Posts: 9,603
Threads: 515
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
09-24-2023, 11:57 AM
(This post was last modified: 09-24-2023, 12:00 PM by Lurker#3.)
I am seeing a lot of people saying the formation isn't right and we need to back to a back 4. What are people's reasons for that?
I think a back 4, when you are nervous defensively quickly becomes a back 6 with your wingers. This is why I prefer a 3. It means you naturally have another player to stay up the pitch, whether that be your second forward, or the 2 #10s.
I think the issue is, as I have mentioned a number of times the attributes and tendancies of the players within the line up. We got the balance much better v Millwall, and with time those #10s should have more of an impact. I think it's absolutely vital that we always have one of either Grady or Sarmiento on the pitch. They are the players that draw defenders towards them, take it on the half turn and are able to manipulate the ball in tight areas.
Tactics wise. Second half it was obvious that CC finally instructed his wingbacks to start higher and wider. This is really vital. It's not so important they act as wingers on the ball, but off it they need to stretch and widen the pitch, rather than stay deep and square making a flat 5.
If we play a back 4. We can only get away with having 1 holder. We would need swift in a deeper role to link the game and act as that extra offensive transitional player as we would naturally have a square and defensive back 4.
For me, either shapes can work, as to be honest it's not about formation, rather the approach.
Back 4:
Palmer
Furlong Ajayi Bartley Townsend
Okay
Wallace Swift Sarmiento Grady
BTA
Back 3:
Palmer
Ajayi Bartley Pieters
Phillips Mowatt Okay Townsend
Sarmiento Grady
BTA
Both of the above has a similar "balance" to it. Neither are overly offensive but not defensive. But the 4 would result in Grady and Wallace being dragged back to support the full backs who in turn are concerned about their CBs being exposed so narrow up. I personally think having the extra CB is the way to go. But balancing out the line up ahead of them and getting at least one of those 2 CMs and wingbacks to break lines is key. Then you can swap between a front 2 (when we have 2 CFs), and a #9 and 2 #10s depending on who we are playing. 2 CFs in this shape is often a more conservative shape given when you play 2 #10s you tend to have 3 "forwards" on the pitch.
"IMO of course..."
Posts: 180
Threads: 0
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
0
Honestly the only reason I think we'd be better off switching to a back four is because there is no combination of centre backs, as a two or a three, that won't concede goals at this level. Despite two clean sheets in the last week, most games this season we've needed to score 3 to win.
So I'd go to a back 4, and bring in an extra midfielder to try and get more players in the box. At one point Asante was whipping a cross into no-one yesterday, because if he's not there we don't fill the gap.
"I'm not a nerd Bart. Nerds are smart"
Posts: 15,277
Threads: 273
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
57
I've been trying to find a quote from, I'm sure it was Guardiola, but now I think it could be Mourinho when a journalist asked about the formation he went with, and they said that the journalist spent more time thinking about the formation than he did as a manager. Formation doesn't really mean anything, it's shape, mentality and the roles players are asked to play at different stages of play that matter.
4-5-1 can be defensive, or it can be ultra attacking by having one sitting midfielder and the other 4 getting forward using two attacking wingers, the other has a flat 5 that worries about creating a defensive and controlling line, the lone forward is a target man winning set pieces. Both are 4-5-1, and both have utterly different game plans.
The issue we have, and I've said a lot, is that our squad has been built without any thought to a tactical style, so not a lot mixes well. We have some good players, but the players that complement them, aren't there. Wallace needs a target man to fire crosses too, we don't have one, Yokuslu needs a centre back that will come and build a fulcrum with him so he can let the other midfielder go and marauder around the pitch pulling defenders around for the attack to benefit, we don't have that now O'Shea has gone. Phillips is a powerful, technically good wide player with the ability to score goals, we need him to sit back far more than he should. Grady needs another player who shifts position a lot that creates space for him to run into and take on players not expecting it, no one else does anything like that, maybe Sarimento.
The constant tinkering by CC suggests to me he is very aware of this and trying to find makeshift solutions to these problems, and I think he'll find it, the second halves of games, where we've been able to settle down and get into our game, we've done well, which is a good sign.
Posts: 9,603
Threads: 515
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
(09-24-2023, 05:48 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: I've been trying to find a quote from, I'm sure it was Guardiola, but now I think it could be Mourinho when a journalist asked about the formation he went with, and they said that the journalist spent more time thinking about the formation than he did as a manager. Formation doesn't really mean anything, it's shape, mentality and the roles players are asked to play at different stages of play that matter.
4-5-1 can be defensive, or it can be ultra attacking by having one sitting midfielder and the other 4 getting forward using two attacking wingers, the other has a flat 5 that worries about creating a defensive and controlling line, the lone forward is a target man winning set pieces. Both are 4-5-1, and both have utterly different game plans.
The issue we have, and I've said a lot, is that our squad has been built without any thought to a tactical style, so not a lot mixes well. We have some good players, but the players that complement them, aren't there. Wallace needs a target man to fire crosses too, we don't have one, Yokuslu needs a centre back that will come and build a fulcrum with him so he can let the other midfielder go and marauder around the pitch pulling defenders around for the attack to benefit, we don't have that now O'Shea has gone. Phillips is a powerful, technically good wide player with the ability to score goals, we need him to sit back far more than he should. Grady needs another player who shifts position a lot that creates space for him to run into and take on players not expecting it, no one else does anything like that, maybe Sarimento.
The constant tinkering by CC suggests to me he is very aware of this and trying to find makeshift solutions to these problems, and I think he'll find it, the second halves of games, where we've been able to settle down and get into our game, we've done well, which is a good sign.
Agree entirely pal.
Funnily enough I think the squad is built best for getting forward and trying to dominate games.
Molumby and Okay are better when we press high and they have that responsibility to hold the middle of the pitch together. Our defenders are probably as a whole best when defending desperately and on the cover, especially Ajayi, Kipre and Furlong as they all have pace and power and aggression in varying amounts.
We do have a plethora of attacking midfielders and wingers. So we need to use them.
I wouldn't be against going back to a 4. But I would want the rest of the team flooded with attacking players who are given licence to roam and be instinctive.
"IMO of course..."
Posts: 15,277
Threads: 273
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
57
Well I certainly wouldn't ask this team to sit back and defend, I don't trust any of them defensively.
Posts: 9,603
Threads: 515
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
(09-24-2023, 04:59 PM)Fall Out Boy Wrote: Honestly the only reason I think we'd be better off switching to a back four is because there is no combination of centre backs, as a two or a three, that won't concede goals at this level. Despite two clean sheets in the last week, most games this season we've needed to score 3 to win.
So I'd go to a back 4, and bring in an extra midfielder to try and get more players in the box. At one point Asante was whipping a cross into no-one yesterday, because if he's not there we don't fill the gap.
Makes sense mate. As I say it's how we set up the 6 players ahead of the back four. You can't get away with a double pivot as our fullbacks are not attacking enough (Pipa hasn't been seen yet). We really need to take the brakes off the offensive players in the team, and allow them flexibility and trust those players to do their job. And try and play as much of the game in the oppos half so we get time to counter press when needed.
"IMO of course..."
Posts: 15,040
Threads: 339
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
93
Unfortunately, we just ain't good enough. The sale of (by far) our best defender leaves us with some real average to poor choices for regulars. This combined with a huge amount of bad luck with forwards leaves whoever is in charge with a problem trying to get the best tune out of them. We have a few decent at this level types but no Jason Roberts, Lee Hughes. Superkev/Bob and no Big Dave, Gilly, Siggy at t'other end. No out and out stars at this level and simply too many poor players.
Posts: 4,002
Threads: 162
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
25
4231 for me with this group. Midfield 3 with Swift at the front of the triangle, he should be supporting BTA and running on behind him in that position, but that’s not really his game. We don’t have that in the squad.
Despite that I still think it’s our best system. Makes use of the wide players better and the full backs can push up, centre backs split and OK becomes a 3rd centre back when necessary.
It’s how we played in our good run last season.
Regardless of the system we don’t have a focal point to our attack, BTA is a wasp of a player, but he’s not the leader of a front line.
Too many different managers, playing different styles, have put this squad together. That comes from the lack of a DoF.
Trump is a Cunt
Posts: 7,971
Threads: 254
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
(09-24-2023, 08:03 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: 4231 for me with this group. Midfield 3 with Swift at the front of the triangle, he should be supporting BTA and running on behind him in that position, but that’s not really his game. We don’t have that in the squad.
Despite that I still think it’s our best system. Makes use of the wide players better and the full backs can push up, centre backs split and OK becomes a 3rd centre back when necessary.
It’s how we played in our good run last season.
Regardless of the system we don’t have a focal point to our attack, BTA is a wasp of a player, but he’s not the leader of a front line.
Too many different managers, playing different styles, have put this squad together. That comes from the lack of a DoF.
First 3 paragraphs spot on.
The spare man should be in midfield. Not back 3
The 2 full backs are not wing backs
When MP plays there we are weaker defensively and he’s ineffective that deep
No point playing wingers as no 10s.
We have got 4 wingers. Play them on their correct sides
Swift has started scoring. Tell him to bust a gut and hit the penalty spot. Like he did on debut
Posts: 6,416
Threads: 305
Joined: Aug 2022
Reputation:
28
Who on here reckons we have any realistic chance of making top 6? Whatever formation we play
Someone could have been killed
|