The politicisation of women’s health choices
#11
I agree with that Squid, basically expands on my complexity comment
Someone could have been killed
Reply
#12
(06-13-2023, 06:54 PM)Squid Wrote:
(06-13-2023, 04:35 PM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: As someone who has worked extensively in provision of sexual health services I can fully see the complexity of this case. Whatever the right and wrongs, prison, and particularly prison in the antiquated service we have in the UK, is a dreadfully sad outcome here

Yes. She shouldn't have gone to prison.

However, some of the reporting/coverage of this case has been less than ideal. The full sentencing remarks are worth a read:

https://crimeline.co.uk/carla-foster-sen...june-2023/

We have time limits for abortion ( unless there are exceptional circumstances) for a reason.

Yes I am inclined to agree with you.

I wouldn't wish to comment on this specific case, I am not qualified to do so.

But it does seem to be one of those very difficult criminal areas where genuinely compelling claims collide against each other.

In general I agree with Duffers and Proth that women should be in complete control of their bodies. However we already accept time limits to legal abortions, which limit that control.

Where that time limit is drawn I'm not qualified to say. But I think there should be a time limit.
Reply
#13
I think the original theory behind the cut off date was viability of the fetus. It was reduced in 1991 to 24 weeks. Nowadays, 22 weekers surviving is not uncommon. I've just googled and the youngest survivor was just 19 weeks when born.

Whether that is the correct factor to apply, however, is an interesting point.
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
#14
"There are no sentencing guidelines for this offence" - "There are no analogous guidelines on which the
court can draw" Clearly he had some room. What possible benefit is there in sending her to prison? What a vindictive prick.
Reply
#15
What possible benefit is there for sending her to prison?

Just screams of vindictiveness, and in the current climate of debate just causes more issues.
Reply
#16
Good to see the outcome has been amended to what was probably the best of a shit range of options in the first place
Someone could have been killed
Reply
#17
(06-14-2023, 11:32 AM)Pontificator Wrote: "There are no sentencing guidelines for this offence" - "There are no analogous guidelines on which the
court can draw" Clearly he had some room. What possible benefit is there in sending her to prison? What a vindictive prick.

Agree. Whatever the rights and wrongs of the law (I really would not like to comment), sending her - a mother of 3 including a disabled child, to gaol was ridiculous.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)