Posts: 3,316
Threads: 58
Joined: Sep 2022
(12-03-2022, 12:54 AM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote: Is it not possible that she was asking - in a really fucking clumsy way - what are your roots and how did your family find itself in this country? Purely by way of making conversation with someone they’ve never met before and have the square root of fuck all in common with.
We are, after all, a nation of mongrels and I doubt any of us could genuinely trace their lineage back to the first ape to beat its fist on these shores like Nick Griffin or Nigel Farage could.
I have a slightly unusual surname that occasionally draws questions as to its origins. Are the interrogators racists? Probably not. If they ask the same question again, are they racist? Again, probably not - they’re probably just stupid or demented.
Move on.
Correct.
Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
(12-02-2022, 11:11 AM)WorcsWBA Wrote: There are a number of people in this thread, with surprising vigour, seeking to sugarcoat what was clear racism. Their reasoning broadly seems to be as follows:
- It's acceptable for people who are above a certain age threshold to be racist
- Someone who has presumably travelled the world with the Queen for many years, experiencing many cultures, faiths and creeds in the process, and who will have had countless briefings that royal staff receive on what is and isn't acceptable, should nevertheless should be excused for naive ignorance in not understanding the simple fact that a person of colour can actually have been born in the UK.
- People born in the UK shouldn't dress culturally, but in a way which emphasises their "Britishness" (no doubt also waving little Union Flags at every opportunity). Perhaps those who believe this can outline what appropriate attire is to ensure that we all follow this requirement? Perhaps people from the UK should only be allowed to have certain hairstyles as well?
- Despite someone stating very clearly where they're from, it's fine to keep badgering them about it on the assumption that they must be lying
- Ngozi Fulani must have exaggerated it or made it up, despite the fact that others overheard the conversation. No doubt they're making it up too, this being more palatable to some people than entertaining the idea that it actually happened.
- It shouldn't be reported because there are more important things going on. Some will be saying the same about the World Cup, the daily updates we were given on Matt Hancock in the jungle and/or the latest antics of the clearly insane Kanye West, to name but a few.
If indeed Lady Hussey is "batty", why was she at given a prominent role at the reception (hosted by the Queen Consort) where this happened? Also, why does she continue to be employed if she can't properly discharge her duties?
Ultimately, for me, there are no excuses for racism enacted by anyone who has sufficient cognitive faculties to be able to understand it.
Well said Worcs.
Posts: 1,115
Threads: 66
Joined: Aug 2022
Reputation:
3
(12-03-2022, 12:01 AM)Yep Spandaubaggie Wrote: (12-02-2022, 08:19 PM)MassDebater Wrote: Then again I'm old and I don't really think Fatkinson was racist in spite of what he said.(including those who weren't white who backed him and knew him) So, obviously I know nothing. And what he said was far worse than what the old bint came out with.
You can say the wrong thing and it not mean what people make it into.
Well some on here, in this very debate, will say you are an evil racist and there's no excuse due to your age. They have a fixed mindset of racism, whatever the hell that is.
You may have used inappropriate language calling someone coloured rather than a person of colour, but in their zero tolerance world you are no different to a 1980 skinhead kicking seven bells of shit out of a lad who is from Indian background.
These people have a no excuses attitude for those unable to adapt to societal changes.
It brings me nicely onto the Atkinson debate. He was defended by a host of black players and he was a man who gave black players more of an opportunity than any before, yet he used a phrase not meant for those outside the studio and it was like he was the guinea pig for what has come since, when you broadcast to all rather than the audience it is meant for.
I would also add that the n word Atkinson used then is far more charged now showing the change in perception of words. Racism has become a catch all word for the slightest indiscretion to close down a discussion. It kills stuff stone dead to the majority.
In life, we all have differences, but some now weaponise words to an unreal degree. There's a lot that makes us different, but it really is down to how much you want to take offence and look for a row sizing up the background of those you wish to take down.
I think broadly speaking most people still have free speech in company they are comfortable with, but we all self check now. Racism, sexism, heightism, fattism. It's all there now for those who want to use it as artillery depending on if the person who said it is a different ethnicity, male, taller or slimmer. Just look carefully you'll find a way if you're hell bent enough.
I'll include ageism too. I still think despite defending her the woman who said it is a silly old bat.
I love it when racism gets the reduced to the level of other isms, heightism hasn’t so far led to the murder of 6 million in death camps
Posts: 8,845
Threads: 269
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
29
12-03-2022, 06:58 AM
(This post was last modified: 12-03-2022, 06:59 AM by Fido.)
