Why I think Yunyai will now look to sell
#41
(05-09-2023, 02:32 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(05-09-2023, 12:53 PM)BurleyBaggie Wrote:
(05-09-2023, 12:47 PM)Mr vertical Wrote: Great post Prag. I've been thinking for a while that the MSD loan was sought out to buy us time to find a buyer. This may also explain why Carlos is still engaged as much as he is.

In many ways the MSD loan forces sale: the debt for shares obligation means any default further increases losses and the terms prohibit any further cash leaving the business.

Therefore, they need to sell now to minimise any further losses.

I'm not aware of any debt for equity swap option being announced? Surely the only way that could happen would be if the loan was in default? S4A have completely missed the point and the structure of these types of loans, as evidenced by some of the questions they asked in the letter recently published.

The club has insufficient cashflow to meet it's day to day obligations, so this loan will most likely be structured with a bullet repayment, possibly with interest rolling up. Asking about what the repayment term is (we know it is 4 years) and the split between capital and interest misses the point.

So if the loan is payable in 4 years time, then pressure from MSD won't be the catalyst for something to happen. It will be when we can't afford to pay the wages, or our committed transfer fees (like the remaining instalments on Grant's loan) that will likely force MSD into action. As Prag suggested in the opening post, Lai will want the club gone before then, otherwise the investors will lose everything.

The only thing we don't know is when will happen? I said early I thought Lai might have one more season, but I'm starting to agree with Prag. I say this because our Turnover in the year ended June 2022 with TV/Parachute monies stripped out was £13.7M. A typical Chump club would receive £5M, so let's round it up to £20M for us in the EFL. Our wage bill in 2022 was £42.7M. And we owe a further £10.7M to other league clubs in transfers(reduced by £2M in the last 12 months). Even with the MSD £20M, I think something has to give. Our monthly outgoings have to be c£4M a month, possibly more.

There’s no debt for equity swap option. 

The S4A questions are very good ones - trying to force details out into the open. Some questions are possible more relevant than others, but there are lots of stones to look underneath.

MSD are no fools - they don’t enter into these loans not expecting to get paid.  They’ve got enough security to satisfy them but they won’t want to call it in.  This is basically bridging finance to buy time for a sale.  I believe Yunyai probably made a decision to sell this time last year, but wanted this season to see if they could sell with Premier League status to try to get £100m more of their money back. They needed a Plan B though, and that is where we are now. 

I don’t think Lai can afford another season, without selling all players worth selling and somehow trying to replace them very cheaply, which hardly enhances the prospects of promotion.  If our chances of promotion in 2022/3 were 30%, then in 2023/4 without a new owner injecting some cash it’s probably less than 5%, and with a much reduced share value with mounting debt.  Not worth the effort compared to taking a sensible price now, and certainly not worth the added risk of administration and losing everything in a year’s time.  But of course there’s no guarantee that a sale of the club will get agreed this summer, so using the £20m loan and making sales of players has to be the alternative. 

Timing-wise it makes no sense to start selling players immediately if a sale is going to happen.  This is why I expect a sale to potentially already lined up now that we know where we are. The sooner the better so that everyone can move forward ready for the new season.  

The next few weeks could be very interesting - one way or another!
Reply
#42
They may be willing to sell. Having willing buyers may be the issue.
Reply
#43
(05-09-2023, 11:41 AM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(05-09-2023, 11:38 AM)Peachy Wrote: Great thread this and an interesting read Prag.

I know nothing about football deals but all through my 20's I worked on land deals for both residential and commercial developers. It was common practice in lots of deals that upsides were built into the land price. The selling party would insert clauses that gave them a second pay day should the purchaser achieve a larger number of units on their land at a later date.

Could this not be a way of making the deal happen quickly? Everyone knows we are only worth ©£50m and Lai and his investors paid £200m. Maybe there could be a structured deal whereby another £10m or so could be paid for each year we spend in the prem up to a maximum of 5 years or something?

Any deal is possible if buyer and seller agree the commercial terms. Another option is for a buyer to acquire a (say) 40% stake with an option to buy the balance.  The Czech investor at West Ham has done something similar.

(05-09-2023, 08:43 AM)spudgun Wrote: An interesting viewpoint, and I apologise in advance for only picking up on a small point of this. I've always wondered why the term 'investment' is used in relation to football clubs as nearly all of them don't even get close to breaking even.

To me, football, especially at our level, can never be an investment as you have very little chance of getting your money back and unless you are looking to have losses on your books so you can offset gains in other profitable areas, why on earth would someone want to 'invest' in football.

Again, apologies for going off on a bit of a tangent as it grinds my gears when fans ask for an 'investment' in their club as the owners might as well burn the money in the street as they have next to no chance of getting any of it back if they 'invest' in the club.


Correct.  Money can only be made by buying an underpriced club because of its circumstances.  There has to be upside, and buying at full value in the Premier League like Yunyai did had no upside whatsoever.  At our correct current value we are probably now an attractive proposition, assuming that a purchaser can buy at that value.  Wolves and Villa were both acquired cheaply because of their huge debts at that time. 

Only a sustained spell in the Premier League MIGHT generate an investment return.  So there have to be other reasons for buying, ie brand development.  The strong US Dollar and weak pound help at present to provide potential upside via currency gains.   And then of course there are some buyers who are just looking to launder money, and for whom any loss is the laundering cost.  

I’m actually struggling to think of many “investors” who will have made money out of buying a UK football club in the top two divisions in the last 20 years.  Brentford might. The Glazers obviously have.  Any others?

There's money to be made if you're willing to commit, invest sensibly and not look for an immediate financial payday.

Leeds' owners bought them for around £40m and whilst they have invested their own cash, they've already sold less than half the club for c.£200m to the 49ers and have an option to sell more this summer. David Sullivan will make a fortune out of West Ham, they're being valued at the best part of a billion quid due to the stadium, and both he and David Gold did very well out of the Bluenoses. Burnley's owners also made a packet out of their sale to the Americans last year.

Ultimately the value is in taking a side from L1/Champ into the PL and selling - this is where Peace made his money, and how despite massive, massive investment both Tony Bloom and Matthew Benham would probably make a profit on their spending should they sell Brighton and Brentford respectively this summer, and Parrish and co will certainly be onto a big payday when he cashes in on Palace. Buying a readymade PL side just isn't profitable unless you're going to run it in a sustainable way and hope the revenue streams keep increasing and sell it several years later such as Ashley did with Newcastle (bought for £55m in 2007, sold for £305m) or FSG will do with Liverpool (bought Liverpool for £300m!!!! 12 years ago and despite having already sold 10% for about £500m, are looking for c.£2bn for their controlling stake!). You can also spend absolutely bucket loads trying to crack the Champions League (ironically Man City's ownership would probably make a profit on all their spending if they were to sell now!) but this is high risk, only have to look at the losses Villa, Sunderland, Everton have racked up without actually winning anything or making viable progress.

We've been an unattractive investment due to how well run we were and with us having such limited further potential for growth. The only way we will attract significant external investment is if there's an upside for the investor - Yunyai thought they could curry favour back home through owning us so making money through the football business wasn't a key factor in their purchase but Chinese policy change and a global pandemic combined with god awful management from the top down has meant the investment as never even come close to washing its face, and with the odds stacked against us in the PL without intelligent ownership or deep pockets, we've massively regressed.
Reply
#44
(05-09-2023, 04:09 PM)Cunninghamismagic Wrote: They may be willing to sell. Having willing buyers may be the issue.

If there's someone who's been willing to buy Blues, there must also be someone out there who's willing to buy us!
Reply
#45
(05-09-2023, 04:52 PM)WorcsWBA Wrote:
(05-09-2023, 04:09 PM)Cunninghamismagic Wrote: They may be willing to sell. Having willing buyers may be the issue.

If there's someone who's been willing to buy Blues, there must also be someone out there who's willing to buy us!

I think there are interested buyers, but the problem is that Lai and co have been asking for too high a price. That may change now, hopefully.
Reply
#46
(05-09-2023, 04:45 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(05-09-2023, 11:41 AM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(05-09-2023, 11:38 AM)Peachy Wrote: Great thread this and an interesting read Prag.

I know nothing about football deals but all through my 20's I worked on land deals for both residential and commercial developers. It was common practice in lots of deals that upsides were built into the land price. The selling party would insert clauses that gave them a second pay day should the purchaser achieve a larger number of units on their land at a later date.

Could this not be a way of making the deal happen quickly? Everyone knows we are only worth ©£50m and Lai and his investors paid £200m. Maybe there could be a structured deal whereby another £10m or so could be paid for each year we spend in the prem up to a maximum of 5 years or something?

Any deal is possible if buyer and seller agree the commercial terms. Another option is for a buyer to acquire a (say) 40% stake with an option to buy the balance.  The Czech investor at West Ham has done something similar.

(05-09-2023, 08:43 AM)spudgun Wrote: An interesting viewpoint, and I apologise in advance for only picking up on a small point of this. I've always wondered why the term 'investment' is used in relation to football clubs as nearly all of them don't even get close to breaking even.

To me, football, especially at our level, can never be an investment as you have very little chance of getting your money back and unless you are looking to have losses on your books so you can offset gains in other profitable areas, why on earth would someone want to 'invest' in football.

Again, apologies for going off on a bit of a tangent as it grinds my gears when fans ask for an 'investment' in their club as the owners might as well burn the money in the street as they have next to no chance of getting any of it back if they 'invest' in the club.


Correct.  Money can only be made by buying an underpriced club because of its circumstances.  There has to be upside, and buying at full value in the Premier League like Yunyai did had no upside whatsoever.  At our correct current value we are probably now an attractive proposition, assuming that a purchaser can buy at that value.  Wolves and Villa were both acquired cheaply because of their huge debts at that time. 

Only a sustained spell in the Premier League MIGHT generate an investment return.  So there have to be other reasons for buying, ie brand development.  The strong US Dollar and weak pound help at present to provide potential upside via currency gains.   And then of course there are some buyers who are just looking to launder money, and for whom any loss is the laundering cost.  

I’m actually struggling to think of many “investors” who will have made money out of buying a UK football club in the top two divisions in the last 20 years.  Brentford might. The Glazers obviously have.  Any others?

There's money to be made if you're willing to commit, invest sensibly and not look for an immediate financial payday.

Leeds' owners bought them for around £40m and whilst they have invested their own cash, they've already sold less than half the club for c.£200m to the 49ers and have an option to sell more this summer. David Sullivan will make a fortune out of West Ham, they're being valued at the best part of a billion quid due to the stadium, and both he and David Gold did very well out of the Bluenoses. Burnley's owners also made a packet out of their sale to the Americans last year.

Ultimately the value is in taking a side from L1/Champ into the PL and selling - this is where Peace made his money, and how despite massive, massive investment both Tony Bloom and Matthew Benham would probably make a profit on their spending should they sell Brighton and Brentford respectively this summer, and Parrish and co will certainly be onto a big payday when he cashes in on Palace. Buying a readymade PL side just isn't profitable unless you're going to run it in a sustainable way and hope the revenue streams keep increasing and sell it several years later such as Ashley did with Newcastle (bought for £55m in 2007, sold for £305m) or FSG will do with Liverpool (bought Liverpool for £300m!!!! 12 years ago and despite having already sold 10% for about £500m, are looking for c.£2bn for their controlling stake!). You can also spend absolutely bucket loads trying to crack the Champions League (ironically Man City's ownership would probably make a profit on all their spending if they were to sell now!) but this is high risk, only have to look at the losses Villa, Sunderland, Everton have racked up without actually winning anything or making viable progress.

