Posts: 4,108
Threads: 50
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
13
(06-28-2023, 08:39 AM)SuperBob2002 Wrote: (06-28-2023, 08:22 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: (06-28-2023, 08:11 AM)SuperBob2002 Wrote: (06-28-2023, 07:40 AM)rsbaggy2 Wrote: (06-28-2023, 07:02 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Backyard cricket was the staple of all my summers growing up (when it wasn't pissing down), easy to play and no need for equipment other than a bat and a ball.
The only sensible PE lesson for cricket is to get in the nets in the school gym, if your school had them, getting kids to play outdoor cricket is as pointless as setting an XI a side footy match up as there's always a few who aren't interested.
Cricket has a lot of problems, being boring isn't one of them, it's potentially the third most played sport in the world. However, in this country we do have an issue, one that will be on show at Lord's at 11am as our 100% white, 73% privately educated England team take to the field against Australia.
In a nutshell.
I'm not sure that's fair considering the following;
Adil Rashid has no interest in red ball but is selected in white ball.
Moeen Ali is injured and obviously played last Test.
Rehan Ahmed was selected in the current squad.
Jordan Archer is injured but would no doubt be selected if fully fit.
Saqib Mahmood has been selected and played relatively recently, ditto Chris Jordan. As has Haseeb Hameed, I think?
That's just a few examples of England selecting BAME based players. Yes, we could do more to encourage participation in children so that the pool is more diverse but the evidence is there that if you're good enough you will be selected, regardless of race. It's the grassroots mentality that appears to be the core issue here? Unless I'm missing the point.
There are clearly issues, and improvements are needed, but to say we're 100% not inclusive is incorrect.
I'm not saying we aren't and haven't been inclusive at times - we're a damn sight more diverse than say, Australia who I think have only ever had about six or seven indigenous players represent them for example. It's just a bit ironic that on the day the report is released saying we have problems with racism and elitism in English cricket, we put out a side at Lords that is 100% white of which three quarters of them went to private schools. What's more ironic is that one of the players you mention Ahmed, should be nowhere near the squad based on his performances with ball in hand so far this season. The obvious next pick would be Liam Dawson, who guess what.... is white and privately educated.
The steps taken to fix the issues highlighted will take years, decades even, to bear fruit. It won't happen overnight! It really does need to start at schools and get children into cricket from an early age and help nurture and develop the talent of all (I'm anti-box ticking - for want of a better phrase. I.e I don't want to see rules introduced that force sides to select players based on their ethnicity etc) so that the best, regardless of race, sex, class etc are given equal chances and selected for counties and countries.
Equality of opportunity rather than equality of outcome. Equality of opportunity is evidently not the case with cricket, and that is the key thing they need to change.
In terms of selecting the players for the Test team, I'm not sure the argument people are making is valid. They're just going to pick the best players for the team (debatable - see Ashes thread, but point remains). The problem is getting more class diverse, more ethnically diverse players interested in the game, into the club and county system. Get more in at the lower levels, and you will see them play for England.
The fact that we have areas with high Asian populations like Birmingham, many towns in Yorkshire, Leicester etc, yet you rarely see them break into the county teams and above, shows you the problem. Read about Moeen's dad, and his story and battle with Warwickshire, and I'm sure you can replicate that across many places.
Posts: 5,201
Threads: 197
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
14
Intersting thread, some accurate insightful comments, some waffle
I suppose you could say that about every thread on here mind ;-)
I think cricket now is so different from where it was back in the 70's/80's and the experiences RS talks of
I played a high level in the 80's early 90's and yes it was very much a closes shop to some, not all, the Asian/EM teams were very much that, teams, WB Dartmouth for example at the time were 90% Asian when we played them, had the misfortune of facing Alimgar Sheriyar........quick! but they very much stuck to theri team and a divide existed, verbals and racism was prominent from both sides
Now, to me, it's different, just a stroll around any village cricket green at the weekend you'll see just as many Black/Asian players as white players so at club level now inclussion shouldn't be an issue to hang your hat on
Cuzer
Fisheatingdeludedsealwankers
Posts: 4,258
Threads: 263
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
25
(06-27-2023, 06:50 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Problems with cricket;
normal comps/ academies don’t play the game much because it’s too much hassle and they don’t get enough PE time to set-up properly with all the pads and helmets etc.
the game isn’t sexy for many young people compared to the more dynamic sports.
there aren’t many places to play these days because parks aren’t set up for people twatting rock hard balls at each other amongst parents and toddlers, gym equipment, cafes etc
I can’t comment on the societal problems the game has because I don’t play the game, I only really have experience at school and tbh unless you’re batting or bowling it’s fugging tedious PE lesson. Far rather do tennis or athletics at the time.
Cricket is fundamentally flawed, it’s dull to play for most kids. To be entertaining for a younger generation it has had to pantomime itself up with daft names, silly pyjamas sorry kits, pointless gimmicks and a shit load of beer to help keep peoples interest and generate an atmosphere. As much as it may be a problem with racism, sexism and other isms its main problem is it can’t compete with other more exciting sports or pastimes.
Derek, your personal antipathy towards cricket is fine, no-one says you have to enjoy it. I'm known to hate rugby union (having played it a lot) and golf (having never tried anything bigger than pitch'n'putt in Singleton Park Swansea on holiday). I'm allowed those opinions.
But the flaws of cricket neither explain nor excuse the elitism, racism and misogyny which are undeniably present in the English game. Poynton CC (Cheshire League) in the mid-80s, the club captain declared "there's never been a black man in Poynton's first XI and there won't be on my watch". Did I call him out? No, as a 30-odd year old who couldn't get many games for the 4th team, I wasn't going to influence anything, but I did pack it in that year.
Posts: 17,072
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(06-28-2023, 08:38 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: (06-28-2023, 08:33 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (06-28-2023, 07:02 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: (06-27-2023, 06:50 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Problems with cricket;
normal comps/ academies don’t play the game much because it’s too much hassle and they don’t get enough PE time to set-up properly with all the pads and helmets etc.
the game isn’t sexy for many young people compared to the more dynamic sports.
there aren’t many places to play these days because parks aren’t set up for people twatting rock hard balls at each other amongst parents and toddlers, gym equipment, cafes etc
I can’t comment on the societal problems the game has because I don’t play the game, I only really have experience at school and tbh unless you’re batting or bowling it’s fugging tedious PE lesson. Far rather do tennis or athletics at the time.
Cricket is fundamentally flawed, it’s dull to play for most kids. To be entertaining for a younger generation it has had to pantomime itself up with daft names, silly pyjamas sorry kits, pointless gimmicks and a shit load of beer to help keep peoples interest and generate an atmosphere. As much as it may be a problem with racism, sexism and other isms its main problem is it can’t compete with other more exciting sports or pastimes.
Backyard cricket was the staple of all my summers growing up (when it wasn't pissing down), easy to play and no need for equipment other than a bat and a ball.
The only sensible PE lesson for cricket is to get in the nets in the school gym, if your school had them, getting kids to play outdoor cricket is as pointless as setting an XI a side footy match up as there's always a few who aren't interested.
Cricket has a lot of problems, being boring isn't one of them, it's potentially the third most played sport in the world. However, in this country we do have an issue, one that will be on show at Lord's at 11am as our 100% white, 73% privately educated England team take to the field against Australia.
Only a handful of countries play the game, the fact that one has a huge population skews the argument that the game is relevant and exciting for most people. The game isn’t relevant or practical at any meaningful level for most kids even before you add in the class and race barriers. Obviously they are intrinsically linked but don’t skew over 1 billion people in one country as proof the game is attractive to the rest of the world.
The game can be relevant and practical - you don't need any specialist equipment to play backyard cricket, I did for years. Just because you don't like it doesn't mean that it is boring and irrelevant.
I think the documentary Freddie Flintoff did was brilliant, showed loads of kids from council estates in Preston that anyone can play cricket with minimal equipment and that it wasn't just a game for "posh kids".
There are issues with the current system but the game itself isn't one of them. As I said, test cricket is arguably the greatest game there is.
There’s a big difference from hitting a few balls in the backyard with a mate or brother/sister and actually wanting to play the sport competitively. Also unless you’re the bowler or batmen and to a lesser extent the wicket keeper it’s essentially standing around in a field hoping something might happen around you. Contrast that with football, basketball etc where there is constant action and you then start to see why many kids don’t want to play the game, not to mention many people from urban areas don’t have backyards or gardens to hit a few balls around and the roads are not safe to hit even tennis balls.
Peoples attention spans are not great these days, which is why you have 20/20 etc and even that relies on people being allowed to get shit faced in grounds to make it enjoyable
If state schools don’t play because it’s a hassle then there in lies the problem, not to mention years of the game being put on subscription only TV, there is very little exposure to the game let alone playing it. I went to a state school thirty years ago and even then we played a handful of times to my memory.
Posts: 10,545
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
(06-28-2023, 09:09 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Peoples attention spans are not great these days, which is why you have 20/20 etc and even that relies on people being allowed to get shit faced in grounds to make it enjoyable
Have you watched the Albion recently?!
