Posts: 10,272
Threads: 694
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
Another way of looking at it is somehow with 20 games left Corbes has got us back to a standing start battling for 4 playoff spots. That’s some achievement.
I will be bold enough to say that I think we have as good a chance as any because the form under CC has been so notable.
It’d be nice to hope Norwich make a duff appointment. That’d help.
Posts: 2,927
Threads: 44
Joined: Sep 2019
Reputation:
7
(12-30-2022, 01:29 PM)BradleyFromTheHalfWayLine Wrote: (12-30-2022, 12:48 PM)MancBaggie Wrote: (12-30-2022, 11:56 AM)Tom Joad Wrote: Spandau. The most important part of your comments. Under Bruce we appeared unlucky when in fact we were careless. So true, and something Bruce himself refused to acknowledge. To be a goal down 15 minutes into every game, easy to correct. To have no threat at set pieces, easy to work on. To keep crossing the ball to diminutive centre forwards, is beyond belief. Carlos has no magic wand, he simply spotted that without hard work and meticulous application no one will get anywhere.
Fact is , we have really been given a Get Out of Jail Free card. How far we go with it is mostly out of our hands. It would take a special type of implosion for either of the top 2 to lose enough games against poor championship sides for us to overtake them. That's assuming we continue this amazing run.
I'm just enjoying every moment and should we get a chance of Wembley, I'll grab it with both hands.
Great post
Seal type arrogance to assume that the top 2 are the only barrier to automatic. Watford and Norwich aren't setting the league alight and as of this very moment I would fancy we will finish above them, however the reality is that their squads are good enough to make as serious a challenge as us for the top 2. Norwich in particular are underachieving spectacularly, their best XI are as good as any in this league. Watford are decimated by injuries and also wasted the first 1/4 of the season by appointing an unproven, out of his depth Rob Edwards at the start of the summer.
If Norwich get their next appointment right and Bilic does a good job at Watford we'll have serious competition should we make the play-offs.
I agree with what a lot of what you're saying but I think I'd rather have our side than those at Norwich or Watford. Watford have got some talented individuals but having seen quite a few of their games on Sky (and them and QPR are on all the flaming time), they are wildly inconsistent and just as likely to be awful as they are to tear teams apart.
Norwich remind me of Albion last season. On paper it looks a decent side for this division but the players look drained of confidence after a couple of recent seasons of being pummelled every week in the Premier League. Their most important players like Pukki are that bit older and other more promising ones like Cantwell have really gone off the boil. I wouldn't discount them if they make a good appointment but I do feel there are deeper issues there and it's more than just a problem of Dean Smith who is generally a very good manager at this level.
Posts: 10,272
Threads: 694
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
(12-30-2022, 02:36 PM)Man from delmonte Wrote: (12-30-2022, 01:29 PM)BradleyFromTheHalfWayLine Wrote: (12-30-2022, 12:48 PM)MancBaggie Wrote: (12-30-2022, 11:56 AM)Tom Joad Wrote: Spandau. The most important part of your comments. Under Bruce we appeared unlucky when in fact we were careless. So true, and something Bruce himself refused to acknowledge. To be a goal down 15 minutes into every game, easy to correct. To have no threat at set pieces, easy to work on. To keep crossing the ball to diminutive centre forwards, is beyond belief. Carlos has no magic wand, he simply spotted that without hard work and meticulous application no one will get anywhere.
Fact is , we have really been given a Get Out of Jail Free card. How far we go with it is mostly out of our hands. It would take a special type of implosion for either of the top 2 to lose enough games against poor championship sides for us to overtake them. That's assuming we continue this amazing run.
I'm just enjoying every moment and should we get a chance of Wembley, I'll grab it with both hands.
Great post
Seal type arrogance to assume that the top 2 are the only barrier to automatic. Watford and Norwich aren't setting the league alight and as of this very moment I would fancy we will finish above them, however the reality is that their squads are good enough to make as serious a challenge as us for the top 2. Norwich in particular are underachieving spectacularly, their best XI are as good as any in this league. Watford are decimated by injuries and also wasted the first 1/4 of the season by appointing an unproven, out of his depth Rob Edwards at the start of the summer.
If Norwich get their next appointment right and Bilic does a good job at Watford we'll have serious competition should we make the play-offs.
I agree with what a lot of what you're saying but I think I'd rather have our side than those at Norwich or Watford. Watford have got some talented individuals but having seen quite a few of their games on Sky (and them and QPR are on all the flaming time), they are wildly inconsistent and just as likely to be awful as they are to tear teams apart.
Norwich remind me of Albion last season. On paper it looks a decent side for this division but the players look drained of confidence after a couple of recent seasons of being pummelled every week in the Premier League. Their most important players like Pukki are that bit older and other more promising ones like Cantwell have really gone off the boil. I wouldn't discount them if they make a good appointment but I do feel there are deeper issues there and it's more than just a problem of Dean Smith who is generally a very good manager at this level.
Clubs like us and Norwich are so used to yo-yoing that at some point we drop below a standard we expect and then an impatience by fans, board etc starts. In other words we've higher expectations than say Preston or Bristol C.
My Norwich mate is bemoaning poor expensive signings that have hardly figured and they are an identikit club to us. They could well end up having the issues we had last season and then having a more major job to do.
The Ishmael demise and Bruce's hapless tenure has kind of made us all appreciate winning that bit more.
Posts: 15,040
Threads: 339
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
93
(12-30-2022, 01:29 PM)BradleyFromTheHalfWayLine Wrote: (12-30-2022, 12:48 PM)MancBaggie Wrote: (12-30-2022, 11:56 AM)Tom Joad Wrote: Spandau. The most important part of your comments. Under Bruce we appeared unlucky when in fact we were careless. So true, and something Bruce himself refused to acknowledge. To be a goal down 15 minutes into every game, easy to correct. To have no threat at set pieces, easy to work on. To keep crossing the ball to diminutive centre forwards, is beyond belief. Carlos has no magic wand, he simply spotted that without hard work and meticulous application no one will get anywhere.
Fact is , we have really been given a Get Out of Jail Free card. How far we go with it is mostly out of our hands. It would take a special type of implosion for either of the top 2 to lose enough games against poor championship sides for us to overtake them. That's assuming we continue this amazing run.
I'm just enjoying every moment and should we get a chance of Wembley, I'll grab it with both hands.
Great post
Seal type arrogance to assume that the top 2 are the only barrier to automatic. Watford and Norwich aren't setting the league alight and as of this very moment I would fancy we will finish above them, however the reality is that their squads are good enough to make as serious a challenge as us for the top 2. Norwich in particular are underachieving spectacularly, their best XI are as good as any in this league. Watford are decimated by injuries and also wasted the first 1/4 of the season by appointing an unproven, out of his depth Rob Edwards at the start of the summer.
If Norwich get their next appointment right and Bilic does a good job at Watford we'll have serious competition should we make the play-offs. Seal type arrogance? Where? You're the one that suggests we'll finish above Watford and Norwich. I merely point out play offs would be nice.
Posts: 10,272
Threads: 694
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
I really don’t think it’s arrogance to think a club that is winning games consistently and is a point behind the playoffs will make them is any form of arrogance. It’s hopeful expectation based on form.
Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
(12-30-2022, 12:48 PM)MancBaggie Wrote: (12-30-2022, 11:56 AM)Tom Joad Wrote: Spandau. The most important part of your comments. Under Bruce we appeared unlucky when in fact we were careless. So true, and something Bruce himself refused to acknowledge. To be a goal down 15 minutes into every game, easy to correct. To have no threat at set pieces, easy to work on. To keep crossing the ball to diminutive centre forwards, is beyond belief. Carlos has no magic wand, he simply spotted that without hard work and meticulous application no one will get anywhere.
Fact is , we have really been given a Get Out of Jail Free card. How far we go with it is mostly out of our hands. It would take a special type of implosion for either of the top 2 to lose enough games against poor championship sides for us to overtake them. That's assuming we continue this amazing run.
I'm just enjoying every moment and should we get a chance of Wembley, I'll grab it with both hands.
