BoE independence
#1
Two of the four Sunak-appointed members on the BoE monetary committee voted against raising interest rates at all. If not for the BoE having independent monetary policy then it's likely we would have kept interest rates at 3%, failing to track the Fed and risking a collapse in pounds sterling.
Reply
#2
(12-15-2022, 01:13 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Two of the four Sunak-appointed members on the BoE monetary committee voted against raising interest rates at all. If not for the BoE having independent monetary policy then it's likely we would have kept interest rates at 3%, failing to track the Fed and risking a collapse in pounds sterling.

It wouldn't be a collapse. Half a percent was priced into the markets already. I wouldn't have increased today. The price of oil is falling, gas is capped. There are signs that inflation has peaked, and the reduction in growth was lower than expected. 

I would have taken a wait and see approach until the next meeting on 2nd Feb.
Reply
#3
(12-15-2022, 02:56 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(12-15-2022, 01:13 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Two of the four Sunak-appointed members on the BoE monetary committee voted against raising interest rates at all. If not for the BoE having independent monetary policy then it's likely we would have kept interest rates at 3%, failing to track the Fed and risking a collapse in pounds sterling.

It wouldn't be a collapse. Half a percent was priced into the markets already. I wouldn't have increased today. The price of oil is falling, gas is capped. There are signs that inflation has peaked, and the reduction in growth was lower than expected. 

I would have taken a wait and see approach until the next meeting on 2nd Feb.

The Fed increased by 0.5 and had we not then the pound would absolutely have collapsed Vs the dollar. 

Inflation might be dropping but it's still 10.7% and isn't projected to get to 2% until 2025.
Reply
#4
(12-15-2022, 01:13 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Two of the four Sunak-appointed members on the BoE monetary committee voted against raising interest rates at all. If not for the BoE having independent monetary policy then it's likely we would have kept interest rates at 3%, failing to track the Fed and risking a collapse in pounds sterling.

If the BoE was truly independent (and sentient) it would have begun normalising monetary policy over a decade ago. We wouldn't be in half the shit we're in now, nor would we have had the asset price bubble we have now if Mark Carney et al hadn't indulged in fantasy-land economics.
Reply
#5
If it didn't have a degree of independence then interest rates would have likely held up given two of the Sunak Treasury appointed members of the monetary committee voted for 3%.

And Carney had his hands tied behind his back in managing monetary policy with brain-dead Tory fiscal policy, maybe if the government weren't running around like morons consistently making stupid decisions that have undermined UK productivity and economic growth over the last 12 years (I'm including the Lib Dems in this, in particular that complete wet Danny Alexander) the BoE would have had more room to be braver on monetary policy instead of constantly being wary of teetering off the knife edge. Least worst though ay it? Maybe that's just the neoliberal in me though.
Reply
#6
Hmm. All you're doing is making a convincing explanation of why the BoE isn't independent in any meaningful way.
Reply
#7
No, I'm pointing out that monetary policy doesn't exist in a vacuum. Carney spelled out multiple times that interest rate rises depended on sufficient growth with failed to be achieved due to poor government policy.

If the BoE was run by the Treasury as it used to be then it's very likely interest rates would have stayed at 3%, that's where the independence is.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)