Today
#1
Bizarre game today.  Tepid first half when we were steady and they were dreadful - before the game got going immediately after the 2nd went in for us.  Could have been 5-5 at the end - not sure we did merit the win at the end but we will take it (especially without a no 9 today). Marks

Palmer 5. Steady first half and reasonable distribution - absolutely no confidence 2nd.  Poor long kicking and his mistake nearly gave them a goal but led to the corner for the 1st. Got to improve

Furlong 6.5. Solid and covered well until getting a stupid booking 1st half. After that, pulled out of a key tackle and gave their dangerous WB too much room. Silly corner with header 

CT 6.5. Tried to be an outlet but didn’t play with much intelligence or leadership. Pieters was constantly telling him to push on to stretch them. Won little defensively when we were struggling but gets a point for the pen 

Semi 7 bit impetuous at times and should have won more aerially but aggressive and pick of back 5. Jumped in a little but did win it.  Good finish for opener

Kipre 5.5. Shaky start and nearly gave a goal away but did settle 2nd half/managed Yates well and covered for Palmer a couple of times. Passing was ok. Nowhere to be seen last 20 when we needed to head the first ball

EP 6 Covered for the other CBs first half and another who can distribute it.  Creaking again 2nd half and doesn’t win enough headers given his size

Okay 6.5. Below standard and didn’t keep the ball well enough 2 half but left a huge gap when subbed.  Key screen and gets his body in/ wins his fair share of headers. Subbed too soon today

Molomby 6.5. Closest thing we have to a leader. After the 2nd Swansea goal he called for a huddle for focus but CT told him it wasnt needed.  Energy and tried to support Jed.  Should not be anywhere near an advanced role

Jed. 6. Off colour again.  Doesn’t use the ball well enough and showed nowhere near enough movement. Got a few crosses in but hits first man a lot

Swift 7.  Disciplined defensive 1st half he got in the game after the break.  Used the ball and decent passes and penno.  Did ok as the point striker after MP subbed

MP 7.  Best player 1st half. One of the few who could see a pass and tried to link play and get in the box. Would have left him on a touch longer

Maja 7. Tried to put himself about and did help us keep the ball in the final part of the 9. Not the quickest but may be an asset

Sarmiento 6.5.  Tricky and a couple of good runs but has to track back more - esp in a game like that. May be useful when chasing games 

Chalobah 5 poor sub and did nothing to stem tide.  Stupid giveaway of a corner that nearly cost us. Offers so little in and out of possession 

Mowatt 4.5. Thought he was even more anonymous. Just filled space and did nothing to break up play.  Barely got on the ball when we needed it most

Bartley 6. Fluffed a routine header as soon as he came on but did marginally settle us down in the final few mins of stoppage time
Reply
#2
Good assessment that pal.

Well spotted on the corners too. That Chalobah one was a bloody joke.

Chalobah does offer something off the ball: time for the opposition to glide effortlessly past him.
Reply
#3
Cheers Manc. Given your scores and assessments it does sound like it wasn't a classic. Lots to work on but thank god we held on. Always important for confidence to get the first win under the belt as early as possible.
Reply
#4
(08-12-2023, 06:31 PM)Peachy Wrote: Cheers Manc. Given your scores and assessments it does sound like it wasn't a classic. Lots to work on but thank god we held on. Always important for confidence to get the first win under the belt as early as possible.

Yep. And that includes pre-season against lower level teams
Reply
#5
I wouldnt argue with any of that. some players were both good and terrible in the same game. I thought the subs came too soon if even necessary at all. I went from relaxed to nerve wracked in the space of 10 minutes.
Reply
#6
Thought we merited the win by a fair bit. Otherwise not much to disagree with
Someone could have been killed
Reply
#7
How was Chalobah received? I’m surprised CC put him on after the reaction to his last “attempt” to play.
Reply
#8
(08-12-2023, 06:47 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: How was Chalobah received? I’m surprised CC put him on after the reaction to his last “attempt” to play.

Few boos but not too bad.
Reply
#9
Thought we were comfortable for 70 minutes. Some lovely link play between midfielders (there weren't any real forwards). A sharp striker and we'd have more
Obviously, I suppose.
Then Swansea woke up and discovered that we're useless defending corners. Bartley just about steaded the defence.
The subs maybe to blame. Too many , too soon.
Good match though.
Reply
#10
(08-12-2023, 06:47 PM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: Thought we merited the win by a fair bit. Otherwise not much to disagree with

Aye, me too. Swansea offered little although we had a warning at 2-0 when they lofted the ball into our box that time. After they noticed we were like rabbits in headlights, they did plenty more of that and no doubt it wont go unnoticed by 22 other sides. If we can't find a Jonas or McCauley for the peanuts on offer, we need to somehow teach our CBs to attack a ball. IMO, we deserved the win but if they had equalised, then it wouldnt have been a shock.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)