Corberan/coaching/tactics
#31
Interesting read this Fred.

I think the club (CC, Pearce and Miles), have sat down and decided, quite rightly, that the team needs an identity. That we need to have a set structure and philosophy which we can scout with it in mind. We need to set the team up to develop players which will have resale value in todays market and going forwards. The game is more and more moving towards a possession based, tactical battle, and for the first time I can't see the usual "cyclical" merry go round of tactics as the game is analaysed and said data processed in such a way its hard to find any novel ways of playing. The only real trend I can see emerging is abstract formations and approaches in terms of personnel.

Now, I don't like tip tappy, possession based football. It bores me. But, what I hate more is having a lack of identity. So I cant have my cake an eat it.

I think CC wants us to be far more aggressive/competitive on/off the ball, which is something he consistently talks about. This is the key for me. I don't think our defensive shape, especially in a 5, is too bad, it seems well drilled. But we tend to let the opposition have far too much time on the ball in "non threatening" areas, which normally allows them to pick good and easy passes. I am not talking about us tear arse-ing all over the pitch ala Val. But in what ever level block we play we need to be more active with our defending. We need to reduce the time the opposition has the ball unchallenged and space between the lines. I think that will make the biggest difference in terms of our goal against column.

Offensively, I think (luckily) its the same issue. We don't do anything with enough pace and purpose. Whether it be the tempo of passing in the final third, the number of 3rd man runs we make, the numbers we get in the box (not the #9). Luckily we have 3 players currently not fully fit to come into that attacking area; Grady, Jezza, Maja. All of whom should increase our output offensively.

In terms of CC specifically - My biggest concern this year, and the last 3rd of last season, has been his willingness to make negative substitutions. We have gotten worse each game when he's made changes. Now this is in complete contrast to last season, between Nov-Feb where his subs regularly impacted the game positively. So I am hoping its the fact his more offensive players aren't fit and he just doesn't think Malcolm, Fellows etc. are ready to help the team.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#32
(08-21-2023, 08:09 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Interesting read this Fred.

I think the club (CC, Pearce and Miles), have sat down and decided, quite rightly, that the team needs an identity. That we need to have a set structure and philosophy which we can scout with it in mind. We need to set the team up to develop players which will have resale value in todays market and going forwards. The game is more and more moving towards a possession based, tactical battle, and for the first time I can't see the usual "cyclical" merry go round of tactics as the game is analaysed and said data processed in such a way its hard to find any novel ways of playing. The only real trend I can see emerging is abstract formations and approaches in terms of personnel.

Now, I don't like tip tappy, possession based football. It bores me. But, what I hate more is having a lack of identity. So I cant have my cake an eat it.

I think CC wants us to be far more aggressive/competitive on/off the ball, which is something he consistently talks about. This is the key for me. I don't think our defensive shape, especially in a 5, is too bad, it seems well drilled. But we tend to let the opposition have far too much time on the ball in "non threatening" areas, which normally allows them to pick good and easy passes. I am not talking about us tear arse-ing all over the pitch ala Val. But in what ever level block we play we need to be more active with our defending. We need to reduce the time the opposition has the ball unchallenged and space between the lines. I think that will make the biggest difference in terms of our goal against column.

Offensively, I think (luckily) its the same issue. We don't do anything with enough pace and purpose. Whether it be the tempo of passing in the final third, the number of 3rd man runs we make, the numbers we get in the box (not the #9). Luckily we have 3 players currently not fully fit to come into that attacking area; Grady, Jezza, Maja. All of whom should increase our output offensively.

In terms of CC specifically - My biggest concern this year, and the last 3rd of last season, has been his willingness to make negative substitutions. We have gotten worse each game when he's made changes. Now this is in complete contrast to last season, between Nov-Feb where his subs regularly impacted the game positively. So I am hoping its the fact his more offensive players aren't fit and he just doesn't think Malcolm, Fellows etc. are ready to help the team.

A very good post Lurker that deserves a response!

The frustrating things is that's taken several years for anyone in a position of power here to have realised this. Even putting to one side the shambolic ownership we have here, the failings of Gourlay and co to make the right decisions for the future of the club have been outrageous. As soon as we got relegated we should have been planning for this season as a worst case scenario, but it appears nobody gave it a moment's thought. We have no external funds and as such generating revenue from player sales was the only long term option we had to compete in with PP teams and those with wealthy backing. 

Unfortunately we seemed oblivious to this and continued down the path of signing ageing players on big contracts and investing into wages over fees and that's subsequently left us with players coming to the end of their career with no value and a wagebill that's too high resulting in us having to sell our better and younger players in a desperate attempt to raise cash to pay the fat contracts of ageing players continuing to let us down. 

Proposed on a different thread, the moment we dropped and Sam decided to walk we needed a total reset. There was serious interest in Townsend, Bartley and Furlong that summer, but we seemed determined to keep them. We should have moved them on and invested into younger players who should we not win promotion, we could have sold on. Players like Sheaf and Gyokeres who went to Coventry, even Hamer from Coventry were available at the right price. Flyn Downs, Obafemi, Piroe, Surridge all went for fees we could have comfortably afforded but instead we renewed contracts here and handed big money deals to the likes of Reach. 

When you look at our most saleable assets currently, they're Molumby and BTA, 2 players picked up relatively young and for decent fees. If Dike does somehow get over his successive injuries he may well still net us a profit too some day! What have we got to show for the millions of pounds we've given Chalobah, Kelly, Reach and co over the last few seasons???
Reply
#33
The last 2 posts are spot on .

What I would like out of this team is to stop the other teams playing through our lines we have to be more aggressive I think we are to passive apart from mulumby.

On a different note we are getting caught out with balls coming into the box I would get Bartley in asap to sort this out he is bang on in the air ....just my onions on it .
Reply
#34
(08-21-2023, 05:52 PM)Woodman scoreboard Wrote: The last 2 posts are spot on .

What I would like out of this team is to stop the other teams playing through our lines we have to be more aggressive I think we are to passive apart from mulumby.

On a different note we are getting caught out with balls coming into the box I would get Bartley in asap to sort this out he is bang on in the air ....just my onions on it .

I also think the previous 2 posts are correct. I don't share the love for Bartley though. For me we've seen him let his man go so many times I just think we all know deep down he isn't the answer. Kipre is a good passer, if nowt else, and Ajayi has pace. It can't be beyond the coach's ability to train them to attack the ball in the air. That is the first part of a centre half's job.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: