Our Transfer Policy
#1
Over last summer an announcement was made by the club that we would be looking to bring in players who knew English football and would 'seamlessly' slot into the championship, however with Norwich's title winning team consisting of journeymen players signed from lower first division and second division German sides we have to ask why insist on signing players who 'know the league'. By stating you are signing such players you are realistically limiting yourself to players deemed not good enough for the prem, who if you gain promotion would be surplus to requirements again which would result in the club having to spend more money to replace them. Or you are searching the championship for players who can contribute and for a club who is aiming for promotion we would be looking at these clubs best players, so in most cases either the club won't sell or we we will be priced out of a deal, eg. Bradley Dack. Either those or players from the top of league 1 such as Marcus Maddison, who yes would come and would be affordable but not all of these signings from league 1 are a success with the difference in quality. 

The Leagues in places such as Croatia and Denmark and Serbia that some would consider obscure can provide players physically able to handle the step up to a physical league such as the championship while also having the natural skill on the ball that some English players simply do not possess. Players from these nations would be cheaper than signing from English clubs as clubs from these leagues need the money and a club like Albion can double their wages even if we are on a tighter budget. Players such as Olsson who have been servants to the club have proved that players from these nations can adapt to English football. 

Moreover, signing players from a nation like Argentina could also be a valuable investment as a fans favourite of ours Yacob was signed from Racing Club and players from there obviously have a skill level above most of the players you will find in the championship and league 1 clubs. You only have to look at the level their national team has performed at for decades although going through a rough patch at the moment, it is often said that if you can play in Argentina you can play anywhere with football being engrained in culture there. 

Now there has to be a mix of the both you can't just sign foreign players as fans loving seeing home grown talent succeed but I think completely disregarding signing players from countries like I have mentioned shows a lazy recruitment policy one that we have held since the days of the prat in the hat.
Reply
#2
It was a cunning plan to throw everyone off the scent of who we were really after but ffs don't tell anyone
Reply
#3
But it is the guy we put in charge of finding these jewels that is the key.
Reply
#4
Get Barry Fry he will get loads of players
Reply
#5
Dowling's task of finding Jewels is never an easy job or everyone would be doing it, sometimes it's just seeing potential and taking the plunge.
He had an opportunity in January to bring somebody/anybody in, but didn't find us a single player. In his highly paid role his personal performance was pathetic IMO. He had plenty to say when he joined, but has now gone into hiding.
We had 4 loans which has helped, but as for his prime objective - Players / Managers / Coaches IMO he has been a complete failure. He restrained GJ knowing he was leaving at the seasons end - he should have just kicked him out. He moved the onus onto Darren which was the actions of a gutless coward.
He may have been shackled or ordered by Jenkins, if so he should declare it or walk away for the good of our club. As for our transfer policy - its sell and back fill with loans,
Reply
#6
(04-30-2019, 08:37 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: Dowling's task of finding Jewels is never an easy job or everyone would be doing it, sometimes it's just seeing potential and taking the plunge.
He had an opportunity in January to bring somebody/anybody in, but didn't find us a single player. In his highly paid role his personal  performance was pathetic IMO. He had plenty to say when he joined, but has now gone into hiding.
We had 4 loans which has helped, but as for his prime objective - Players / Managers / Coaches IMO he has been a complete failure. He restrained GJ knowing he was leaving at the seasons end - he should have just kicked him out. He moved the onus onto Darren which was the actions of a gutless coward.
He may have been shackled or ordered by Jenkins, if so he should declare it or walk away for the good of our club. As for our transfer policy - its sell and back fill with loans,

It's far too early to deem Dowling a failure. He's been in role for around seven months and has had one transfer window, which he had a limited time to plan for. 

Of the players that have come in I'd say Holgate has improved us and Johansen adds a different dimension to the midfield. Murphy has been disappointing on the whole so far and Montero has not worked out. 

How do you know that he moved the onus onto Moore with regards Jones? And if he did leave the decision with Moore rather than making decisions on his coaching staff is that so wrong?

With regards to the the managerial situation we don't really know the inner workings and it'll only be the fullness of time that shows whether the decisions to remove Moore and stick with Shan were the right ones. 

As we saw with Ashworth, the Technical Director role is one that is long-term, requires planning, organisation and patience. It's impossible to say at the moment whether Dowling can be as successful, but it's certain that anyone would fail if we based our hiring and firing decisions on on seven months and one transfer window.
Reply
#7
From what we've seen so far I think you can add him to the pile with McDonut and Terraneosauras rex.
Reply
#8
(04-30-2019, 09:28 PM)OmarLittle Wrote:
(04-30-2019, 08:37 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: Dowling's task of finding Jewels is never an easy job or everyone would be doing it, sometimes it's just seeing potential and taking the plunge.
He had an opportunity in January to bring somebody/anybody in, but didn't find us a single player. In his highly paid role his personal  performance was pathetic IMO. He had plenty to say when he joined, but has now gone into hiding.
We had 4 loans which has helped, but as for his prime objective - Players / Managers / Coaches IMO he has been a complete failure. He restrained GJ knowing he was leaving at the seasons end - he should have just kicked him out. He moved the onus onto Darren which was the actions of a gutless coward.
He may have been shackled or ordered by Jenkins, if so he should declare it or walk away for the good of our club. As for our transfer policy - its sell and back fill with loans,

It's far too early to deem Dowling a failure. He's been in role for around seven months and has had one transfer window, which he had a limited time to plan for. 

Of the players that have come in I'd say Holgate has improved us and Johansen adds a different dimension to the midfield. Murphy has been disappointing on the whole so far and Montero has not worked out. 

How do you know that he moved the onus onto Moore with regards Jones? And if he did leave the decision with Moore rather than making decisions on his coaching staff is that so wrong?

With regards to the the managerial situation we don't really know the inner workings and it'll only be the fullness of time that shows whether the decisions to remove Moore and stick with Shan were the right ones. 

As we saw with Ashworth, the Technical Director role is one that is long-term, requires planning, organisation and patience. It's impossible to say at the moment whether Dowling can be as successful, but it's certain that anyone would fail if we based our hiring and firing decisions on on seven months and one transfer window.

Id just like to see us have a scouting network that ranges outside of the UK, we don't even have one in European countries such as Germany and France where Data is readily available and being confined to English players limits our potential. Although I do agree that it takes time to set up a network its a complete contrast to the extensive network that we had under Ashworth where it seemed we had a plan for the next 5 years, and the sudden drop off is alarming.
Reply
#9
(04-30-2019, 09:28 PM)OmarLittle Wrote:
(04-30-2019, 08:37 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: Dowling's task of finding Jewels is never an easy job or everyone would be doing it, sometimes it's just seeing potential and taking the plunge.
He had an opportunity in January to bring somebody/anybody in, but didn't find us a single player. In his highly paid role his personal  performance was pathetic IMO. He had plenty to say when he joined, but has now gone into hiding.
We had 4 loans which has helped, but as for his prime objective - Players / Managers / Coaches IMO he has been a complete failure. He restrained GJ knowing he was leaving at the seasons end - he should have just kicked him out. He moved the onus onto Darren which was the actions of a gutless coward.
He may have been shackled or ordered by Jenkins, if so he should declare it or walk away for the good of our club. As for our transfer policy - its sell and back fill with loans,

It's far too early to deem Dowling a failure. He's been in role for around seven months and has had one transfer window, which he had a limited time to plan for. 

Of the players that have come in I'd say Holgate has improved us and Johansen adds a different dimension to the midfield. Murphy has been disappointing on the whole so far and Montero has not worked out. 

How do you know that he moved the onus onto Moore with regards Jones? And if he did leave the decision with Moore rather than making decisions on his coaching staff is that so wrong?

With regards to the the managerial situation we don't really know the inner workings and it'll only be the fullness of time that shows whether the decisions to remove Moore and stick with Shan were the right ones. 

As we saw with Ashworth, the Technical Director role is one that is long-term, requires planning, organisation and patience. It's impossible to say at the moment whether Dowling can be as successful, but it's certain that anyone would fail if we based our hiring and firing decisions on on seven months and one transfer window.

That is a very reasoned post mate. It doesn't fit in with the usual blame culture on here. Patience is hardly a virtue either. You must be new  Wink
Reply
#10
(04-30-2019, 05:57 PM)Bruntsleftpeg Wrote: Over last summer an announcement was made by the club that we would be looking to bring in players who knew English football and would 'seamlessly' slot into the championship, however with Norwich's title winning team consisting of journeymen players signed from lower first division and second division German sides we have to ask why insist on signing players who 'know the league'. By stating you are signing such players you are realistically limiting yourself to players deemed not good enough for the prem, who if you gain promotion would be surplus to requirements again which would result in the club having to spend more money to replace them. Or you are searching the championship for players who can contribute and for a club who is aiming for promotion we would be looking at these clubs best players, so in most cases either the club won't sell or we we will be priced out of a deal, eg. Bradley Dack. Either those or players from the top of league 1 such as Marcus Maddison, who yes would come and would be affordable but not all of these signings from league 1 are a success with the difference in quality. 

The Leagues in places such as Croatia and Denmark and Serbia that some would consider obscure can provide players physically able to handle the step up to a physical league such as the championship while also having the natural skill on the ball that some English players simply do not possess. Players from these nations would be cheaper than signing from English clubs as clubs from these leagues need the money and a club like Albion can double their wages even if we are on a tighter budget. Players such as Olsson who have been servants to the club have proved that players from these nations can adapt to English football. 

Moreover, signing players from a nation like Argentina could also be a valuable investment as a fans favourite of ours Yacob was signed from Racing Club and players from there obviously have a skill level above most of the players you will find in the championship and league 1 clubs. You only have to look at the level their national team has performed at for decades although going through a rough patch at the moment, it is often said that if you can play in Argentina you can play anywhere with football being engrained in culture there. 

Now there has to be a mix of the both you can't just sign foreign players as fans loving seeing home grown talent succeed but I think completely disregarding signing players from countries like I have mentioned shows a lazy recruitment policy one that we have held since the days of the prat in the hat.
Signing players from places like Argentina or Uruguay shouldn`t be beyond us, many people there have dual nationality with Spanish or Italian grandparents. Likewise Germany or Denmark are 2 hour flights away, should be easy to scout. Unfortunately, When Ashworth left we never brought in a proper replacement, appointing Garlick, who is a good bloke but essentially a solicitor. It will take ages to rebuild the system we had, require patience and the right people.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)