Best Way to Develop Youth
#1
We have had some of our most talented youth players leave for bigger clubs such as Jerome Sinclair and Izzy Brown now neither of these have gone on to be world beaters but it raises the question can we keep our most coveted youth prospects from leaving for the bright lights of the Top 6. Recently I have heard on here that Soule could be on his way to dortmund and  Louie Barry to Barcelona, plus the potential of Harper leaving for the Premier League, if this happens due to being academy players Soule and Barry would only bring in small amounts of compensation, while Harper's contract being up would result in him also not bringing in a large sum. So is it really worth having a great academy recognised across England if these players are lured away before making 10 league appearances? 

There is an alternative approach that can be taken, which has been adopted by the likes of Brentford. This includes signing players that have failed to make the grade at the top 6 clubs for small fees and developing them. Seen as these are 17-18 year olds that have been deemed surplus to requirements they do not cost large amounts of money so they are fairly low risk high reward deals. Not all will come off and some won't make the grade but some will go on to realise there potential and become first team regulars, which can then be sold for around 10 million pounds to mid-table clubs in the Premier League. This means the club can sign a young talent for say 500k and sell them for 8 million making a 7.5 million profit, or  developing your own academy players and losing them at 16 while only getting around 250k in compensation. 

However, everybody loves to see an academy graduate developed at the club go on to wear the kit, that's why many of the fans love the likes of Sam Field, Harper and Edwards. If you have no culture of youth then you risk alienating the fans as we saw under Pulis with the insistence on playing experienced players and not trusting in our well regarded academy. Plus with Players like Field and Rogers who we currently have in our academy who have been scouted in the local area and support the club then there will be more of a chance of them staying at the club long term. As we saw with our youth team that got to the FA youth cup semi final, all of our players except 1 were from the local area and that one was from Cheltenham if I remember correctly. 

I don't think there is a right or wrong way to approach this and I agree with the way we are scouting as well as developing local talent at the present time and I think we deserve great credit for that. However with the potential loss of millions of pounds in transfer fees from the likes of Soule, Barry and Rogers not to mention Harper if they have their heads turned, I also wouldn't blame the club for changing its stance on youth policy.
Reply
#2
(05-03-2019, 08:10 PM)Bruntsleftpeg Wrote: We have had some of our most talented youth players leave for bigger clubs such as Jerome Sinclair and Izzy Brown now neither of these have gone on to be world beaters but it raises the question can we keep our most coveted youth prospects from leaving for the bright lights of the Top 6. Recently I have heard on here that Soule could be on his way to dortmund and  Louie Barry to Barcelona, plus the potential of Harper leaving for the Premier League, if this happens due to being academy players Soule and Barry would only bring in small amounts of compensation, while Harper's contract being up would result in him also not bringing in a large sum. So is it really worth having a great academy recognised across England if these players are lured away before making 10 league appearances? 

There is an alternative approach that can be taken, which has been adopted by the likes of Brentford. This includes signing players that have failed to make the grade at the top 6 clubs for small fees and developing them. Seen as these are 17-18 year olds that have been deemed surplus to requirements they do not cost large amounts of money so they are fairly low risk high reward deals. Not all will come off and some won't make the grade but some will go on to realise there potential and become first team regulars, which can then be sold for around 10 million pounds to mid-table clubs in the Premier League. This means the club can sign a young talent for say 500k and sell them for 8 million making a 7.5 million profit, or  developing your own academy players and losing them at 16 while only getting around 250k in compensation. 

However, everybody loves to see an academy graduate developed at the club go on to wear the kit, that's why many of the fans love the likes of Sam Field, Harper and Edwards. If you have no culture of youth then you risk alienating the fans as we saw under Pulis with the insistence on playing experienced players and not trusting in our well regarded academy. Plus with Players like Field and Rogers who we currently have in our academy who have been scouted in the local area and support the club then there will be more of a chance of them staying at the club long term. As we saw with our youth team that got to the FA youth cup semi final, all of our players except 1 were from the local area and that one was from Cheltenham if I remember correctly. 

I don't think there is a right or wrong way to approach this and I agree with the way we are scouting as well as developing local talent at the present time and I think we deserve great credit for that. However with the potential loss of millions of pounds in transfer fees from the likes of Soule, Barry and Rogers not to mention Harper if they have their heads turned, I also wouldn't blame the club for changing its stance on youth policy.

Great post BLP.

You are never going to be able to stop clubs wanting to take your best kids so what has to happen for me is a change in the laws regarding these pathetic "compensation" fee's.

Having nurtured these kids we should be able to ask for proper fees should a big club want them. Otherwise there is really no point running an academy.

The current laws make it so easy for big clubs to stockpile the best kids for little outlay. They would have to think twice if they had to make a £5m decision on a 15 year old instead of a £200k punt.

I just really hope we get to see these kids in an Albion shirt. At least a few of the really promising ones.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)