Posts: 11,922
Threads: 798
Joined: Oct 2022
Reputation:
50
You don't get the coked up louts at the cricket though.
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Posts: 4,668
Threads: 183
Joined: Nov 2022
Reputation:
14
I'm not sure the attention span argument is entirely true. I often lose concentration at T20. It doesn't grab me like a 4 day Champ match or a Test match, which absolutely grips me, unless it's meandering to a draw on a featherbed pitch. I just don't get the same intrigue and tension at T20's. But I accept the longer format isn't for everyone.
Cricket is a fantastic sport to watch AND play. Not everyone will agree, that's fine. Not everyone likes football! But there's plenty of children who would love the chance to play for a club on a regular basis, given the chance. Counties, schools or whoever must ensure they are given every opportunity to do so.
I went to watch Central Sparks at Edgbaston a few weeks back when I was on annual leave. There were two blocks of school kids (probably about 1,000?) A lot of which were Asian girls. I got the impression they absolutely loved the experience of watching. They certainly made enough racket! This kind of initiative from Warwickshire is the exact thing that needs to happen regularly if we're to get girls and ethnic groups falling in love with the game.
Although I'm not sure how often you can take kids out of school for the best part of 3 hours!
Posts: 656
Threads: 43
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
3
(06-28-2023, 09:05 AM)Cuzer Wrote: Intersting thread, some accurate insightful comments, some waffle
I suppose you could say that about every thread on here mind ;-)
I think cricket now is so different from where it was back in the 70's/80's and the experiences RS talks of
I played a high level in the 80's early 90's and yes it was very much a closes shop to some, not all, the Asian/EM teams were very much that, teams, WB Dartmouth for example at the time were 90% Asian when we played them, had the misfortune of facing Alimgar Sheriyar........quick! but they very much stuck to theri team and a divide existed, verbals and racism was prominent from both sides
Now, to me, it's different, just a stroll around any village cricket green at the weekend you'll see just as many Black/Asian players as white players so at club level now inclusion shouldn't be an issue to hang your hat on
Cuzer Your completely myopic!!!!..... "see no evil hear no evil".
For gods sake listen to the people its affected over 4000 contributed to this report just because its always summer and G&Ts at your village cricket game its not the same in the real world!!.
Posts: 6,454
Threads: 192
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
26
(06-28-2023, 11:06 AM)pindgill Wrote: (06-28-2023, 09:05 AM)Cuzer Wrote: Intersting thread, some accurate insightful comments, some waffle
I suppose you could say that about every thread on here mind ;-)
I think cricket now is so different from where it was back in the 70's/80's and the experiences RS talks of
I played a high level in the 80's early 90's and yes it was very much a closes shop to some, not all, the Asian/EM teams were very much that, teams, WB Dartmouth for example at the time were 90% Asian when we played them, had the misfortune of facing Alimgar Sheriyar........quick! but they very much stuck to theri team and a divide existed, verbals and racism was prominent from both sides
Now, to me, it's different, just a stroll around any village cricket green at the weekend you'll see just as many Black/Asian players as white players so at club level now inclusion shouldn't be an issue to hang your hat on
Cuzer Your completely myopic!!!!..... "see no evil hear no evil".
For gods sake listen to the people its affected over 4000 contributed to this report just because its always summer and G&Ts at your village cricket game its not the same in the real world!!. The real world is anathema to some.
Posts: 8,841
Threads: 315
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
78
(06-27-2023, 06:50 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Problems with cricket;
normal comps/ academies don’t play the game much because it’s too much hassle and they don’t get enough PE time to set-up properly with all the pads and helmets etc.
the game isn’t sexy for many young people compared to the more dynamic sports.
there aren’t many places to play these days because parks aren’t set up for people twatting rock hard balls at each other amongst parents and toddlers, gym equipment, cafes etc
I can’t comment on the societal problems the game has because I don’t play the game, I only really have experience at school and tbh unless you’re batting or bowling it’s fugging tedious PE lesson. Far rather do tennis or athletics at the time.
Cricket is fundamentally flawed, it’s dull to play for most kids. To be entertaining for a younger generation it has had to pantomime itself up with daft names, silly pyjamas sorry kits, pointless gimmicks and a shit load of beer to help keep peoples interest and generate an atmosphere. As much as it may be a problem with racism, sexism and other isms its main problem is it can’t compete with other more exciting sports or pastimes.
There's cricket being played every weekend at Victoria Park in Smethwick.
|