Posts: 15,277
Threads: 273
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
57
(09-13-2023, 09:53 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: I can't summon up a whit of sympathy for Harry Maguire. He's never been as good as the hype - that's the fault of the game, the way players are rated for their transfer fees not their actual ability or performance. It's bullshit when people say "form is temporary, class is permanent", but players like Maguire, John Stones and Michael Keane seem to prove that "ability is important but transfer fees are more important".
So Harry's basic lack of talent has found him out. If he weren't so feckin' arrogant, he'd make a move and play some football, play himself back into credibility. Instead of which he's backing himself to turn things around at Man Utd (never going to happen) and Southgate is piling the pressure on him by picking him for England when he shouldn't even be in the squad. Sad but also a bit funny.
And by the way, Duffers, we aren't here because people have been having a go at Maguire for years. We're here because Maguire isn't as good as everyone thought he was, wanted him to be and were determined to believe he was. Only two people still have the belief, Harry and Gareth Southgate.
Maguire, he's another Johnny Evans level defender, fantastic at mid-table clubs where the team plays more conservatively, however expected to push up, be more dynamic with and without the ball, and deficiences are shown heavily. I do think he was stupid not to go to West Ham, Moyes would have him back to being a fantastic Central Defender again, focusing on his strengths and not exposing his weaknesses. Is it arrogance? Or was it simply the fact Man Utd pay him far, far too much, would you halve your wages just so you can drop a level to look better at your job? He knows Man Utd probably won't renew that contract, he can step down then, with a massive signing-on bonus and more years earning more. He shouldn't be playing for England perhaps, but he has also rarely let Southgate down, so Southgate trusts him, maybe too much.
This is my point on Southgate, he's been the best England manager in my lifetime, considering I was cheering Germany on as they slaughtered us in a World Cup because we were a team of detestable, underachieving, lazy cunts, yet now I watch England again, I cheer them on, get fully involved in talking about them again, and we've done well under him. However he's hit that point now, when some of the players he bought in, and have been key for him, are on the downward slope, and need to move on, and I'm not sure he's ready to ditch them yet. Something I can totally understand, and why I think after the Euros it's time he stepped aside, whatever happens.
Posts: 27,981
Threads: 1,168
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
64
(09-14-2023, 04:18 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (09-13-2023, 09:53 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: I can't summon up a whit of sympathy for Harry Maguire. He's never been as good as the hype - that's the fault of the game, the way players are rated for their transfer fees not their actual ability or performance. It's bullshit when people say "form is temporary, class is permanent", but players like Maguire, John Stones and Michael Keane seem to prove that "ability is important but transfer fees are more important".
So Harry's basic lack of talent has found him out. If he weren't so feckin' arrogant, he'd make a move and play some football, play himself back into credibility. Instead of which he's backing himself to turn things around at Man Utd (never going to happen) and Southgate is piling the pressure on him by picking him for England when he shouldn't even be in the squad. Sad but also a bit funny.
And by the way, Duffers, we aren't here because people have been having a go at Maguire for years. We're here because Maguire isn't as good as everyone thought he was, wanted him to be and were determined to believe he was. Only two people still have the belief, Harry and Gareth Southgate.
Maguire, he's another Johnny Evans level defender, fantastic at mid-table clubs where the team plays more conservatively, however expected to push up, be more dynamic with and without the ball, and deficiences are shown heavily. I do think he was stupid not to go to West Ham, Moyes would have him back to being a fantastic Central Defender again, focusing on his strengths and not exposing his weaknesses. Is it arrogance? Or was it simply the fact Man Utd pay him far, far too much, would you halve your wages just so you can drop a level to look better at your job? He knows Man Utd probably won't renew that contract, he can step down then, with a massive signing-on bonus and more years earning more. He shouldn't be playing for England perhaps, but he has also rarely let Southgate down, so Southgate trusts him, maybe too much.
This is my point on Southgate, he's been the best England manager in my lifetime, considering I was cheering Germany on as they slaughtered us in a World Cup because we were a team of detestable, underachieving, lazy cunts, yet now I watch England again, I cheer them on, get fully involved in talking about them again, and we've done well under him. However he's hit that point now, when some of the players he bought in, and have been key for him, are on the downward slope, and need to move on, and I'm not sure he's ready to ditch them yet. Something I can totally understand, and why I think after the Euros it's time he stepped aside, whatever happens.
Only other option was Tomori and for whatever reason Southgate doesn't seem to trust him.
As I said in the match thread the other night, Maguire feels like Southgate's safety blanket. He'd gone for a younger, more experimental two to begin with in Guehi and Dunk (both of whom played well). Half time comes, they're 2-0 up and Guehi has picked up a knock, the logical option given it's a friendly would be to give Tomori a run, but Southgate chooses to go with what he thought was the safer option.
Henderson definitely needs moving on. Phillips can stay as he played pretty well the other night.
It'll be interesting to see whether Maguire keeps his place if he's still not getting game time once Stones and Mings are fit and Levi Colwill has had a few more Chelsea games.
Posts: 15,277
Threads: 273
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
57
Lewis Dunk is 31. Hardly young.
He should have had more caps by now considering how great he's been for Brighton tbf.
Posts: 27,981
Threads: 1,168
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
64
(09-14-2023, 05:10 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Lewis Dunk is 31. Hardly young.
He should have had more caps by now considering how great he's been for Brighton tbf.
31??? Good lord! Thought he was mid-20's or something.
Posts: 15,277
Threads: 273
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
57
Like GMac, he's peaked really late so he has probably 5-6 years in him yet.
Posts: 27,981
Threads: 1,168
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
64
You'd imagine Stones is first choice once fit again. So it's him plus one of Guehi, Dunk, Maguire, Tomori or Colwill for the Euros.
|