The negativity amongst our fans about the play offs
#31
Put my name into the negativity hat. I just feel the combination of their ten match winning run (an achievement that shouldn't be overlooked, by the way!), our clueless messing about with a new manager, generally how we've peformed unconvincingly for a large part of the season - despite good results, we've been very poor, peformance wise, and finally the fact I'm a pessimistic cunt at the best of times, means that in my mind, Villa will beat us with ease in the play offs.

It'll be horrible.
Clarnet v2.0
Reply
#32
(04-23-2019, 12:56 PM)KratosBaggie Wrote: Put my name into the negativity hat. I just feel the combination of their ten match winning run (an achievement that shouldn't be overlooked, by the way!), our clueless messing about with a new manager, generally how we've peformed unconvincingly  for a large part of the season - despite good results, we've been very poor, peformance wise, and finally the fact I'm a pessimistic cunt at the best of times, means that in my mind, Villa will beat us with ease in the play offs.

It'll be horrible.

This makes me feel much more confident about our chances...  Cool Big Grin
Reply
#33
(04-23-2019, 12:01 PM)Statto Wrote:
(04-23-2019, 10:46 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(04-23-2019, 10:30 AM)Loanee Wrote: Think the negativity comes from the top of the club, for example:

-Non appointment of a new head coach
-Little comment / direction from those in charge
-Questionable team / tactics over the last few games (eg not going out to win with our best players yesterday)

That coupled with Villa being massively in form & our inability to cope with teams in form this season (eg getting blown away by Leeds / Bristol City)
What about us being top 6 all season, being one of the country’s top scorers, blasting 7 past QPR getting 4s galore. Having a squad near full of prem players.
The negativity comes entirely from the way people look at the world themselves. Quite a pitiful and miserable post.

+1

What an absolute load of horse's excrement.

Without stepping on King of the Stats MancBaggie's toes it comes from the fact that since 1960 we've played the Villa home (36) and away (36) 72 times. We've won 22, drawn 20 and lost 36 (yes 50%).  In terms of home games we've won 13, drawn 12 and lost 11 out of 36. Away from home we've won 9 and lost 19.

Now stats mean absolutely nothing and are no indicator of the future. 

I feel a lack of optimism not because of the way I look at the world (I mean that must be the most outlandish and ridiculous post ever on this dump and that says something) but because generally in my lifetime we've tended to come out on the wrong side of results against the Villa. Most recently the FA Cup game at Villa and more often than not when battering them for 90 mins.

For me it's spin of a coin match and hopefully we'll get our tactics right and give them a hiding.
Reply
#34
(04-23-2019, 01:03 PM)billybassett Wrote:
(04-23-2019, 12:01 PM)Statto Wrote:
(04-23-2019, 10:46 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(04-23-2019, 10:30 AM)Loanee Wrote: Think the negativity comes from the top of the club, for example:

-Non appointment of a new head coach
-Little comment / direction from those in charge
-Questionable team / tactics over the last few games (eg not going out to win with our best players yesterday)

That coupled with Villa being massively in form & our inability to cope with teams in form this season (eg getting blown away by Leeds / Bristol City)
What about us being top 6 all season, being one of the country’s top scorers, blasting 7 past QPR getting 4s galore. Having a squad near full of prem players.
The negativity comes entirely from the way people look at the world themselves. Quite a pitiful and miserable post.

+1

What an absolute load of horse's excrement.

Without stepping on King of the Stats MancBaggie's toes it comes from the fact that since 1960 we've played the Villa home (36) and away (36) 72 times. We've won 22, drawn 20 and lost 36 (yes 50%).  In terms of home games we've won 13, drawn 12 and lost 11 out of 36. Away from home we've won 9 and lost 19.

Now stats mean absolutely nothing and are no indicator of the future. 

I feel a lack of optimism not because of the way I look at the world (I mean that must be the most outlandish and ridiculous post ever on this dump and that says something) but because generally in my lifetime we've tended to come out on the wrong side of results against the Villa. Most recently the FA Cup game at Villa and more often than not when battering them for 90 mins.

For me it's spin of a coin match and hopefully we'll get our tactics right and give them a hiding.

Have my maths suddenly gone out of the window.
Reply
#35
(04-23-2019, 12:47 PM)Albion Wrote:
(04-23-2019, 12:32 PM)billybassett Wrote:
(04-23-2019, 08:01 AM)Albion Wrote: Interesting to see what formation/team we played in the two games:

West Brom 2 Aston Villa 2 Friday 7 December 2018 8pm

(4-3-3)

Johnstone; Adarabioyo (Burke 82’), Dawson, Hegazi, Gibbs; Barry, Livermore (Brunt 72’), Phillips; Gayle, Rodriguez, Barnes

Subs Not Used:
Myhill (gk); Mears, Harper, Sako, Hoolahan

Aston Villa 0 West Brom 2 Saturday 16 February 2019 3pm

(4-3-3)

Johnstone; Holgate, Dawson, Hegazi, Gibbs; Barry (Johansen 86’), Livermore, Harper; Robson-Kanu (Field 45’), Rodriguez, Murphy (Bartley 78’)

Subs Not Used:
Bond (gk); Adarabioyo, Hoolahan, Montero

What were their line-ups and formation mon?

When we played them at Home:

(4-3-3)

Nyland; Hutton, Tuanzebe, Chester, Taylor (El Mohamady 52’); Hourihane, McGinn, Grealish (Whelan 87’); El Ghazi, Abraham, Boalsie (Kodija 82’)

Subs Not Used:

Bunn (gk), O’Hare, Revan, Hogan


When we played them Away:

(4-3-3)

Kalinic (Steer 45’); Hutton, Elphick, Mings, Hause; Whelan, Hourihane (Ramsey 61’), McGinn; El Mohamady, Abraham, Green (Kodjia 71’)

Subs Not Used:

Taylor, Jedinak, El Ghazi, Adomah

Currently they look something like this:

(4-3-3)

Steer; El Mohamady, Hause, Mings, Taylor; Hourihane, McGinn, Grealish; El Ghazi, Abraham, Adomah

Interesting. More compact second game without Barnes plus more legs doing the water carrying - Harper, Kanu, instead of Phillips and Gayle. If I remember they were toothless that day whereas at home we gave them room galore with all that fking around at the back.

I just hope to god Toisin doesn't play any part in these games. He's one second away from a rick. We won't have Barry but I see no reason why we can't beat them over two legs if we play the right tactics.
Reply
#36
(04-23-2019, 12:01 PM)Statto Wrote:
(04-23-2019, 10:46 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(04-23-2019, 10:30 AM)Loanee Wrote: Think the negativity comes from the top of the club, for example:

-Non appointment of a new head coach
-Little comment / direction from those in charge
-Questionable team / tactics over the last few games (eg not going out to win with our best players yesterday)

That coupled with Villa being massively in form & our inability to cope with teams in form this season (eg getting blown away by Leeds / Bristol City)
What about us being top 6 all season, being one of the country’s top scorers, blasting 7 past QPR getting 4s galore. Having a squad near full of prem players.
The negativity comes entirely from the way people look at the world themselves. Quite a pitiful and miserable post.

+1

Tales of woe doing my head in too. Trying to be realistic, Villa will be favourites due to this rub, but the ridiculous negativity by some is a sign of their world outlook undoubtedly.
Most of our fans will be aware this is a close run game. We've won enough to be a solid team just shy of automatic promotion all season. Yes, we haven't hit the heights of late we once did earlier in the season, but our home form has picked up dramatically and we have a very strong squad.
My suspicion is they'll be nothing in this. 
Prepare for the worst but hope for the best.
Reply
#37
(04-23-2019, 01:08 PM)cornishbaggie Wrote:
(04-23-2019, 01:03 PM)billybassett Wrote:
(04-23-2019, 12:01 PM)Statto Wrote:
(04-23-2019, 10:46 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(04-23-2019, 10:30 AM)Loanee Wrote: Think the negativity comes from the top of the club, for example:

-Non appointment of a new head coach
-Little comment / direction from those in charge
-Questionable team / tactics over the last few games (eg not going out to win with our best players yesterday)

That coupled with Villa being massively in form & our inability to cope with teams in form this season (eg getting blown away by Leeds / Bristol City)
What about us being top 6 all season, being one of the country’s top scorers, blasting 7 past QPR getting 4s galore. Having a squad near full of prem players.
The negativity comes entirely from the way people look at the world themselves. Quite a pitiful and miserable post.

+1

What an absolute load of horse's excrement.

Without stepping on King of the Stats MancBaggie's toes it comes from the fact that since 1960 we've played the Villa home (36) and away (36) 72 times. We've won 22, drawn 20 and lost 30 (yes 42%).  In terms of home games we've won 13, drawn 12 and lost 11 out of 36. Away from home we've won 9 and lost 19.

Now stats mean absolutely nothing and are no indicator of the future. 

I feel a lack of optimism not because of the way I look at the world (I mean that must be the most outlandish and ridiculous post ever on this dump and that says something) but because generally in my lifetime we've tended to come out on the wrong side of results against the Villa. Most recently the FA Cup game at Villa and more often than not when battering them for 90 mins.

For me it's spin of a coin match and hopefully we'll get our tactics right and give them a hiding.

Have my maths suddenly gone out of the window.

Big Grin Hence why MancBaggies does this. 30 defeats.... in 72 a respectable 42% loss
Reply
#38
(04-23-2019, 12:56 PM)KratosBaggie Wrote: Put my name into the negativity hat. I just feel the combination of their ten match winning run (an achievement that shouldn't be overlooked, by the way!), our clueless messing about with a new manager, generally how we've peformed unconvincingly  for a large part of the season - despite good results, we've been very poor, peformance wise, and finally the fact I'm a pessimistic cunt at the best of times, means that in my mind, Villa will beat us with ease in the play offs.

It'll be horrible.

Might as well give up then ?
Villa have done well but hardly unbeatable and we have the fire power to hurt them !
Reply
#39
1. We've taken 4 points off them this season.

2. Their run can't continue and a few I've spoken to think they have peaked too early.

3. Gayle and Jrod are in good form.

4. They don't want to play us just as much as we don't want to play them.

5. Our defence is stronger now in this new formation.

6. More pressure on them given their finances.

7. More pressure on them given they shit the bed in last year's play offs.

There's 7 reasons to be cheerful!
Reply
#40
(04-23-2019, 01:15 PM)billybassett Wrote:
(04-23-2019, 01:08 PM)cornishbaggie Wrote:
(04-23-2019, 01:03 PM)billybassett Wrote:
(04-23-2019, 12:01 PM)Statto Wrote:
(04-23-2019, 10:46 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: What about us being top 6 all season, being one of the country’s top scorers, blasting 7 past QPR getting 4s galore. Having a squad near full of prem players.
The negativity comes entirely from the way people look at the world themselves. Quite a pitiful and miserable post.

+1

What an absolute load of horse's excrement.

Without stepping on King of the Stats MancBaggie's toes it comes from the fact that since 1960 we've played the Villa home (36) and away (36) 72 times. We've won 22, drawn 20 and lost 30 (yes 42%).  In terms of home games we've won 13, drawn 12 and lost 11 out of 36. Away from home we've won 9 and lost 19.

Now stats mean absolutely nothing and are no indicator of the future. 

I feel a lack of optimism not because of the way I look at the world (I mean that must be the most outlandish and ridiculous post ever on this dump and that says something) but because generally in my lifetime we've tended to come out on the wrong side of results against the Villa. Most recently the FA Cup game at Villa and more often than not when battering them for 90 mins.

For me it's spin of a coin match and hopefully we'll get our tactics right and give them a hiding.

Have my maths suddenly gone out of the window.

Big Grin Hence why MancBaggies does this. 30 defeats.... in 72 a respectable 42% loss
 
Rolleyes Big Grin 

Decent post though.  Also agree with Peachy - and that TAs fitness could be a factor.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: