Posts: 11,928
Threads: 798
Joined: Oct 2022
Reputation:
50
I'd just like to point that it is simultaneously possible to to have retained your critical thinking abilities whilst presenting absolutist viewpoints on the internet.
That's nuance, FTW.
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Posts: 4,323
Threads: 139
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
11
(09-28-2023, 09:28 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: It's more complex. It's Google/Facebook algorithyms etc. News of a certain leaning is handed to us the same way as if we were looking for music- just showing what you have shown you are interested in and getting fed more and more. You then never get to hear something different.
(09-28-2023, 10:11 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: I think it’s a tad patronising to suggest people aren’t aware that they are being given choices that reflect what they read, listened to or watched previously. The idea that in previous generations people who got their news and current affairs by buying every morning the Daily Mail, Sun, Guardian and Mirror is a bit far fetched to say the least. Likewise that everyone listened intently to the other persons opinion and made ‘nuanced ffs’ arguments in reply. I’m old enough to remember that wasn’t the case at all, it was just not as easy to see millions of peoples opinions down the pub, in school, at work etc.
I was thinking along the same lines as Derek, if anything social media makes it easier to access differing opinions and see the other side of the story.
Posts: 1,399
Threads: 12
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
4
(09-28-2023, 11:08 AM)sickParrot Wrote: (09-28-2023, 09:28 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: It's more complex. It's Google/Facebook algorithyms etc. News of a certain leaning is handed to us the same way as if we were looking for music- just showing what you have shown you are interested in and getting fed more and more. You then never get to hear something different.
(09-28-2023, 10:11 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: I think it’s a tad patronising to suggest people aren’t aware that they are being given choices that reflect what they read, listened to or watched previously. The idea that in previous generations people who got their news and current affairs by buying every morning the Daily Mail, Sun, Guardian and Mirror is a bit far fetched to say the least. Likewise that everyone listened intently to the other persons opinion and made ‘nuanced ffs’ arguments in reply. I’m old enough to remember that wasn’t the case at all, it was just not as easy to see millions of peoples opinions down the pub, in school, at work etc.
I was thinking along the same lines as Derek, if anything social media makes it easier to access differing opinions and see the other side of the story.
Confirmation bias - while it may make it easier to find other opinions - many people only seek out opinions that only confirm their view of the world
Posts: 2,941
Threads: 57
Joined: Jan 2022
Reputation:
25
Well, my wife's view of the world (sadly) has become largely driven by What Doctors Don't Tell You and The Light, whilst her elderly parents' thoughts are largely shaped by the Daily Fail.
Propaganda attracts people down a particular rabbit hole from which it can become difficult to escape, partly because of deliberate inertia and partly because they are bombarded with further propaganda that reinforces the notions that attracted them to the rabbit hole in the first place, whilst continuing to add new ones into the mix. The more they're indoctrinated, the less capable of rational, discerning thought they become.
Why else would Trump still have the support of 40%+ of Americans?
Posts: 17,072
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(09-28-2023, 10:41 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: (09-28-2023, 10:11 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: I think it’s a tad patronising to suggest people aren’t aware that they are being given choices that reflect what they read, listened to or watched previously. The idea that in previous generations people who got their news and current affairs by buying every morning the Daily Mail, Sun, Guardian and Mirror is a bit far fetched to say the least. Likewise that everyone listened intently to the other persons opinion and made ‘nuanced ffs’ arguments in reply. I’m old enough to remember that wasn’t the case at all, it was just not as easy to see millions of peoples opinions down the pub, in school, at work etc.
It’s far easier to read, listen and watch articles, broadcasts and tv shows from across the political spectrum now than it was in previous generations. I like to read opposing points of view of Twitter, in the news example and despite the caricature on here I have linked to pretty much every U.K. media outlets articles sometimes in support, sometimes just to provide a different angle and sometimes just to provoke a ‘heated’ debate
My conclusion that we never used to live in an echo chamber, that we had nuanced arguments all the time and that people aren’t aware now that they are fed stuff the algorithm and company think will gain the the most clicks, viewers or listeners… is a generalisation that ahem lacks nuance. As with every generation you can seek out opinions and thoughts you don’t agree with and challenge you… whether you do or not is always up to the individual and people will always tend to flock together when they believe in the same values, that’s just human nature.
Regarding GB news they failed to uphold standards that are required by broadcasters, they had no choice but to suspend the two protagonists. It’s not difficult, it’s not about fugging nuance or about yawn cancel culture, they fell below the standards expected that’s it.
I'm happy to be patronising on this as I have a very low opinion of the general populace and think people have, by and large, got more stupid and easier to manipulate by those with half a brain. I was actually discussing this with a German corporate law barrister at the weekend, whilst he was explaining how many British firms he knows who have lost millions and jobs galore due to Brexit.
If you care to look at a political debate from 30 years ago on a TV channel you'll see people have become angrier and less willing to respect opposing views. The internet has done this. We've all become puppets of some kind, but some always
Just because a few well spoken ex-politicians, and professors all sat on comfy chairs in wobbly studios politely discussing politics did not translate into what was happening in society at the time. You’re confusing BBC buttoned up conservatism with a small c at the time with actual political events. The Miners strikes, National Front demo’s the riots up and down the country showing only too well how polarised the real debates and political discourse was in the past.
Posts: 4,323
Threads: 139
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
11
(09-28-2023, 10:41 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: If you care to look at a political debate from 30 years ago on a TV channel you'll see people have become angrier and less willing to respect opposing views.
Agree with this and the biggest difference is the intelligence of the MPs. Major, Blair, Brown etc were a world away from the current crop.
Posts: 2,941
Threads: 57
Joined: Jan 2022
Reputation:
25
(09-28-2023, 11:11 AM)strawman Wrote: Confirmation bias - while it may make it easier to find other opinions - many people only seek out opinions that only confirm their view of the world
Which is what I do. I'm not the slightest bit interested in what Brexiteers, climate change deniers and far right-wing nutters in general think, although I am concerned by the extent to which their views can (and do) influence others.
Anyone I come across on Twitter (the only social media I use) writing stuff I strongly disagree with will get blocked if I see things like "Conservative", "anti-woke", "evangelical Christian", "Brexiteer" and so-on in their profile.
Posts: 1,987
Threads: 36
Joined: Jul 2023
Reputation:
4
(09-28-2023, 11:08 AM)sickParrot Wrote: (09-28-2023, 09:28 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: It's more complex. It's Google/Facebook algorithyms etc. News of a certain leaning is handed to us the same way as if we were looking for music- just showing what you have shown you are interested in and getting fed more and more. You then never get to hear something different.
(09-28-2023, 10:11 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: I think it’s a tad patronising to suggest people aren’t aware that they are being given choices that reflect what they read, listened to or watched previously. The idea that in previous generations people who got their news and current affairs by buying every morning the Daily Mail, Sun, Guardian and Mirror is a bit far fetched to say the least. Likewise that everyone listened intently to the other persons opinion and made ‘nuanced ffs’ arguments in reply. I’m old enough to remember that wasn’t the case at all, it was just not as easy to see millions of peoples opinions down the pub, in school, at work etc.
I was thinking along the same lines as Derek, if anything social media makes it easier to access differing opinions and see the other side of the story.
Easier access, yes, actually still getting people to seek balance... no chance.
Posts: 10,272
Threads: 694
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
(09-28-2023, 11:12 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (09-28-2023, 10:41 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: (09-28-2023, 10:11 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: I think it’s a tad patronising to suggest people aren’t aware that they are being given choices that reflect what they read, listened to or watched previously. The idea that in previous generations people who got their news and current affairs by buying every morning the Daily Mail, Sun, Guardian and Mirror is a bit far fetched to say the least. Likewise that everyone listened intently to the other persons opinion and made ‘nuanced ffs’ arguments in reply. I’m old enough to remember that wasn’t the case at all, it was just not as easy to see millions of peoples opinions down the pub, in school, at work etc.
It’s far easier to read, listen and watch articles, broadcasts and tv shows from across the political spectrum now than it was in previous generations. I like to read opposing points of view of Twitter, in the news example and despite the caricature on here I have linked to pretty much every U.K. media outlets articles sometimes in support, sometimes just to provide a different angle and sometimes just to provoke a ‘heated’ debate
My conclusion that we never used to live in an echo chamber, that we had nuanced arguments all the time and that people aren’t aware now that they are fed stuff the algorithm and company think will gain the the most clicks, viewers or listeners… is a generalisation that ahem lacks nuance. As with every generation you can seek out opinions and thoughts you don’t agree with and challenge you… whether you do or not is always up to the individual and people will always tend to flock together when they believe in the same values, that’s just human nature.
Regarding GB news they failed to uphold standards that are required by broadcasters, they had no choice but to suspend the two protagonists. It’s not difficult, it’s not about fugging nuance or about yawn cancel culture, they fell below the standards expected that’s it.
I'm happy to be patronising on this as I have a very low opinion of the general populace and think people have, by and large, got more stupid and easier to manipulate by those with half a brain. I was actually discussing this with a German corporate law barrister at the weekend, whilst he was explaining how many British firms he knows who have lost millions and jobs galore due to Brexit.
If you care to look at a political debate from 30 years ago on a TV channel you'll see people have become angrier and less willing to respect opposing views. The internet has done this. We've all become puppets of some kind, but some always
Just because a few well spoken ex-politicians, and professors all sat on comfy chairs in wobbly studios politely discussing politics did not translate into what was happening in society at the time. You’re confusing BBC buttoned up conservatism with a small c at the time with actual political events. The Miners strikes, National Front demo’s the riots up and down the country showing only too well how polarised the real debates and political discourse was in the past. I see your point, but mine is more general dumbing down in the news is the issue with more sophisticated media, armed with more data, pressing the buttons.
Posts: 17,072
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(09-28-2023, 11:11 AM)strawman Wrote: (09-28-2023, 11:08 AM)sickParrot Wrote: (09-28-2023, 09:28 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: It's more complex. It's Google/Facebook algorithyms etc. News of a certain leaning is handed to us the same way as if we were looking for music- just showing what you have shown you are interested in and getting fed more and more. You then never get to hear something different.
(09-28-2023, 10:11 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: I think it’s a tad patronising to suggest people aren’t aware that they are being given choices that reflect what they read, listened to or watched previously. The idea that in previous generations people who got their news and current affairs by buying every morning the Daily Mail, Sun, Guardian and Mirror is a bit far fetched to say the least. Likewise that everyone listened intently to the other persons opinion and made ‘nuanced ffs’ arguments in reply. I’m old enough to remember that wasn’t the case at all, it was just not as easy to see millions of peoples opinions down the pub, in school, at work etc.
I was thinking along the same lines as Derek, if anything social media makes it easier to access differing opinions and see the other side of the story.
Confirmation bias - while it may make it easier to find other opinions - many people only seek out opinions that only confirm their view of the world
You can always find opposing views, you only have to look and tbh if you do, your Twitter timeline algorithm for example will throw up different opinions. It only becomes an echo-chamber if you allow it to as was always the case with traditional news particularly printed. The misconception seems to be that unless you write a reply in the neutral style of the BBC you are only seeing it from one point of view or your argument lacks ahem nuance.
|