We've been an unattractive investment due to how well run we were and with us having such limited further potential for growth. The only way we will attract significant external investment is if there's an upside for the investor - Yunyai thought they could curry favour back home through owning us so making money through the football business wasn't a key factor in their purchase but Chinese policy change and a global pandemic combined with god awful management from the top down has meant the investment as never even come close to washing its face, and with the odds stacked against us in the PL without intelligent ownership or deep pockets, we've massively regressed.

That’s largely correct.  All of those clubs where a big gain has been made already are big clubs in big cities (ie they were sleeping giants like Leeds, West Ham and Newcastle).  A profit would be made on selling Brentford, but Bloom has invested over £400m in Brighton and I doubt he’ll see all that back.  Ironically, one could argue that Brighton and Brentford are not in a very different place to where we were when Lai bought us - small clubs at their peak and with very limited upside. Relegation might easily come their way within a couple of years and their new owners would really struggle to make back their top price paid.
Reply
#47
Commercial conjecture, surmising or whatever - it’s a good read Prag.  Agree on the cultural factor too and see it with our corporate clients from China. Who knows what weight it has here

I doubt whether Y will care who they sell to. But on the scale 1-100 
/ speaking relatively - I don’t think the new owners could be much worse than the current lot
Reply
#48
(05-09-2023, 05:51 PM)MancBaggie Wrote: Commercial conjecture, surmising or whatever - it’s a good read Prag.  Agree on the cultural factor too and see it with our corporate clients from China. Who knows what weight it has here

I doubt whether Y will care who they sell to. But on the scale 1-100 
/ speaking relatively - I don’t think the new owners could be much worse than the current lot

*checks to make sure it wasn't CIM saying that  Big Grin
Reply
#49
The fact is the longer the club stays in the championship the less value the club is, but conversely it becomes more attractive for a would be investor with long term aspirations like the owners at Villa and possibly now at Blues...to buy at the lower end, should the owners look to sell on.

Worryingly taking out the £20m loan to assist with working capital commitments is a concern too and highlights liquidity issues.... who knows how this translates to next season and the playing staff, who goes who stays. We seem to be sliding downwards, slower than some have done in the past, but nonetheless the wrong way and there does not seem to be any indicators this will reverse soon.

As some have already mentioned the only way to make money is to sell on. Liverpool and Man Utd the examples where the current owners will stand to make money.

If you look back in time to the criteria for owning  a club, it's  staggering to think where we are now.

70 - 80's millionaire
90s -00s multi millionaire
10-20' Billionaire
20s......multi Billonaire...
Next Trillionaire

The thirst to be 1st in football, knows no limits and is not abating. The fact is there doesn't appear to be any real adequate controls in place to govern the elite clubs from one season to the next -  when you look at the sums  now involved -  and the losses those clubs suffer, the clubs will continue to spend. 

The Premier League brand continues to grow at a pace which is why English Clubs should appear to be an attractive position for owners with deep pockets and a long term plan, hopefully the Baggies will fall into that category some day soon..
Reply
#50
(05-09-2023, 09:10 AM)SausEggBaton Wrote:
(05-09-2023, 09:05 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(05-09-2023, 09:01 AM)SausEggBaton Wrote:
(05-09-2023, 08:45 AM)baggiebloke Wrote: Given their clear cashperation, I see the merits of this to them, and to us.

God knows who we'll end up with though.

I know I'd rather have Mickey Mouse running us than Pikachu.

Pokemon is Japanese, not Chinese.

Rumbled, I couldn't think of any Chinese cartoons.

Angel Big Grin

Hong Kong Phooey :-)
Sponsored by Bet365 - other betting sites are available
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: