(07-15-2023, 09:19 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: (07-15-2023, 05:52 AM)rsbaggy2 Wrote: (07-14-2023, 11:46 PM)Cuzer Wrote: I see the usual suspects have had their cages rattled
So much poverty in such a big country and the money goes to the rich whilst the poor live off handouts?
You must be so proud boys….
Cuzer
I see the usual suspect has had his cage rattled.
Pride in trying to rebuild a country that was abandoned with a 24 hour derived plan to split it in 2. The legacy that still provokes friction to this day.
As for the poor and rich divide .. I see it only increasing across the world in so called developed nations.
You only reinforce your intense dislike of India with every post. It tells me what I have known for a good while.
You are a pathetic clown.
You've trotted this one out again RSB. You need to expand on it. Are you suggesting that partition was a bad idea? You think that a unified India would have somehow gone on to be a truly multi-cultural and multi-faith society, but the bad old Brits stymied it by splitting it into two? Do you think that 75 years of thoroughly bad behaviour towards each other by both Indian and Pakistani governments is also the fault of the bad old Brits? Are we responsible for the sharp swerve towards Islam in Pakistan and the woeful oppression of all other religions by the Hindu government in India?
I've been to Mumbai and seen people living on the streets, shitting in the streets. It's the most horrible place I've ever been. India has such wealth, such education, intelligence and potential. Why don't the many people who've got something good going for them care about the many more people who live in squalor? Even better, try to do something about it?
And by the way, excusing the woeful inequalities in Indian society by saying that everywhere else is heading the same way is a bit weak. What a trade unionist might call a "race to the bottom".
The partition resulted in a displacement of many millions, the murder of over 1 million and the rape of thousands of women. this shows it was a mistake. To partition a country by religious means was always a recipe for disaster. The message that people of different religions cannot live in harmony (as they were prior) is not a sound basis to split them into different nations.
As for Cyril Radcliffe who was tasked to draw up the lines of partition ... well even he was not agreeable to the haste with which he was told to act. FFS we still haven't done brexit yet and that has been going on for years. He decided to forego his salary as he was not satisfied with the way things ensued.
"I had no alternative, the time at my disposal was so short that I could not do a better job. Given the same period I would do the same thing. However, if I had two to three years, I might have improved on what I did."
Maybe a united India would have posed a threat ... rising from the regime of being a colony to a much more powerful nation.
Sitting here in our relative comfort we can only imagine the horrors that were suffered by the journey made by the millions to get to the ''right country''. My late uncle happened to be in ''Pakistan'' and he had to make the trek to be in what was to become India. He recounted many a time the memories of what he saw and survived, every time bringing him to tears. So yes I may have referred to it before, but to have lived the experience vicariously through his memories of those horrors I don't offer an excuse for raising it when people post such nonsense without knowing what they are talking about.
(07-14-2023, 06:07 PM)Cornflake Wrote: We give aid in a deal for business. It's very calculated and there is little empathy involved.
In a nutshell. No powerful nation, in these times gives something for no return. there will always be an equal opposite side of the equation.