Posts: 4,002
Threads: 162
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
25
We have other assets, not just players. A training ground and football ground to start with. The ground is far from safe with the community interest/heritage (whatever it’s called), that just gives people a 6 month opportunity to buy and preserve the status.
Buy if for a knock down fire sale price (I’m sure they could speak to some of their contacts to put in low prices to justify a low Market Value on a sealed bid process) then lease it back for a stupidly high amount. MSD paid off, the club would still play football at the hawthorns and they would be taking their money back, and some, for years to come. A new owner could always buy the ground back for a price to suit Lai.
Lai would be crazy to let it go to MSD when he could just cash those in.
Trump is a Cunt
Posts: 944
Threads: 20
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
0
MSD’s charge prevents Lai from selling the ground or any other capital assets unless used to pay off their loan.
Posts: 18,398
Threads: 256
Joined: Jan 2019
04-25-2023, 10:09 PM
(This post was last modified: 04-25-2023, 10:11 PM by Kit Kat Chunky.)
(04-25-2023, 08:31 PM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote: (04-25-2023, 06:57 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: It depends on the loan documentation, which we are not privy to.
The process of Administration is designed to protect the limited company and prevent Liquidation. Derby appointed Administrators to protect the club, which MSD as debenture holders must have consented to, and agreed on who the Administrator was.
There will be clauses in the loan agreement, including non repayment which will allow MSD to appoint an Administrative Receiver. Prag seems certain there is something in there which means MSD can take over without Admin. I guess that could only be an assignment (transfer) of the shares if the loan defaults.
I'm not sure on this though. MSD would have to be fit and proper, and as owners they would assume responsibility for all debts and obligations (including transfer instalments) and I'm not sure they would want that. It also means that Lai's consortium has agreed to give the club away for £20M.
We know the loan is repayable in 4 years, and this is when MSD will come knocking. More likely is that when the £20M is used to pay the bills next season, then we will not have the funds to pay bills in 24/25. The wage bill will still be too high for a Champ club, and we will still have some transfer obligations like the Grant fee. I think this is when the fire sale starts, and if that isn't enough to balance the books, then the creditors owed money will be knocking on the door - forcing the club into Admin. Breach of FFP is likely at this point as well. Our losses will be massive (we are borrowing £20M to cover losses now we have no parachute) so we will be on the verge of breaching FFP.
The only decent saleable assets will be Dara, and the keepers. The others are Chump journeymen, and nobody in the Chump will have the money to buy them.
Would MSD become liable for outstanding liabilities? Not too sure about that, myself.
If you buy a controlling stake in a Ltd company then you don’t become personally liable for the company’s debts.
As for the fit and proper thing - if a potless dwarf can blah that test then I’m sure big Micky Dell will manage just fine.
You don't buy a stake, that's the whole point. The debts are still there. Even if you bought a stake, the debts are live. As shareholder your personal liability is the extent of your investment. The Limited Company is its own legal entity and responsible for its obligations.
The only way to lose the debts is Admin. A majority of unsecured creditors have to agree a reduced payout. HMRC won't do a deal and all football debts have to be paid. In this scenario MSD can use their security (the ground, training ground etc) to achieve 100% repayment of their debt.
Posts: 18,398
Threads: 256
Joined: Jan 2019
Wouldn't surprise me if the interest was "rolled up". We just don't know until we see some accounts which are 12 months away.