(12-03-2022, 12:54 AM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote: Is it not possible that she was asking - in a really fucking clumsy way - what are your roots and how did your family find itself in this country? Purely by way of making conversation with someone they’ve never met before and have the square root of fuck all in common with.
We are, after all, a nation of mongrels and I doubt any of us could genuinely trace their lineage back to the first ape to beat its fist on these shores like Nick Griffin or Nigel Farage could.
I have a slightly unusual surname that occasionally draws questions as to its origins. Are the interrogators racists? Probably not. If they ask the same question again, are they racist? Again, probably not - they’re probably just stupid or demented.
Move on.
+1, Mr Cnut.
Posts: 136
Threads: 9
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
0
(12-03-2022, 12:54 AM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote: I have a slightly unusual surname that occasionally draws questions as to its origins. Are the interrogators racists? Probably not. If they ask the same question again, are they racist? Again, probably not - they’re probably just stupid or demented.
Move on.
That "occasional" questioning comes from those you have informed of your name. You can't liken it to racism unless your surname was tattooed across your forehead since birth along with everyone else with strange names (myself included).
Posts: 2,914
Threads: 33
Joined: Nov 2021
Reputation:
11
(12-03-2022, 12:01 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: (12-02-2022, 08:19 PM)MassDebater Wrote: Then again I'm old and I don't really think Fatkinson was racist in spite of what he said.(including those who weren't white who backed him and knew him) So, obviously I know nothing. And what he said was far worse than what the old bint came out with.
You can say the wrong thing and it not mean what people make it into.
Well some on here, in this very debate, will say you are an evil racist and there's no excuse due to your age. They have a fixed mindset of racism, whatever the hell that is.
You may have used inappropriate language calling someone coloured rather than a person of colour, but in their zero tolerance world you are no different to a 1980 skinhead kicking seven bells of shit out of a lad who is from Indian background.
These people have a no excuses attitude for those unable to adapt to societal changes.
It brings me nicely onto the Atkinson debate. He was defended by a host of black players and he was a man who gave black players more of an opportunity than any before, yet he used a phrase not meant for those outside the studio and it was like he was the guinea pig for what has come since, when you broadcast to all rather than the audience it is meant for.
I would also add that the n word Atkinson used then is far more charged now showing the change in perception of words. Racism has become a catch all word for the slightest indiscretion to close down a discussion. It kills stuff stone dead to the majority.
In life, we all have differences, but some now weaponise words to an unreal degree. There's a lot that makes us different, but it really is down to how much you want to take offence and look for a row sizing up the background of those you wish to take down.
I think broadly speaking most people still have free speech in company they are comfortable with, but we all self check now. Racism, sexism, heightism, fattism. It's all there now for those who want to use it as artillery depending on if the person who said it is a different ethnicity, male, taller or slimmer. Just look carefully you'll find a way if you're hell bent enough.
I'll include ageism too. I still think despite defending her the woman who said it is a silly old bat.
As MassDebater pointed out, Atkinson may not have been a member of the NF but what he said was racist. It’s really that simple with this incident as well.
Posts: 10,272
Threads: 694
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
12-03-2022, 09:09 AM
(This post was last modified: 12-03-2022, 09:49 AM by Spandaubaggie.)
(12-03-2022, 08:20 AM)KRO Wrote: (12-03-2022, 12:01 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: (12-02-2022, 08:19 PM)MassDebater Wrote: Then again I'm old and I don't really think Fatkinson was racist in spite of what he said.(including those who weren't white who backed him and knew him) So, obviously I know nothing. And what he said was far worse than what the old bint came out with.
You can say the wrong thing and it not mean what people make it into.
Well some on here, in this very debate, will say you are an evil racist and there's no excuse due to your age. They have a fixed mindset of racism, whatever the hell that is.
You may have used inappropriate language calling someone coloured rather than a person of colour, but in their zero tolerance world you are no different to a 1980 skinhead kicking seven bells of shit out of a lad who is from Indian background.
These people have a no excuses attitude for those unable to adapt to societal changes.
It brings me nicely onto the Atkinson debate. He was defended by a host of black players and he was a man who gave black players more of an opportunity than any before, yet he used a phrase not meant for those outside the studio and it was like he was the guinea pig for what has come since, when you broadcast to all rather than the audience it is meant for.
I would also add that the n word Atkinson used then is far more charged now showing the change in perception of words. Racism has become a catch all word for the slightest indiscretion to close down a discussion. It kills stuff stone dead to the majority.
In life, we all have differences, but some now weaponise words to an unreal degree. There's a lot that makes us different, but it really is down to how much you want to take offence and look for a row sizing up the background of those you wish to take down.
I think broadly speaking most people still have free speech in company they are comfortable with, but we all self check now. Racism, sexism, heightism, fattism. It's all there now for those who want to use it as artillery depending on if the person who said it is a different ethnicity, male, taller or slimmer. Just look carefully you'll find a way if you're hell bent enough.
I'll include ageism too. I still think despite defending her the woman who said it is a silly old bat.
As MassDebater pointed out, Atkinson may not have been a member of the NF but what he said was racist. It’s really that simple with this incident as well. What Atkinson said was a racist insult and extremely stupid. How you can compare him using a toxic slur like that to this incident is mind boggling.
I have been asked many times where my family are from as people assume I’m of Irish background. Once I asked it to an Irish guy who was very off with me and took umbrage. Does that make me a racist?
Sorry KRO I hate real prejudice that keeps people down, that mocks them cruelly etc, but we’ve got to a point where people who are looking for something to beat someone with has hit lunacy.
My view is that the charity girl started out with a hostile attitude towards the old gal and as she clumsily talked the girl was deliberately awkward. I think it’s pretty obvious that the posh old toff was enquiring about her background etc.
It might have led to a chat on her own visits there and the beauty of the place. However it simply was used a ploy to make a stand against the Royal Family in this climate.
(12-03-2022, 05:57 AM)Ournextstriker Wrote: (12-03-2022, 12:01 AM)Yep Spandaubaggie Wrote: (12-02-2022, 08:19 PM)MassDebater Wrote: Then again I'm old and I don't really think Fatkinson was racist in spite of what he said.(including those who weren't white who backed him and knew him) So, obviously I know nothing. And what he said was far worse than what the old bint came out with.
You can say the wrong thing and it not mean what people make it into.
Well some on here, in this very debate, will say you are an evil racist and there's no excuse due to your age. They have a fixed mindset of racism, whatever the hell that is.
You may have used inappropriate language calling someone coloured rather than a person of colour, but in their zero tolerance world you are no different to a 1980 skinhead kicking seven bells of shit out of a lad who is from Indian background.
These people have a no excuses attitude for those unable to adapt to societal changes.
It brings me nicely onto the Atkinson debate. He was defended by a host of black players and he was a man who gave black players more of an opportunity than any before, yet he used a phrase not meant for those outside the studio and it was like he was the guinea pig for what has come since, when you broadcast to all rather than the audience it is meant for.
I would also add that the n word Atkinson used then is far more charged now showing the change in perception of words. Racism has become a catch all word for the slightest indiscretion to close down a discussion. It kills stuff stone dead to the majority.
In life, we all have differences, but some now weaponise words to an unreal degree. There's a lot that makes us different, but it really is down to how much you want to take offence and look for a row sizing up the background of those you wish to take down.
I think broadly speaking most people still have free speech in company they are comfortable with, but we all self check now. Racism, sexism, heightism, fattism. It's all there now for those who want to use it as artillery depending on if the person who said it is a different ethnicity, male, taller or slimmer. Just look carefully you'll find a way if you're hell bent enough.
I'll include ageism too. I still think despite defending her the woman who said it is a silly old bat.
I love it when racism gets the reduced to the level of other isms, heightism hasn’t so far led to the murder of 6 million in death camps I guess it is what some define as racism. If asking where you are from is the same as a black kid being killed by white supremacists that’s what we get. Until some people with agendas stop shouting racism as a catch all umbrella term to cause problems that aren’t there that’s where we are.
Racist is an incredibly powerful word and its power isn’t lost on some who wield it.
Posts: 19,719
Threads: 2,734
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
49
I had dinner with Brendon and his wife Cecily not long after the BFR "N" bomb. We chatted about it and Brendon was insistent that BFR wasn't racist but she was quite the opposite in her opinion.
At a couple of after lunch/dinner speeches BFR started his speak pretending that the mic wasn't working and joked he'd wished that had happened in the studio.
Posts: 11,922
Threads: 798
Joined: Oct 2022
Reputation:
50
It’s only racist if it conforms to a 1980s image of what racism looks like.
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Posts: 5,322
Threads: 356
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
Spandau is brilliant at starting threads, that in essence complain about the attention given to issues such as this.
If you genuinely think that this is a storm in a teacup and far too much has been made about it, starting a thread that goes on and on is possibly not the way to go.
|