WBAUnofficial
Maguire - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Maguire (/showthread.php?tid=31181)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5


Maguire - Duffers - 09-13-2023

Just reading Southgate's defence of him in light of all the abuse and criticism he receives and he has a point. The abuse and treatment he gets is pretty disgraceful.

I'm sure some will say "yeah but he's shit" or "yeah but he gets paid loads" but it can't be easy stepping onto the pitch knowing that every online edgelord and banter merchant is waiting for you to slip up so they can turn you into another meme. I challenge anyone to enjoy life knowing that you're being mocked and derided by seemingly millions of people just for trying to do your job.

Maguire's worst crime (other than that one in Greece) is not being an elite level defender. Put him somewhere like West Ham with greatly reduced pressure and he'd be just fine. Should he have cost £75m? Absolutely not? Should he be starting for England without playing domestically? Absolutely not. Should he receive the treatment he does because of these things? Absolutely not.

https://www.theguardian.com/football/2023/sep/12/southgate-backs-england-stalwart-maguire-after-own-goal-against-scotland


RE: Maguire - Woodman scoreboard - 09-13-2023

(09-13-2023, 08:39 AM)Duffers Wrote: Just reading Southgate's defence of him in light of all the abuse and criticism he receives and he has a point. The abuse and treatment he gets is pretty disgraceful.

I'm sure some will say "yeah but he's shit" or "yeah but he gets paid loads" but it can't be easy stepping onto the pitch knowing that every online edgelord and banter merchant is waiting for you to slip up so they can turn you into another meme. I challenge anyone to enjoy life knowing that you're being mocked and derided by seemingly millions of people just for trying to do your job.

Maguire's worst crime (other than that one in Greece) is not being an elite level defender. Put him somewhere like West Ham with greatly reduced pressure and he'd be just fine. Should he have cost £75m? Absolutely not? Should he be starting for England without playing domestically? Absolutely not. Should he receive the treatment he does because of these things? Absolutely not.

https://www.theguardian.com/football/2023/sep/12/southgate-backs-england-stalwart-maguire-after-own-goal-against-scotland

nobody is having a go at maguire on this one they know he is struggling they are angry at southgate for putting him in this position .


RE: Maguire - Duffers - 09-13-2023

(09-13-2023, 08:42 AM)Woodman scoreboard Wrote:
(09-13-2023, 08:39 AM)Duffers Wrote: Just reading Southgate's defence of him in light of all the abuse and criticism he receives and he has a point. The abuse and treatment he gets is pretty disgraceful.

I'm sure some will say "yeah but he's shit" or "yeah but he gets paid loads" but it can't be easy stepping onto the pitch knowing that every online edgelord and banter merchant is waiting for you to slip up so they can turn you into another meme. I challenge anyone to enjoy life knowing that you're being mocked and derided by seemingly millions of people just for trying to do your job.

Maguire's worst crime (other than that one in Greece) is not being an elite level defender. Put him somewhere like West Ham with greatly reduced pressure and he'd be just fine. Should he have cost £75m? Absolutely not? Should he be starting for England without playing domestically? Absolutely not. Should he receive the treatment he does because of these things? Absolutely not.

https://www.theguardian.com/football/2023/sep/12/southgate-backs-england-stalwart-maguire-after-own-goal-against-scotland

nobody is having a go at maguire on this one they know he is struggling they are angry at southgate for putting him in this position .

People have been having a go at him for years, it's how we've ended up here.


RE: Maguire - Squid - 09-13-2023

All true, but why did Southgate select him when he's not even playing regularly?


RE: Maguire - Duffers - 09-13-2023

(09-13-2023, 08:43 AM)Squid Wrote: All true, but why did Southgate select him when he's not even playing regularly?

A fair and valid question.


RE: Maguire - Pipes of Peace - 09-13-2023

he needs to go and play football out of the spotlight for a while. getting away from united is possibly the best thing he could do.


RE: Maguire - Shabby Russian - 09-13-2023

(09-13-2023, 08:44 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(09-13-2023, 08:43 AM)Squid Wrote: All true, but why did Southgate select him when he's not even playing regularly?

A fair and valid question.

Well it is and it isn't. 

So many excellent players are at a handful of clubs, it's perfectly possible that a player might not be playing regularly fir their club, but still be by a long way the best player for their country.

Zinchenko is an example of this, was by no means a first choice pick for City, Ukraine would always pick him if available. 

Should Maguire be starting for England now...certainly there is more viable competition now for his position, and I doubt he would be starting if Stones was fit.

But it is still the case, England have had a consistent run of good results and performances with Maguire in central defence, 3 good tournaments (in my opinion  other opinions are no doubt available) . Not sure what all the hulaboo is about.


RE: Maguire - Duffers - 09-13-2023

(09-13-2023, 09:06 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(09-13-2023, 08:44 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(09-13-2023, 08:43 AM)Squid Wrote: All true, but why did Southgate select him when he's not even playing regularly?

A fair and valid question.

Well it is and it isn't. 

So many excellent players are at a handful of clubs, it's perfectly possible that a player might not be playing regularly fir their club, but still be by a long way the best player for their country.

Zinchenko is an example of this, was by no means a first choice pick for City, Ukraine would always pick him if available. 

Should Maguire be starting for England now...certainly there is more viable competition now for his position, and I doubt he would be starting if Stones was fit.

But it is still the case, England have had a consistent run of good results and performances with Maguire in central defence, 3 good tournaments (in my opinion  other opinions are no doubt available) . Not sure what all the hulaboo is about.

I can see the argument for sticking with consistency, as you say Maguire has largely been solid in England shirt for years now. Plus injuries to Stones and Mings mean we aren't well stocked at CB right now, there's certainly no argument against including him in the squad.

Furthermore it's worth remembering that Dunk/Guehi started the match and had Guehi not picked up a knock they probably would have played well into the second half.

Purely from a footballing perspective though I'm not sure what benefits there are to bringing on Maguire at HT when you're 2-0 up in a friendly. Why not give Tomori a go?


RE: Maguire - Pipes of Peace - 09-13-2023

(09-13-2023, 09:13 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(09-13-2023, 09:06 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(09-13-2023, 08:44 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(09-13-2023, 08:43 AM)Squid Wrote: All true, but why did Southgate select him when he's not even playing regularly?

A fair and valid question.

Well it is and it isn't. 

So many excellent players are at a handful of clubs, it's perfectly possible that a player might not be playing regularly fir their club, but still be by a long way the best player for their country.

Zinchenko is an example of this, was by no means a first choice pick for City, Ukraine would always pick him if available. 

Should Maguire be starting for England now...certainly there is more viable competition now for his position, and I doubt he would be starting if Stones was fit.

But it is still the case, England have had a consistent run of good results and performances with Maguire in central defence, 3 good tournaments (in my opinion  other opinions are no doubt available) . Not sure what all the hulaboo is about.

I can see the argument for sticking with consistency, as you say Maguire has largely been solid in England shirt for years now. Plus injuries to Stones and Mings mean we aren't well stocked at CB right now, there's certainly no argument against including him in the squad.

Furthermore it's worth remembering that Dunk/Guehi started the match and had Guehi not picked up a knock they probably would have played well into the second half.

Purely from a footballing perspective though I'm not sure what benefits there are to bringing on Maguire at HT when you're 2-0 up in a friendly. Why not give Tomori a go?

its this blinkered approach that will blight the legacy of Southgate, if he doesn't win something.


RE: Maguire - Fido - 09-13-2023

(09-13-2023, 09:13 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(09-13-2023, 09:06 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(09-13-2023, 08:44 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(09-13-2023, 08:43 AM)Squid Wrote: All true, but why did Southgate select him when he's not even playing regularly?

A fair and valid question.

Well it is and it isn't. 

So many excellent players are at a handful of clubs, it's perfectly possible that a player might not be playing regularly fir their club, but still be by a long way the best player for their country.

Zinchenko is an example of this, was by no means a first choice pick for City, Ukraine would always pick him if available. 

Should Maguire be starting for England now...certainly there is more viable competition now for his position, and I doubt he would be starting if Stones was fit.

But it is still the case, England have had a consistent run of good results and performances with Maguire in central defence, 3 good tournaments (in my opinion  other opinions are no doubt available) . Not sure what all the hulaboo is about.

I can see the argument for sticking with consistency, as you say Maguire has largely been solid in England shirt for years now. Plus injuries to Stones and Mings mean we aren't well stocked at CB right now, there's certainly no argument against including him in the squad.

Furthermore it's worth remembering that Dunk/Guehi started the match and had Guehi not picked up a knock they probably would have played well into the second half.

Purely from a footballing perspective though I'm not sure what benefits there are to bringing on Maguire at HT when you're 2-0 up in a friendly. Why not give Tomori a go?

That’s the most salient point at the end.