Great post
+2
Posts: 10,272
Threads: 694
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
(12-30-2022, 11:56 AM)Tom Joad Wrote: Spandau. The most important part of your comments. Under Bruce we appeared unlucky when in fact we were careless. So true, and something Bruce himself refused to acknowledge. To be a goal down 15 minutes into every game, easy to correct. To have no threat at set pieces, easy to work on. To keep crossing the ball to diminutive centre forwards, is beyond belief. Carlos has no magic wand, he simply spotted that without hard work and meticulous application no one will get anywhere.
Fact is , we have really been given a Get Out of Jail Free card. How far we go with it is mostly out of our hands. It would take a special type of implosion for either of the top 2 to lose enough games against poor championship sides for us to overtake them. That's assuming we continue this amazing run.
I'm just enjoying every moment and should we get a chance of Wembley, I'll grab it with both hands.
Thanks Tom.
You are bang on. Bruce put so much down to bad luck and not taking chances. Simply thought always giving a goal lead in a few minutes was appalling. His lack of effort to make the players fit and aware added terribly to the forwards too.
Grant has been public enemy no one but the added pressure of being a goal behind when you get a chance can’t help.
Posts: 3,109
Threads: 184
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
Under Bruce, I felt we were a bit unlucky at times, but careless in other games (Swansea and Huddersfield stand out). We were not short of scoring goals, but we didn't seem to stop conceding, particularly early on. The 5-2 v Hull should have kickstarted the season, but it failed to do so. We weren't fit enough in general, and tactically at times poor or all over the place.
After the short break for the Queen's death and was it an international one, we should have played Birmingham refreshed, fully organised/prepared and looking to turn an ok start to the season into a good one. Instead, we went backwards. This was why Bruce had to go and we may have done it earlier, but CC wasn't available then.
The only positive was that we were always going to improve at some point and we were not short of goals. CC has enhanced that by sorting out the defence. Plus we are far sharper when we pass the ball. We will get better IMO.
Posts: 15,040
Threads: 339
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
93
(12-30-2022, 08:29 PM)ColliersWoodBaggie Wrote: Under Bruce, I felt we were a bit unlucky at times, but careless in other games (Swansea and Huddersfield stand out). We were not short of scoring goals, but we didn't seem to stop conceding, particularly early on. The 5-2 v Hull should have kickstarted the season, but it failed to do so. We weren't fit enough in general, and tactically at times poor or all over the place.
After the short break for the Queen's death and was it an international one, we should have played Birmingham refreshed, fully organised/prepared and looking to turn an ok start to the season into a good one. Instead, we went backwards. This was why Bruce had to go and we may have done it earlier, but CC wasn't available then.
The only positive was that we were always going to improve at some point and we were not short of goals. CC has enhanced that by sorting out the defence. Plus we are far sharper when we pass the ball. We will get better IMO.
I saw no sign whatsoever, we were going to improve. Results were getting worse, inevitably so was our league position. Confidence was rock bottom and the players unfit and unmotivated. At some point in the season they would have faced a few 'must wins'. I wouldn't have fancied them one bit.
We should improve further under CC. Just look at the attitude and team spirit come the final whistle.
Posts: 880
Threads: 30
Joined: Aug 2022
Reputation:
2
12-30-2022, 09:20 PM
(This post was last modified: 12-30-2022, 09:37 PM by BradleyFromTheHalfWayLine.)
(12-30-2022, 02:36 PM)Man from delmonte Wrote: (12-30-2022, 01:29 PM)BradleyFromTheHalfWayLine Wrote: (12-30-2022, 12:48 PM)MancBaggie Wrote: (12-30-2022, 11:56 AM)Tom Joad Wrote: Spandau. The most important part of your comments. Under Bruce we appeared unlucky when in fact we were careless. So true, and something Bruce himself refused to acknowledge. To be a goal down 15 minutes into every game, easy to correct. To have no threat at set pieces, easy to work on. To keep crossing the ball to diminutive centre forwards, is beyond belief. Carlos has no magic wand, he simply spotted that without hard work and meticulous application no one will get anywhere.
Fact is , we have really been given a Get Out of Jail Free card. How far we go with it is mostly out of our hands. It would take a special type of implosion for either of the top 2 to lose enough games against poor championship sides for us to overtake them. That's assuming we continue this amazing run.
I'm just enjoying every moment and should we get a chance of Wembley, I'll grab it with both hands.
Great post
Seal type arrogance to assume that the top 2 are the only barrier to automatic. Watford and Norwich aren't setting the league alight and as of this very moment I would fancy we will finish above them, however the reality is that their squads are good enough to make as serious a challenge as us for the top 2. Norwich in particular are underachieving spectacularly, their best XI are as good as any in this league. Watford are decimated by injuries and also wasted the first 1/4 of the season by appointing an unproven, out of his depth Rob Edwards at the start of the summer.
If Norwich get their next appointment right and Bilic does a good job at Watford we'll have serious competition should we make the play-offs.
I agree with what a lot of what you're saying but I think I'd rather have our side than those at Norwich or Watford. Watford have got some talented individuals but having seen quite a few of their games on Sky (and them and QPR are on all the flaming time), they are wildly inconsistent and just as likely to be awful as they are to tear teams apart.
Norwich remind me of Albion last season. On paper it looks a decent side for this division but the players look drained of confidence after a couple of recent seasons of being pummelled every week in the Premier League. Their most important players like Pukki are that bit older and other more promising ones like Cantwell have really gone off the boil. I wouldn't discount them if they make a good appointment but I do feel there are deeper issues there and it's more than just a problem of Dean Smith who is generally a very good manager at this level.
I agree that Watford are inconsistent and they will need to be more so to get promoted. As I say, we've been fortunate that they've picked up so many injuries and made an equally foolish appointment in Edwards this summer as we did by sticking with Bruce. I see Pedro is now out for two months, huge blow for them and massive for us and other contenders. I still expect them to prove a serious test if we were to play them in the play-offs. As to Norwich, I wouldn't even say Pukki is their most important striker now, this is Sargent who is quality at this level, while Cantwell has been only a fringe player this season. Player-for-player they are IMO at least on a par with us but have been as poorly coached by Smith as we were by Bruce. A good manager will sort them out as Corbs has us and they will make top 6. Either way, I think it's bizarre that they are all but dismissed by most on here when it comes to talk of promotion contenders, it's the kind of assumption that could easily come back to bite people on the arse come May.
(12-30-2022, 04:23 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: (12-30-2022, 01:29 PM)BradleyFromTheHalfWayLine Wrote: (12-30-2022, 12:48 PM)MancBaggie Wrote: (12-30-2022, 11:56 AM)Tom Joad Wrote: Spandau. The most important part of your comments. Under Bruce we appeared unlucky when in fact we were careless. So true, and something Bruce himself refused to acknowledge. To be a goal down 15 minutes into every game, easy to correct. To have no threat at set pieces, easy to work on. To keep crossing the ball to diminutive centre forwards, is beyond belief. Carlos has no magic wand, he simply spotted that without hard work and meticulous application no one will get anywhere.
Fact is , we have really been given a Get Out of Jail Free card. How far we go with it is mostly out of our hands. It would take a special type of implosion for either of the top 2 to lose enough games against poor championship sides for us to overtake them. That's assuming we continue this amazing run.
I'm just enjoying every moment and should we get a chance of Wembley, I'll grab it with both hands.
Great post
Seal type arrogance to assume that the top 2 are the only barrier to automatic. Watford and Norwich aren't setting the league alight and as of this very moment I would fancy we will finish above them, however the reality is that their squads are good enough to make as serious a challenge as us for the top 2. Norwich in particular are underachieving spectacularly, their best XI are as good as any in this league. Watford are decimated by injuries and also wasted the first 1/4 of the season by appointing an unproven, out of his depth Rob Edwards at the start of the summer.
If Norwich get their next appointment right and Bilic does a good job at Watford we'll have serious competition should we make the play-offs. Seal type arrogance? Where? You're the one that suggests we'll finish above Watford and Norwich. I merely point out play offs would be nice.
I didn't say we will finish above them but that on current form I fancied us to - not the same thing.
I shouldn't have singled you out for the 'seal' comment though and for that I apologise, reading back again your thoughts are fairly close to mine.
It just seems to me that many on here are already writing off the other teams (such as Watford and Norwich) considering that only 6-8 weeks ago many were fretting about our possible relegation. Things have changed rapidly for us but people appear to forget they can for the other contenders.
|