Injury Time
#21
Rugby Union has a stopped clock, the ball is rarely in play longer than 40 minutes of the 80. The impact might be lessened than you'd expect.
Reply
#22
(11-22-2022, 10:14 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote:
(11-22-2022, 08:47 PM)Logic1 Wrote:
(11-22-2022, 10:48 AM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote:
(11-22-2022, 10:44 AM)Logic1 Wrote: This is great - stops teams from taking the piss. I'm sick and tired of being short-changed as a supporter and it kills off Pulis type tactics. I think at the end of the season, his teams typically played one less game in terms of time.

They should introduce a formal timer of 60mins for a game. Everytime the play stops, the clock stops. At the end of each half, the game ends when the ball goes out. If a foul is committed that stops the play, then the game continues until the ball is out.

And then what? Four quarters and not two halves? Calling draws 'ties', or eradicating them altogether? Po' boys, nacho hats and tee-shirt bazooka intervals complete with kiss-cam, all sponsored by Cheesy Codeine Puffs?

No thanks. I like the Britishness of added time. I totally agree with the comment above that more added time is great when consistent, not a bad thing. And as a team in form under Corbynbran, we stand only to benefit from that, rather than Bruce's chumps at the foot of the league watching the teams above get the preferential clock treatment.
No, just two halves. This would completely get rid of the time wasting. Something like this will happen because with 5 subs a team, games are getting longer. Also, let the ref concentrate on the game not on keeping time. This ensures that every team has the same amount of time. You shouldn't be able to gain an advantage from sitting on the floor.

I suppose there's no harm trying in a lower league, and seeing what the fans think. Or at least there wouldn't be. 

But it won't happen that way, though; the clock-stop revenue will ensure it starts at the top first. And even though it isn't offensive in the cricket, that's gonna be weird - and also, I imagine, quite an atmos killer - at the football. Which is why I am not sold. 

I still don't see what's wrong with stoppage time if it's done right, but it isn't I guess, which is why we're debating something that should at least be foolproof.

Why would it worsen the atmosphere? I think it would improve it. It would basically say to teams... you can't waste time so get on with the game.
Reply
#23
Would mean people missing last trains on away days during the week or having to leave early to catch them. If running, of course.
Reply
#24
(11-23-2022, 08:10 AM)Fido Wrote: Would mean people missing last trains on away days during the week or having to leave early to catch them. If running, of course.

Perhaps they should strike to get better terms of employment and continue to run?
In the form of his life.
Reply
#25
(11-23-2022, 08:10 AM)Fido Wrote: Would mean people missing last trains on away days during the week or having to leave early to catch them. If running, of course.

Why would it? There would be less time-wasting as there is no incentive to time-waste. Would make it more likely you catch your train.
Reply
#26
(11-23-2022, 10:12 AM)Logic1 Wrote:
(11-23-2022, 08:10 AM)Fido Wrote: Would mean people missing last trains on away days during the week or having to leave early to catch them. If running, of course.

Why would it? There would be less time-wasting as there is no incentive to time-waste. Would make it more likely you catch your train.

So you're saying players won't go down like a bag of shit and roll on the ground anyway?
Reply
#27
(11-23-2022, 10:24 AM)Fido Wrote:
(11-23-2022, 10:12 AM)Logic1 Wrote:
(11-23-2022, 08:10 AM)Fido Wrote: Would mean people missing last trains on away days during the week or having to leave early to catch them. If running, of course.

Why would it? There would be less time-wasting as there is no incentive to time-waste. Would make it more likely you catch your train.

So you're saying players won't go down like a bag of shit and roll on the ground anyway?

They might still do it to break up the play but there would be less of an incentive to do it. They do it now because they know they will get away with it because time keeping is not transparent. Some of the games we have had this season really take the piss. It is great FIFA have noticed this and they are doing something about it. Official time-keeping would completely change the culture. Furthermore, if games continue to take excessive time, then a panel of experts could be set up to assess if a team is taking the piss and there could be fines or points deductions as in cricket. I think this strategy would completely kill time-wasting.

It is annoying that a time-wasting culture has been allowed to set in to the game but it is not surprising with all the opportunities for subs and the fact that refs stop the game when someone goes down injured. How many times do we observe that gamesmanship over the course of a season. It happens almost every week.

Furthermore, I actually think that a free-kick should be awarded to the opposition if the referee believes that a team is deliberately trying to time waste in the corner of the pitch instead of trying to score a goal or win a corner.
Reply
#28
(11-23-2022, 10:52 AM)Logic1 Wrote:
(11-23-2022, 10:24 AM)Fido Wrote:
(11-23-2022, 10:12 AM)Logic1 Wrote:
(11-23-2022, 08:10 AM)Fido Wrote: Would mean people missing last trains on away days during the week or having to leave early to catch them. If running, of course.

Why would it? There would be less time-wasting as there is no incentive to time-waste. Would make it more likely you catch your train.

So you're saying players won't go down like a bag of shit and roll on the ground anyway?

They might still do it to break up the play but there would be less of an incentive to do it. They do it now because they know they will get away with it because time keeping is not transparent. Some of the games we have had this season really take the piss. It is great FIFA have noticed this and they are doing something about it. Official time-keeping would completely change the culture. Furthermore, if games continue to take excessive time, then a panel of experts could be set up to assess if a team is taking the piss and there could be fines or points deductions as in cricket. I think this strategy would completely kill time-wasting.

It is annoying that a time-wasting culture has been allowed to set in to the game but it is not surprising with all the opportunities for subs and the fact that refs stop the game when someone goes down injured. How many times do we observe that gamesmanship over the course of a season. It happens almost every week.

Furthermore, I actually think that a free-kick should be awarded to the opposition if the referee believes that a team is deliberately trying to time waste in the corner of the pitch instead of trying to score a goal or win a corner.

I don't disagree but they can't even control the laws of the game that are in place now: disrespect of officials/bad language (which should be priority #1 given the knock-on effect to grassroots etc.), obstruction (which is tied to time-wasting in the corner but also applies to letting the ball run for a corner) and diving/faking injury. All of these should be dealt with first, within the current laws and these might actually work towards removing the necessity for the above.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: