Posts: 3,034
Threads: 20
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
8
(09-06-2023, 05:05 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (09-06-2023, 04:57 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: (09-06-2023, 04:54 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (09-06-2023, 04:42 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: (09-06-2023, 04:28 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
FFS. That is not a good faith suggestion, that is an empty statement.
What? What is that? Banning people from driving full stop? Reducing the provision of public services as you need to cost in legal action instead?
How do you square the circle? Brainstorm. Come at me with a genuine alternative that simultaneously improves localised air quality and doesn't impact the bottom line of the poorest.
As for why people are pissed off, people were pissed off at gay marriage being introduced. People were pissed off at income tax. People were pissed off at Jewish refugees coming from Russia. People were pissed off at my grandparents coming to this country. People get pissed off at everything, people are getting pissed off at poor air quality and the reduction of life expectancy as well as a rise in chronic conditions linked to that as well. Khan literally said he was going to expand ULEZ to the outer boroughs in 2021 and still got voted in.
They are ridiculous comparisons that don’t impact the poor and vulnerable like the ULEZ expansion does!
If the scrappage schemes etc were good enough, why the kickback?!
The poorest arent supporting the ulez are they? Have you not noticed?
It’s like needing to raise more tax and getting it off the poorest! You would not normally support things that hammer the working classes, but that goes out the window with green issues.
The fact that you are unable to come up with a single alternative suggestion to ULEZ expansion in order to improve surface air quality in spite of me asking multiple times shows you are not interested in a good faith argument on this whatsoever. All you want to do is whinge about change, and you are also cont
And they are not "ridiculous comparisons". They are a direct analogue of there being "kickback" from legislation. People get pissed off at all sorts of crap.
What's your alternative to the scrappage scheme? There was kickback, they amended it to cover everyone. Now the 10% affected can afford a new compliant car. What do you want? More generous allowances? You have to fund that. Outer jurisdictions having a scrappage scheme? Good luck getting TfL to pay people living outside the GLA. More public transport provisions? They bringing in that loop thing to link the outer boroughs.
There are so many first hand accounts of people shafted by this, and you still think the schemes are good enough!
I didn’t come up with the ULEZ scheme, and I can’t right now come up with a perfect alternative on the spot. That doesn’t make it ok.
There's also plenty of empirical evidence that links poor air quality to poor health outcomes. I don't think the "schemes are good enough", there are flaws. I think it should be delayed to a similar timeframe as the last expansion and areas like Hook and Chessington in South London should be removed from the zone. Regardless, that doesn't detract from the principle of the policy which is to avoid fiscal recklessness and avoid even more encroaching and authoritarian solutions.
Which goes back to, what is your alternative to improve localised air quality? The fact that you don't want to answer this is the point, there isn't an easy and perfect alternative. It's the lesser of the evils. If you can magically make people not drive when they don't have to (already a subjective) then you may have scope to avoid it but good luck with that, I don't consider that realistic.
And if they pay the charge, they can pollute anyway!
I can’t come up with a policy on the spot, but that doesn’t mean the current one is unfair. I’d suggest bringing this in when 0.1% of cars, not 10%, are impacted, would be more sensible for a start!
Listen to those affected by it, there’s tons of stories of people badly impacted, but the fact remains it is the poor and working classes and disabled and vulnerable who are angry. The unaffected in many cases don’t give a toss…. which is very clear!
There’s going to be a big kickback if more green policies impact ORDINARY people while the well off can get round it. But the answer from those who put the environment over the needs of people here and now will always be that ”we have to, we have no choice”. Good luck persuading people of that when these type of policies impact more and more people… which they will.
Posts: 13,569
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
(09-06-2023, 05:11 PM)boingingjim Wrote: Air quality on the London Tube would be the first thing you'd worry about if you wanted to help people's health.
No, because that affects a fractional amount of people (TfL employees) compared to London as a whole. Surface air quality is more pertinent because you don't spend 24 hours a day on the underground section of the Central Line.
Posts: 516
Threads: 12
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
3
I doubt people spend 24 hours a day sat outside their house next to a road either. The levels of pollution on the tube vs the air quality in a now ULEZ encased home would be interesting to see.
A lot of people spend a couple hours a day commuting on the tube and would be far more if you had your travel pass policy adopted.
Posts: 13,569
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
09-06-2023, 05:23 PM
(This post was last modified: 09-06-2023, 05:25 PM by Borin' Baggie.)
(09-06-2023, 05:14 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: (09-06-2023, 05:05 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (09-06-2023, 04:57 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: (09-06-2023, 04:54 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (09-06-2023, 04:42 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: They are ridiculous comparisons that don’t impact the poor and vulnerable like the ULEZ expansion does!
If the scrappage schemes etc were good enough, why the kickback?!
The poorest arent supporting the ulez are they? Have you not noticed?
It’s like needing to raise more tax and getting it off the poorest! You would not normally support things that hammer the working classes, but that goes out the window with green issues.
The fact that you are unable to come up with a single alternative suggestion to ULEZ expansion in order to improve surface air quality in spite of me asking multiple times shows you are not interested in a good faith argument on this whatsoever. All you want to do is whinge about change, and you are also cont
And they are not "ridiculous comparisons". They are a direct analogue of there being "kickback" from legislation. People get pissed off at all sorts of crap.
What's your alternative to the scrappage scheme? There was kickback, they amended it to cover everyone. Now the 10% affected can afford a new compliant car. What do you want? More generous allowances? You have to fund that. Outer jurisdictions having a scrappage scheme? Good luck getting TfL to pay people living outside the GLA. More public transport provisions? They bringing in that loop thing to link the outer boroughs.
There are so many first hand accounts of people shafted by this, and you still think the schemes are good enough!
I didn’t come up with the ULEZ scheme, and I can’t right now come up with a perfect alternative on the spot. That doesn’t make it ok.
There's also plenty of empirical evidence that links poor air quality to poor health outcomes. I don't think the "schemes are good enough", there are flaws. I think it should be delayed to a similar timeframe as the last expansion and areas like Hook and Chessington in South London should be removed from the zone. Regardless, that doesn't detract from the principle of the policy which is to avoid fiscal recklessness and avoid even more encroaching and authoritarian solutions.
Which goes back to, what is your alternative to improve localised air quality? The fact that you don't want to answer this is the point, there isn't an easy and perfect alternative. It's the lesser of the evils. If you can magically make people not drive when they don't have to (already a subjective) then you may have scope to avoid it but good luck with that, I don't consider that realistic.
And if they pay the charge, they can pollute anyway!
I can’t come up with a policy on the spot, but that doesn’t mean the current one is unfair. I’d suggest bringing this in when 0.1% of cars, not 10%, are impacted, would be more sensible for a start!
Listen to those affected by it, there’s tons of stories of people badly impacted, but the fact remains it is the poor and working classes and disabled and vulnerable who are angry. The unaffected in many cases don’t give a toss…. which is very clear!
There’s going to be a big kickback if more green policies impact ORDINARY people while the well off can get round it. But the answer from those who put the environment over the needs of people here and now will always be that ”we have to, we have no choice”. Good luck persuading people of that when these type of policies impact more and more people… which they will.
So you're suggesting a ban on those cars full stop?
You are advocating for a delay which I already mentioned, but the fact is you cannot look at this from one side of the argument and completely ignore the need to address the other side which is to improve surface air quality. The only practical alternatives in this country to avoid CAZ being enforced were road structure reorganisation but those were in places where NOx and PM are lower than outer London and the affected areas are much smaller. The costs and timeframe to do that for London are impractical.
And if you want to get into the wider environmental policy I'd rather not screw over the global poor and future poor quite by allowing the costs to snowball as past generations have levied onto mine, frankly.
(09-06-2023, 05:22 PM)boingingjim Wrote: I doubt people spend 24 hours a day sat outside their house next to a road either. The levels of pollution on the tube vs the air quality in a now ULEZ encased home would be interesting to see.
Do you think that the air in houses, shops, gyms and offices are somehow unconnected to the air from the road just outside them?
Posts: 3,034
Threads: 20
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
8
No I’m not suggesting banning cars full stop. FFS.
Listen to those impacted. It’s very unpopular for a reason. It’s shafting a lot of ordinary people… ironically those who were told to buy diesels and even incentivised with cheaper road tax a few years ago!
Posts: 13,569
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
09-06-2023, 05:35 PM
(This post was last modified: 09-06-2023, 05:35 PM by Borin' Baggie.)
(09-06-2023, 05:30 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: No I’m not suggesting banning cars full stop. FFS.
Listen to those impacted. It’s very unpopular for a reason. It’s shafting a lot of ordinary people… ironically those who were told to buy diesels and even incentivised with cheaper road tax a few years ago!
I have listened to those affected, that is why I brought up the expansion of the scrappage scheme, that is why I brought up the delay to implementation and that is why I brought up Hook. What I'm not going to do is ignore the other side of the argument completely which is the need to improve surface air quality in London and the effects of that.
And if you don't want to ban cars then what is your alternative to improve surface air quality in London? Because it is going to keep going back to that and without an alternative to address that then why would I believe you are being empirical?
Posts: 15,278
Threads: 273
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
57
I find it weird I don't pay emissions tax on my 2014 Diesel, but need to pay Clean Air charges anywhere, while the same engine, but registered in 2015, with NOTHING different to it, literally nothing at all, same emissions, doesn't need to pay. That alone proves it has nothing to do with emissions, it's just another tax, one that hits the poorest hardest.
Posts: 6,416
Threads: 305
Joined: Aug 2022
Reputation:
28
(09-06-2023, 04:47 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: (09-06-2023, 04:45 PM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: Bollocks to all the kids living in low income areas hey lads - let them suck those particles up and worship the heroes of the working class as they ingest
So why isn’t there massive support for the ULEZ from the poor and vulnerable?
This just smacks of “we know what’s best for you (while it doesn’t impact me)”
Youve not looked at the actual data on that, have you?
Someone could have been killed
Posts: 13,569
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
09-06-2023, 05:36 PM
(This post was last modified: 09-06-2023, 05:38 PM by Borin' Baggie.)
(09-06-2023, 05:35 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: I find it weird I don't pay emissions tax on my 2014 Diesel, but need to pay Clean Air charges anywhere, while the same engine, but registered in 2015, with NOTHING different to it, literally nothing at all, same emissions, doesn't need to pay. That alone proves it has nothing to do with emissions, it's just another tax, one that hits the poorest hardest.
Because this is about NOx and PM, not carbon.
Diesels are worse for NOx and PM than petrol.
Diesels are better for carbon than petrol.
NOx and PM are what affect localised air quality. If you don't live in an area that breaches WHO guidance on safe air quality levels (like London or central Birmingham or Bath) then why would you need to worry about NOx or PM?
Posts: 15,278
Threads: 273
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
57
But there is no difference between the 2014 engine I own, and the 2015 one that doesn't have to pay, in any way both have the same emissions, I went to check this before posting.
I travel a lot for gigs, I had to pay £18 to go into Bristol for literally minutes this week for example. And seeing the emissions coming from a bus, which had no one on it, I don't see how my car is worse honestly.
|