What did we make
#21
If you were sat with me listening to the views in my Uncles local Tory party leisure club in the Lancashire shires a couple of months back, you’d know it’s anything but bollocks. Your argument seems to be that some not being racist mean non are. I’d say that’s where you may be missing reality somewhat.
Someone could have been killed
Reply
#22
(02-28-2023, 11:10 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(02-28-2023, 06:06 PM)hudds Wrote: Had that vote been among sane people, Sunak would have won.

All the sane people had left the Conservative Party by then.

(02-28-2023, 07:41 PM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: As I said a while back, like it or not, and some won’t, there are plenty of Tories, particularly in marginal rural seats, that simply won’t vote for a non-white PM. Doesn’t matter how much people like to think otherwise, it’s a shit reality. And was undoubtedly why someone as dense at Truss still beat him.

I actually think that's bollocks tbh. You only have to look at, oh, Rishi Sunak's own constituency party's selection committee (or Sajid Javid's, or Adam Afriye's, or Kemi Badenoch's)

It really isn't.  I can tell you from first-hand experience, a significant minority of the older generations still have the same prejudices. It's a legacy thing, nothing can be done. From my own point of view, I don't even blame them, that's how they were brought up. 

Take that recent issue about the old women at garden parties saying stupid things.  The media did their big outrage but most black people I knew, didn't even bother reading it, they just got on with whatever they were doing. It was quite literally a non-story to us. We've probably all experienced it and know we can't change it. And to be honest, why bother? In the nicest possible way, they are on their way out and most of their power has gone. What they think no longer has an impact on me or my family. Life is too short for pointless battles.

So would a lot of older tories refuse to vote for a black man? I think so, but then I'm sure many wouldn't have voted for truss if there was a viable white male alternative! But ultimately, it's a unique case, that demographic rarely has the chance to influence anything anymore.

Thankfully, things are changing for the better in many ways in society, despite what the doom merchants say.
Reply
#23
A great summary that. And a very accurate one, rather than being mired in wishful thinking or self echo chamber WhatsApp groups
Someone could have been killed
Reply
#24
(03-01-2023, 10:54 AM)fuzzbox Wrote: It really isn't.  I can tell you from first-hand experience, a significant minority of the older generations still have the same prejudices. It's a legacy thing, nothing can be done. From my own point of view, I don't even blame them, that's how they were brought up. 

Take that recent issue about the old women at garden parties saying stupid things.  The media did their big outrage but most black people I knew, didn't even bother reading it, they just got on with whatever they were doing. It was quite literally a non-story to us. We've probably all experienced it and know we can't change it. And to be honest, why bother? In the nicest possible way, they are on their way out and most of their power has gone. What they think no longer has an impact on me or my family. Life is too short for pointless battles.

So would a lot of older tories refuse to vote for a black man? I think so, but then I'm sure many wouldn't have voted for truss if there was a viable white male alternative! But ultimately, it's a unique case, that demographic rarely has the chance to influence anything anymore.

Thankfully, things are changing for the better in many ways in society, despite what the doom merchants say.

You may well be right about a significant minority of the older generations, but I'm giving you my personal experience of 30-odd years in the Tory Party. Tory Party members have consistently adopted ethnic minority, female and gay council and Parliamentary candidates over white middle aged fellas - particularly since 2007 - I've been at the selection meetings FFS. You're commenting on what you believe, I'm commenting on what I've experienced and it'd be pretty fair to say that I fundamentally disagree with you and so would my gay / lesbian / black / chinese and asian friends. 

The so-called progressive party in this country has never had a female as leader, isn't actually sure what a female is right now either - and an ethnic minority MP has never held any of the great offices of state in a Labour Government - whereas they've held all of them in Tory governments. 

You just seem a little prejudiced IMO.
Reply
#25
The original point was that some seasoned Tory voters won’t vote for a man with brown skin and non of the above makes it any less true. Not even the comical old line about how many friends you have from various ‘minority’ groups. And my experience of that is every bit as first hand as yours.

As an aside, the elected MP for said seat is gay himself (and standing down at the next election due to aspects of the party he can no longer tolerate). Most of his constituents aren’t prejudiced. Many are.
Someone could have been killed
Reply
#26
(03-01-2023, 11:34 AM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: The original point was that some seasoned Tory voters won’t vote for a man with brown skin and non of the above makes it any less true. Not even the comical old line about how many friends you have from various ‘minority’ groups. And my experience of that is every bit as first hand as yours.

As an aside, the elected MP for said seat is gay himself (and standing down at the next election due to aspects of the party he can no longer tolerate). Most of his constituents aren’t prejudiced. Many are.

You were specifically calling about Tory Members not Tory voters, so let's not start rewriting your narrative eh?

I'm simply judging the Tory Party's objective actions (and my experience) in consistently favouring minority candidates over straight white men. You're choosing to ignore them to suit you're own subjective experience. I find that pretty laughable tbh when all the evidence is against you.

I am no longer a member so I have no axe to grind either.
Reply
#27
Are Tory members not Tory voters? How odd. I’m talking about what will be a tangible impact at the ballot box. You may not like it. I don’t. But it will. And I wouldn’t call one of their few openly gay MPs leaving subjective in any shape or form
Someone could have been killed
Reply
#28
(03-01-2023, 11:25 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(03-01-2023, 10:54 AM)fuzzbox Wrote: It really isn't.  I can tell you from first-hand experience, a significant minority of the older generations still have the same prejudices. It's a legacy thing, nothing can be done. From my own point of view, I don't even blame them, that's how they were brought up. 

Take that recent issue about the old women at garden parties saying stupid things.  The media did their big outrage but most black people I knew, didn't even bother reading it, they just got on with whatever they were doing. It was quite literally a non-story to us. We've probably all experienced it and know we can't change it. And to be honest, why bother? In the nicest possible way, they are on their way out and most of their power has gone. What they think no longer has an impact on me or my family. Life is too short for pointless battles.

So would a lot of older tories refuse to vote for a black man? I think so, but then I'm sure many wouldn't have voted for truss if there was a viable white male alternative! But ultimately, it's a unique case, that demographic rarely has the chance to influence anything anymore.

Thankfully, things are changing for the better in many ways in society, despite what the doom merchants say.

You may well be right about a significant minority of the older generations, but I'm giving you my personal experience of 30-odd years in the Tory Party. Tory Party members have consistently adopted ethnic minority, female and gay council and Parliamentary candidates over white middle aged fellas - particularly since 2007 - I've been at the selection meetings FFS. You're commenting on what you believe, I'm commenting on what I've experienced and it'd be pretty fair to say that I fundamentally disagree with you and so would my gay / lesbian / black / chinese and asian friends. 

The so-called progressive party in this country has never had a female as leader, isn't actually sure what a female is right now either - and an ethnic minority MP has never held any of the great offices of state in a Labour Government - whereas they've held all of them in Tory governments. 

You just seem a little prejudiced IMO.

I seem a little prejudiced? Wow. You obviously have more experience of racial prejudice than me. I can only imagine all the doors that were closed for you!

Here's a little tip. Don't use your minority friends as proof of anything. Speaking as said 'friend', nothing is more irritating than when somebody does that to you! We usually just smile, agree and then when they've gone,talk amongst ourselves and laugh at what a tit they are...

But, as you called me prejudiced...

I'm married to a white woman, my 'genetic' children look 'white', my adopted daughter is white (we think), my business partners are all white, the vast majority of my clients are white, most of the people I recruit are white and all my role models growing up were white (except for certain west brom players)

Oh, and the people who supported me when I was a child and young adult were mostly white. I've never forgotten them - even when other people were spitting at us. That's why I've funded a scheme where for the last twenty years, children from the same social background as me get full scholarships to a midlands school. It's a similar scheme that 'white' people gave me.

As it happens, most of the recipients of the scheme have been white.

But yes, you've found me out, I secretly hate whitey.

If I was going to make an assumption, I would say there's always a certain type of middle-aged man who thinks he knows everything and so searches for 'facts' to back up his opinion, rather than the other way round.
Reply
#29
(03-01-2023, 12:20 PM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: Are Tory members not Tory voters? How odd. I’m talking about what will be a tangible impact at the ballot box. You may not like it. I don’t. But it will. And I wouldn’t call one of their few openly gay MPs leaving subjective in any shape or form

For my twopence worth, I've never been racially abused by a Labour member or Lib Dem member (even in rural England).

Can't say the same with Tory members, remember being referred to as a Paki Lib Dem by some of the Tory club at uni.
Reply
#30
Horrendous BB, whoever it was. Never helped by a culture of denial which still pervades. I can’t and wouldn’t repeat some of the stuff I heard with my own ears a few weeks back.
Someone could have been killed
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: