English Cricket
#61
(06-28-2023, 12:19 PM)Squid Wrote:
(06-27-2023, 06:50 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Problems with cricket;

normal comps/ academies don’t play the game much because it’s too much hassle and they don’t get enough PE time to set-up properly with all the pads and helmets etc.

the game isn’t sexy for many young people compared to the more dynamic sports.

there aren’t many places to play these days because parks aren’t set up for people twatting rock hard balls at each other amongst parents and toddlers, gym equipment, cafes etc

I can’t comment on the societal problems the game has because I don’t play the game, I only really have experience at school and tbh unless you’re batting or bowling it’s fugging tedious PE lesson. Far rather do tennis or athletics at the time.

Cricket is fundamentally flawed, it’s dull to play for most kids. To be entertaining for a younger generation it has had to pantomime itself up with daft names, silly pyjamas sorry kits, pointless gimmicks and a shit load of beer to help keep peoples interest and generate an atmosphere. As much as it may be a problem with racism, sexism and other isms its main problem is it can’t compete with other more exciting sports or pastimes.

There's cricket being played every weekend at Victoria Park in Smethwick.

Incorrect. Derek doesn't like it and it is therefore rubbish and irrelevant.
Reply
#62
Out of interest how many dalits have played for India? Or tamils for Sri Lanka? Or indigenous for Aus?
Doesn’t excuse our failings but at least we’ve taken the first steps in acknowledging them
Being brutally honest 
Reply
#63
(06-28-2023, 12:30 PM)Beachboysbaggie Wrote: Out of interest how many dalits have played for India? Or tamils for Sri Lanka? Or indigenous for Aus?
Doesn’t excuse our failings but at least we’ve taken the first steps in acknowledging them
Off the top of my head Sirajs pops was of lower caste I believe. 
Think you'll find there are quite a few more.
Reply
#64
(06-28-2023, 12:57 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote:
(06-28-2023, 12:30 PM)Beachboysbaggie Wrote: Out of interest how many dalits have played for India? Or tamils for Sri Lanka? Or indigenous for Aus?
Doesn’t excuse our failings but at least we’ve taken the first steps in acknowledging them
Off the top of my head Sirajs pops was of lower caste I believe. 
Think you'll find there are quite a few more.

Nope only 3 more
Being brutally honest 
Reply
#65
Muralitharan is a Tamil
Pakistan have picked Christians, the last one being Yousef Youhana
Namibias cricket team does not reflect their countries ethnic make up
Zimbabwe's nearly does

Most of the North and East European's T20 sides do not
Reply
#66
(06-28-2023, 12:23 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(06-28-2023, 12:19 PM)Squid Wrote:
(06-27-2023, 06:50 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Problems with cricket;

normal comps/ academies don’t play the game much because it’s too much hassle and they don’t get enough PE time to set-up properly with all the pads and helmets etc.

the game isn’t sexy for many young people compared to the more dynamic sports.

there aren’t many places to play these days because parks aren’t set up for people twatting rock hard balls at each other amongst parents and toddlers, gym equipment, cafes etc

I can’t comment on the societal problems the game has because I don’t play the game, I only really have experience at school and tbh unless you’re batting or bowling it’s fugging tedious PE lesson. Far rather do tennis or athletics at the time.

Cricket is fundamentally flawed, it’s dull to play for most kids. To be entertaining for a younger generation it has had to pantomime itself up with daft names, silly pyjamas sorry kits, pointless gimmicks and a shit load of beer to help keep peoples interest and generate an atmosphere. As much as it may be a problem with racism, sexism and other isms its main problem is it can’t compete with other more exciting sports or pastimes.

There's cricket being played every weekend at Victoria Park in Smethwick.

Incorrect. Derek doesn't like it and it is therefore rubbish and irrelevant.

…and there is nobody playing in my two local parks whenever I visit which is most days. Also my son has had one lesson in cricket all term and even that was indoors and he’s at a school that traditionally would have played the game all late spring/summer. I’m not sure anecdotal evidence really helps see the bigger problem with the sport. 

Also you are no more biased than I am, given you think it’s the best sport in the world. Somewhere between our two positions on the game is probably where the sport is. Cricket I’m sure suffers from societal problems but it also suffers from not being a sexy game that loads of young people want to play from across the whole of society not sections of it.
Reply
#67
(06-28-2023, 01:09 PM)Beachboysbaggie Wrote:
(06-28-2023, 12:57 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote:
(06-28-2023, 12:30 PM)Beachboysbaggie Wrote: Out of interest how many dalits have played for India? Or tamils for Sri Lanka? Or indigenous for Aus?
Doesn’t excuse our failings but at least we’ve taken the first steps in acknowledging them
Off the top of my head Sirajs pops was of lower caste I believe. 
Think you'll find there are quite a few more.

Nope only 3 more
Are you saying that that India’s issues with cast mitigates the racism sexism classism & elitism in English cricket!!??.. Huh 

Just for your your information India’s highest office President is a lady from the SC community
Reply
#68
(06-28-2023, 03:34 PM)pindgill Wrote:
(06-28-2023, 01:09 PM)Beachboysbaggie Wrote:
(06-28-2023, 12:57 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote:
(06-28-2023, 12:30 PM)Beachboysbaggie Wrote: Out of interest how many dalits have played for India? Or tamils for Sri Lanka? Or indigenous for Aus?
Doesn’t excuse our failings but at least we’ve taken the first steps in acknowledging them
Off the top of my head Sirajs pops was of lower caste I believe. 
Think you'll find there are quite a few more.

Nope only 3 more
Are you saying that that India’s issues with cast mitigates the racism sexism classism & elitism in English cricket!!??.. Huh 

Just for your your information India’s highest office President is a lady from the SC community

No I’m not, hence my sentence “doesn’t excuse our failings….”
However I am saying that classism and elitism aren’t just issues in the English game, and that at least we’ve started the process of rectifying by shining a light on it.
Being brutally honest 
Reply
#69
(06-28-2023, 03:34 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(06-28-2023, 12:23 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(06-28-2023, 12:19 PM)Squid Wrote:
(06-27-2023, 06:50 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Problems with cricket;

normal comps/ academies don’t play the game much because it’s too much hassle and they don’t get enough PE time to set-up properly with all the pads and helmets etc.

the game isn’t sexy for many young people compared to the more dynamic sports.

there aren’t many places to play these days because parks aren’t set up for people twatting rock hard balls at each other amongst parents and toddlers, gym equipment, cafes etc

I can’t comment on the societal problems the game has because I don’t play the game, I only really have experience at school and tbh unless you’re batting or bowling it’s fugging tedious PE lesson. Far rather do tennis or athletics at the time.

Cricket is fundamentally flawed, it’s dull to play for most kids. To be entertaining for a younger generation it has had to pantomime itself up with daft names, silly pyjamas sorry kits, pointless gimmicks and a shit load of beer to help keep peoples interest and generate an atmosphere. As much as it may be a problem with racism, sexism and other isms its main problem is it can’t compete with other more exciting sports or pastimes.

There's cricket being played every weekend at Victoria Park in Smethwick.

Incorrect. Derek doesn't like it and it is therefore rubbish and irrelevant.

…and there is nobody playing in my two local parks whenever I visit which is most days. Also my son has had one lesson in cricket all term and even that was indoors and he’s at a school that traditionally would have played the game all late spring/summer. I’m not sure anecdotal evidence really helps see the bigger problem with the sport. 

Also you are no more biased than I am, given you think it’s the best sport in the world. Somewhere between our two positions on the game is probably where the sport is. Cricket I’m sure suffers from societal problems but it also suffers from not being a sexy game that loads of young people want to play from across the whole of society not sections of it.


Thing is Derek, when folk see you coming, EVERYONE legs it...
Reply
#70
(06-28-2023, 11:16 AM)rsbaggy2 Wrote:
(06-28-2023, 11:06 AM)pindgill Wrote:
(06-28-2023, 09:05 AM)Cuzer Wrote: Intersting thread, some accurate insightful comments, some waffle

I suppose you could say that about every thread on here mind ;-)

I think cricket now is so different from where it was back in the 70's/80's and the experiences RS talks of

I played a high level in the 80's early 90's and yes it was very much a closes shop to some, not all, the Asian/EM teams were very much that, teams, WB Dartmouth for example at the time were 90% Asian when we played them, had the misfortune of facing Alimgar Sheriyar........quick! but they very much stuck to theri team and a divide existed, verbals and racism was prominent from both sides

Now, to me, it's different, just a stroll around any village cricket green at the weekend you'll see just as many Black/Asian players as white players so at club level now inclusion shouldn't be an issue to hang your hat on

Cuzer
Your completely myopic!!!!..... "see no evil hear no evil".
For gods sake listen to the people its affected over 4000 contributed to this report just because its always summer and G&Ts at your village cricket game its not the same in the real world!!.
The real world is anathema to some.
Bit harsh. My experience is similar to Cuzer's. I've been around clubs in the B'ham league for years (unfortunately not playing), and I see little to no racism. (dons ton hat!). My grandad played that level for M and B over a long time, he played with some of the first wave of immigrants. I've been a visitor at West Brom Dartmouth, (mainly Asian) and it was renowned as the worst place for sledging. Very sociable after the game though! I also have experience of Attock CC and that is never particularly sociable. I dont doubt the report being accurate  though, somehow we seem to have gone backwards. Cricket is riddled with class distinctions, absolutely. I've already posted about my earlier experience on trying to get a game as a council house urchin at a club full of grammer school boys. I hope this report results in a real initiative to open the game up to all.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: