Reverse gentrification...
#11
Whenever I find myself back in Birmingham I am always taken aback at how shit the city centre is, both aesthetically and in terms of facilities, shops, etc. The redevelopment of the Bull Ring and then New St station killed the high street shops and then Covid killed large chunks of the Bull Ring. John Lewis building that massive store in Grand Central then fucking off after a couple of years sums it up.

Sutton Coldfield is a shithole too.
Reply
#12
(07-11-2023, 09:40 AM)Duffers Wrote: Whenever I find myself back in Birmingham I am always taken aback at how shit the city centre is, both aesthetically and in terms of facilities, shops, etc. The redevelopment of the Bull Ring and then New St station killed the high street shops and then Covid killed large chunks of the Bull Ring. John Lewis building that massive store in Grand Central then fucking off after a couple of years sums it up.

Sutton Coldfield is a shithole too.

On the other hand the development around the Library and Town Hall is really smart. Birmingham really isn't shit, not when compared to similar UK cities.
Reply
#13
Reform business rates into a land levy so small, independent businesses aren't screwed over for operating in densely populated areas.

(07-11-2023, 09:40 AM)Duffers Wrote: Whenever I find myself back in Birmingham I am always taken aback at how shit the city centre is, both aesthetically and in terms of facilities, shops, etc. The redevelopment of the Bull Ring and then New St station killed the high street shops and then Covid killed large chunks of the Bull Ring. John Lewis building that massive store in Grand Central then fucking off after a couple of years sums it up.

Sutton Coldfield is a shithole too.

Better than whatever the fuck has happened to Oxford Street in London. Or the Royal Mile in Edinburgh.
Reply
#14
(07-11-2023, 09:44 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Reform business rates into a land levy so small, independent businesses aren't screwed over for operating in densely populated areas.

(07-11-2023, 09:40 AM)Duffers Wrote: Whenever I find myself back in Birmingham I am always taken aback at how shit the city centre is, both aesthetically and in terms of facilities, shops, etc. The redevelopment of the Bull Ring and then New St station killed the high street shops and then Covid killed large chunks of the Bull Ring. John Lewis building that massive store in Grand Central then fucking off after a couple of years sums it up.

Sutton Coldfield is a shithole too.

Better than whatever the fuck has happened to Oxford Street in London.

If you like American sweet shops then fuggedaboutit.
Reply
#15
Strange, Birmingham is one of the better cities to me. But maybe I'm biased. London has some nice areas, admittedly, but whenever I visit (mainly for the NFL games) I'm always amazed at how derelict and dirty large parts of the city are. Especially in and around Tottenham and Wembley. Around the O2 doesn't seem as bad.

Give me Brum over Landan any day.
Reply
#16
This might just be a case of "things were better in my day" thinking, but I grew up in Birmingham in the 90's and remember the city centre before the massive redevelopments of the 00's and 10's. To me the city has lost its soul a little compared to back then.
Reply
#17
(07-11-2023, 09:48 AM)Duffers Wrote: This might just be a case of "things were better in my day" thinking, but I grew up in Birmingham in the 90's and remember the city centre before the massive redevelopments of the 00's and 10's. To me the city has lost its soul a little compared to back then.

Birmingham in the early 1990s was just getting out of being placed into managed decline for 40 years by Whitehall, finally being able to build new commercial and office developments for the first time since the 1960s. I would say you're likely looking at it from a rose-tinted angle especially given the incorrect consensus that Birmingham is a shithole comes from the 80s and 90s, and the consensus now is that it's on the up in terms of the city centre. Probably been a level of decline relative to the early 2010s but that's been every town and city in the country.

Oxford Street or the Royal Mile would be better examples, smaller businesses being completely locked out by rent and business rates, bigger businesses being phased out and dodgy tat stores that are probably fronts for money laundering taking their place.
Reply
#18
(07-11-2023, 09:57 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(07-11-2023, 09:48 AM)Duffers Wrote: This might just be a case of "things were better in my day" thinking, but I grew up in Birmingham in the 90's and remember the city centre before the massive redevelopments of the 00's and 10's. To me the city has lost its soul a little compared to back then.

Birmingham in the early 1990s was just getting out of being placed into managed decline for 40 years by Whitehall, finally being able to build new commercial and office developments for the first time since the 1960s. I would say you're likely looking at it from a rose-tinted angle especially given the incorrect consensus that Birmingham is a shithole comes from the 80s and 90s, and the consensus now is that it's on the up in terms of the city centre. Probably been a level of decline relative to the early 2010s but that's been every town and city in the country.

Oxford Street or the Royal Mile would be better examples, smaller businesses being completely locked out by rent and business rates, bigger businesses being phased out and dodgy tat stores that are probably fronts for money laundering taking their place.

You're probably right, and at least I acknowledged that at the start of my post.

You always look fondly on the time you grew up in.
Reply
#19
(07-11-2023, 09:40 AM)Duffers Wrote: Whenever I find myself back in Birmingham I am always taken aback at how shit the city centre is, both aesthetically and in terms of facilities, shops, etc. The redevelopment of the Bull Ring and then New St station killed the high street shops and then Covid killed large chunks of the Bull Ring. John Lewis building that massive store in Grand Central then fucking off after a couple of years sums it up.

Sutton Coldfield is a shithole too.

Sutton Coldfield high street is up there with Erdington high street.

Tragic

Solihull town centre far ahead now.
Reply
#20
(07-11-2023, 10:23 AM)Super-Okay Wrote:
(07-11-2023, 09:40 AM)Duffers Wrote: Whenever I find myself back in Birmingham I am always taken aback at how shit the city centre is, both aesthetically and in terms of facilities, shops, etc. The redevelopment of the Bull Ring and then New St station killed the high street shops and then Covid killed large chunks of the Bull Ring. John Lewis building that massive store in Grand Central then fucking off after a couple of years sums it up.

Sutton Coldfield is a shithole too.

Sutton Coldfield high street is up there with Erdington high street.

Tragic

Solihull town centre far ahead now.

Re Solihull town centre 

M&S relocated from Mell Sq, to 2 miles out of town on to a retail park
As did mountain warehouse 

House of Frasier is closing down this month, if it hasn’t already. 

So around Mell Sq is dying. 

A number of other shops are vacant. 

I understand there’s the intention to demolish the shops around Mell Square and to replace them with flats with restaurants below, similar to Brindley place. 


If ever you’re in Solihull and you fancy a coffee, you’ve come to the right place, as the town centre is full of them now.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: