the inadequacy of this system.

I think the Jones red card was the right decision, but was it a clear and obvious error. Nowhere near for me. What's the point of this guideline if it's never applied.

On Jotas red card, the second yellow was probably deserved and he was an idiot for making that tackle knowing he was 9n a yellow. But the first was ridiculous. Not being able to review yellow cards is a problem if they can lead to red cards is an issue, especially when straight red cards are reviewed.

The offside goal is something else and to my mind potentially sinister. The explanation last night is plausible but stinks of incompetence. But when you see things like this happens it makes you think that the ability for var to manipulate results is there.

I would take offside decisions away from var, and give the power back to the linesman.

Actually I would scrap var altogether.
Just get rid of VAR. It's totally unnecessary in a league. Keep it for cups.
Reply
#3
(10-01-2023, 08:58 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: Actually I would scrap var altogether.

I used to be in this camp until yesterday.

The typical extreme Bin Dippers' reaction to yesterday's events has convinced me that, after all, VAR is a vary good thing.
Reply
#4
Surely an AI program could deal with offsides? Basic decisions involved defined within strict parameters should be relatively easy to write. Interfering with play decisions could be tricky I suppose, but I guess even those could have definitions established (distance from keeper, whether within a certain field of view angle etc).
Reply
#5
If it had been Liverpool vs Burnley or Luton or (insert name of non fashionable (rich) club here....) the discussion would have got no further than jug ears and co on MotD. Because it's Liverpool, and their gurning ventriloquist's dummy of a manager, it's made GMB and BBC Breakfast.

Terrible decision, great result  Big Grin
Reply
#6
Thought it was really bizarre at the time how quickly it was resolved without any lines being drawn.

The "miscommunication" excuse makes no sense either, surely if the VAR officials thought they were giving the goal and saw the game being restarted then it's quickly apparent that a "clear and obvious error" has occured.

Is this not the literal definition of why VAR exists?

VAR should have been scrapped the second they failed to step in when that Sheff Utd goal at Seal Park wasn't awarded.
Reply
#7
(10-02-2023, 08:49 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: If it had been Liverpool vs Burnley or Luton or (insert name of non fashionable (rich) club here....) the discussion would have got no further than jug ears and co on MotD. Because it's Liverpool, and their gurning ventriloquist's dummy of a manager, it's made GMB and BBC Breakfast.

Terrible decision, great result  Big Grin

Not sure I agree with this,  well not the first paragraph. 

It's a really embarrassing screw up.

It's plausible that the var ref might have missed the linesman raising his flag for offside,, but to allow the game to start again with a free kick, not a kick off. When he saw that the ball was not being placed on the centre circle to restart the game, didn't he think that this would be a good time to tell the on pitch ref that a mighty fuck up was about to occur.

Don't think it matters which teams were involved...this is a big story.
Reply
#8
Get rid. Wank
Someone could have been killed
Reply
#9
VAR for objective decisions should be a given. As long as you can remove human error. Chips in the players boots, they have chips in their tracking bra thing already, so surely it can't be that difficult to have an offside system like the goal line review system?

Otherwise, it's clearly been shown that they can't implement it to work properly, so fuck the rest of it off.
Reply
#10
(10-02-2023, 09:45 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(10-02-2023, 08:49 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: If it had been Liverpool vs Burnley or Luton or (insert name of non fashionable (rich) club here....) the discussion would have got no further than jug ears and co on MotD. Because it's Liverpool, and their gurning ventriloquist's dummy of a manager, it's made GMB and BBC Breakfast.

Terrible decision, great result  Big Grin

Not sure I agree with this,  well not the first paragraph. 

It's a really embarrassing screw up.

It's plausible that the var ref might have missed the linesman raising his flag for offside,, but to allow the game to start again with a free kick, not a kick off. When he saw that the ball was not being placed on the centre circle to restart the game, didn't he think that this would be a good time to tell the on pitch ref that a mighty fuck up was about to occur.

Don't think it matters which teams were involved...this is a big story.

This is my point exactly, the whole point of VAR was to intervene when a "clear and obvious" error had occurred.

Surely this qualifies as clear and obvious??
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)