Progress
#1
I’ve read some nonsense on here that the train workers should embrace the new ways of working (less people, more profit for shareholders) but the reality of these new ways of working are potentially this…

What’s the plan?
Reply
#2
I'm sorry but this is luddite bollocks. I'm sympathetic to a lot of the strike justifications from the RMT (not ASLEF) and especially fully appreciate the need for maintenance staff and the people represented by the RMT deserving pay rises but ticket office closures and driver only operation are perfectly justifiable. We already have services with driver only operation in this country and they work fine, other countries have it widespread on both heavy rail and light rail and it works fine. There's loads of stations in this country that don't have ticket offices or managers and they work fine, and even stations with ticket offices have had them closed for the last 3 years and the world hasn't caved in.

Why are people pretending that the situation in a lot of the UK and the rest of Europe is suddenly irrelevant to keep ticket offices nobody even uses anymore?
Reply
#3
(01-09-2023, 09:14 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: I'm sorry but this is luddite bollocks. I'm sympathetic to a lot of the strike justifications from the RMT (not ASLEF) and especially fully appreciate the need for maintenance staff and the people represented by the RMT deserving pay rises but ticket office closures and driver only operation are perfectly justifiable. We already have services with driver only operation in this country and they work fine, other countries have it widespread on both heavy rail and light rail and it works fine. There's loads of stations in this country that don't have ticket offices or managers and they work fine, and even stations with ticket offices have had them closed for the last 3 years and the world hasn't caved in.

Why are people pretending that the situation in a lot of the UK and the rest of Europe is suddenly irrelevant to keep ticket offices nobody even uses anymore?

I partially agree with you but I get the train every day and tons of people (mainly over 50 admittedly) still use the ticket offices. Which is doubly funny because everyone under 30 just dont buy tickets at all cos there is more or less no consequence to not doing so.
Reply
#4
(01-09-2023, 09:23 AM)CaptainFantastico Wrote:
(01-09-2023, 09:14 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: I'm sorry but this is luddite bollocks. I'm sympathetic to a lot of the strike justifications from the RMT (not ASLEF) and especially fully appreciate the need for maintenance staff and the people represented by the RMT deserving pay rises but ticket office closures and driver only operation are perfectly justifiable. We already have services with driver only operation in this country and they work fine, other countries have it widespread on both heavy rail and light rail and it works fine. There's loads of stations in this country that don't have ticket offices or managers and they work fine, and even stations with ticket offices have had them closed for the last 3 years and the world hasn't caved in.

Why are people pretending that the situation in a lot of the UK and the rest of Europe is suddenly irrelevant to keep ticket offices nobody even uses anymore?

I partially agree with you but I get the train every day and tons of people (mainly over 50 admittedly) still use the ticket offices. Which is doubly funny because everyone under 30 just dont buy tickets at all cos there is more or less no consequence to not doing so.

"Old people use it" isn't a justification for keeping an outdated mode with an additional operating cost that is redundant in this age of ticket machines, smart cards and QR codes.

The only stations where they should keep ticket offices are major stations that apply additional services e.g. New Street. My local station doesn't even have a ticket office and I can't recall the last time the one at the JQ, The Hawthorns etc was open.
Reply
#5
West Midlands Railway is such a shambles that I can't remember the last time I actually bought a ticket.

You never get asked to show one and if you get into town and the barriers are down you just buy from the JQ to Snow Hill, job done.
Reply
#6
(01-09-2023, 09:14 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: I'm sorry but this is luddite bollocks. I'm sympathetic to a lot of the strike justifications from the RMT (not ASLEF) and especially fully appreciate the need for maintenance staff and the people represented by the RMT deserving pay rises but ticket office closures and driver only operation are perfectly justifiable. We already have services with driver only operation in this country and they work fine, other countries have it widespread on both heavy rail and light rail and it works fine. There's loads of stations in this country that don't have ticket offices or managers and they work fine, and even stations with ticket offices have had them closed for the last 3 years and the world hasn't caved in.

Why are people pretending that the situation in a lot of the UK and the rest of Europe is suddenly irrelevant to keep ticket offices nobody even uses anymore?

What provision is there for helping disabled people on and off the train and ensuring a space for wheelchairs etc? I’d rather trust the lived experiences of those who are in this situation rather than the rail operators and those who don’t need to worry about these things because they think they understand but really don’t.
Reply
#7
The driver can get out of the cab to help people get on, which is not only what happens in other European countries but also what happens on a lot of the UK rail network where there's no managed stations and the lines are driver only operated. I mean fuck me TfL manage it on the DLR with no drivers, conductors and where only 4 stations are managed so it's not hard.
Reply
#8
(01-09-2023, 09:41 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(01-09-2023, 09:23 AM)CaptainFantastico Wrote:
(01-09-2023, 09:14 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: I'm sorry but this is luddite bollocks. I'm sympathetic to a lot of the strike justifications from the RMT (not ASLEF) and especially fully appreciate the need for maintenance staff and the people represented by the RMT deserving pay rises but ticket office closures and driver only operation are perfectly justifiable. We already have services with driver only operation in this country and they work fine, other countries have it widespread on both heavy rail and light rail and it works fine. There's loads of stations in this country that don't have ticket offices or managers and they work fine, and even stations with ticket offices have had them closed for the last 3 years and the world hasn't caved in.

Why are people pretending that the situation in a lot of the UK and the rest of Europe is suddenly irrelevant to keep ticket offices nobody even uses anymore?

I partially agree with you but I get the train every day and tons of people (mainly over 50 admittedly) still use the ticket offices. Which is doubly funny because everyone under 30 just dont buy tickets at all cos there is more or less no consequence to not doing so.

"Old people use it" isn't a justification for keeping an outdated mode with an additional operating cost that is redundant in this age of ticket machines, smart cards and QR codes.

The only stations where they should keep ticket offices are major stations that apply additional services e.g. New Street. My local station doesn't even have a ticket office and I can't recall the last time the one at the JQ, The Hawthorns etc was open.

The Hawthorns one was open ten minutes ago. I think catering for 30% of the population is reasonable
Reply
#9
I don't believe that taxpayer subsidising something that is an easy cost to cut by implementing a solution that's already used on parts of the UK heavy rail network, parts of the UK light rail network and across Europe is in any way reasonable. The driver can assume responsibility for helping disabled people get on the train from the platform and old people not wanting to use an automated ticket machine isn't an excuse.
Reply
#10
Fella, they cant run a single one of the fuggers on time as it is now! As you’ll know.

Tickets - 5-10 years I’ll be aligned with your view. As it stands today, it lacks verstehen.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)