Simple stuff on the folly of Brexit
#1
Had a good chat with a mate who lives in Germany last night. He’s from Brum originally. 
He said there was some minor disruption to the supply chain following the start of the Ukraine war and his gas prices are up about 50 per cent. 
Aside of that it is all normal. 
We discussed the issues here of strikes, empty shelves and the service sector in disarray. 
They had covid, they’ve had Ukraine issues but the one thing they didn’t have is Brexit. 
Any one on here care to share their wisdom about why it is still a great idea and how we are better off? Will it really get better and this is just some transition issues? I really don’t think so.
By the way his views mirror that of a mate from Switzerland who I met up with a few weeks ago.
Reply
#2
Please explain “empty shelves” and “service sector in disarray”.
Reply
#3
(12-17-2022, 08:46 AM)Fido Wrote: Please explain “empty shelves” and “service sector in disarray”.

I’m surprised I have to, but here goes. 
In the days of not so long ago I pretty much knew if I wanted to get eggs, pitta bread, hob nobs and matches from Sainsbury’s I could but now often it’s like Kwik Save circa 1990. 
I used to go to pubs in Brum and there were bar staff aplenty ready to help. Now there’s generally 1 or 2 being shouted at. 
A bar manager in Brum a few weeks ago told me that it is impossible almost getting staff and it’s impacting the whole sector.
I’m not trying to be rude but honestly haven’t you noticed or is it that you’re not involved in buying stuff or going out socially?
Reply
#4
Went out last night for a meal and there were staff aplenty. Went to Waitrose, Tesco and a small independent food shop this week and no "empty shelves". I don't mean to be rude but maybe you are just going into "ex-journalist" mode and making a story where there isn't one? As for Germany I had a few days over there in August and travelled by train. What used to be a service that you could set a watch to was AOTS shops with cancellations and late running services.
Reply
#5
(12-17-2022, 09:11 AM)Fido Wrote: Went out last night for a meal and there were staff aplenty. Went to Waitrose, Tesco and a small independent food shop this week and no "empty shelves". I don't mean to be rude but maybe you are just going into "ex-journalist" mode and making a story where there isn't one? As for Germany I had a few days over there in August and travelled by train. What used to be a service that you could set a watch to was AOTS shops with cancellations and late running services.

It seems you’re ignoring absolutely overwhelming evidence that this country is having huge economic problems due to Brexit. Really don’t need to go into journo mode for that. Blinkered lived in experiences really need to be taken out of any serious discussion without any supporting evidence to show your standpoint as having a wider perspective.
You’re clearly not talking to people affected either. I know plenty in business who have huge issues. I’m a member of the Chamber of Commerce.
Here’s something non political but might enlighten you if you’re willing enough to open your mind to the possibility that Brexit isn’t going great.
https://www.instituteforgovernment.org.u...ins/causes
Reply
#6
I don't think the article you linked is unfair. We have huge economic problems for which FoM essentially papered over the cracks. The greatest problem we have is productivity - and industry's depressing perennial demand is simply for even more cheap labour. There will need to be structural shifts and huge investment in some industries - particularly agriculture where already marginal businesses have got away with outrageous practices on the back of FoM. Some businesses will fall by the wayside - but they'll generally be the worst most marginal businesses anyway.

The government should also be accelerating deregulation of the City which pretty much bankrolls the rest of the UK anyway and always will, and deregulating gene editing and GMO (where we are a world leader) and which has the potential to contribute enormously to coping with climate change.

Another stonking elephant in the room is planning reform. Until we grasp the nettle and build more lab space between Oxford & Cambridge, more warehouses on green belt land between Rugby and Stoke and literally 3 new cities dotted around the M25 we can't really say we're serious about long term economic growth.

So yes, FoM is a contributory issue in our wider malaise. But rejoining the EU would not address the structural issues we face. Fair to say that neither a Tory or Labour government will either.
Reply
#7
Brexit… it’s a bit shit!

(12-17-2022, 11:45 AM)Protheroe Wrote: I don't think the article you linked is unfair. We have huge economic problems for which FoM essentially papered over the cracks. The greatest problem we have is productivity - and industry's depressing perennial demand is simply for even more cheap labour. There will need to be structural shifts and huge investment in some industries - particularly agriculture where already marginal businesses have got away with outrageous practices on the back of FoM. Some businesses will fall by the wayside - but they'll generally be the worst most marginal businesses anyway.

The government should also be accelerating deregulation of the City which pretty much bankrolls the rest of the UK anyway and always will, and deregulating gene editing and GMO (where we are a world leader) and which has the potential to contribute enormously to coping with climate change.

Another stonking elephant in the room is planning reform. Until we grasp the nettle and build more lab space between Oxford & Cambridge, more warehouses on green belt land between Rugby and Stoke and literally 3 new cities dotted around the M25 we can't really say we're serious about long term economic growth.

So yes, FoM is a contributory issue in our wider malaise. But rejoining the EU would not address the structural issues we face. Fair to say that neither a Tory or Labour government will either.

Proth’s bold vision for the future of the U.K., paving over heaven to put up a parking lot / ginormous ugly warehouse. Oh and robots picking turnips.
Reply
#8
Protheroe Wrote:I don't think the article you linked is unfair. We have huge economic problems for which FoM essentially papered over the cracks. The greatest problem we have is productivity - and industry's depressing perennial demand is simply for even more cheap labour. There will need to be structural shifts and huge investment in some industries - particularly agriculture where already marginal businesses have got away with outrageous practices on the back of FoM. Some businesses will fall by the wayside - but they'll generally be the worst most marginal businesses anyway.

The government should also be accelerating deregulation of the City which pretty much bankrolls the rest of the UK anyway and always will, and deregulating gene editing and GMO (where we are a world leader) and which has the potential to contribute enormously to coping with climate change.

Another stonking elephant in the room is planning reform. Until we grasp the nettle and build more lab space between Oxford & Cambridge, more warehouses on green belt land between Rugby and Stoke and literally 3 new cities dotted around the M25 we can't really say we're serious about long term economic growth.

So yes, FoM is a contributory issue in our wider malaise. But rejoining the EU would not address the structural issues we face. Fair to say that neither a Tory or Labour government will either.
The cheap labour issue is a huge problem. When we have shops like Primark (or whoever) knocking out clothing at unbelievably cheap prices, and you can walk in a supermarket and buy meat at stupidly cheap prices, veg at a price it is not worth paying someone local to go out and pick it. I really don't see an answer but I do know I don't want to join the race to the bottom.
Also, re Green Belt; I wouldn't allow a single new build on it until all the brownfield sites have been cleaned, particularly in industrial areas where the road and rail links plus other infrastructure is already in place. This of course costs. It looks to me simply like no one expects to pay for anything.
Reply
#9
Difference between you and I Tom, is that I spent a large part of my career cleaning up coalfield sites and ex-power stations in the green belt creating thousands of quality, sustainable jobs that wouldn’t kill you via lung disease.

Look at Hams Hall, Birch Coppice, Bermuda, Keresley and tell me I’m wrong. There are tens of thousands of acres of scrubby unproductive and unattractive fields surrounding every city that wouldn’t cost a fortune to bring forward like the rancid, foul polluted crap I worked on.

And there’s none of that crap left to bring forward anyway. It’s all been done.
Reply
#10
Strange, I’ve just had a long letter from my mate in Germany. A native of Gera and a Carl Zeiss supporter, which is how we met. And he has been telling me of the dire stuff going on over there. Their economy is stagnating and expected to be in recession next quarter. Industry electricity prices in Germany have rocketed more than 600% in the year to July thanks to soaring natural gas prices, piling the pressure on businesses and consumers prices alike.

He tells me Producer price inflation, a measure of the prices charged by manufacturers when goods leave their factories, surged to 37% in the year to July. Apparently, there are massive problems with supply shortages. He works in the heating industry and they are struggling to get heating and aircon units, spare parts and trunking. My own bit of research indicates there is currently a shortage of specialists in several sectors of Germany's industry, information technology, medicine, finance, and science and education. Can’t find anything of bar staff in Bierkellers though!  Oh, don’t tell, you know who, but he also mentioned the massive rise in the number of people using Food Banks and also pawnbrokers. He likens Germany now to the East Germany he grew up in.

He is far from happy with the E.U. and its edicts on energy and illegal immigration or Germany’s financial contribution to the EU and propping up the smaller members.
 
As for here, I frequented a Toby for dinners and breakfasts two days last week. No staff shortage as far as I could see. We shop at Tesco every week and have had no trouble with anything. No empty shelves in there. As for eggs; I’m not being rude but haven’t you seen the news or the notices on the supermarket shelves about avian flu? And there are still eggs available, just no free range.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: