1917
#21
(12-28-2022, 12:13 PM)baggiebloke Wrote:
(12-28-2022, 11:15 AM)Ministry Of Silly Signings Wrote:
(12-27-2022, 11:12 PM)Duffers Wrote: It’s a great film, brilliantly shot and acted and like you say, hammers home the sheer pointlessness of that war.

My family has a lot of history of WW1. My Nans brother died a couple of months before the Armistice, and rests in a War Grave in Arras, a few years back, my cousin gave me the medals he won, as she didn`t know what to do with them. They are safe in my cupboard.
When I first met Mrs Ministry, her Dad, on hearing of my interest in military history, told me of his great uncle, who died in the battle of the Somme, July 1916. He had tried to find out the story, but, the War Graves Commision etc said they had no record of the bloke, to be fair, some records were destroyed in the Blitz in 1940.
By chance, at the time, I worked with a lad who was in the T.A, who gave me the name of a regimental historian, a retired Captain or whatever. He sent us loads of details, we found out where and how he was killed, and a copy of his Regiments war diary for that week, copies of officers reports etc.
We all went to Northern France, and found his name on the British memorial at Thiepval, 1 of 60,000 who had no known grave. We also drove to a place caled Ouvillers, where he had died, about 5 houses, 2 farms and a phone box, ( there is a small war cemetry there ).
Driving around that area, there is a war cemetry every couple of miles. In 2016, we went back, to pay our respects on the 100th anniversary of his death, we took my then 14 year old out of school for a week, telling his head teacher it was not negotiable, he, to his credit was very understanding, and, a few weeks later, asked my lad to read at Worcester Cathedral in a memorial service, in front of M.Ps, Military dignitaries, Mayors etc. Very moving.

Crikey. Indeed, that must have been very moving.

It was. However, there is another part to the story, from WW2. The man who died on the Somme in 1916, had a son, who he never knew. My father in law knew this man, as his uncle, when he was a 4 year old child.
His uncle, who called my father in law `Tin Ribs`, volunteered for the R.A.F in 1940, and, as he had worked as a journalist, went to Canada to train as a navigator. On his return, he was sent to a place near Ipswich, where he trained other navigators.
My father in law remembered the Police coming to their house in 1942, to tell the family that the man had died ,`shot down returning from a bombing raid`. 
A few years back, we found a website about WW2 Bomber Command, and found this mans details etc.
It turned out he had not been shot down on a bombing raid, but, on a training flight, crashed in bad weather, into a hillside near Durham,
the local museum had newspaper clippings about it etc. We all went up there, and the farmland he crashed on is now owned by a very wealthy family, who made us very welcome, and were delighted to show us around, he reckoned he is still ploughing up fragments of Stirling bomber, bullets etc. As a slightly funny side, the bloke from the local museum told us, `If you thought Dad`s Army`was fictitious....` Apparently, the local Home Guard platoon came to guard the wreck, and, being short of ammunition, took some from the wreck, for target practice. They didn`t know that every 3rd bullet was a phosphorous `tracer`, and proceeded to set half the place on fire.
Reply
#22
(12-28-2022, 12:45 PM)Baggeridgebaggy Wrote:
(12-27-2022, 10:51 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Just watched the film. Every time I watch, read or hear about WWI it makes me angry and sad. What an absolute waste of life and all due to a pointless war for greedy, self serving, squabbling 

Not suggesting you do, but it’s accepted that too much historical perspective of WW1 got taken from ‘Oh what a lovely war’ & similar left wing, anti war propaganda 

A lot of the causes of WW1 were about protecting national interests, but Britain fundamentally got involved because an aggressive, nationalistic Germany invaded Belgium to attack France 

An awful war that affected virtually every family in the country, but to categorise it as a war’ for squabbling, aristocratic families isn’t correct in my opinion

Correct. Even though the main players were related Germany had been looking for or trying to manufacture the spark for years. Archduke Ferdinand was pretty much sacrificed for this whole debacle having practically no guards in an area that generally despised him.
Reply
#23
This book reveals another side of trench life

Mud, Blood and Poppycock: Britain and the Great War (W&N Military): Amazon.co.uk: Gordon Corrigan: 9780304366590: Books

Boredom was a major feature in everyday life, soldiers did not spend as much time 'at the front' as portrayed and many had a regular income and food for the first time in their lives.
On returning home, many jobs advertised 'no veterans' and may fell on hard times.
Reply
#24
(12-28-2022, 04:36 PM)Fido Wrote:
(12-28-2022, 12:45 PM)Baggeridgebaggy Wrote:
(12-27-2022, 10:51 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Just watched the film. Every time I watch, read or hear about WWI it makes me angry and sad. What an absolute waste of life and all due to a pointless war for greedy, self serving, squabbling 

Not suggesting you do, but it’s accepted that too much historical perspective of WW1 got taken from ‘Oh what a lovely war’ & similar left wing, anti war propaganda 

A lot of the causes of WW1 were about protecting national interests, but Britain fundamentally got involved because an aggressive, nationalistic Germany invaded Belgium to attack France 

An awful war that affected virtually every family in the country, but to categorise it as a war’ for squabbling, aristocratic families isn’t correct in my opinion

Correct. Even though the main players were related Germany had been looking for or trying to manufacture the spark for years. Archduke Ferdinand was pretty much sacrificed for this whole debacle having practically no guards in an area that generally despised him.

Yes - Habsburg shot by a Serb in Sarajevo. That corner of Europe has been a harbinger so many times.  It might be happening again in North Kosovo
Reply
#25
(12-28-2022, 07:39 PM)MancBaggie Wrote:
(12-28-2022, 04:36 PM)Fido Wrote:
(12-28-2022, 12:45 PM)Baggeridgebaggy Wrote:
(12-27-2022, 10:51 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Just watched the film. Every time I watch, read or hear about WWI it makes me angry and sad. What an absolute waste of life and all due to a pointless war for greedy, self serving, squabbling 

Not suggesting you do, but it’s accepted that too much historical perspective of WW1 got taken from ‘Oh what a lovely war’ & similar left wing, anti war propaganda 

A lot of the causes of WW1 were about protecting national interests, but Britain fundamentally got involved because an aggressive, nationalistic Germany invaded Belgium to attack France 

An awful war that affected virtually every family in the country, but to categorise it as a war’ for squabbling, aristocratic families isn’t correct in my opinion

Correct. Even though the main players were related Germany had been looking for or trying to manufacture the spark for years. Archduke Ferdinand was pretty much sacrificed for this whole debacle having practically no guards in an area that generally despised him.

Yes - Habsburg shot by a Serb in Sarajevo. That corner of Europe has been a harbinger so many times.  It might be happening again in North Kosovo

“One day the great European War will come out of some damned foolish thing in the Balkans.”– Otto von Bismarck (1888)
Reply
#26
(12-28-2022, 07:39 PM)MancBaggie Wrote:
(12-28-2022, 04:36 PM)Fido Wrote:
(12-28-2022, 12:45 PM)Baggeridgebaggy Wrote:
(12-27-2022, 10:51 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Just watched the film. Every time I watch, read or hear about WWI it makes me angry and sad. What an absolute waste of life and all due to a pointless war for greedy, self serving, squabbling 

Not suggesting you do, but it’s accepted that too much historical perspective of WW1 got taken from ‘Oh what a lovely war’ & similar left wing, anti war propaganda 

A lot of the causes of WW1 were about protecting national interests, but Britain fundamentally got involved because an aggressive, nationalistic Germany invaded Belgium to attack France 

An awful war that affected virtually every family in the country, but to categorise it as a war’ for squabbling, aristocratic families isn’t correct in my opinion

Correct. Even though the main players were related Germany had been looking for or trying to manufacture the spark for years. Archduke Ferdinand was pretty much sacrificed for this whole debacle having practically no guards in an area that generally despised him.

Yes - Habsburg shot by a Serb in Sarajevo. That corner of Europe has been a harbinger so many times.  It might be happening again in North Kosovo
Have seen that tensions are increasing in North Kosovo, I really hope that NATO`s troops there, KFOR, can control things.
To me, at least, it is barmy that, us and France and Germany etc, fought 2 World wars in the space of 30 years, but are now friends, but these folks are still fighting over something that happened hundreds of years ago.
Reply
#27
(12-28-2022, 07:07 PM)baggpuss Wrote: This book reveals another side of trench life

Mud, Blood and Poppycock: Britain and the Great War (W&N Military): Amazon.co.uk: Gordon Corrigan: 9780304366590: Books

Boredom was a major feature in everyday life, soldiers did not spend as much time 'at the front' as portrayed and many had a regular income and food for the first time in their lives.
On returning home, many jobs advertised 'no veterans' and may fell on hard times.

Thanks for sharing this. £1.99 on Kindle, and added to my lengthy 'to read' pile. I've got a terrible habit/addiction to purchasing books quicker than I can read them!
Reply
#28
(12-28-2022, 07:59 PM)Ministry Of Silly Signings Wrote:
(12-28-2022, 07:39 PM)MancBaggie Wrote:
(12-28-2022, 04:36 PM)Fido Wrote:
(12-28-2022, 12:45 PM)Baggeridgebaggy Wrote:
(12-27-2022, 10:51 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Just watched the film. Every time I watch, read or hear about WWI it makes me angry and sad. What an absolute waste of life and all due to a pointless war for greedy, self serving, squabbling 

Not suggesting you do, but it’s accepted that too much historical perspective of WW1 got taken from ‘Oh what a lovely war’ & similar left wing, anti war propaganda 

A lot of the causes of WW1 were about protecting national interests, but Britain fundamentally got involved because an aggressive, nationalistic Germany invaded Belgium to attack France 

An awful war that affected virtually every family in the country, but to categorise it as a war’ for squabbling, aristocratic families isn’t correct in my opinion

Correct. Even though the main players were related Germany had been looking for or trying to manufacture the spark for years. Archduke Ferdinand was pretty much sacrificed for this whole debacle having practically no guards in an area that generally despised him.

Yes - Habsburg shot by a Serb in Sarajevo. That corner of Europe has been a harbinger so many times.  It might be happening again in North Kosovo
Have seen that tensions are increasing in North Kosovo, I really hope that NATO`s troops there, KFOR, can control things.
To me, at least, it is barmy that, us and France and Germany etc, fought 2 World wars in the space of 30 years, but are now friends, but these folks are still fighting over something that happened hundreds of years ago.

The historical differences have never been settled so fester still and are provoked by nationalism on both sides, Kosovo is 94% Albanian Muslim and 6% Serb Christian but the Serbs are concentrated in a few areas where they are the majority
Reply
#29
(12-28-2022, 08:12 PM)SuperBob2002 Wrote:
(12-28-2022, 07:07 PM)baggpuss Wrote: This book reveals another side of trench life

Mud, Blood and Poppycock: Britain and the Great War (W&N Military): Amazon.co.uk: Gordon Corrigan: 9780304366590: Books

Boredom was a major feature in everyday life, soldiers did not spend as much time 'at the front' as portrayed and many had a regular income and food for the first time in their lives.
On returning home, many jobs advertised 'no veterans' and may fell on hard times.

Thanks for sharing this. £1.99 on Kindle, and added to my lengthy 'to read' pile. I've got a terrible habit/addiction to purchasing books quicker than I can read them!

Welcome mate - I found it a real eye opener
Reply
#30
Anyone who wants to read about the origins and then the mess that led to the trenches should have a go at August 1914 by Barbara Tuchman - the first (and one of only two) women ever to win the Pulitzer Prize twice. All her books are works of art let alone superb history and her writing is utterly elegant, readable and compelling. Unputdownable.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)