Posts: 10,700
Threads: 674
Joined: Feb 2020
01-26-2023, 01:44 PM
(This post was last modified: 01-26-2023, 01:59 PM by Fulham Fallout.)
(01-26-2023, 01:01 PM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote: Does the MSD loan get made public if the likes of S4A and A4A aren’t putting pressure on and putting the club under scrutiny, though? I highly doubt it.
MSD have lent money to the likes of Burnley and Southampton - I’d say the first their fans heard of it was in connection with our loan.
Both groups are doing fantastic work at a crucial time for the club. Anyone knocking them is a pure cunt and can FODTV, as far as I’m concerned.
Clearing the old charges at companies house was a tell tale sign we were about to borrow funds.
WBA Group Ltd also had to amend the articles of association at companies house for the loan and so this would have flagged the intention of the loan.
The next lot of accounts are due to be submitted to companies house at the end of March and these would have to mention the loan as a material post balance sheet event in the notes to the accounts and a mention of the loan under going concern.
WBA Group Ltd also had to notify the minority shareholders holders of the proposed loan and that a vote was going to be undertaken which was going to be approved by the 88% share holdings. This was actually the first source made public about the MSD loan.
I’m amazed S4A didn’t go mental about the proposed Perira deal which involved cash going directly to Lai and amounting to theft of an asset.
I’m also amazed they didn’t kick off about the Lai loan being repaid following a proposed dividend. I know they stated they didn’t want a dividend to be issued, but amazed they didn’t flag that as robbing Peter to pay Paul. Totally legal. Totally ethical is another question altogether.
Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
(01-26-2023, 01:01 PM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote: Does the MSD loan get made public if the likes of S4A and A4A aren’t putting pressure on and putting the club under scrutiny, though? I highly doubt it.
MSD have lent money to the likes of Burnley and Southampton - I’d say the first their fans heard of it was in connection with our loan.
Both groups are doing fantastic work at a crucial time for the club. Anyone knocking them is a pure cunt and can FODTV, as far as I’m concerned.
+1
We’re apathetic generally as a fan base, but A4A are doing an excellent job of raising awareness, and Alistair is coming over well on various media outlets and podcasts when describing the situation.
The likes of Kieran Maguire who is very influential in football finance circles and is close to Tracy Crouch and the potential watchdog has been giving us and A4A a lot of air time and this is only positive news - accounts released or not.
Posts: 1,636
Threads: 52
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
11
(01-26-2023, 01:01 PM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote: Does the MSD loan get made public if the likes of S4A and A4A aren’t putting pressure on and putting the club under scrutiny, though? I highly doubt it.
MSD have lent money to the likes of Burnley and Southampton - I’d say the first their fans heard of it was in connection with our loan.
Both groups are doing fantastic work at a crucial time for the club. Anyone knocking them is a pure cunt and can FODTV, as far as I’m concerned.
Totally agree. It’s very easy to sit in your ivory tower’s pouring scorn on people who are giving up their spare time to try and do something for the future of OUR club. Fuck half of these moaners don’t even go to games FFS
Posts: 852
Threads: 60
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
10
The MSD story broke in local and mainstream media way before A4A were making anyone aware. The Telegraph article by Burt emphasises this.
I’ve no doubt A4A have done a great job of raising fan base awareness and driving a collective mission.
Also it is nothing to do with apathy, simple pragmatism. There is nothing they, we or even the MPs can do for us in terms of ownership or forcing of loan repayment. If the football regulator ever comes into existence then yes they can protect club ownership - though not retrospectively.
The best we can hope is promotion and more than a one year stay in the prem. This will be a bigger lever to ownership change than any other activity.
Posts: 4,108
Threads: 50
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
13
(01-26-2023, 02:27 PM)BurleyBaggie Wrote: The MSD story broke in local and mainstream media way before A4A were making anyone aware. The Telegraph article by Burt emphasises this.
I’ve no doubt A4A have done a great job of raising fan base awareness and driving a collective mission.
Also it is nothing to do with apathy, simple pragmatism. There is nothing they, we or even the MPs can do for us in terms of ownership or forcing of loan repayment. If the football regulator ever comes into existence then yes they can protect club ownership - though not retrospectively.
The best we can hope is promotion and more than a one year stay in the prem. This will be a bigger lever to ownership change than any other activity.
Yep surely best case scenario is we get promoted, Lai sells us asap to recoup as much as he can from his original investment.
Posts: 852
Threads: 60
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
10
(01-26-2023, 01:49 PM)johntoewba Wrote: (01-26-2023, 01:01 PM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote: Does the MSD loan get made public if the likes of S4A and A4A aren’t putting pressure on and putting the club under scrutiny, though? I highly doubt it.
MSD have lent money to the likes of Burnley and Southampton - I’d say the first their fans heard of it was in connection with our loan.
Both groups are doing fantastic work at a crucial time for the club. Anyone knocking them is a pure cunt and can FODTV, as far as I’m concerned.
Totally agree. It’s very easy to sit in your ivory tower’s pouring scorn on people who are giving up their spare time to try and do something for the future of OUR club. Fuck half of these moaners don’t even go to games FFS
This is why I’m not supportive. It becomes an evangelical choice and almost tribal.
You’re with us and a friend or you’re against and you can feck off. It’s childish.
It’s perfectly reasonable discourse to challenge statements or have a different view. I tire of evidence lacking statements like this that divide the fan base.
Many of us who live 150 miles away still get to half our games - if we have a different view on the effectiveness of A4A we shouldn’t feel ostracised. As per my post they’ve done a great job of mobilising the fan base but beyond that they have limited ability to influence.
If people wish to give up their spare time to do this then good on them. However, it does not change the fact their ability to change anything is extremely limited.
Posts: 863
Threads: 29
Joined: Mar 2022
Posts: 10,700
Threads: 674
Joined: Feb 2020
(01-26-2023, 02:32 PM)BurleyBaggie Wrote: (01-26-2023, 01:49 PM)johntoewba Wrote: (01-26-2023, 01:01 PM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote: Does the MSD loan get made public if the likes of S4A and A4A aren’t putting pressure on and putting the club under scrutiny, though? I highly doubt it.
MSD have lent money to the likes of Burnley and Southampton - I’d say the first their fans heard of it was in connection with our loan.
Both groups are doing fantastic work at a crucial time for the club. Anyone knocking them is a pure cunt and can FODTV, as far as I’m concerned.
Totally agree. It’s very easy to sit in your ivory tower’s pouring scorn on people who are giving up their spare time to try and do something for the future of OUR club. Fuck half of these moaners don’t even go to games FFS
This is why I’m not supportive. It becomes an evangelical choice and almost tribal.
You’re with us and a friend or you’re against and you can feck off. It’s childish.
It’s perfectly reasonable discourse to challenge statements or have a different view. I tire of evidence lacking statements like this that divide the fan base.
Many of us who live 150 miles away still get to half our games - if we have a different view on the effectiveness of A4A we shouldn’t feel ostracised. As per my post they’ve done a great job of mobilising the fan base but beyond that they have limited ability to influence.
If people wish to give up their spare time to do this then good on them. However, it does not change the fact their ability to change anything is extremely limited.
At the end of the day… we all want the same things
1. WBA FC to continue for the next 100+ years, competing in the top leagues and not have to be another Wimbledon and start from the beginning again.
2. For Lai to pay back the loans he owes, now.
3. For Lai to sell up to an investor who sees the club as a long term investment. This is where the problem lies. Any investor will want to see a return on their investment, be it an income stream
(dividends) or capital growth or a marketing potential or any combination thereof.
Unfortunately, we don’t have any control over any of the above.
Posts: 15,040
Threads: 339
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
93
01-26-2023, 05:51 PM
(This post was last modified: 01-26-2023, 06:10 PM by Tom Joad.)
Fulham Fallout Wrote:Malcolm Tucker Wrote:Does the MSD loan get made public if the likes of S4A and A4A aren’t putting pressure on and putting the club under scrutiny, though? I highly doubt it.
MSD have lent money to the likes of Burnley and Southampton - I’d say the first their fans heard of it was in connection with our loan.
Both groups are doing fantastic work at a crucial time for the club. Anyone knocking them is a pure cunt and can FODTV, as far as I’m concerned.
Clearing the old charges at companies house was a tell tale sign we were about to borrow funds.
WBA Group Ltd also had to amend the articles of association at companies house for the loan and so this would have flagged the intention of the loan.
The next lot of accounts are due to be submitted to companies house at the end of March and these would have to mention the loan as a material post balance sheet event in the notes to the accounts and a mention of the loan under going concern.
WBA Group Ltd also had to notify the minority shareholders holders of the proposed loan and that a vote was going to be undertaken which was going to be approved by the 88% share holdings. This was actually the first source made public about the MSD loan.
I’m amazed S4A didn’t go mental about the proposed Perira deal which involved cash going directly to Lai and amounting to theft of an asset.
I’m also amazed they didn’t kick off about the Lai loan being repaid following a proposed dividend. I know they stated they didn’t want a dividend to be issued, but amazed they didn’t flag that as robbing Peter to pay Paul. Totally legal. Totally ethical is another question altogether. This was exactly what raised a red flag for S4A, I know because one of them told me at the time knowledge first leaked. At the same time he told me Lai had attempted to take money out and was initially rebuffed. As we know, he eventually managed to do so. (I did bring it up on here at the time yet only two people PM-ed me to ask more).
Also, S4A did say they were against a dividend being used to repay Lai's loan as it was taking money from the club.
Their insistence that all wasn't well was what led to A4A which has led to the council agreeing to The Hawthorns being listed as a community asset and the MP raising the issue in Parliament.
How on Earth can you say it is pointless, and we should all do nothing? When has doing nothing ever changed anything, ever? No one can do anything about Lai's ownership but A4A are ensuring whatever he does next will be in the spotlight.
Posts: 4,043
Threads: 149
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
10
|