ulez vigilantes
(09-06-2023, 07:41 PM)Woodman scoreboard Wrote:
(09-06-2023, 07:37 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(09-06-2023, 07:31 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(09-06-2023, 07:21 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(09-06-2023, 07:18 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: We have already seen the contempt that some have for the disabled on here when it comes to support to use trains or public transport in general. They seem to want to make travel for wheelchair users, their families and others who need a vehicle prisoners in their own cities and towns either by taking away help at stations, pricing them off the road etc. If any other section of society was spoken about, treated in this way the same posters would be up queuing up to condemn them.

And you don't want poor people to be able to ever afford a house.

Wind your neck in with your emotive populist rhetoric.

Lib Dem telling someone to wind their neck is about as threatening as bag of limp rocket lettuce. It’s not populist to defend the rights of the disabled who need vehicles ffs and not the jelly moulds on wheels you think are practical. I said about housing don’t build houses in already struggling towns whose infrastructures and services are creaking and particularly not on the only green spaces in the area people can use. ULEZ only changes the behaviour of those who can’t afford to pay, it’s unfair and discriminatory.

Well done on, yet again, doing what you always do. Ignoring the facts, engaging in emotion, playing the populist.

What rights need defending here? The disabled have a 4 year grace period and they have a £6k scrappage grant on top of any other mobility grants. How is that discriminatory? They have 4 years to plan and use their current vehicles, and in 4 years time they get a £6k scrappage grant.

And you also opposed densifying urban areas to European averages, like Copenhagen or Nice or Amsterdam. What a shame if Birmingham was more like those cities?

So yes, wind your neck in.

Alot on disabilities can just about to put gas and electric on FFS

Good job they get a 4-year grace period to plan around this and then an enhanced scrappage grant to be used in conjunction with other mobility schemes so they don't have to pay a single penny towards that then. Isn't it?

Or do you just want to ignore the facts.

I think things that actually affect them, like access to PIP, housing benefit, fuel allowances and care are more pertinent, if I am honest.
Reply
(09-06-2023, 07:47 PM)Woodman scoreboard Wrote:
(09-06-2023, 07:45 PM)CaptainFantastico Wrote:
(09-06-2023, 07:38 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(09-06-2023, 07:27 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(09-06-2023, 07:24 PM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: If that was an area my mind was focused on, i'd suggest campaigning for a fee waiver for blue badge holders, for example. Not the abolition of an entire scheme. Sledgehammer/nut.

If you are disabled and your vehicle (or your nominated driver's vehicle) does not meet ULEZ emissions standards, you may qualify for a temporary discount from the ULEZ charge called a grace period. Eligible applicants for these grace periods will not need to pay the ULEZ charge until 25 October 2027.

So it turns out, Derek, blue badge holders or the cars they travel in, are exempt for the next 4 years.........

As I already mentioned in this thread...

Then what? Who’s paying for the electric vehicle? How do they pay after 2027? Unless they qualify for mobility they are going to be priced off the roads and onto public transport that isn’t fit for purpose for many disabled as most research backs up. Any system has to have fairness for all at the moment the rich don’t suffer any real difficulties or discouragment from using their vehicles.

The majority if not all will receive higher rate PiP and so be on Motability and have vehicles that are therefore exempt anyway.

Have you ever tried to get PiP ...?

Yes. Takes about 6-9 months because of the chronic state of the DWP, who are understaffed. Now there is an area to direct your action and anger

God help anyone who needs to appeal. Be worth a poll on who voted for the government that bought it in and have it in the state that it is in.
Someone could have been killed
Reply
(09-06-2023, 07:40 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(09-06-2023, 07:38 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(09-06-2023, 07:27 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(09-06-2023, 07:24 PM)CaptainFantastico Wrote:
(09-06-2023, 07:18 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: We have already seen the contempt that some have for the disabled on here when it comes to support to use trains or public transport in general. They seem to want to make travel for wheelchair users, their families and others who need a vehicle prisoners in their own cities and towns either by taking away help at stations, pricing them off the road etc. If any other section of society was spoken about, treated in this way the same posters would be up queuing up to condemn them.

If that was an area my mind was focused on, i'd suggest campaigning for a fee waiver for blue badge holders, for example. Not the abolition of an entire scheme. Sledgehammer/nut.

If you are disabled and your vehicle (or your nominated driver's vehicle) does not meet ULEZ emissions standards, you may qualify for a temporary discount from the ULEZ charge called a grace period. Eligible applicants for these grace periods will not need to pay the ULEZ charge until 25 October 2027.

So it turns out, Derek, blue badge holders or the cars they travel in, are exempt for the next 4 years.........

As I already mentioned in this thread...

Then what? Who’s paying for the electric vehicle? How do they pay after 2027? Unless they qualify for mobility they are going to be priced off the roads and onto public transport that isn’t fit for purpose for many disabled as most research backs up. Any system has to have fairness for all at the moment the rich don’t suffer any real difficulties or discouragment from using their vehicles.

Then they get a £6k scrappage grant for their old vehicle.

Not hard to Google this stuff?

You think that many disabled people and their families have £20k or more to spend on a ULEZ acceptable vehicle? How out of touch are you?
Reply
(09-06-2023, 07:27 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(09-06-2023, 07:24 PM)CaptainFantastico Wrote:
(09-06-2023, 07:18 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(09-06-2023, 07:08 PM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: How many of those you speak of do you think are more likely to have kids whose health benefits or cars that cost them the fee? Well intended for definite Derek, we just disagree on what and who is being protected here.

We have already seen the contempt that some have for the disabled on here when it comes to support to use trains or public transport in general. They seem to want to make travel for wheelchair users, their families and others who need a vehicle prisoners in their own cities and towns either by taking away help at stations, pricing them off the road etc. If any other section of society was spoken about, treated in this way the same posters would be up queuing up to condemn them.

If that was an area my mind was focused on, i'd suggest campaigning for a fee waiver for blue badge holders, for example. Not the abolition of an entire scheme. Sledgehammer/nut.

If you are disabled and your vehicle (or your nominated driver's vehicle) does not meet ULEZ emissions standards, you may qualify for a temporary discount from the ULEZ charge called a grace period. Eligible applicants for these grace periods will not need to pay the ULEZ charge until 25 October 2027.

So it turns out, Derek, blue badge holders or the cars they travel in, are exempt for the next 4 years.........

As I already mentioned in this thread...

But their carers aren't exempt. Have you not heard the stories of those that can't travel into the zone as they earn minimum wage so it isn't practical?  Have you not heard of the tradesmen who would sooner retire than invest in the new van they need to go about their business (Good job we aren't short of tradesmen, eh)?  What about those that have to travel into the zone to visit ageing parents?  Then the small business in the zone that loses much of it's custom because of ULEZ but is tied in to a long lease? 
  This is a city with how many airports? Don't they pollute? Or is that ok because they can afford to pay a carbon tax? As I said upthread, how come a 6 litre AMG is allowed in the zone? 
  Like the race to EVs, it is divisive and ill thought through. Last time in London, I noticed around the leafy St. Johns Wood streets, lamp posts with chargers for EVs. No such facilities exist for those on the Lost City, The Wrenna, Friar Park or on the 10th floor of a tower block. And for those quoting imaginary Venn Diagrams -whatever the fuck they might be-  just maybe we are creating a class of people that feel alienated by the wealth they see, but have no chance of sharing.
Reply
(09-06-2023, 07:51 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(09-06-2023, 07:40 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(09-06-2023, 07:38 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(09-06-2023, 07:27 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(09-06-2023, 07:24 PM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: If that was an area my mind was focused on, i'd suggest campaigning for a fee waiver for blue badge holders, for example. Not the abolition of an entire scheme. Sledgehammer/nut.

If you are disabled and your vehicle (or your nominated driver's vehicle) does not meet ULEZ emissions standards, you may qualify for a temporary discount from the ULEZ charge called a grace period. Eligible applicants for these grace periods will not need to pay the ULEZ charge until 25 October 2027.

So it turns out, Derek, blue badge holders or the cars they travel in, are exempt for the next 4 years.........

As I already mentioned in this thread...

Then what? Who’s paying for the electric vehicle? How do they pay after 2027? Unless they qualify for mobility they are going to be priced off the roads and onto public transport that isn’t fit for purpose for many disabled as most research backs up. Any system has to have fairness for all at the moment the rich don’t suffer any real difficulties or discouragment from using their vehicles.

Then they get a £6k scrappage grant for their old vehicle.

Not hard to Google this stuff?

You think that many disabled people and their families have £20k or more to spend on a ULEZ acceptable vehicle? How out of touch are you?

How much do you think petrol cars from 2006 are going for, exactly?

And you accuse me as being out of touch? I literally found an ULEZ compliant Citroen C2 with 40k miles on it for £1.5k earlier. That was through Autotrader, not even schemes like Motability or having access to other allowances. Now add on 4 years depreciation.
Reply
(09-06-2023, 07:54 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(09-06-2023, 07:51 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(09-06-2023, 07:40 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(09-06-2023, 07:38 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(09-06-2023, 07:27 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: As I already mentioned in this thread...

Then what? Who’s paying for the electric vehicle? How do they pay after 2027? Unless they qualify for mobility they are going to be priced off the roads and onto public transport that isn’t fit for purpose for many disabled as most research backs up. Any system has to have fairness for all at the moment the rich don’t suffer any real difficulties or discouragment from using their vehicles.

Then they get a £6k scrappage grant for their old vehicle.

Not hard to Google this stuff?

You think that many disabled people and their families have £20k or more to spend on a ULEZ acceptable vehicle? How out of touch are you?

How much do you think petrol cars from 2006 are going for, exactly?

And you accuse me as being out of touch? I literally found an ULEZ compliant Citroen C2 with 40k miles on it for £1.5k earlier. That was through Autotrader, not even schemes like Motability or having access to other allowances. Now add on 4 years depreciation.

Yeah that‘s exactly the type of car a family with a wheelchair users needs. You are out of touch in your MC bubble.
Reply
(09-06-2023, 07:54 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(09-06-2023, 07:51 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(09-06-2023, 07:40 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(09-06-2023, 07:38 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(09-06-2023, 07:27 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: As I already mentioned in this thread...

Then what? Who’s paying for the electric vehicle? How do they pay after 2027? Unless they qualify for mobility they are going to be priced off the roads and onto public transport that isn’t fit for purpose for many disabled as most research backs up. Any system has to have fairness for all at the moment the rich don’t suffer any real difficulties or discouragment from using their vehicles.

Then they get a £6k scrappage grant for their old vehicle.

Not hard to Google this stuff?

You think that many disabled people and their families have £20k or more to spend on a ULEZ acceptable vehicle? How out of touch are you?

How much do you think petrol cars from 2006 are going for, exactly?

And you accuse me as being out of touch? I literally found an ULEZ compliant Citroen C2 with 40k miles on it for £1.5k earlier. That was through Autotrader, not even schemes like Motability or having access to other allowances. Now add on 4 years depreciation.
That's because those things are disposable, a single garage bill will kill off that.
Reply
(09-06-2023, 07:51 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: But their carers aren't exempt. Have you not heard the stories of those that can't travel into the zone as they earn minimum wage so it isn't practical?  Have you not heard of the tradesmen who would sooner retire than invest in the new van they need to go about their business (Good job we aren't short of tradesmen, eh)?  What about those that have to travel into the zone to visit ageing parents?  Then the small business in the zone that loses much of it's custom because of ULEZ but is tied in to a long lease? 
  This is a city with how many airports? Don't they pollute? Or is that ok because they can afford to pay a carbon tax? As I said upthread, how come a 6 litre AMG is allowed in the zone? 
  Like the race to EVs, it is divisive and ill thought through. Last time in London, I noticed around the leafy St. Johns Wood streets, lamp posts with chargers for EVs. No such facilities exist for those on the Lost City, The Wrenna, Friar Park or on the 10th floor of a tower block. And for those quoting imaginary Venn Diagrams -whatever the fuck they might be-  just maybe we are creating a class of people that feel alienated by the wealth they see, but have no chance of sharing.

Carers: Without trying to get ultra-political, I would class that as a separate argument as there are many deficiencies in that sector where this is a drop in the ocean.

People in outer-boroughs that work in London: I agree and I also want some more corridors in the ULEZ zone to help that (I specifically called out Hook and Chessington as an example). There's also the issue of this being made into a political football so the external councils don't themselves want to engage in an equivalent scrappage scheme.

Airports: What exactly can you do there? You can't close London City and Heathrow. I support measures to price in the costs of negative externalities but it's not like you can incentivise the use of low NOx planes yet as you can with cars.

Visits to visit aging parents: Pay the charge if your car isn't compliant? Just because you need to visit your parents doesn't mean your car suddenly stops emitting NOx or PMs. How is that different to anyone else?

6-litre AMG: This isn't a carbon tax, it's for NOx and PM2.5s. If the level isn't breached then they aren't deemed an issue for air quality.

As to all the above: They were all issues with the introduction of ULEZ and the first expansion as well as the CAZs, the sky didn't fall in and people managed. And this still goes back to the charge being fairer than banning cars (as they do in German cities, and even if your car is fine you have to pay for a green sticker).

The bottom line is the air quality issues in outer London are a massive problem (as I looked at earlier, it can be worse at peak times than central Birmingham which was forced by Whitehall to implement a CAZ). You can't not try to solve that problem, especially with the link to reduced health outcomes and reduced life expectancy.

(09-06-2023, 08:03 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(09-06-2023, 07:54 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(09-06-2023, 07:51 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(09-06-2023, 07:40 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(09-06-2023, 07:38 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Then what? Who’s paying for the electric vehicle? How do they pay after 2027? Unless they qualify for mobility they are going to be priced off the roads and onto public transport that isn’t fit for purpose for many disabled as most research backs up. Any system has to have fairness for all at the moment the rich don’t suffer any real difficulties or discouragment from using their vehicles.

Then they get a £6k scrappage grant for their old vehicle.

Not hard to Google this stuff?

You think that many disabled people and their families have £20k or more to spend on a ULEZ acceptable vehicle? How out of touch are you?

How much do you think petrol cars from 2006 are going for, exactly?

And you accuse me as being out of touch? I literally found an ULEZ compliant Citroen C2 with 40k miles on it for £1.5k earlier. That was through Autotrader, not even schemes like Motability or having access to other allowances. Now add on 4 years depreciation.

Yeah that‘s exactly the type of car a family with a wheelchair users needs. You are out of touch in your MC bubble.

I didn't say that was a WAV, did I?

Just had a look, it's actually a £10k grant. £6k is for a retrofit. Even better.
Reply
(09-06-2023, 08:09 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(09-06-2023, 07:51 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: But their carers aren't exempt. Have you not heard the stories of those that can't travel into the zone as they earn minimum wage so it isn't practical?  Have you not heard of the tradesmen who would sooner retire than invest in the new van they need to go about their business (Good job we aren't short of tradesmen, eh)?  What about those that have to travel into the zone to visit ageing parents?  Then the small business in the zone that loses much of it's custom because of ULEZ but is tied in to a long lease? 
  This is a city with how many airports? Don't they pollute? Or is that ok because they can afford to pay a carbon tax? As I said upthread, how come a 6 litre AMG is allowed in the zone? 
  Like the race to EVs, it is divisive and ill thought through. Last time in London, I noticed around the leafy St. Johns Wood streets, lamp posts with chargers for EVs. No such facilities exist for those on the Lost City, The Wrenna, Friar Park or on the 10th floor of a tower block. And for those quoting imaginary Venn Diagrams -whatever the fuck they might be-  just maybe we are creating a class of people that feel alienated by the wealth they see, but have no chance of sharing.

Carers: Without trying to get ultra-political, I would class that as a separate argument as there are many deficiencies in that sector where this is a drop in the ocean.

People in outer-boroughs that work in London: I agree and I also want some more corridors in the ULEZ zone to help that (I specifically called out Hook and Chessington as an example). There's also the issue of this being made into a political football so the external councils don't themselves want to engage in an equivalent scrappage scheme.

Airports: What exactly can you do there? You can't close London City and Heathrow. I support measures to price in the costs of negative externalities but it's not like you can incentivise the use of low NOx planes yet as you can with cars.

Visits to visit aging parents: Pay the charge if your car isn't compliant? Just because you need to visit your parents doesn't mean your car suddenly stops emitting NOx or PMs. How is that different to anyone else?

6-litre AMG: This isn't a carbon tax, it's for NOx and PM2.5s. If the level isn't breached then they aren't deemed an issue for air quality.

As to all the above: They were all issues with the introduction of ULEZ and the first expansion as well as the CAZs, the sky didn't fall in and people managed. And this still goes back to the charge being fairer than banning cars (as they do in German cities, and even if your car is fine you have to pay for a green sticker).

The bottom line is the air quality issues in outer London are a massive problem (as I looked at earlier, it can be worse at peak times than central Birmingham which was forced by Whitehall to implement a CAZ). You can't not try to solve that problem, especially with the link to reduced health outcomes and reduced life expectancy.

(09-06-2023, 08:03 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(09-06-2023, 07:54 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(09-06-2023, 07:51 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(09-06-2023, 07:40 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Then they get a £6k scrappage grant for their old vehicle.

Not hard to Google this stuff?

You think that many disabled people and their families have £20k or more to spend on a ULEZ acceptable vehicle? How out of touch are you?

How much do you think petrol cars from 2006 are going for, exactly?

And you accuse me as being out of touch? I literally found an ULEZ compliant Citroen C2 with 40k miles on it for £1.5k earlier. That was through Autotrader, not even schemes like Motability or having access to other allowances. Now add on 4 years depreciation.

Yeah that‘s exactly the type of car a family with a wheelchair users needs. You are out of touch in your MC bubble.

I didn't say that was a WAV, did I?

Just had a look, it's actually a £10k grant. £6k is for a retrofit. Even better.

You live in a ableist bubble. Enjoy not having to think about these things outside of theory rather than practice.
Reply
(09-06-2023, 08:19 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(09-06-2023, 08:09 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: I didn't say that was a WAV, did I?

Just had a look, it's actually a £10k grant. £6k is for a retrofit. Even better.

You live in a ableist bubble. Enjoy not having to think about these things outside of theory rather than practice.

£10k scrappage grant.

Second hand WAVs paid for outright (not even through a scheme like Motability) that are ULEZ compliant for less than the scrappage grant which I found in 10 seconds:

https://www.wavsgb.com/wheelchair_vehicl...chair-krd/

https://www.wavsgb.com/wheelchair_vehicl...o-wav-frn/

"Ableist bubble". "Theory not in practice".
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 3 Guest(s)