The Democratic Republic of the Kingdom of Britain
#21
(01-24-2023, 09:57 AM)baggy1 Wrote: I'm loving the way Proth can explain to everyone what an expert in politics, taxation and the nation's business he is after spending the last decade promoting austerity and Brexit, the two policies that have driven us headlong into this position. If only we'd have taken the path of low taxation at the same time we could have been buried in this Tory pile of shit rather than just up to our nostrils in it.

You can lead a horse to water but you can't make it buy gold.
Reply
#22
(01-24-2023, 07:36 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(01-23-2023, 06:59 PM)Logic1 Wrote: I love how it's convenient for you to invoke the... "economics isn't a science" strawman when the evidence doesn't fit your view of the world. We all know you love your voodoo economics - in that other thread you remarkably argued that tax increases (fiscal contraction) would create inflation! I've not heard that one before. It's a good job we have economic theory and empirical evidence to test propositions like that.

Also, given what you say, i.e. that people who pay the higher rate can avoid it anyway, then on that basis why would there be capital flight, surely the money is already out of here at the 45% rate? Also, given the fact Labour are miles ahead in the polls wouldn't investors be moving their money now given a likely Labour victory? From what I've seen, the pound is doing much better (although nowhere near its pre-Brexit level).


I invoke the word “scientist” to call out your utter bullshit that economics is in any way a science. Most scientists can actually read - and I suggested tax increases would lead to higher pay claims that would feedback into inflation which is pefectly reasonable argument.

And again, you haven’t even read my reply about capital flight so I’ll give you the chance to do that again before asking me about income tax again. Remind me where you teach so I ensure my kids don’t go there.
You seem a bit angry today.

I have never said Economics is a science - this is your device when confronted fronted with a simple economic argument (based on facts and evidence) that you disagree with. Economics is hard (as with all social sciences due to it being the study of humans). There is a long standing debate as to whether Economics is or isn't a science. See these articles:

Is economics a science? | Robert Shiller | The Guardian

Is Economics a Science? (Of course it is...) (stanford.edu)


I read your reply and it doesn't make sense and I don't remember reading research that says fiscal contraction boosts inflation. This is why we study economics, if you have a theory like that, build a model, then take it to the data, and show evidence for it. If there isn't any evidence, then you are a snake-oil salesman. Your theory might make sense if there is expansionary monetary policy at the same time, but then the impact on inflation would be due to excessive money and not the tax rise. 

In terms of the personal attack - I teach at a wonderful inclusive institution that has incredible graduate outcomes given our demographic and have won numerous teaching awards so I'm sure your kids would be very successful. I'd be happy for my kids to go to my university. I'll leave it to you to  guess where it is.
Reply
#23
(01-24-2023, 09:57 AM)baggy1 Wrote: I'm loving the way Proth can explain to everyone what an expert in politics, taxation and the nation's business he is after spending the last decade promoting austerity and Brexit, the two policies that have driven us headlong into this position. If only we'd have taken the path of low taxation at the same time we could have been buried in this Tory pile of shit rather than just up to our nostrils in it.

If we hadn't flung ourselves headlong into bailing everyone and everything out we'd never be in this position. And we never really had much actual austerity either.

Even Logic will agree with me the economics is all about incentives. Remove the wrong ones and you're generally fucked, as we are.

(01-24-2023, 11:34 AM)Logic1 Wrote: I have never said Economics is a science. 

I read your reply and it doesn't make sense and I don't remember reading research that says fiscal contraction boosts inflation. This is why we study economics, if you have a theory like that, build a model, then take it to the data, and show evidence for it. If there isn't any evidence, then you are a snake-oil salesman. Your theory might make sense if there is expansionary monetary policy at the same time, but then the impact on inflation would be due to excessive money and not the tax rise. 

In terms of the personal attack - I teach at a wonderful inclusive institution that has incredible graduate outcomes given our demographic and have won numerous teaching awards so I'm sure your kids would be very successful. I'd be happy for my kids to go to my university. I'll leave it to you to  guess where it is.

I'm pretty sure you have argued that economics is science before, why on Earth would I bring it up otherwise?

You may believe that additional taxes on income do not lead to increased wage claims, but I find that belief bizarre and not borne out by the evidence of my own client group. Though I'm happy to concede that increased taxes are not the *only* reason for increased claims.

And there are plenty of plenty of snake oil salesmen in academia too.
Reply
#24
I think your grasp of economics has been shown up on the Lockdown Legacy thread.
Reply
#25
(01-24-2023, 11:36 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(01-24-2023, 09:57 AM)baggy1 Wrote: I'm loving the way Proth can explain to everyone what an expert in politics, taxation and the nation's business he is after spending the last decade promoting austerity and Brexit, the two policies that have driven us headlong into this position. If only we'd have taken the path of low taxation at the same time we could have been buried in this Tory pile of shit rather than just up to our nostrils in it.

If we hadn't flung ourselves headlong into bailing everyone and everything out we'd never be in this position. And we never really had much actual austerity either.

Even Logic will agree with me the economics is all about incentives. Remove the wrong ones and you're generally fucked, as we are.

(01-24-2023, 11:34 AM)Logic1 Wrote: I have never said Economics is a science. 

I read your reply and it doesn't make sense and I don't remember reading research that says fiscal contraction boosts inflation. This is why we study economics, if you have a theory like that, build a model, then take it to the data, and show evidence for it. If there isn't any evidence, then you are a snake-oil salesman. Your theory might make sense if there is expansionary monetary policy at the same time, but then the impact on inflation would be due to excessive money and not the tax rise. 

In terms of the personal attack - I teach at a wonderful inclusive institution that has incredible graduate outcomes given our demographic and have won numerous teaching awards so I'm sure your kids would be very successful. I'd be happy for my kids to go to my university. I'll leave it to you to  guess where it is.

I'm pretty sure you have argued that economics is science before, why on Earth would I bring it up otherwise?

You may believe that additional taxes on income do not lead to increased wage claims, but I find that belief bizarre and not borne out by the evidence of my own client group. Though I'm happy to concede that increased taxes are not the *only* reason for increased claims.

And there are plenty of plenty of snake oil salesmen in academia too.

I've never argued that economics is a science before and most snake oil salesman academics typically get found out.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)