ulez vigilantes
(09-10-2023, 12:12 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(09-10-2023, 11:56 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(09-10-2023, 11:52 AM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(09-10-2023, 11:41 AM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote:
(09-10-2023, 09:20 AM)Tom Joad Wrote: I intended to let this lie as we all appear convinced to our own opinion. But yesterday I needed a quick visit to a couple of our maintenance sites so I jumped in Mrs Joad's car rather than the van. I left the site at  Bourneville en route for between Lichfield/ Sutton Coldfield, A38 all the way, through the city centre (I'm not normally allowed) in tunnels. Never needed to change down, 4th and 5th all the way, no lights, roundabouts and I guess, little pollution. One side of the city to the other in about 35 minutes. This week I'll need to make the same journey but with a van full of gear. It will involve a detour to avoid ULEZ, round the ring road and queueing at traffic lights, filters, roundabouts. An hours drive. Now I am now toying with the idea of simply paying the charge and making up with more time working. Also, if I'd chosen to go in my relatives 6ltr AMG, we would be allowed in the ULEZ zone anyway. None of this makes sense to me.
You make sensible points which need response from decision makers.
But the overriding issue is, do we want to breathe in clean air?
The rest is details.

Except I maintain the air is cleaner by driving through the tunnels, straight through town in 5th gear, than all that queuing on the middle ring road on the outskirts. It's a badly thought out, box ticking policy. IMO.

Except the report that UoB produced (that Proth misrepresented) disagrees, reduced in the CAZ and no increased effect outside the CAZ after just 7 months.

I know people working on this at the uni and every time they bring it up they say it's empirically working.

There's no reduction in PM2.5 - the pollutant with the greatest health effects in the CAZ. You've made your own misrepresentation there.

So how is it "empirically working" if it's failing to reduce the most most harmful pollutant?

Because there was a  measured reduction in one of the key target pollutants that was assessed to be statistically significant after just 7 months with no increase outside the area of the CAZ and a non-significant decrease in PM. That is empirical data that backs up the measures working in reducing NOx.

Do you want to take your misinterpretation of the report up with the authors?
Reply
I'm sorry BB, then it's "empirically working", apparently, to reduce one pollutant (by not much) that is far from the worst pollutant. The blanket statement "it's empirically working" is simply incorrect.

I don't need to take it up with the authors when they've stated it themselves.

"Our work provides the first comprehensive evaluation of the Birmingham Clean Air Zone, an internationally significant policy to improve urban air quality in the UK’s second city. As predicted, Birmingham’s CAZ reduced NO2 pollution, but it has no detectable impact in the concentrations of fine particles, PM2.5 – the air pollutant with greatest health effects."
Dr Bowen Liu - assistant professor, University of Birmingham
Reply
Your definition of "not much" is entirely subjective, the fact is it that the report is explicit in the significant reduction of NOx and it is consistently referenced as such. That implies that it has breached the baseline reduction in order for it to be considered a significant reduction, and that implication is due to the definition of significant in the context of statistical analysis. As much as you contend with the definition of significant, your protestations are irrelevant because statistical significance is an actual thing and not a subjective assessment - hence why the reduction in NOx was considered significant and the reduction in PM was considered insignificant. Furthermore, I would contest a 7% average drop in NOx, including an 11% reduction in Ladywood, after just 7 months of the scheme as "not much".

And achieving reduced NOx is one of the two goals of the CAZ - hence it is shown to be empirically working. That is not an opinion. One of the two targets is to reduce NOx, NOx has been measured to be significantly reduced. Therefore, it is empirically working, if it wasn't empirically working then NOx would have either had a non-significant reduction or no reduction at all, yet the data shows there has been a reduction. That is an observable, measured assessment to back up the statement, in other words the CAZ is empirically working. It also parallels with the Imperial study on London's ULEZ, short term significant reductions in NOx with insignificant PM2.5 reductions - if you extrapolate the projections for Birmingham's CAZ from a longer period (which is safe because of the parallels over the immediate term assessments) with the UWE study (3-year assessment) then you can project a statistically significant reduction in PM10 over 60% of Birmingham by 2024.

I've already outlined the issues with PM reduction over the immediate term, if you contact Professor Bloss or his associates in the GEES they will also point out the difficulty in measurement of PM over a condensed timeframe. PM does not easily break up or dissolve, it lingers. That is why I contend with the recomendations of the article for more disruptive measures ASAP to deal with PM2.5 and P10 levels and want to see a 3-year and 5-year assessment to determine whether trends match those in central London.
Reply
So we'll know it's "empirically working" in a few years time then. OK.
Reply
(09-10-2023, 03:05 PM)Protheroe Wrote: So we'll know it's "empirically working" in a few years time then. OK.

We already know that it was "empirically working" 7 months in, hence there being a statistically significant reduction in the amount of NOx over that first 7 months with no increase in PM. That is half of the purpose of the CAZ already showing a measured, quantitative result in its favour. And it matches the early datasets from the Imperial study in London that assessed between 2019 and early 2020, the data outputted from which informed central government to enforce the CAZ on Birmingham.

You can't argue that because only half of the reason shows an empirical result towards meeting its goal none of it does, that isn't how statistics works. And I suggest you shadow my line of "more data needed" on PM before more restrictive covenants are enforced (especially in a cash strapped council area that needs to make up a £9m revenue shortfall).
Reply
I can argue what I like, you don't necessarily have to agree with it.

TBH I'd be banning wood burning stoves everywhere. Even over here I find myself choking on a Winter morning when walking the dog down Brake Lane if there's a temperature inversion.
Reply
(09-10-2023, 04:05 PM)Protheroe Wrote: I can argue what I like, you don't necessarily have to agree with it.

TBH I'd be banning wood burning stoves everywhere. Even over here I find myself choking on a Winter morning when walking the dog down Brake Lane if there's a temperature inversion.

But you're arguing against the data. If you're in charge of the CAZ are you going to look at the analysis which is explicit in the significant reduction of NOx, shadow that with the preliminary decisions to enforce the CAZ on Birmingham in the first place being in line with the early predictions as per the models in London (significant immediate term NOx drop, non-significant immediate term PM drop) that were used to inform the decision for the CAZ in the first instance and then confer with the people in charge of analysing and monitoring what are you going to get? I'd rather people argue using the data to delay and hopefully block further measures by pointing out the lag on PM reductions in conjunction with why PM lingers compared to NOx. You are already seeing with that report that the preliminary UoB summary is arguing for harsher restrictions on PM moving forward, now half of that is academic speak but half of it is genuine.

RE wood burning stoves: Not really sure. You can definitely feel the noticeable air quality drop around winter near where I live (as someone with asthma) but ultimately are they really correlated with noticeable air quality reductions below the WHO guidelines and legal limits? Genuine question, I haven't seen the data and ultimately that is what is going to inform any restrictions. I have one personally but I've never used it, think the chimney needs a clean if I do want to use it.
Reply
(09-10-2023, 04:17 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(09-10-2023, 04:05 PM)Protheroe Wrote: I can argue what I like, you don't necessarily have to agree with it.

TBH I'd be banning wood burning stoves everywhere. Even over here I find myself choking on a Winter morning when walking the dog down Brake Lane if there's a temperature inversion.



RE wood burning stoves: Not really sure. You can definitely feel the noticeable air quality drop around winter near where I live (as someone with asthma) but ultimately are they really correlated with noticeable air quality reductions below the WHO guidelines and legal limits? Genuine question, I haven't seen the data and ultimately that is what is going to inform any restrictions. I have one personally but I've never used it, think the chimney needs a clean if I do want to use it.
We have a woodburner, I'm told they are carbon neutral (which I know is a different argument to air quality). We don't have gas central heating. I think if you want to really start improving both air quality and global warming then maybe we should all be given a certain amount of points to spend on all things bad. I would be very disappointed to lose the woodburner which runs at literally half a log every 40 minutes for part of the day-in winter, when people boast having gas central heating on all year round. I find much of the anti wood burner diatribe is because The Guardian believes only the upper middle classes have them.
Reply
(09-10-2023, 04:30 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: We have a woodburner, I'm told they are carbon neutral (which I know is a different argument to air quality). We don't have gas central heating. I think if you want to really start improving both air quality and global warming then maybe we should all be given a certain amount of points to spend on all things bad. I would be very disappointed to lose the woodburner which runs at literally half a log every 40 minutes for part of the day-in winter, when people boast having gas central heating on all year round. I find much of the anti wood burner diatribe is because The Guardian believes only the upper middle classes have them.

I mean, they are carbon neutral in terms of just the fuel (Scope 1). You're burning wood, you're capturing the carbon by growing the tree and then releasing it by burning it. And if the wood is local then you're likely going to tend to net zero (theoretically you could get to net negative but to practically achieve that you'd need to plant a load of saplings from the tree you're felling, chop the tree by hand and transport it by hand to achieve that, not sure how practical that is for you TJ).
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 4 Guest(s)