It's The Ashes (again)
(06-29-2023, 04:58 PM)SuperBob2002 Wrote:
(06-29-2023, 04:39 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Can we check Cameron Green isn't spot fixing?

It'd be unlike the Aussies to cheat?

Not sure bowling a load of no balls is helping the Aussies out much personally. It's cost them at least one, probably two wickets.
Reply
(06-29-2023, 05:38 PM)wba13 Wrote: Well done England a good days cricket, yes a couple of stupid dismissals but Stokes bought a calm to the end of the day.
Say what you like but Englands brand of cricket is never negative or dull can’t say that about some teams.
We will win more than we lose, we just have to work out how to play against negative tactics.

Aye a good day's cricket but again we are architects of our own downfall. It isn't dull, true, but it is infuriating. Duckett does what he does but Root and Pope's dismissals were ridiculous and just gifted the Aussies. Sometimes you need to take advantage of the situation and with Lyons out we should have let the bowlers wear themselves out.
Reply
I’ve watched the smith catch to dismiss Root a dozen times and I don’t know what the video saw but the ball definitely touches the ground it should have been not out. Just like the green Duckett in the first test.
For me unless they can be absolutely sure it should be not out. There guessing wrong
Just my unbiased opinion of course.
Reply
(06-29-2023, 07:18 PM)wba13 Wrote: I’ve watched the smith catch to dismiss Root a dozen times and I don’t know what the video saw but the ball definitely touches the ground it should have been not out. Just like the green Duckett in the first test.
For me unless they can be absolutely sure it should be not out. There guessing wrong
Just my unbiased opinion of course.

Good post. It wasn't a catch. If you pause it at the right spot the ball makes contact with the grass. 

The fact the third umpire had to have several looks at it tells me he wasn't sure, therefore it's not out - you shouldn't give a wicket unless you're 100% sure it's out.
Reply
All in all a great day’s cricket. Some cheap batting at times, but that’s our style. And I back it. This lot can’t play their way, and we’d be foolish to be lulled into that on either pitch so far.

That said, we should all probably post a few on the Women’s ashes thread, for fear of being labelled misogynists.
Reply
Lyon is a massive massive loss for the Aussies, presuming he’s out for the whole series.
Reply
(06-29-2023, 08:15 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: Lyon is a massive massive loss for the Aussies, presuming he’s out for the whole series.

Unlike us however, they do have an spinning alternative in Todd Murphy who went well in India earlier in the year. 

They've made me eat my words a little today, much sharper, much more on it and focussed and the batsmen stood up when I questioned whether they would. Need Brook to go big tomorrow and support from Stokes and Bairstow. If we can bat until tea time tomorrow we'll give ourselves a real chance in this game - from pretty much nowhere yesterday.
Reply
Batting last, I won't be comfortable with anything other than a first innings lead. A tough ask with only Bairstow's batting to come after these.
Reply
(06-29-2023, 08:18 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(06-29-2023, 08:15 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: Lyon is a massive massive loss for the Aussies, presuming he’s out for the whole series.

Unlike us however, they do have an spinning alternative in Todd Murphy who went well in India earlier in the year. 

They've made me eat my words a little today, much sharper, much more on it and focussed and the batsmen stood up when I questioned whether they would. Need Brook to go big tomorrow and support from Stokes and Bairstow. If we can bat until tea time tomorrow we'll give ourselves a real chance in this game - from pretty much nowhere yesterday.

Yes they have Murphy, but he won’t be close to the class of Lyon this series (he could well be good in future)
Reply
(06-29-2023, 07:49 PM)SuperBob2002 Wrote:
(06-29-2023, 07:18 PM)wba13 Wrote: I’ve watched the smith catch to dismiss Root a dozen times and I don’t know what the video saw but the ball definitely touches the ground it should have been not out. Just like the green Duckett in the first test.
For me unless they can be absolutely sure it should be not out. There guessing wrong
Just my unbiased opinion of course.

Good post. It wasn't a catch. If you pause it at the right spot the ball makes contact with the grass. 

The fact the third umpire had to have several looks at it tells me he wasn't sure, therefore it's not out - you shouldn't give a wicket unless you're 100% sure it's out.

Not sure I really agree with you guys. Only in the modern era with such good video coverage can these things be reviewed in such detail. It's judged on whether the fielder had the ball in his control, not simply whether the ball touched the ground or not. In the old days the umpires would have seen that he had hold of the ball before he and it hit the ground and that he came up holding it. If he claimed he'd caught it they'd take his word. We're creating our own problems dealing with these Aussies. I don't think these disputed catches are the key to it.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: