My team for Vile
#1
Smile 
4-1-3-2

                  Sam 
Holgate-Hegazi-Dawson-Gibbs
                   Jake
     Phillips-Johansen-Brunt
               JRod-Gayle

Subs: Bond, Townsend, Tulloch, Field, Harper, Edwards & Bartley
Reply
#2
(05-06-2019, 11:40 AM)11amstart Wrote: 4-1-3-2

                  Sam 
Holgate-Hegazi-Dawson-Gibbs
                   Jake
     Phillips-Johansen-Brunt
               JRod-Gayle

Subs: Bond, Townsend, Tulloch, Field, Harper, Edwards & Bartley

I'd agree with that on tye whole but do worry whether Brunt will be up to it.
Reply
#3
Remarkable similarity to my thread this morning

Big Grin
Reply
#4
(05-06-2019, 11:41 AM)Solihull Throstle Wrote:
(05-06-2019, 11:40 AM)11amstart Wrote: 4-1-3-2

                  Sam 
Holgate-Hegazi-Dawson-Gibbs
                   Jake
     Phillips-Johansen-Brunt
               JRod-Gayle

Subs: Bond, Townsend, Tulloch, Field, Harper, Edwards & Bartley

I'd agree with that on tye whole but do worry whether Brunt will be up to it.

That midfield has got to nullify McGinn and Grealish. Jake will see yellow sooner or later and Brunt won't have the pace to keep up. I don't pretend to know the answer but coping with those two is key imho
Reply
#5
He’s played. 3 at the back every game since takaing over. He’s not going to change that now.
Reply
#6
(05-06-2019, 12:03 PM)Dumbo Wrote: He’s played. 3 at the back every game since takaing over. He’s not going to change that now.

Worryingly I agree. He needs to though. The ease with which Waghorn got between them yesterday for the opener will have given Abraham all the encouragement he needs to be fit.
Reply
#7
(05-06-2019, 12:41 PM)B36baggie Wrote:
(05-06-2019, 12:03 PM)Dumbo Wrote: He’s played. 3 at the back every game since takaing over. He’s not going to change that now.

Worryingly I agree. He needs to though. The ease with which Waghorn got between them yesterday for the opener will have given Abraham all the encouragement he needs to be fit.

When did facts become irrelevant on this dump? Eh? Shan started the first five matches in the league with a back four. He changed to five at half time against Bristol City and has stuck with it ever since.

I've always said that if two centre backs aren't hacking it, adding a third who isn't even as good won't help. Organizing three is more difficult than organizing two, plus you have two others to blame when it all goes wrong. Chaotic marking yesterday. If any of our coaches this season had tried to find a stable midfield line-up that worked, we would be OK with our best back four. Over-reliance on Barry (38) and Brunt (35) has crippled us IMO. Field should be starting (in midfield, of course) and Bartley should be sitting on the bench.

I'm disturbed by the choice of Bartley as captain in recent weeks. He must have hitherto unnoticed leadership qualities - or maybe the hierarchy suspect that any other candidates (Hegazi, Gibbs, JRod, Dawson) will be off in summer, promoted or not.
Reply
#8
(05-06-2019, 01:42 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(05-06-2019, 12:41 PM)B36baggie Wrote:
(05-06-2019, 12:03 PM)Dumbo Wrote: He’s played. 3 at the back every game since takaing over. He’s not going to change that now.

Worryingly I agree. He needs to though. The ease with which Waghorn got between them yesterday for the opener will have given Abraham all the encouragement he needs to be fit.

When did facts become irrelevant on this dump? Eh? Shan started the first five matches in the league with a back four. He changed to five at half time against Bristol City and has stuck with it ever since.

I've always said that if two centre backs aren't hacking it, adding a third who isn't even as good won't help. Organizing three is more difficult than organizing two, plus you have two others to blame when it all goes wrong. Chaotic marking yesterday. If any of our coaches this season had tried to find a stable midfield line-up that worked, we would be OK with our best back four. Over-reliance on Barry (38) and Brunt (35) has crippled us IMO. Field should be starting (in midfield, of course) and Bartley should be sitting on the bench.

I'm disturbed by the choice of Bartley as captain in recent weeks. He must have hitherto unnoticed leadership qualities - or maybe the hierarchy suspect that any other candidates (Hegazi, Gibbs, JRod, Dawson) will be off in summer, promoted or not.
Agree, would do a Pulis for the first leg, 4.5.1 including Sam Field in Mid
Reply
#9
(05-06-2019, 11:40 AM)11amstart Wrote: 4-1-3-2

                  Sam 
Holgate-Hegazi-Dawson-Gibbs
                   Jake
     Phillips-Johansen-Brunt
               JRod-Gayle

Subs: Bond, Townsend, Tulloch, Field, Harper, Edwards & Bartley

Brunt for Jake, Jake for Johansen, Murphy for Brunt.

I would have Barry for Jake, but obviously can't. This way we don't have to worry about Brunt's legs, but I admit having Murphy in there worries me. 

Back 4/5 and front 2 pick themselves. The midfield is a real conundrum, though. Pick any 4 from 8.
Reply
#10
(05-06-2019, 01:42 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(05-06-2019, 12:41 PM)B36baggie Wrote:
(05-06-2019, 12:03 PM)Dumbo Wrote: He’s played. 3 at the back every game since takaing over. He’s not going to change that now.

Worryingly I agree. He needs to though. The ease with which Waghorn got between them yesterday for the opener will have given Abraham all the encouragement he needs to be fit.

When did facts become irrelevant on this dump? Eh? Shan started the first five matches in the league with a back four. He changed to five at half time against Bristol City and has stuck with it ever since.

I've always said that if two centre backs aren't hacking it, adding a third who isn't even as good won't help. Organizing three is more difficult than organizing two, plus you have two others to blame when it all goes wrong. Chaotic marking yesterday. If any of our coaches this season had tried to find a stable midfield line-up that worked, we would be OK with our best back four. Over-reliance on Barry (38) and Brunt (35) has crippled us IMO. Field should be starting (in midfield, of course) and Bartley should be sitting on the bench.

I'm disturbed by the choice of Bartley as captain in recent weeks. He must have hitherto unnoticed leadership qualities - or maybe the hierarchy suspect that any other candidates (Hegazi, Gibbs, JRod, Dawson) will be off in summer, promoted or not.
Good call Idea
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)