As always - Stats / 90mins to make it easy. Figure in brackets is the percentile that they are in for each stat compared to their positional peers in the Chump, colour coded for that bit of ease in looking. Sadly Kyle doesnt have this cause he hasn't played more that 610 minutes of footy, so I have gave him a rough percentile ratings against our own players. Happy Statt-ing...
Kyle Bartley:
Non-Penalty Goals - 0.30 (95)
Shots Total - 1.48 (95)
Assists (AG) - 0 (x)
SCA - 0.44 (26)
Passes Attempted - 51.05 (40)
Completion % - 77.5% (40)
Progressive Passes - 1.92 (19)
Progressive Carries - 0 (x)
Touches in Oppo Area - 2.21 (95)
Progressive Passes Received - 0.15 (40)
Tackles - 1.03 (40)
Interceptions - 1.33 (60)
Blocks - 1.03 (40)
Clearances - 7.82 (95)
Aerials Won - 8.41 (100)
Summary - He is closest to the typical CB we have, and the only one not to be credited with an "error" this season. Has played the least amount of minutes however so these stats will level out across the board over 10 games. He does however give us the biggest presence in both boxes and keeps things steady. Must start for me in either a 2 or a 3.
Semi Ajayi:
Non-Penalty Goals - 0.14 (87)
Shots Total - 0.57 (62)
Assists (AG) - 0.14 (93)
SCA - 0.71 (42)
Passes Attempted - 57.00 (43)
Completion % - 83% (49)
Progressive Passes - 4.00 (76)
Progressive Carries - 1.14 (89)
Touches in Oppo Area - 1.00 (62)
Progressive Passes Received - 0.29 (64)
Tackles - 1.29 (49)
Interceptions - 0.71 (3)
Blocks - 0.71 (11)
Clearances - 2.00 (4)
Aerials Won - 2.86 (61)
Summary - Semi is our John Stones. He is a fantastic transitional outlet, and offensively he's as good as it gets for a CB. Some really poor defensive stats however, which shows how passive he is when it comes to facing up and defending. The stat I cant find is "recoveries" however. I am sure he would be pretty highly scoring in terms of the number of times his paces gets us out of trouble where a pass from the defensive 1/3 goes long and his long legs recover the ball before its a successful pass. I think as part of a 3 Semi has to play for his transitional ability and his Pace on recovery. As a 2, I wouldn't play him.
Cedric Kipre:
Non-Penalty Goals - 0.15 (89)
Shots Total - 0.59 (67)
Assists (AG) - 0 (x)
SCA - 0.29 (13)
Passes Attempted - 55.68 (41)
Completion % - 84.7% (61)
Progressive Passes - 2.21 (23)
Progressive Carries - 0.15 (27)
Touches in Oppo Area - 0.74 (35)
Progressive Passes Received - 0 (x)
Tackles - 1.47 (65)
Interceptions - 0.74 (5)
Blocks - 1.33 (53)
Clearances - 4.57 (71)
Aerials Won - 1.77 (21)
Summary - Cedric is a rash defender and his stats prove that, He is a decent tackler, makes dramatic clearances and is a threat at the other end with his aggression. However he struggles in the air, and notably in possession which was the main reason he was in the team. I would play Cedric in a back 2, but not in a three unless Bartley was injured of course.
Eric Pieters:
Non-Penalty Goals - 0 (32)
Shots Total - 0.68 (71)
Assists (AG) - 0 (x)
SCA - 0.68 (39)
Passes Attempted - 64.77 (63)
Completion % - 83.9% (55)
Progressive Passes - 3.92 (73)
Progressive Carries - 0.51 (57)
Touches in Oppo Area - 0.34 (9)
Progressive Passes Received - 0.51 (87)
Tackles - 1.88 (90)
Interceptions - 1.36 (63)
Blocks - 1.19 (45)
Clearances - 2.73 (13)
Aerials Won - 2.39 (45)
Summary - Erics stats say everything you would expect. A fantastic tackler, good at reading the game and nippin in and intercepting, but average in the air and in making blocks due to his lack of physicality. What is impressive about Eric is the level of progressive actions he contributes. Not only does he progressively pass. He also breaks that defensive line into midfield to receive passes well.
Conclusion:
For me it depends on shape as to the make up of the back line when all are fit.
If we resort to a back 4 I would play Bartley and Kipre, as those 2 CBs need to defend first, and be able to win challenges against the odds when balls are delivered into the box.
In a three, I would go; Ajayi, Bartley and Pieters, as we would need to progress the ball more from the back than we would with a back 2.
Kyle Bartley:
Non-Penalty Goals - 0.30 (95)
Shots Total - 1.48 (95)
Assists (AG) - 0 (x)
SCA - 0.44 (26)
Passes Attempted - 51.05 (40)
Completion % - 77.5% (40)
Progressive Passes - 1.92 (19)
Progressive Carries - 0 (x)
Touches in Oppo Area - 2.21 (95)
Progressive Passes Received - 0.15 (40)
Tackles - 1.03 (40)
Interceptions - 1.33 (60)
Blocks - 1.03 (40)
Clearances - 7.82 (95)
Aerials Won - 8.41 (100)
Summary - He is closest to the typical CB we have, and the only one not to be credited with an "error" this season. Has played the least amount of minutes however so these stats will level out across the board over 10 games. He does however give us the biggest presence in both boxes and keeps things steady. Must start for me in either a 2 or a 3.
Semi Ajayi:
Non-Penalty Goals - 0.14 (87)
Shots Total - 0.57 (62)
Assists (AG) - 0.14 (93)
SCA - 0.71 (42)
Passes Attempted - 57.00 (43)
Completion % - 83% (49)
Progressive Passes - 4.00 (76)
Progressive Carries - 1.14 (89)
Touches in Oppo Area - 1.00 (62)
Progressive Passes Received - 0.29 (64)
Tackles - 1.29 (49)
Interceptions - 0.71 (3)
Blocks - 0.71 (11)
Clearances - 2.00 (4)
Aerials Won - 2.86 (61)
Summary - Semi is our John Stones. He is a fantastic transitional outlet, and offensively he's as good as it gets for a CB. Some really poor defensive stats however, which shows how passive he is when it comes to facing up and defending. The stat I cant find is "recoveries" however. I am sure he would be pretty highly scoring in terms of the number of times his paces gets us out of trouble where a pass from the defensive 1/3 goes long and his long legs recover the ball before its a successful pass. I think as part of a 3 Semi has to play for his transitional ability and his Pace on recovery. As a 2, I wouldn't play him.
Cedric Kipre:
Non-Penalty Goals - 0.15 (89)
Shots Total - 0.59 (67)
Assists (AG) - 0 (x)
SCA - 0.29 (13)
Passes Attempted - 55.68 (41)
Completion % - 84.7% (61)
Progressive Passes - 2.21 (23)
Progressive Carries - 0.15 (27)
Touches in Oppo Area - 0.74 (35)
Progressive Passes Received - 0 (x)
Tackles - 1.47 (65)
Interceptions - 0.74 (5)
Blocks - 1.33 (53)
Clearances - 4.57 (71)
Aerials Won - 1.77 (21)
Summary - Cedric is a rash defender and his stats prove that, He is a decent tackler, makes dramatic clearances and is a threat at the other end with his aggression. However he struggles in the air, and notably in possession which was the main reason he was in the team. I would play Cedric in a back 2, but not in a three unless Bartley was injured of course.
Eric Pieters:
Non-Penalty Goals - 0 (32)
Shots Total - 0.68 (71)
Assists (AG) - 0 (x)
SCA - 0.68 (39)
Passes Attempted - 64.77 (63)
Completion % - 83.9% (55)
Progressive Passes - 3.92 (73)
Progressive Carries - 0.51 (57)
Touches in Oppo Area - 0.34 (9)
Progressive Passes Received - 0.51 (87)
Tackles - 1.88 (90)
Interceptions - 1.36 (63)
Blocks - 1.19 (45)
Clearances - 2.73 (13)
Aerials Won - 2.39 (45)
Summary - Erics stats say everything you would expect. A fantastic tackler, good at reading the game and nippin in and intercepting, but average in the air and in making blocks due to his lack of physicality. What is impressive about Eric is the level of progressive actions he contributes. Not only does he progressively pass. He also breaks that defensive line into midfield to receive passes well.
Conclusion:
For me it depends on shape as to the make up of the back line when all are fit.
If we resort to a back 4 I would play Bartley and Kipre, as those 2 CBs need to defend first, and be able to win challenges against the odds when balls are delivered into the box.
In a three, I would go; Ajayi, Bartley and Pieters, as we would need to progress the ball more from the back than we would with a back 2.
"IMO of course..."


