WBAUnofficial
Why I think Yunyai will now look to sell - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Why I think Yunyai will now look to sell (/showthread.php?tid=29924)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6


Why I think Yunyai will now look to sell - Pragmatist - 05-09-2023

I’ve been convinced for some time now that Yunyai will actively look to sell the club. It is totally understandable that they would not sell before knowing whether they would be selling a Premier League club or a Championship club (with no parachute funding left) as that’s the difference between selling a club worth £150m or a club worth £60m.  They now know. 

They don’t have funds to invest into the club, but they know that extra cash is needed to keep the club ticking over.  I don’t believe they took out the £20m MSD loan as a long-term strategy.  I believe they took it to buy time and breathing space to sell the club this summer as a going concern.  Without that cash flow boost, the club may well have been likely to run out of cash before the end of next season (despite being balance sheet solvent) which would have meant that the threat of administration was much higher and would reduce the value to Yunyai to a lot less than £60m.  

They know that without parachute funding, every other club in the Championship is dependent on shareholder loans, which they cannot provide. The risk of relegation within 2-3 years would be a lot higher, further reducing the value of their investment. 

There is not a single reason left now for Yunyai to hang on to their investment.  The chances of promotion have now diminished massively, while the chances of relegation or mere stagnation have risen proportionately.  Now is the time to achieve an orderly sale at the best price possible, at a time when there is no significant external debt (the £20m MSD loan has not yet been spent, so the cash sits on the other side of the balance sheet.  Right now, the club is still worth around £60m to £70m, but that price will diminish soon when that MSD cash gets used up. 

Yunyai are now likely to be talking to the potential (American) buyers who wanted to buy last year for around £100m, plus others.  

There is not a single reason remaining for Yunyai to retain this investment. Their 1,000+ investors will have already lost 70% of their original investment. 30% is the absolute most they will get back, and it could quickly become 15% if they don’t sell in the coming weeks. 

“Loss of face” (important in Chinese culture) has already happened.  Holding out for promotion via the play-offs was fully justified to try to recover “face”.  But the investors aren’t totally stupid. Notwithstanding the “face” factor, every bad investment eventually comes to an end with a commercial decision. 

I’m not remotely ITK, although I know a fair bit about Chinese culture. I would be very surprised indeed if the button has not already been pressed in Shanghai to seek to sell the club this summer.  Their investment has completely run its course.


RE: Why I think Yunyai will now look to sell - rsbaggy2 - 05-09-2023

(05-09-2023, 08:32 AM)Pragmatist Wrote: I’ve been convinced for some time now that Yunyai will actively look to sell the club. It is totally understandable that they would not sell before knowing whether they would be selling a Premier League club or a Championship club (with no parachute funding left) as that’s the difference between selling a club worth £150m or a club worth £60m.  They now know. 

They don’t have funds to invest into the club, but they know that extra cash is needed to keep the club ticking over.  I don’t believe they took out the £20m MSD loan as a long-term strategy.  I believe they took it to buy time and breathing space to sell the club this summer as a going concern.  Without that cash flow boost, the club may well have been likely to run out of cash before the end of next season (despite being balance sheet solvent) which would have meant that the threat of administration was much higher and would reduce the value to Yunyai to a lot less than £60m.  

They know that without parachute funding, every other club in the Championship is dependent on shareholder loans, which they cannot provide. The risk of relegation within 2-3 years would be a lot higher, further reducing the value of their investment. 

There is not a single reason left now for Yunyai to hang on to their investment.  The chances of promotion have now diminished massively, while the chances of relegation or mere stagnation have risen proportionately.  Now is the time to achieve an orderly sale at the best price possible, at a time when there is no significant external debt (the £20m MSD loan has not yet been spent, so the cash sits on the other side of the balance sheet.  Right now, the club is still worth around £60m to £70m, but that price will diminish soon when that MSD cash gets used up. 

Yunyai are now likely to be talking to the potential (American) buyers who wanted to buy last year for around £100m, plus others.  

There is not a single reason remaining for Yunyai to retain this investment. Their 1,000+ investors will have already lost 70% of their original investment. 30% is the absolute most they will get back, and it could quickly become 15% if they don’t sell in the coming weeks. 

“Loss of face” (important in Chinese culture) has already happened.  Holding out for promotion via the play-offs was fully justified to try to recover “face”.  But the investors aren’t totally stupid. Notwithstanding the “face” factor, every bad investment eventually comes to an end with a commercial decision. 

I’m not remotely ITK, although I know a fair bit about Chinese culture. I would be very surprised indeed if the button has not already been pressed in Shanghai to seek to sell the club this summer.  Their investment has completely run its course.

I hope and believe this is a realistic situation we are now in. Currently it would be the best thing we could hope for provided any new owners are realistic and arrive with the intention of enhancing their investment. It may be that we will have to wait a few years to tilt at the Premier League again but a secure and vested owner(s) is the priority now.


RE: Why I think Yunyai will now look to sell - SW4Baggie - 05-09-2023

As ever you speak a lot of sense Prag, and I'd also add to the above that the USD is weakening and forecast to continue to do so meaning now is the best time for Americans to invest, and with the global political situation so very fluid at present, the Chinese may not have the opportunity to offload Western assets, or sell for USD in the near future also.

Yunyai's gamble has failed, and I also expect they will sell in the next 12 months as whilst there is still a chance of promotion next season (look at the squad we are likely to still have + the MSD loan propping up our financial position), their record in running a football club thus far suggests they do not have the expertise or know-how to capitalise on this opportunity.

Concerns for me will be just how much due diligence they will do on the incoming owners, how attractive a proposition we will be when there are clubs available at half our price in the same division with significantly lower running costs (although admittedly our lack of debt is attractive), and how easily both the outstanding dividend and Wisdom loans can "disappear" in the magic of a takeover.


RE: Why I think Yunyai will now look to sell - spudgun - 05-09-2023

An interesting viewpoint, and I apologise in advance for only picking up on a small point of this. I've always wondered why the term 'investment' is used in relation to football clubs as nearly all of them don't even get close to breaking even.

To me, football, especially at our level, can never be an investment as you have very little chance of getting your money back and unless you are looking to have losses on your books so you can offset gains in other profitable areas, why on earth would someone want to 'invest' in football.

Again, apologies for going off on a bit of a tangent as it grinds my gears when fans ask for an 'investment' in their club as the owners might as well burn the money in the street as they have next to no chance of getting any of it back if they 'invest' in the club.


RE: Why I think Yunyai will now look to sell - Birdman1811 - 05-09-2023

I hope you're right.


RE: Why I think Yunyai will now look to sell - Spandaubaggie - 05-09-2023

Thanks for this post Prag and I hope you are right.

The amount of people on this board who have seemingly relished doom-mongering in the past 24 hours I've found unpalatable.

Facing no parachute payments and a 3rd season in a row in the champ for the first time since the 90s, together with a faceless regime who don't seem to have a plan or the clubs interests at heart, we all know we are up against it.

However, as I've said before nothing is without hope in our situation as things can change quickly in football.

Those writing our obituary seem to overlook the many clubs who have been through the mill and now are coming back like 3 of them in the play-offs, plus our standing as a club.

We are in many people's eyes a big club with a rich history and a million miles away from the likes of Bury.

We have to accept there's little as fans we can do at the minute, as Blues have shown under a similar regime, but hopefully our dark tunnel might be a short one.


RE: Why I think Yunyai will now look to sell - baggiebloke - 05-09-2023

Given their clear cashperation, I see the merits of this to them, and to us.

God knows who we'll end up with though.


RE: Why I think Yunyai will now look to sell - Duffers - 05-09-2023

Here's hoping....


RE: Why I think Yunyai will now look to sell - rsbaggy2 - 05-09-2023

(05-09-2023, 08:44 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: Thanks for this post Prag and I hope you are right.

The amount of people on this board who have seemingly relished doom-mongering in the past 24 hours I've found unpalatable.

Facing no parachute payments and a 3rd season in a row in the champ for the first time since the 90s, together with a faceless regime who don't seem to have a plan or the clubs interests at heart, we all know we are up against it.

However, as I've said before nothing is without hope in our situation as things can change quickly in football.

Those writing our obituary seem to overlook the many clubs who have been through the mill and now are coming back like 3 of them in the play-offs, plus our standing as a club.

We are in many people's eyes a big club with a rich history and a million miles away from the likes of Bury.

We have to accept there's little as fans we can do at the minute, as Blues have shown under a similar regime, but hopefully our dark tunnel might be a short one.

If Blues can attract ''investors'' in their current situation, then I would hope that we would certainly have options for new ownership given our less parlous state.


RE: Why I think Yunyai will now look to sell - Remi_Moses - 05-09-2023

Sensible common sense post bar the comments about Chinese culture.
While companies they own are still providing funds they do not sell.
Even just the few million Ken and Lai take in wages is as far as they are concerned a reason not to sell.
They have demonstrated time and time again selling is not an option.
That's Chinese culture.