BTA
If anything comes of this thread I hope its people learning that they can quote a post without quoting the entire massive thread it belongs to...
Reply
(08-31-2023, 01:05 PM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: If anything comes of this thread I hope its people learning that they can quote a post without quoting the entire massive thread it belongs to...
I'm thinking of going into finance myself after this, feel like I've done my Masters over the last few days!
Reply
(08-31-2023, 01:07 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(08-31-2023, 01:05 PM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: If anything comes of this thread I hope its people learning that they can quote a post without quoting the entire massive thread it belongs to...
I'm thinking of going into finance myself after this, feel like I've done my Masters over the last few days!

It’s fiancé professionalism isn’t it?
Reply
(08-31-2023, 01:01 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(08-31-2023, 12:25 PM)lemon Wrote: I think it's time for Birdy to create a 'Financial' forum for all of the experts, self appointed experts and the remaining incapables to partake in regular sparring on various legalities, vagaries and technicalities of modern day accounting in football.
Seconded!

Only those who can provide their full LinkedIn profile need apply.
Reply
(08-31-2023, 12:30 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(08-31-2023, 11:57 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(08-31-2023, 11:50 AM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(08-31-2023, 07:55 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote:
(08-31-2023, 07:43 AM)Fulham Fallout Wrote: I wouldn’t call in excess of £30m debt very little.

The depts are significantly higher then £30 million.
Take into account outstanding transfer fee payments and unpaid depts like ex manager payments, the money Lai owes it's probably closer to £60 million and rising at £2m a month.
This Ostrich approach expecting a rich person to pop up is not going to happen. If it was it would have happened a long time ago. 
Cash flow is indeed the factor that drives companies into administration. The question is do we want it to happen today or tomorrow.

Incorrect.  You’re assuming that the £20m loan has already been fully spent along with the £8m transfer fee revenue.    The transfer fees owing as at the last accounts in 2022 will also be all or mostly paid already. 

The money Lai owes is owed TO us, not BY us.  Those are debtors, not creditors.

There is no way today that the debts are “significantly higher” than £30m.  They might potentially be by the end of the season, but not today.

(08-31-2023, 10:54 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(08-31-2023, 10:43 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote: I lost count of how many times the so called experts said Lai couldn't simply take money out of our accounts. Well he did. And while him and his cronies continue to draw money from our accounts they won't be going anywhere. Apply common sense, would anyone give up a nice cheque every month.
It's gossip that Lai only put £10m of his own cash in the original buy out. He must be quids in now.
That's why he's a millionaire.

This. The problem is there is a legal framework that a Limited Company cannot breach, but unless somebody has deep pockets (or the company falls insolvent/breaches terms of a legal agreement and an Insolvency Practitioner is appointed) then they are difficult and costly to enforce. 

There is a picture painted on here that a lender has a complete "Police Department" waiting to jump on any borrower that breaches the terms of the agreement; this just isn't so. No lender wants the hassle and cost (not to mention the potential losses) of dealing with a disposal. 

In the market at the moment many borrowers are breaching serviceability covenants. Most lenders are issuing "Reservation of Rights" letters. This means they tell you you have breached the terms, they therefore can pursue you, but as long as you are paying your debts, they leave you alone.

We’ve had this conversation before.  I’ve seen exactly how MSD operate re another football club.  They are a niche lender and they don’t operate like other lenders re the ongoing reporting and due diligence.  They don’t get bad debts in their lending book because their credit monitoring is water right.  They will know very quickly if there has been a breach of the debenture terms by insisting that they receive copies of all bank statements directly from the bank.

(08-31-2023, 11:29 AM)BurleyBaggie Wrote: Prag is right though and I know I’m repeating myself, but the MSD loan is the current best protection we have over money disappearing from the club.

What’s gone before is not what is happening today.

Thanks Burley.  That’s 100% correct

Derby County, Prag? MSD have documentation (as does every other lender) to control a business. But the spectacular failure of Derby whom owed them £15M proves that MSD lends to basket cases and doesn't monitor all that well. We are such a basket case. Point of order - banks do not issue Bank Statements to third parties - Tournier v National Provincial 1924.

This is a half decent (dated) summary. It does have some inaccuracies, but carries the gist https://www.chroniclelive.co.uk/sport/fo...y-18757889 Whilst it would be painful, we could do far worse than end up in the arms of MSD, in my opinion.


MSD only came into Derby at the 11th hour - they owed over £190m to Morris and were days away from liquidation, let alone administration. 

MSD did not lose a penny on the Derby deal and were repaid in full.  And Morris hadn’t been taking money out of the club.  He already owned the ground.  MSD had appropriate security for their loan so weren’t concerned.   

MSD is not a bank. It is a specialist lender who writes strict criteria into their bespoke lending terms and conditions.  Banks don’t as a matter of right have access to bank statements but if MSD insist on it (as they do) otherwise they won’t lend, then the accountholder can instruct the bank to do so. 

Everything you say refers to “normal” lending by regular banking institutions.  MSD is a private family office which does very specialist lending to football clubs.  Their rules apply - nobody else’s.

MSD were involved with Derby 13 months before Administration - hardly last minute. Their decision was strategic, and they did so knowing that Derby did not own their own ground.

MSD is not a family office - it doesn't have a London Office for a start. The fact they were repaid in full on Derby does not take into account their time cost through this process, or indeed the risk they undertook. 15% interest verses millions of capital doesn't equate. 

When you look at some of the names they are involved with (Burnley, Southampton, us, Derby, Sunderland) suggests to me they are looking for an investment in UK Football. Don't tell me about their fantastic debenture monitoring regime though. Derby tells you of the mess going on there, and MSD had to pump in an additional £5M to protect their loan.
Reply
I get all of the above cynicism re MSD and trust me they’re not your lender of choice, however, in this specific instance with the securities they are a benefit to the club in respect of Lai taking monies out.

That’s a medium term protection though as admin is still a real possibility. That said, the MSD loan, securities and debenture actually make a sale more likely as failure to repay will force admin and Lai and cronies get nothing.
Reply
KKC

MSD knew exactly what they were doing when they got involved with Derby. They knew what their security would be worth. They are very shrewd and very conservative.

MSD is the specialist football finance arm of the Michael Dell family office. Why on earth would it need a London Office? It’s very niche and very nimble. They factor their time costs on any deal into their (very high) interest rate return. They have been doing this lending for a while - they know exactly what they are doing. The Derby deal admittedly got more complex and time-consuming in the later stages. Probably they’re toughest yet although it’s quite possible that our loan might prove almost as burdensome!
They price their interest rate based on their perceived risk. Our loan is currently around 14% when base rate is just over 5%. When they were charging Derby 15% interest the base rate was only around 1%. These guys are not amateurs.

No they are not looking for an investment in UK football. They have no desire to own a club. In fact that would be very bad for them because it would inhibit them from lending to other clubs.

Of course not every deal is going to go smoothly. Occasionally a Derby situation presents something unexpected that they have to react to - which is exactly what they did. Those were circumstances which arose because of the separate ground ownership. They probably had a choice of pumping in extra £5m (which they got back in full) or having to either enforce liquidation or take control of the club.

If we think our club is a mess then Derby was another scale altogether. At one point liquidation looked inevitable as it was looking impossible for anyone to buy it.
Reply
(08-31-2023, 01:33 PM)Pragmatist Wrote: KKC

MSD knew exactly what they were doing when they got involved with Derby. They knew what their security would be worth.  They are very shrewd and very conservative.

MSD is the specialist football finance arm of the Michael Dell family office.  Why on earth would it need a London Office?  It’s very niche and very nimble. They factor their time costs on any deal into their (very high) interest rate return.  They have been doing this lending for a while - they know exactly what they are doing. The Derby deal admittedly got more complex and time-consuming in the later stages.  Probably they’re toughest yet although it’s quite possible that our loan might prove almost as burdensome!
They price their interest rate based on their perceived risk.  Our loan is currently around 14% when base rate is just over 5%.  When they were charging Derby 15% interest the base rate was only around 1%. These guys are not amateurs.

No they are not looking for an investment in UK football.  They have no desire to own a club. In fact that would be very bad for them because it would inhibit them from lending to other clubs. 

Of course not every deal is going to go smoothly. Occasionally a Derby situation presents something unexpected that they have to react to - which is exactly what they did.  Those were circumstances which arose because of the separate ground ownership.  They probably had a choice of pumping in extra £5m (which they got back in full) or having to either enforce liquidation or take control of the club.

If we think our club is a mess then Derby was another scale altogether.  At one point liquidation looked inevitable as it was looking impossible for anyone to buy it.

+1

The only benefit to MSD taking control of our club would be it would result in a change of ownership, however their due diligence will be nothing more than "do they have the £20m+ interest + our accrued costs" and flipping it asap. Like Prag says, owning a UK club would prevent them lending to other English clubs and shut off a very lucrative sideline for them. They also have no interest in the wellbeing of the club, so that ownership could quite feasibly be essentially selling the stadium and land to a hosuebuilding company if they coughed up the right price. It's not like a high street bank which would no doubt feel the force of public opinion if they tried to do this.

MSD taking ownership rids us of Chinese ownership but opens a potentially much darker end game - I think it's highly unlikely to come to that, but they certainly wont throw any money in if the club is deemed insolvent.
Reply
(08-31-2023, 01:05 PM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: If anything comes of this thread I hope its people learning that they can quote a post without quoting the entire massive thread it belongs to...

Have you seen the average poster thread, more than half of em are managers / directors / financial gurus, they can barely do numbers and you expect them to tidily quote Fred's!!! Big Grin
Reply
(08-31-2023, 01:33 PM)Pragmatist Wrote: KKC

MSD knew exactly what they were doing when they got involved with Derby. They knew what their security would be worth.  They are very shrewd and very conservative.

MSD is the specialist football finance arm of the Michael Dell family office.  Why on earth would it need a London Office?  It’s very niche and very nimble. They factor their time costs on any deal into their (very high) interest rate return.  They have been doing this lending for a while - they know exactly what they are doing. The Derby deal admittedly got more complex and time-consuming in the later stages.  Probably they’re toughest yet although it’s quite possible that our loan might prove almost as burdensome!
They price their interest rate based on their perceived risk.  Our loan is currently around 14% when base rate is just over 5%.  When they were charging Derby 15% interest the base rate was only around 1%. These guys are not amateurs.

No they are not looking for an investment in UK football.  They have no desire to own a club. In fact that would be very bad for them because it would inhibit them from lending to other clubs. 

Of course not every deal is going to go smoothly. Occasionally a Derby situation presents something unexpected that they have to react to - which is exactly what they did.  Those were circumstances which arose because of the separate ground ownership.  They probably had a choice of pumping in extra £5m (which they got back in full) or having to either enforce liquidation or take control of the club.

If we think our club is a mess then Derby was another scale altogether.  At one point liquidation looked inevitable as it was looking impossible for anyone to buy it.

Prag - thanks for your reply.

Para 1. Security value verses realisation cost are very different. What the hell else would you use Pride Park for? Short of knocking flat and building houses on it. That land is almost worthless unless you have a sports club that can play out of it, and that is dependent up on the retention of the "golden share" that grants footballl league status. The FA can revoke this if an insolvency event takes place.

Para 2  - you said they were a Family Office. They aren't. They are an unregulated lender, no better than a private bridging fund. They aren't FCA regulated, and there is no formal recourse to a regulator if you borrow off them.  MSD will have an agenda, and they will have an exit plan. The Derby exit plan involved an extra £5M of debt, and the goodwill of the EFL - the same level of goodwill that wasn't extended to Bury.

Para 3  - Is that why the fund before it became MSD expressed a desire to own Sunderland, who they advanced money to first?

Para 4 - No lender when a company is in administration wants to advance that kind of money. They got that terribly wrong - which points fingers at their due diligence and ongoing monitoring of the debt.

Para 5  - In the Armageddon scenario - which as you say was very close for Derby, I think MSD would have taken the club over. Long term play to recover their funds. Liquidation wouldn't have helped them, as we all know realisation funds are a fraction of the asset value.

I still think we will see more sales tomorrow to assist short term cashflow (as Prag has highlighted previously), I dread to think how the next set of accounts will look, as Prag has here mentioned before. 

It isn't good at all.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: