ulez vigilantes
#51
(09-06-2023, 04:14 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(09-06-2023, 04:10 PM)Cornflake Wrote: ULEZ is a well intentioned policy poorly executed.

Racists and right wing media are all over it because the London Mayor is of Pakistani origin and Labour and the election is approaching.

Nope, loads of normal people are made poorer by it, and can’t understand why a Labour mayor would tax the most poor and vulnerable to clean the air up

Meanwhile, those in favour label these people racist, anti immigration, daily mail etc etc

Agree. All 3 statements are true.
Reply
#52
(09-06-2023, 04:03 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(09-06-2023, 03:56 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Yes, get to fuck

I just checked your Chigwell to Enfield example on Google Maps, it's 37 minutes not 17 minutes and it doesn't factor in projected bus service times when the the TfL loop service comes in. So that's a bad faith example. It is also only 20 minutes more to cycle than drive. Furthermore, if your car is not compliant you get a subsidy to replace it. So if you really want to drive from Chigwell to Enfield you can get money from TfL to put towards buying a new car such as this Citroen C2 which is sold in Enfield of all places for £1.5k, so you aren't even out of pocket, instead you're quids in to £500.

What is your alternative to bringing air quality levels to avoid London being liable to legal action? Banning those cars full stop? You are arguing from an entirely bad faith position wherein there are no consequences to your side which, to put it bluntly, is a total nonsense.

Ok swear at me again, it’s still clear you’re not bothered about the most vulnerable.

I used Rometorio travel site and it says 17 minutes. Whichever it is, it’s tons quicker than public transport.

If the scrappage schemes were ok, why has there been so much kickback?

What about people who can’t use public transport? The scrappage scheme is not enough for some. And paying 12.50 a day is unaffordable. Do you think this didn’t impact the by election result? That surely shows ordinary people are impacted unfairly?

You’re literally not giving a toss about those affected by this. I guess it’s because it doesn’t impact you.

You are arguing in bad faith and saying I don't care about poor and vulnerable people, and have the cheek to complain about me swearing. Give over.

Khan initially screwed up the scrappage scheme and it had a reduced eligibility. Thanks to political pressure from Keir Starmer and the London Lib Dems it was expanded to cover everyone. And, as I just evidenced, you can find an ULEZ compliant car in outer London for less than the scrappage.

R2R is a journeymapper, not a sat nav. It shows perceived "optimums", not realistic travel times.

And for the people who "can't use public transport", they probably have a disability which means they're eligible for a mobility allowance and a £6k ULEZ grant, and they don't need to pay for ULEZ until 2027. And if they don't have a disability they can get a subsidy from the scrappage allowance.

You have completely failed to address the issue of what the realistic alternatives to ULEZ expansion are, and saying nothing isn't a realistic alternative. London has already been threatened with legal action over air quality, surface air quality in outer London is worse than central Manchester. They need to do something. And I'd rather this than more authoritarian measures like banning cars or fiscally reckless ones like budgeting in £500m of revenue being lost to cover fines and legal action. I'd rather expend my energy calling out realistic issues with it like Chessington being included or the scrappage scheme needing to be expanded (which happened, a win for analysing the proposal and the justification then fixing those issues instead of having a tantrum) than whine about it being introduced with zero suggestion of what else to do.
Reply
#53
Some great passion in this thread, nice to see people aren't completely apathetic towards everything just yet.

A real shame we can't channel the vast swathes of public anger towards; our crumbling health service, failing youth services, our schools that are literally falling to bits, your ever decreasing chances of enjoying a happy retirement, the blatant profiteering of large corporations, the tonnes of actual poo being pumped into our waterways or the litany of illegal shit our Government has done in the last four years.

Still, smashing up some signs and cameras is a start. Keep fighting the good fight, lads.
Reply
#54
(09-06-2023, 04:18 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(09-06-2023, 04:03 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(09-06-2023, 03:56 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Yes, get to fuck

I just checked your Chigwell to Enfield example on Google Maps, it's 37 minutes not 17 minutes and it doesn't factor in projected bus service times when the the TfL loop service comes in. So that's a bad faith example. It is also only 20 minutes more to cycle than drive. Furthermore, if your car is not compliant you get a subsidy to replace it. So if you really want to drive from Chigwell to Enfield you can get money from TfL to put towards buying a new car such as this Citroen C2 which is sold in Enfield of all places for £1.5k, so you aren't even out of pocket, instead you're quids in to £500.

What is your alternative to bringing air quality levels to avoid London being liable to legal action? Banning those cars full stop? You are arguing from an entirely bad faith position wherein there are no consequences to your side which, to put it bluntly, is a total nonsense.

Ok swear at me again, it’s still clear you’re not bothered about the most vulnerable.

I used Rometorio travel site and it says 17 minutes. Whichever it is, it’s tons quicker than public transport.

If the scrappage schemes were ok, why has there been so much kickback?

What about people who can’t use public transport? The scrappage scheme is not enough for some. And paying 12.50 a day is unaffordable. Do you think this didn’t impact the by election result? That surely shows ordinary people are impacted unfairly?

You’re literally not giving a toss about those affected by this. I guess it’s because it doesn’t impact you.

You are arguing in bad faith and saying I don't care about poor and vulnerable people, and have the cheek to complain about me swearing. Give over.

Khan initially screwed up the scrappage scheme and it had a reduced eligibility. Thanks to political pressure from Keir Starmer and the London Lib Dems it was expanded to cover everyone. And, as I just evidenced, you can find an ULEZ compliant car in outer London for less than the scrappage.

R2R is a journeymapper, not a sat nav. It shows perceived "optimums", not realistic travel times.

And for the people who "can't use public transport", they probably have a disability which means they're eligible for a mobility allowance and a £6k ULEZ grant, and they don't need to pay for ULEZ until 2027. And if they don't have a disability they can get a subsidy from the scrappage allowance.

You have completely failed to address the issue of what the realistic alternatives to ULEZ expansion are, and saying nothing isn't a realistic alternative. London has already been threatened with legal action over air quality, surface air quality in outer London is worse than central Manchester. They need to do something. And I'd rather this than more authoritarian measures like banning cars or fiscally reckless ones like budgeting in £500m of revenue being lost to cover fines and legal action. I'd rather expend my energy calling out realistic issues with it like Chessington being included or the scrappage scheme needing to be expanded (which happened, a win for analysing the proposal and the justification then fixing those issues instead of having a tantrum) than whine about it being introduced with zero suggestion of what else to do.

A scheme that doesn’t impact the poorest is my suggestion.

Totally disagree that those who can’t use public transport probably have a disability. There’s tons of people that need to carry stuff in a boot, or are not fit enough to use public transport but not officially disabled.

Again, the by election result showed what a lot of ordinary people think about it.

If the schemes were so good, why are so many people pissed off? Can you answer that?

Public transport can not get close to doing what a car does. It’s way slower, and that’s for those able to use it. I know you’re not bothered about those impacted, so feel free to swear at me again for pointing that out.
Reply
#55
(09-06-2023, 04:25 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: A scheme that doesn’t impact the poorest is my suggestion.
 
FFS. That is not a good faith suggestion, that is an empty statement.

What? What is that? Banning people from driving full stop? Reducing the provision of public services as you need to cost in legal action instead?

How do you square the circle? Brainstorm. Come at me with a genuine alternative that simultaneously improves localised air quality and doesn't impact the bottom line of the poorest.

As for why people are pissed off, people were pissed off at gay marriage being introduced. People were pissed off at income tax. People were pissed off at Jewish refugees coming from Russia. People were pissed off at my grandparents coming to this country. People get pissed off at everything, people are getting pissed off at poor air quality and the reduction of life expectancy as well as a rise in chronic conditions linked to that as well. Khan literally said he was going to expand ULEZ to the outer boroughs in 2021 and still got voted in.
Reply
#56
(09-06-2023, 04:23 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: Some great passion in this thread, nice to see people aren't completely apathetic towards everything just yet.

A real shame we can't channel the vast swathes of public anger towards; our crumbling health service, failing youth services, our schools that are literally falling to bits, your ever decreasing chances of enjoying a happy retirement, the blatant profiteering of large corporations, the tonnes of actual poo being pumped into our waterways or the litany of illegal shit our Government has done in the last four years.

Still, smashing up some signs and cameras is a start. Keep fighting the good fight, lads.

It's OK, you'll have the chance to vote for Keir Starmer next year and it all be alright thereafter.

(09-06-2023, 04:28 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: What? What is that? Banning people from driving full stop? 

With the move to expensive electric cars and the inevitable road pricing that follows, that's exactly what you'll be doing to poor people.
Reply
#57
(09-06-2023, 04:10 PM)Cornflake Wrote: ULEZ is a well intentioned policy poorly executed.

Racists and right wing media are all over it because the London Mayor is of Pakistani origin and Labour and the election is approaching.

Nonsense. I lived around London when Ken Livingstone was leader of the GLC. No one has ever got that much abuse and I don't think he was Pakistani.
Reply
#58
A lady I work with who lives in south Herts uses a dog walker whose clientele sit either side of the ULEZ divide. She's had to trade in her old van for a newer one to get around this which probably kills a fair amount of profit for this and the forthcoming years.
Reply
#59
(09-06-2023, 04:31 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(09-06-2023, 04:23 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: Some great passion in this thread, nice to see people aren't completely apathetic towards everything just yet.

A real shame we can't channel the vast swathes of public anger towards; our crumbling health service, failing youth services, our schools that are literally falling to bits, your ever decreasing chances of enjoying a happy retirement, the blatant profiteering of large corporations, the tonnes of actual poo being pumped into our waterways or the litany of illegal shit our Government has done in the last four years.

Still, smashing up some signs and cameras is a start. Keep fighting the good fight, lads.

It's OK, you'll have the chance to vote for Keir Starmer next year and it all be alright thereafter.

I was out knocking doors in 2015, 2017 and 2019 campaigning for a Labour Government. I have since left the party as the direction they are taking is at odds with my own values and the values that the party was founded on. However next year from behind an enormous red rosette, I shall be encouraging people down the path of #LeastWorst whilst simultaneously telling everyone I can that I am not at fault for any of the shit that comes thereafter.
Reply
#60
(09-06-2023, 04:31 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(09-06-2023, 04:28 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: What? What is that? Banning people from driving full stop? 

With the move to expensive electric cars and the inevitable road pricing that follows, that's exactly what you'll be doing to poor people.

BEV manufacturing costs are trending down, ICE manufacturing costs are trending up.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)