Administration
#11
(04-25-2023, 04:47 PM)Johnny akes Wrote: Doesn’t need HMRC to put us into administration, any creditor could if there’s no likelihood of repayments and MSD could do it as soon as we default on the loan payments. Should be noted that MSD’s past record is quite positive I believe, in that they kept Derby going without asset stripping until a buyer could be found; they know it is easier to find a buyer for a viable business than one which has been stripped of its worth, although it could be different in our case as we (or rather Holdings) owns the ground whereas Derby didn’t and in their case their assets might not have been sufficient to cover the loan.

I know, it's just usually HMRC that do it.

Either way, we are in for a frustrating few years. Even with promotion.
Reply
#12
(04-25-2023, 04:50 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(04-25-2023, 04:47 PM)Johnny akes Wrote: Doesn’t need HMRC to put us into administration, any creditor could if there’s no likelihood of repayments and MSD could do it as soon as we default on the loan payments. Should be noted that MSD’s past record is quite positive I believe, in that they kept Derby going without asset stripping until a buyer could be found; they know it is easier to find a buyer for a viable business than one which has been stripped of its worth, although it could be different in our case as we (or rather Holdings) owns the ground whereas Derby didn’t and in their case their assets might not have been sufficient to cover the loan.

I know, it's just usually HMRC that do it.

Either way, we are in for a frustrating few years. Even with promotion.

Thats the spirit.  Tongue
Reply
#13
We aren't having the 20m in stages, we've had the full amount.
Reply
#14
Indeed.

The full amount has been drawn down.
Reply
#15
It depends on the loan documentation, which we are not privy to.


The process of Administration is designed to protect the limited company and prevent Liquidation. Derby appointed Administrators to protect the club, which MSD as debenture holders must have consented to, and agreed on who the Administrator was.

There will be clauses in the loan agreement, including non repayment which will allow MSD to appoint an Administrative Receiver. Prag seems certain there is something in there which means MSD can take over without Admin. I guess that could only be an assignment (transfer) of the shares if the loan defaults.

I'm not sure on this though. MSD would have to be fit and proper, and as owners they would assume responsibility for all debts and obligations (including transfer instalments) and I'm not sure they would want that. It also means that Lai's consortium has agreed to give the club away for £20M.

We know the loan is repayable in 4 years, and this is when MSD will come knocking. More likely is that when the £20M is used to pay the bills next season, then we will not have the funds to pay bills in 24/25. The wage bill will still be too high for a Champ club, and we will still have some transfer obligations like the Grant fee. I think this is when the fire sale starts, and if that isn't enough to balance the books, then the creditors owed money will be knocking on the door - forcing the club into Admin. Breach of FFP is likely at this point as well. Our losses will be massive (we are borrowing £20M to cover losses now we have no parachute) so we will be on the verge of breaching FFP.

The only decent saleable assets will be Dara, and the keepers. The others are Chump journeymen, and nobody in the Chump will have the money to buy them.
Reply
#16
Despite Lai using the Club as a piggy bank I am inclined to believe that somehow whoever owns us can drum up enough cash to stave off administration and cover the short term liabilities. 

They have far too much to lose.

It will be interesting to see it pan out.
Reply
#17
(04-25-2023, 07:06 PM)baggiebloke Wrote: Despite Lai using the Club as a piggy bank I am inclined to believe that somehow whoever owns us can drum up enough cash to stave off administration and cover the short term liabilities. 

They have far too much to lose.

It will be interesting to see it pan out.

In your scenario, the tipping point will be when they don't believe they can sell the club for more than they owe. My guess is the club "clean" is worth £50M, so with MSD owed £20M (is interest accumulating or being paid?), then after £15M - £20M, their investment is worthless.
Reply
#18
(04-25-2023, 07:16 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(04-25-2023, 07:06 PM)baggiebloke Wrote: Despite Lai using the Club as a piggy bank I am inclined to believe that somehow whoever owns us can drum up enough cash to stave off administration and cover the short term liabilities. 

They have far too much to lose.

It will be interesting to see it pan out.

In your scenario, the tipping point will be when they don't believe they can sell the club for more than they owe. My guess is the club "clean" is worth £50M, so with MSD owed £20M (is interest accumulating or being paid?), then after £15M - £20M, their investment is worthless.

Sorry, don’t agree.

£30-£40, but as things go, could get worse.

(04-25-2023, 07:16 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(04-25-2023, 07:06 PM)baggiebloke Wrote: Despite Lai using the Club as a piggy bank I am inclined to believe that somehow whoever owns us can drum up enough cash to stave off administration and cover the short term liabilities. 

They have far too much to lose.

It will be interesting to see it pan out.

In your scenario, the tipping point will be when they don't believe they can sell the club for more than they owe. My guess is the club "clean" is worth £50M, so with MSD owed £20M (is interest accumulating or being paid?), then after £15M - £20M, their investment is worthless.

Sorry, don’t agree.

£30-£40M, but as things go, could get worse.
Reply
#19
And the blouse are fetching upwards of £30m it's been rumoured?
If that is an indicator then we are worth at least £50m.
Reply
#20
(04-25-2023, 06:57 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: It depends on the loan documentation, which we are not privy to.


The process of Administration is designed to protect the limited company and prevent Liquidation. Derby appointed Administrators to protect the club, which MSD as debenture holders must have consented to, and agreed on who the Administrator was.

There will be clauses in the loan agreement, including non repayment which will allow MSD to appoint an Administrative Receiver. Prag seems certain there is something in there which means MSD can take over without Admin. I guess that could only be an assignment (transfer) of the shares if the loan defaults.

I'm not sure on this though. MSD would have to be fit and proper, and as owners they would assume responsibility for all debts and obligations (including transfer instalments) and I'm not sure they would want that. It also means that Lai's consortium has agreed to give the club away for £20M.

We know the loan is repayable in 4 years, and this is when MSD will come knocking. More likely is that when the £20M is used to pay the bills next season, then we will not have the funds to pay bills in 24/25. The wage bill will still be too high for a Champ club, and we will still have some transfer obligations like the Grant fee. I think this is when the fire sale starts, and if that isn't enough to balance the books, then the creditors owed money will be knocking on the door - forcing the club into Admin. Breach of FFP is likely at this point as well. Our losses will be massive (we are borrowing £20M to cover losses now we have no parachute) so we will be on the verge of breaching FFP.

The only decent saleable assets will be Dara, and the keepers. The others are Chump journeymen, and nobody in the Chump will have the money to buy them.

Would MSD become liable for outstanding liabilities? Not too sure about that, myself. 

If you buy a controlling stake in a Ltd company then you don’t become personally liable for the company’s debts. 

As for the fit and proper thing - if a potless dwarf can blah that test then I’m sure big Micky Dell will manage just fine.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: