Just stop oil protests
(07-20-2023, 12:28 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: What do we do then?  We managed as a species to survive before the jet engine was developed.  We shouldn't be flying products round the world just because we want strawberries at Xmas or the flowers that smell nicer than the one we've grown here.  There has to be an acceptance that this type of commercialism isn't really needed. 

Why do we import Lamb from NZ or Beef from Argentina?  We should be able to produce enough food products here.  Accept that we have to eat less beef if the methane is a problem.  Most people really can't tell the difference in taste.

We've globally over-populated to such an extent that we just need more and more resources all the time and we're creeping further and further into the green lands, forests etc along side needing more food, more animals for us to eat.  If this doesn't change it will end mankind as we know it.

You asked me what type of restrictions or adaptations - I've no idea if air mile restrictions would work, it was just an example.  It would have to be applied globally and to rich/poor alike.  Maybe our co-vid vaccine chips can track us  Big Grin

There are very good reasons why New Zealand lamb is imported; it's both cheaper to produce and costs less in terms of carbon emissions. If you want to impact emissions then import more lamb and close down our awfully uncompetitive and disastrously high emitting Welsh hill farms. And pay the farmers to plant trees.
Reply
(07-20-2023, 12:49 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 12:46 PM)WorcsWBA Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 12:38 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 12:28 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: What do we do then?  We managed as a species to survive before the jet engine was developed.  We shouldn't be flying products round the world just because we want strawberries at Xmas or the flowers that smell nicer than the one we've grown here.  There has to be an acceptance that this type of commercialism isn't really needed. 

Why do we import Lamb from NZ or Beef from Argentina?  We should be able to produce enough food products here.  Accept that we have to eat less beef if the methane is a problem.  Most people really can't tell the difference in taste.

We've globally over-populated to such an extent that we just need more and more resources all the time and we're creeping further and further into the green lands, forests etc along side needing more food, more animals for us to eat.  If this doesn't change it will end mankind as we know it.

You asked me what type of restrictions or adaptations - I've no idea if air mile restrictions would work, it was just an example.  It would have to be applied globally and to rich/poor alike.  Maybe our co-vid vaccine chips can track us  Big Grin

I think you're totally going against human nature. We managed as a species in medieval times, but that doesn't mean quality of life was as good as now. People want to enjoy life!

"Accept that we have to eat less red meat". I'd wager there's a huge proportion of the population that won't accept that. Its not North Korea (I know this phrase gets overused, but my point is people like to have choice).

Plus, if we get to air mile restrictions and red meat restrictions on the public, that's effectively 'carbon credits' for the population isn't it?

I agree regarding producing our own things and not flying stuff round needlessly BTW. But all these things have impacts on jobs etc. Its complex.

Attitudes like this have brought us to the cliff-edge with the climate and it's the same attitudes that will drive us over it like lemmings.

Attitudes like people want to enjoy life? That's hardly unusual!

People like to have choice? Again, hardly unusual!

What sort of society do you want to live in, where people don't want to enjoy life or have choice?

Isn’t that just being an Albion fan?
Reply
(07-20-2023, 12:44 PM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 12:42 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 12:02 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: New BEVs are better than new ICEs for carbon emissions, but driving an old car for as long as possible and buying used are also better than buying new ICEs. There's still a point where the manufactured emissions of a BEV go below the operational emissions of an ICE though.

As for the "eco-friendly" solutions, that's walking, cycling and electrified public transport.

As the owner of 4 used (and 2 ancient) ICEs I'm glad I'm doing my bit for the planet.

I still maintain that EVs will hasten the end of cheap, convenient personal transportation. The price of late model small turbo petrol engined cars will soar post 2030.

Hopefully they'll keep up with the exponential rise in the price of gold.

I will plate the dog's Passat Estate in gold to ensure growth one way or the other. As the new tax on cars will be based on the published kerb weight (apparently) I assume I don't have to declare the additional 250kg or thereabouts?
Reply
(07-20-2023, 12:53 PM)Duffers Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 12:49 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 12:46 PM)WorcsWBA Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 12:38 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 12:28 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: What do we do then?  We managed as a species to survive before the jet engine was developed.  We shouldn't be flying products round the world just because we want strawberries at Xmas or the flowers that smell nicer than the one we've grown here.  There has to be an acceptance that this type of commercialism isn't really needed. 

Why do we import Lamb from NZ or Beef from Argentina?  We should be able to produce enough food products here.  Accept that we have to eat less beef if the methane is a problem.  Most people really can't tell the difference in taste.

We've globally over-populated to such an extent that we just need more and more resources all the time and we're creeping further and further into the green lands, forests etc along side needing more food, more animals for us to eat.  If this doesn't change it will end mankind as we know it.

You asked me what type of restrictions or adaptations - I've no idea if air mile restrictions would work, it was just an example.  It would have to be applied globally and to rich/poor alike.  Maybe our co-vid vaccine chips can track us  Big Grin

I think you're totally going against human nature. We managed as a species in medieval times, but that doesn't mean quality of life was as good as now. People want to enjoy life!

"Accept that we have to eat less red meat". I'd wager there's a huge proportion of the population that won't accept that. Its not North Korea (I know this phrase gets overused, but my point is people like to have choice).

Plus, if we get to air mile restrictions and red meat restrictions on the public, that's effectively 'carbon credits' for the population isn't it?

I agree regarding producing our own things and not flying stuff round needlessly BTW. But all these things have impacts on jobs etc. Its complex.

Attitudes like this have brought us to the cliff-edge with the climate and it's the same attitudes that will drive us over it like lemmings.

Attitudes like people want to enjoy life? That's hardly unusual!

People like to have choice? Again, hardly unusual!

What sort of society do you want to live in, where people don't want to enjoy life or have choice?

Isn’t that just being an Albion fan?

Ha! Maybe the first bit!

Its a real strange take though WorcWBA, would you really expect people not to want to enjoy life or have choices? Maybe the North Korea example does appeal to some!
Reply
(07-20-2023, 12:49 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Good for you, I maintain that the apex of cheap, convenient personal transportation is the bicycle and cars don't even get close.

If I could find a bike that had heated seats that massaged me whilst I zip down the M5 at 70, staying dry in the pouring rain then I'd happily change modes of transport.
Reply
(07-20-2023, 12:56 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 12:49 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Good for you, I maintain that the apex of cheap, convenient personal transportation is the bicycle and cars don't even get close.

If I could find a bike that had heated seats that massaged me whilst I zip down the M5 at 70, staying dry in the pouring rain then I'd happily change modes of transport.

I can't find a bike that carries my golf clubs and trolley either. Nor gets me to Scotland in 5 hours. Or my parents in 3 hours.

Nor one that overweight, disabled and the elderly can use. Nor one that keeps people safe through dodgy areas at night. Nor one that's any good in crap weather.

The idea that more than a few people can be persuaded to use bikes is completely detached from reality IMO.
Reply
(07-20-2023, 01:01 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 12:56 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 12:49 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Good for you, I maintain that the apex of cheap, convenient personal transportation is the bicycle and cars don't even get close.

If I could find a bike that had heated seats that massaged me whilst I zip down the M5 at 70, staying dry in the pouring rain then I'd happily change modes of transport.

I can't find a bike that carries my golf clubs and trolley either. Nor gets me to Scotland in 5 hours. Or my parents in 3 hours.

Buy a Dutch cargo bike and eat more.

Also I reckon that overweight people should probably cycle more.
Reply
(07-20-2023, 01:01 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 12:56 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 12:49 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Good for you, I maintain that the apex of cheap, convenient personal transportation is the bicycle and cars don't even get close.

If I could find a bike that had heated seats that massaged me whilst I zip down the M5 at 70, staying dry in the pouring rain then I'd happily change modes of transport.

I can't find a bike that carries my golf clubs and trolley either. Nor gets me to Scotland in 5 hours. Or my parents in 3 hours.

Nor one that overweight, disabled and the elderly can use. Nor one that keeps people safe through dodgy areas at night. Nor one that's any good in crap weather.

The idea that more than a few people can be persuaded to use bikes is completely detached from reality IMO.

Particularly if they can afford a car.
Reply
(07-20-2023, 12:49 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 12:46 PM)WorcsWBA Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 12:38 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 12:28 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: What do we do then?  We managed as a species to survive before the jet engine was developed.  We shouldn't be flying products round the world just because we want strawberries at Xmas or the flowers that smell nicer than the one we've grown here.  There has to be an acceptance that this type of commercialism isn't really needed. 

Why do we import Lamb from NZ or Beef from Argentina?  We should be able to produce enough food products here.  Accept that we have to eat less beef if the methane is a problem.  Most people really can't tell the difference in taste.

We've globally over-populated to such an extent that we just need more and more resources all the time and we're creeping further and further into the green lands, forests etc along side needing more food, more animals for us to eat.  If this doesn't change it will end mankind as we know it.

You asked me what type of restrictions or adaptations - I've no idea if air mile restrictions would work, it was just an example.  It would have to be applied globally and to rich/poor alike.  Maybe our co-vid vaccine chips can track us  Big Grin

I think you're totally going against human nature. We managed as a species in medieval times, but that doesn't mean quality of life was as good as now. People want to enjoy life!

"Accept that we have to eat less red meat". I'd wager there's a huge proportion of the population that won't accept that. Its not North Korea (I know this phrase gets overused, but my point is people like to have choice).

Plus, if we get to air mile restrictions and red meat restrictions on the public, that's effectively 'carbon credits' for the population isn't it?

I agree regarding producing our own things and not flying stuff round needlessly BTW. But all these things have impacts on jobs etc. Its complex.

Attitudes like this have brought us to the cliff-edge with the climate and it's the same attitudes that will drive us over it like lemmings.

Attitudes like people want to enjoy life? That's hardly unusual!

People like to have choice? Again, hardly unusual!

What sort of society do you want to live in, where people don't want to enjoy life or have choice?

Since we first came onto the scene, mankind has selfishly plundered, pillaged and exploited the planet (and it's flora and fauna) in the name of "enjoying life" in one respect or another. The irony that the end result is going to be that planet will become unliveable on for humans if we carry on the same is obviously lost on you.
Reply
(07-20-2023, 01:02 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 01:01 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 12:56 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 12:49 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Good for you, I maintain that the apex of cheap, convenient personal transportation is the bicycle and cars don't even get close.

If I could find a bike that had heated seats that massaged me whilst I zip down the M5 at 70, staying dry in the pouring rain then I'd happily change modes of transport.

I can't find a bike that carries my golf clubs and trolley either. Nor gets me to Scotland in 5 hours. Or my parents in 3 hours.

Buy a Dutch cargo bike and eat more.

Also I reckon that overweight people should probably cycle more.

Crikey, I've just googled those. So yes you're right I reckon I could get my clubs in there. So do I want to cycle the 10 miles to the golf club? Or get in a car.... tough choice...... Most of my mates live a 15 minute trip down the motorway.... That would be ages on a bicycle, not to mention the fact i tend to go on an evening and come back about midnight. Cycling there? Really? If bikes were so good, millions would use them every day.

And good luck telling overweight people they should cycle more. They have the choice to do that now. People can't even be arsed to walk 15 minutes when they can drive 3 minutes.

And then for many, they physically can't cycle due to disablities. Its cloud cuckoo land stuff.

The way I see it, the only way to get society to take on these things (less driving, less meat, less travel) is to force it. Restrictions. Many have suggested carbon credits is a thing for the future on social media, but it gets dismisses as a conspiracy theory. I never took it seriously, but are some suggesting this could actually be a thing? Really? These kind of restrictions?

(07-20-2023, 01:14 PM)WorcsWBA Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 12:49 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 12:46 PM)WorcsWBA Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 12:38 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 12:28 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: What do we do then?  We managed as a species to survive before the jet engine was developed.  We shouldn't be flying products round the world just because we want strawberries at Xmas or the flowers that smell nicer than the one we've grown here.  There has to be an acceptance that this type of commercialism isn't really needed. 

Why do we import Lamb from NZ or Beef from Argentina?  We should be able to produce enough food products here.  Accept that we have to eat less beef if the methane is a problem.  Most people really can't tell the difference in taste.

We've globally over-populated to such an extent that we just need more and more resources all the time and we're creeping further and further into the green lands, forests etc along side needing more food, more animals for us to eat.  If this doesn't change it will end mankind as we know it.

You asked me what type of restrictions or adaptations - I've no idea if air mile restrictions would work, it was just an example.  It would have to be applied globally and to rich/poor alike.  Maybe our co-vid vaccine chips can track us  Big Grin

I think you're totally going against human nature. We managed as a species in medieval times, but that doesn't mean quality of life was as good as now. People want to enjoy life!

"Accept that we have to eat less red meat". I'd wager there's a huge proportion of the population that won't accept that. Its not North Korea (I know this phrase gets overused, but my point is people like to have choice).

Plus, if we get to air mile restrictions and red meat restrictions on the public, that's effectively 'carbon credits' for the population isn't it?

I agree regarding producing our own things and not flying stuff round needlessly BTW. But all these things have impacts on jobs etc. Its complex.

Attitudes like this have brought us to the cliff-edge with the climate and it's the same attitudes that will drive us over it like lemmings.

Attitudes like people want to enjoy life? That's hardly unusual!

People like to have choice? Again, hardly unusual!

What sort of society do you want to live in, where people don't want to enjoy life or have choice?

Since we first came onto the scene, mankind has selfishly plundered, pillaged and exploited the planet (and it's flora and fauna) in the name of "enjoying life" in one respect or another. The irony that the end result is going to be that planet will become unliveable on for humans if we carry on the same is obviously lost on you.

Its not lost on me! I understand we're working towards net zero by 2050. I have nothing against that at all, as long as it doesn't affect the poor and working classes. Nothing wrong with my view there.

So tell me, what's your vision for society on how you want to get people to stop having choices and enjoying life? Banning air travel? Severe restrictions? As I said in my earlier post, people want to know detail on how it actually affects life. By criticising enjoyment and choices, you're not being very persuasive.

So what's your vision on how we should save the planet? Restrictions? Limiting carbon use per person?
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: