FFP Points deductions
#1
I understand that the EFL meeting on Wednesday (24th) could be very interesting re FFP points deductions based on the assessments for the current 2018/9, being the third year of the 3-year cycle which Villa, Derby and Sheffield Wednesday are believed to have massively breached. 

Villa and Derby may have good reason to be very nervous (Wednesday unlikely to be badly affected by any sanctions). The rules were specifically changed to make sure that sanctions could be applied in the current season, rather than after the promotion/relegation places and play-offs had already been decided.  And any sanctions are now also enforced by the Premier League - getting promoted to escape then no longer works. 

Watch this space....
Reply
#2
Unfortunately even a 9 point deduction like Blues received would leave Villa able to qualify for the playoffs, and further give them a reason to keep up some intensity going into the final 2 games of the season... it would also likely set up a semi final meeting between us and Tony.......

If it were to happen, we’d see

4- Us - 77
5- Boro - 67
6- Villa - 66
7- Bristol City 66
8- Sheff Wed 63
9- Swansea 62

But both Swansea and Bristol would have a game in hand.
Reply
#3
(04-22-2019, 09:35 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Unfortunately even a 9 point deduction like Blues received would leave Villa able to  qualify for the playoffs, and further give them a reason to keep up some intensity going into the final 2 games of the season... it would also likely set up a semi final meeting between us and Tony.......

If it were to happen, we’d see

4- Us - 77
5- Boro - 67
6- Villa - 66
7- Bristol City 66
8- Sheff Wed 63
9- Swansea 62

But both Swansea and Bristol would have a game in hand.

The sanctions are a lot wider than points deductions. The EFL regulations specifically allow them to debt a club automatic promotion, deny them participation in the playoffs, points deductions, fines, relegation, or any of the above. What Birmingham suffered (re a breach for 2017/8) does not bind them.
Reply
#4
(04-22-2019, 09:40 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(04-22-2019, 09:35 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Unfortunately even a 9 point deduction like Blues received would leave Villa able to  qualify for the playoffs, and further give them a reason to keep up some intensity going into the final 2 games of the season... it would also likely set up a semi final meeting between us and Tony.......

If it were to happen, we’d see

4- Us - 77
5- Boro - 67
6- Villa - 66
7- Bristol City 66
8- Sheff Wed 63
9- Swansea 62

But both Swansea and Bristol would have a game in hand.

The sanctions are a lot wider than points deductions. The EFL regulations specifically allow them to debt a club automatic promotion, deny them participation in the playoffs, points deductions, fines, relegation, or any of the above. What Birmingham suffered (re a breach for 2017/8) does not bind them.

I realise that, but do you have any confidence that they’ll actually enforce anything in this scenario?

The 9 point deduction is a nice and easy solution... Villa unlikely to appeal/put up a fight and a precident can be set.
Reply
#5
(04-22-2019, 09:47 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(04-22-2019, 09:40 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(04-22-2019, 09:35 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Unfortunately even a 9 point deduction like Blues received would leave Villa able to  qualify for the playoffs, and further give them a reason to keep up some intensity going into the final 2 games of the season... it would also likely set up a semi final meeting between us and Tony.......

If it were to happen, we’d see

4- Us - 77
5- Boro - 67
6- Villa - 66
7- Bristol City 66
8- Sheff Wed 63
9- Swansea 62

But both Swansea and Bristol would have a game in hand.

The sanctions are a lot wider than points deductions. The EFL regulations specifically allow them to debt a club automatic promotion, deny them participation in the playoffs, points deductions, fines, relegation, or any of the above. What Birmingham suffered (re a breach for 2017/8) does not bind them.

I realise that, but do you have any confidence that they’ll actually enforce anything in this scenario?

The 9 point deduction is a nice and easy solution... Villa unlikely to appeal/put up a fight and a precident can be set.

Am I confident?  Reasonably, yes. They are determined to enforce and either Villa or Derby “buying” promotion through cheating is exactly what they are trying to confront. The fact that they changed the regulations to be able to provide correct-season sanctions is quite telling re their intentions.

Each case is unique so we shouldn’t take Birmingham's penalty to be the benchmark. Their owner went to prison for fraud, and that impacted on the club. Villa, Derby and Wednesday have brazenly overspent, well aware that they were under close scrutiny. Villa could well be £20m-£30m over their limit yet they still went out and signed Abraham and Mings on expensive loan details and declined to sell Grealish last summer, so didn’t exactly take it seriously.
Reply
#6
(04-22-2019, 10:06 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(04-22-2019, 09:47 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(04-22-2019, 09:40 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(04-22-2019, 09:35 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Unfortunately even a 9 point deduction like Blues received would leave Villa able to  qualify for the playoffs, and further give them a reason to keep up some intensity going into the final 2 games of the season... it would also likely set up a semi final meeting between us and Tony.......

If it were to happen, we’d see

4- Us - 77
5- Boro - 67
6- Villa - 66
7- Bristol City 66
8- Sheff Wed 63
9- Swansea 62

But both Swansea and Bristol would have a game in hand.

The sanctions are a lot wider than points deductions. The EFL regulations specifically allow them to debt a club automatic promotion, deny them participation in the playoffs, points deductions, fines, relegation, or any of the above. What Birmingham suffered (re a breach for 2017/8) does not bind them.

I realise that, but do you have any confidence that they’ll actually enforce anything in this scenario?

The 9 point deduction is a nice and easy solution... Villa unlikely to appeal/put up a fight and a precident can be set.

Am I confident?  Reasonably, yes. They are determined to enforce and either Villa or Derby “buying” promotion through cheating is exactly what they are trying to confront. The fact that they changed the regulations to be able to provide correct-season sanctions is quite telling re their intentions.

Each case is unique so we shouldn’t take Birmingham's penalty to be the benchmark. Their owner went to prison for fraud, and that impacted on the club. Villa, Derby and Wednesday have brazenly overspent, well aware that they were under close scrutiny. Villa could well be £20m-£30m over their limit yet they still went out and signed Abraham and Mings on expensive loan details and declined to sell Grealish last summer, so didn’t exactly take it seriously.

I totally understand why you’re confident, and you’ve shown you know this subject far better than most  on here, however with only 2 weeks until the playoffs start, and potentially 2 out of 4 competing teams affected, I can’t see them them taking any action that will cause any amount of uncertainty to the schedules. Any club that receives a penalty will no doubt be able to appeal, and a denial of promotion/denial of entering the playoffs, or even a points penalty that impacts these will be challenged and I’m not sure we have enough time for this to occur.

Like I’ve said, I imagine the league will deduct a meaningless amount of points, or throw a “soft” summer embargo which the PL will enforce should either Derby or Villa get promoted
Reply
#7
If they fail to do anything QPR will be wanting £42,000,000 fine repaid and I wouldn't blame them.
Blues will be after the 9 pts back and move up the league a few places.
The EFL managers will be a laughing stock or rightfully accused of victimisation if they ignore the continued rule breaking, they have to be seen to be doing something ffs.
Reply
#8
Prag has been on the money with FFP and company law.

There are plenty of Chairmen looking to make examples of clubs who ignore the rules.

I would love to see both miss out on promotion by losing in the play-offs, and then be embargoed all next season. Rather that, than a legal battle concerning deduction of points at this late stage

The EFL cannot ignore this, because of the precedent it sets. More importantly, the majority of clubs do not want it ignored

I expect something to happen, even if it does not stop a promotion.
Reply
#9
(04-22-2019, 10:13 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(04-22-2019, 10:06 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(04-22-2019, 09:47 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(04-22-2019, 09:40 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(04-22-2019, 09:35 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Unfortunately even a 9 point deduction like Blues received would leave Villa able to  qualify for the playoffs, and further give them a reason to keep up some intensity going into the final 2 games of the season... it would also likely set up a semi final meeting between us and Tony.......

If it were to happen, we’d see

4- Us - 77
5- Boro - 67
6- Villa - 66
7- Bristol City 66
8- Sheff Wed 63
9- Swansea 62

But both Swansea and Bristol would have a game in hand.

The sanctions are a lot wider than points deductions. The EFL regulations specifically allow them to debt a club automatic promotion, deny them participation in the playoffs, points deductions, fines, relegation, or any of the above. What Birmingham suffered (re a breach for 2017/8) does not bind them.

I realise that, but do you have any confidence that they’ll actually enforce anything in this scenario?

The 9 point deduction is a nice and easy solution... Villa unlikely to appeal/put up a fight and a precident can be set.

Am I confident?  Reasonably, yes. They are determined to enforce and either Villa or Derby “buying” promotion through cheating is exactly what they are trying to confront. The fact that they changed the regulations to be able to provide correct-season sanctions is quite telling re their intentions.

Each case is unique so we shouldn’t take Birmingham's penalty to be the benchmark. Their owner went to prison for fraud, and that impacted on the club. Villa, Derby and Wednesday have brazenly overspent, well aware that they were under close scrutiny. Villa could well be £20m-£30m over their limit yet they still went out and signed Abraham and Mings on expensive loan details and declined to sell Grealish last summer, so didn’t exactly take it seriously.

I totally understand why you’re confident, and you’ve shown you know this subject far better than most  on here, however with only 2 weeks until the playoffs start, and potentially 2 out of 4 competing teams affected, I can’t see them them taking any action that will cause any amount of uncertainty to the schedules. Any club that receives a penalty will no doubt be able to appeal, and a denial of promotion/denial of entering the playoffs, or even a points penalty that impacts these will be challenged and I’m not sure we have enough time for this to occur.

Like I’ve said, I imagine the league will deduct a meaningless amount of points, or throw a “soft” summer embargo which the PL will enforce should either Derby or Villa get promoted

The timing issue is very relevant. The EFL changed the rules specifically to enable them to act in the current season, and every Championship has, since 1st March, had to provide their forecast figures for this current season so that they can be taken into account alongside their audited accounts for the prior two seasons (which only had to be filed by 31st March).  It is a small window in which the EFL need to carry out their work.  Their focus is on the three clubs who they already know are “pushing the envelope”.  They are determined not to allow any club to cheat its way to promotion.  Can you imagine if Villa or Derby broke the limit by £30m (which is quite possible) yet still went up?  There would very likely be litigation from several clubs who missed out.  These laws are there for a reason, and need to be applied.  The EFL have therefore been reviewing the 3 clubs’ forecasts for this season over the past 6 weeks and asking all kinds of questions. 

I will be more surprised if the EFL end up taking no action this season, because otherwise the regulations may as well be incinerated.  I know Villa fans think that Purslow may have found a loophole (will EFL agree?).   Boro’s owner Steve Gibson and Bristol’s owner Steve Lansdown are all over this.  The EFL cannot sweep it under the carpet.
Reply
#10
(04-23-2019, 05:44 AM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(04-22-2019, 10:13 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(04-22-2019, 10:06 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(04-22-2019, 09:47 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(04-22-2019, 09:40 PM)Pragmatist Wrote: The sanctions are a lot wider than points deductions. The EFL regulations specifically allow them to debt a club automatic promotion, deny them participation in the playoffs, points deductions, fines, relegation, or any of the above. What Birmingham suffered (re a breach for 2017/8) does not bind them.

I realise that, but do you have any confidence that they’ll actually enforce anything in this scenario?

The 9 point deduction is a nice and easy solution... Villa unlikely to appeal/put up a fight and a precident can be set.

Am I confident?  Reasonably, yes. They are determined to enforce and either Villa or Derby “buying” promotion through cheating is exactly what they are trying to confront. The fact that they changed the regulations to be able to provide correct-season sanctions is quite telling re their intentions.

Each case is unique so we shouldn’t take Birmingham's penalty to be the benchmark. Their owner went to prison for fraud, and that impacted on the club. Villa, Derby and Wednesday have brazenly overspent, well aware that they were under close scrutiny. Villa could well be £20m-£30m over their limit yet they still went out and signed Abraham and Mings on expensive loan details and declined to sell Grealish last summer, so didn’t exactly take it seriously.

I totally understand why you’re confident, and you’ve shown you know this subject far better than most  on here, however with only 2 weeks until the playoffs start, and potentially 2 out of 4 competing teams affected, I can’t see them them taking any action that will cause any amount of uncertainty to the schedules. Any club that receives a penalty will no doubt be able to appeal, and a denial of promotion/denial of entering the playoffs, or even a points penalty that impacts these will be challenged and I’m not sure we have enough time for this to occur.

Like I’ve said, I imagine the league will deduct a meaningless amount of points, or throw a “soft” summer embargo which the PL will enforce should either Derby or Villa get promoted

The timing issue is very relevant. The EFL changed the rules specifically to enable them to act in the current season, and every Championship has, since 1st March, had to provide their forecast figures for this current season so that they can be taken into account alongside their audited accounts for the prior two seasons (which only had to be filed by 31st March).  It is a small window in which the EFL need to carry out their work.  Their focus is on the three clubs who they already know are “pushing the envelope”.  They are determined not to allow any club to cheat its way to promotion.  Can you imagine if Villa or Derby broke the limit by £30m (which is quite possible) yet still went up?  There would very likely be litigation from several clubs who missed out.  These laws are there for a reason, and need to be applied.  The EFL have therefore been reviewing the 3 clubs’ forecasts for this season over the past 6 weeks and asking all kinds of questions. 

I will be more surprised if the EFL end up taking no action this season, because otherwise the regulations may as well be incinerated.  I know Villa fans think that Purslow may have found a loophole (will EFL agree?).   Boro’s owner Steve Gibson and Bristol’s owner Steve Lansdown are all over this.  The EFL cannot sweep it under the carpet.

All good stuff Prag. I expect a points deduction but one not enough to knock Villa out of the play offs unfortunately. 

Those spawny toe rags will somehow get away with this of that I'm convinced.

Every owner that has cut their cloth accordingly has every bloody right to challenge the EFL on this.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)