Tyrone Mings
#1
Listening to BBC WM yesterday, Paul Franks stated that we didn’t sign Mings because we couldn’t guarantee him first team football. Anyone think this could be true?

IMO Mings would have made a back 3 work better:

Dawson - Hegazi - Mings ?

Personally I think our thinking in January became muddled - hence the signings of Murphy and Montero. Surely prioritising Mings over Montero would have been more beneficial?
Reply
#2
Hindsight is a wonderful thing.

The general consensus amongst fans were that we needed to replace (try to) Barnes. The club obviously shared this view.
Reply
#3
Who cares. Old shit raking shudda wudda cudda bollox. Look forward and SOTV
Reply
#4
During the window the priority was to replace Barnes and strengthen our midfield and attacking options.

Most on here felt the loan fee could have been better spent elsewhere.
Reply
#5
(04-23-2019, 06:19 PM)Duffers Wrote: During the window the priority was to replace Barnes and strengthen our midfield and attacking options.

Most on here felt the loan fee could have been better spent elsewhere.

Duff IIRC
A LB was the priority and tbf we took on Holgate which was spot on.
We had 4 CH's and 2 RB's 
Midfield needed energy and without JRod or Gayle we were struggling in attack.
Holgate - Johansen were very good loans M & M haven't worked out.
Looking forward IMO we could do worse then sign Johansen who's available on a free.
Reply
#6
I think that’s right. He’d have played in a three but not a four. The feeling at the time was three at home, four away.

He’s a class act but it was a lot of money for someone with a poor injury record. As it happens, he’s been a major difference for them.

If we do go up, we should be in for him, but our fans anti Villa complex would see him rubbished.
Reply
#7
I think if Barnes had stayed we would have gone for Mings. But as soon as he left the priority was to replace him. Unfortunately we replaced him with powder puff Murphy and Montero who seems to have disappeared.
Reply
#8
He’s a great player, said it at the time, always rated him at Ipswich where he mainly played as a left back

Our decision not to pursue him was purely financial

I’d love him to roll his ankle before the play offs mind ?

Cuzer
Reply
#9
(04-23-2019, 07:14 PM)Cuzer Wrote: He’s a great player, said it at the time, always rated him at Ipswich where he mainly played as a left back

Our decision not to pursue him was purely financial

I’d love him to roll his ankle before the play offs mind ?

Cuzer

When you say purely financial? Surely that means the club made a choice to sign Montero/Murphy over Mings? So the budget was there ie finances where available. We as a club chose to spend it differently. 
I genuinely believe Edwards should have been earmarked as Barnes replacement.
Reply
#10
(04-23-2019, 06:29 PM)Statto Wrote: I think that’s right. He’d have played in a three but not a four. The feeling at the time was three at home, four away.

He’s a class act but it was a lot of money for someone with a poor injury record. As it happens, he’s been a major difference for them.

If we do go up, we should be in for him, but our fans anti Villa complex would see him rubbished.

Mings is an excellent player, but like has been said, when Barnes was recalled the deal became too rich for us. Plus, with both Villa and us circling Bournemouth took advantage - by all accounts it was a million-£+ fee plus his wages of about 40k on top.

If Villa make it up it was a gamble worth taking as he's been massive for them, but at the time we had other priorities.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)